Melanie Amaro Judges House Performing "Will You Be There"

[teinaellis]

Love her voice, dont understand what went through simons head! lucky he came to his senses. :)

[jbrewer1268]

Replay button wore out a few days after it aired. Good thing she's viral on yt.

[guillermoquiray]

You are one of the gifted

[pipi917]

When first saw Melanie's performance at the Judges House I though she has a great voice but something was missing. Melanie has gain more confidence on stage and now I know she has the X FACTOR! She is destined to win if she keeps pushing forward never looking back...We love you Melanie! You are destined for Greatness with that awesome voice and beautiful spirit that God has blessed you with.

[MariZion1]

a whole lot of auto tune but she is amazing



[ShockNAweMack]

I disagree...Josh has more soul, passion and a very powerful voice. She has a great voice also but she just sounds like every other Christina Aguilera wannabe out there.

[Estas01]

@ShockNAweMack She might sound like Christina Aguilera, but she can't even compete with Christina look wise.

[ShockNAweMack]

@Estas01 Christina Haguilera is a typical hollywood whore. Right there with Hilton, Miley Cyrus, Spears, Lohan.

I give Amaro respect because she does have a great voice but they chose her because her voice is the same hippity hoppity cookie cutter voice they want in Hollywood these days.

Josh should have won it. His voice is more unique and more heartfelt and genuine. Not to mention he writes his own music. Unlike the rest of those hollywood manufactured "artists".

[Estas01]

@ShockNAweMack You have no guarantee that Melanie is not gonna become a whore once she tastes money & fame...Anyway, I agree, Josh Krajcik should have won. The dude is awesome.

[MrReflectionEternal]

@ShockNAweMack Shut the fuck up! You don't know shit CockNAweMick

[adamlambertisanangel]

when are music shows going to be based on talent and talent alone ???

[icimj23]

I'm gonna get so mad if she doesn't win the x factor

she is the best by far!!

[thickythcikgirl209]

woooooow woooooooow she is awsome i cant believe she isnt signd already

[yankees101979]

SHE IS WINNING IT ALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[owegas]

she needs a cd out right now..the best of the best.....good luck...love your voice...

[TheWaggaBloke]

mate! I'm in love with the Women! WOOOOOWWWWWWWWWWWWW.. ever single time I hear her Voice! Bless God in Jesus Name! Wooooooowwww

[gula26able]

What an amazing voice. I can't stop listening to her. You have to win Melanie!

[miritavirgo]

melanie is a super star..!!

[skikdia01]

It's between her and stacy francis

[mstracitrent]

SIMPLY AMAZING!!!

[mlsherman1982]

Theres sumthn about her voice that jus moves me!

[REtiPATHAME]

Thumbs up if you want to X simon for making it hard for her!

[thesparksplug]

Melanie! Melanie! Melanie! "Gyal, dem cyah stop yuh this year!" (Jamaican for "You are unstoppable this year!")

I don't even want to share that prize money with you because you deserve every penny.

[pietersite26]

That sustained Eb5 was SUPEEERB!!!She kinda reminds me of Tiffany Evans!

[ellu9611]

I LOVE SIMONS REACTION <3<3<3<3

[jenanjeha]

The new beyonce!!

[XXHOLLYXX1000]

how the hell did simon say no to this? so annoying why couldnt he just put her through in the first place, he is so annoying he had to go to her house and do it why be a drama queen seriously

[thesparksplug]

@XXHOLLYXX1000 Couldn't agree with you more. Same way they got of Gamu Nhegu (from Zimbabwe) last year and nobody could beat her on X-Factor. She was also a fantastic talent. I love Melanie'e energy. Listen how smoothly she goes into the bridge!!!

[staceymp0wnz]

@thesparksplug Gamu Nhegu used auto tune just listen to her audition carefully.

[thesparksplug]

@staceymp0wnz Really?? I saw a footage of her (Gamu) on a huge stage singing lead for a 100+ looking choir filled with white people and she was still fantastic. Do you think she has the resources to pull that off with auto tuning? Some wicked vocals in the Black continent you know. I listen to them Africans sing almost everyday.

[astherreyes]

melanie and drew will be in the finals,,,,,



[saratogawayne]

WE LOVE you MELANIE! Let us ALL know when you are coming out with a CD or a Concert, I want front row seats for that one:) SUPERSTAR!

[cripsyfrenchflies]

Simon was NEVER going to leave her, people. Please recognize when you are being played. Life will go smoother for all in involved when you activate your BS detector. Simon is a drama queen and he is taking a show with great potential and burying it like a dog with a bone.

[ukeinfused]

@cripsyfrenchflies: couldn't agree with you more that Simon burying the show in his drama. alot of viewers show up because they love to see amazing talent be supported. he's done the opposite with Melanie since the judges house - created drama at her expense, because he knew that he could bring her back. he doesn't realize how much damage he does to his show. i liked him better when he came off as a critical but smart talent scout.... now i just think 'YUCK!' with all his fakey acting...

[cripsyfrenchflies]

@ukeinfused What is ticking me off is that she has this self doubt in her face, as though he truly passed over her. She doesn't deserve that! She is the most marketable female left in the competition (since Simon dumped 2 talented girls to have the throwaways Tiah and Simone). I have been DVRing the show and FFing to the performances because I am no longer a fan of "X Factor". I am a fan of some of the performers.

[ukeinfused]

@cripsyfrenchflies: yes, even if the live performance was not her very best, she still was amazing. it was painful to see the stress and distrust she'd developed after the first two fab performances - she didn't even smile on the last one. I don't know if i want to watch the show anymore. i hope that Melanie can see that it's all about Simon's games, and that she can go forward trusting her voice and find her joy again. (I also think he missed the mark on Caitlyn and Tora...)

[jopette99]

she will be loved by all!!!! amazing!!!

[sheng21]

damn shes good

[139jordanb]

cant beleave simon was gonna kick her

[xjustinex19]

how hasnt she gone through o0mg she is so talented

[portojomyut]

she made me miss michael

[karladacosta]

Amazing voice! :)

[mirasol999]

what a great voice...

[qtal2010]

Definitely the best!!!

[TheMCJ123456789]

Notice how simon can't sit still at all near the end. Hahahaha

[doneyboyz]

sHe gave me crazy chiLLs

[jswilliams951]

Follow Melanie On Twitter @ItsMelanieAmaro

[drherbman]

she has the best voice, the most talent,better vocal skills..,I think the reason she did not go through is because they look for personality as part of the performers marketability,, shame on that.. that could be a simple fix for melanie.. if those so called mentors get there heads out of the rich conceited butts, they should of known right from the git go that melanie amaro is a super star waiting to be born..

[chevyandnovasmom]

@drherbman She is def my favorite on the show and had he not gone to Fla to go and get her I would NOT have watched the rest of the show!! Fingers crossed for this young lady! She's amazing!!

[mj10013]

@drherbman she dint go through ? omg

[meatloafify]

it's weird, on UK version of X Factor, they heavily promote the fact that the mentors are competing against each other. Therefore having equal numbers of contestants in each of the categories is a must. I wonder if Simon having 5 in his category means they are going to do away with the unofficial mentor competition aspect of the X Factor show. For UK, it was really great seeing how Louis Walsh (an X Factor UK mentor) would always get stuck with the groups, and always get booted out first.

[AuraENoor]

I just was about to find the number of Simon and tell him WHAT THE HELL U DID?

How he could put out this blessed girl to chose one who not even can remember the lyrics!!!!!

Sometimes I think Simon decides with his other head...

[MrPirate408]

the best so far she has great talent

[rocked30]

I just and watched the show tonight and she didn't make it to the live shows. I'm in total shock!!! Simone said she was a great singer but he couldn't put her through. He put through a bunch of lesser singers that he thought would make good TV.... This is the only reason I could come up with to understand this travesty... I 100 percent will not watch the show. It has no legitimacy with me or the American viewer anymore.

[Cherluvsfl67]

She is Sooo Amazing! I was Soo relieved when Simon realized what a HUGE mistake he made sending her Home! She can Win this! U go Melanie! My vote is on U!

[thegingerbreadman181]

This girl kicked some serious ass..talent isn't even the word for this girl

[tigguh19]

I want her to win X-Factor she is amazing

[Jadon3003]

Luv it!!!!!!

[mistre1x]

Melanie is absolutely brilliant, pretty and star indeed .. Simon will not go to the live shows without her.. My fav to win no doubt!!

[MrTL0319]

I also watch X factor for Melanie. She sings like a pro :-)

[njugunaize]

OMG i love her voice

[miritavirgo]

melanieeee you're the best singer in this competition...!!! great voice..amazing..!!!

[ba4774]

Simon wants to win and she is his best chance at it. I don't like him most of the time, but he's no fool. 

[MrLambDude]

i only watch Xfactor for Melanie

[tsdempster1]

That last part about a look was from a different audition. They had to do that because simon made it too obvious that Melanie was through by throwing up his hand and ripping up the rest of the competition.

[healthhavencom]

Goddess.

Great boobs.

Did she sing something?

[MrLambDude]

why are you f'ing idiots talking about Simons soda and the couch???? the issue here is that Melanie is the DIva of our era and n amazing talent... shesh... what a bunch of fuck tards

[MrLambDude]

ooooooooh dears!! she is gonna is TOUGH to beat...... a fan... i am a FAN!! cant wait to get her first CD

[ba4774]

Dear LA Reid: remember that girl that made it worth you quitting your label? I didn't put her through. Sorry, Simon. Not going to happen. Simon's just doing is drama queen stuff.

[MrDomDomenico]

When the Judges House show 1 aired in Canada they stuffed up the editing at the end and you can see Simon saying sorry to Melanie you didn't make it. It was edited out when it aired in the USA

[16brooke1992]

@MrDomDomenico im from canada and no that did not happen..

[MrDomDomenico]

@16brooke1992 Yes it did there is plenty of discussion about it and videos and photos . CHeck out the IDOLFORUMS there is plenty of talk and screenshots and video.

[Prboi92]

@MrDomDomenico Those photos and videos were edited to throw you off.

[MrDomDomenico]

@Prboi92 No they weren't what was seen ended up being correct Simon gave her a No at his house.

[Prboi92]

@MrDomDomenico OK but did she make it is the final question. Because all these images and videos were made to throw you off and make you question. They want you to watch the show. They aren't stupid. lol

[MrDomDomenico]

@Prboi92 The end of show 8 they stuffed the editing and showed Melanie getting a No. It was the exact same in tonight show. Nothing was to throw anyone off they just happened to do a bad edit and leave to much in. It was know for a few days that Melanie was going to et a NO from simon.

[Prboi92]

@MrDomDomenico Ok but in the end, you said she was going home for sure and that was the final decision. And in the end, they threw you off. You didn't know she was going to be brought back because you would have said it.

[MrDomDomenico]

@Prboi92 She did get a 100% No. What Simon did after has nothing to do with it. Simon gave her a No at his house which was known for days.ANyway who really cares she is in now and all is good.

[Prboi92]

@MrDomDomenico You're right! I don't even know why I started with you. lol sorry!

[MrDomDomenico]

@16brooke1992 I have the espisode right in font of me ow and it clearly does happen. Right at the end you can see that it's defiantly Melanies hair and top. The USA airing it was edited out.

[Rastis35]

Simon doesn't give a standing O in an audition for just no one. If she doesn't make it, I can guarantee you he's already in the works on a contract for her. He's played this game before. Melanie would be one of the "season shockers" voted off too soon for being too good. It never fails.

[lilcrazyaznboy]

Hmmmm.... I guess you guys right..

[methedmann]

All these rumors I'm hearing about Melanie not makin' it to live shows, I hope its not true. But at the end of the show when Simon was talkin' about the "one everyone thought would make it" but will not got through, got me thinkin' it's Melanie. Man, this sucks!

[Prboi92]

@methedmann Nobody knows who's making it through! People just put up who they think is going through and they are calling it Spoilers. But its not Spoilers because nobody has seen the results yet.

[symmetricalastic]

Simon said at the end that Melanie gave her a look and that someone who everyone thought would be an automatic yes is not being put through. I think it is her

[KimberleeAnneNolin]

She's got amazing talent. You can't train a person to have that talent, they either got it or they don't. She makes it look so easy and soulful. I just hope they see this. I only watch this show to see her! She won me over with Listen by Beyonce. If you look up Beyonce listen live performance, Melanie wins it! AHH haha i just honestly can't say enough about her!!! <3 she so XoXoLLent!!!

[Rastis35]

Oh for Gods sake people. Seriously? Any idiot knows these things are edited. His posture/sitting and even drink does not change enough for anyone to give a shit about. Some of you just look for any petty little thing to criticize and it's ridiculous. Look at the real issue here and that is her voice, which is amazing. Not which side of the couch Simon's ass is on etc. Geez.

[Worm31094]

@EcentralC Same here and i was laughing at the soda the whole time for some reason after i saw ur comment. Wtf was Simon doing while this girl was singing!

[Worm31094]

@EcentralC actually he did put the soda on the ground. Just look at it u can see it. Anyway, what did u think about the performance cause thats what u should be listening to



[flame0731]

@EcentralC um there is a table next to him with refreshments. He could adjust his position if he so desired. I think someone is just upset about talent shows. I mean overall it's really irrelevant because she obviously can sing. People that sound like Melanie don't just have good moment and bad moments in a song. It's good throughout.

[krythel]

@EcentralC Obviously he was just keeping it on the ground? O.o

[monleo1705]

Her boobies are gigantic.... They look like watermelons!

[pacificnwson]

@MrDomDomenico: STFU you POS. You will be proved a fool in two days.

[nanasanju]

If America does not think that you have the x-factor to be a star, you should come to Indonesia. I bet you will be a star here.

[TJPITT91]

Is this from Free Willy? lol

[MrDomDomenico]

You didn't look well enough. She drops so many hints that she didn't make it. She already had one Twitter account suspended for saying too much. Just accept it she does not make it. Im jut as upset as others she has a fantastic voice.

[Worm31094]

@MrDomDomenico I hate to keep goin but can u please lay down 1 hint 

[krythel]

@MrDomDomenico Shut the fuck up... You're the only one spouting those dirt filth lies.

[MrDomDomenico]

There is maybe going to be a wild card show according to some sources, hopefully this lady gets another go, she does have an amazing voice. I think Simon made a mistake not put her through at the Judges homes

[flame0731]

@MrDomDomenico lol okay I could understand maybe a girl that was good but was still on the fence, but um...obviously Melanie is going to make it all the way through. I mean really? Do you just want attention? In all honesty you can say what you please because on Tuesday when you're wrong all the people who disagree with you will descend.

[1234Natashaa]

dont think i have ever heard this song before but would definitely buy her version!

[MrDomDomenico]

She does have a twitter, did you even look?. Without doubt 100% for sure Simon will not put her through on Tuesdays nights show.

ItsMelanieAmaro <, Twitter

[2luckynumber]

She deserves to win!!!

[Worm31094]

Yea dont listen to this guy saying shes not gonna make it. Hes already contradicted himself on Rachel Crow's video saying first that Rachel made it and then saying she didnt make it. Idk sounds like bs to me I mean...whos the competition when it comes to this girl and her group (girls)? Simone? yea right

[MrDomDomenico]

@Worm31094 Never contradicted myself Rachel Crow does make. Go and read Melanie's Tweets it's 100% clear she is no longer int eh competition

[Worm31094]

@MrDomDomenico She has no twitter. Or give me her twitter so i can see cause im not coming up with results. Oh and btw u did say that Rachel Crow makes it to one guy and then you said she didnt in a general comment.

[MrDomDomenico]

@Worm31094 Nowhere i said Rachel Crow doesn't make it. She is 100% in.

[Worm31094]

@MrDomDomenico Anyway..... I found her twitter and nowhere in it do I see any hint that she didnt make it. Plus its illegal to talk about the competition while the show is airing. So im sure wherever you got your "100%" proof from its not true at all. Another thing btw its impossible to ever know if someone's twitter is actually therre twitter. For all we know, it can be a randome person pretending to be her. People always do that on twitter dont you know that?

[newsense87]

Stop listening to people talking about 'spoilers' guys. The idea that Simon wouldn't put this girl through to sing live is just comical. Trolls gunna troll.

[MrDomDomenico]

@newsense87 Prepare for disappointment. Simon even said in an interview he made a massive mistake.

[newsense87]

@MrDomDomenico Keep trolling troll.

[Prboi92]

@MrDomDomenico Are you seriously gonna believe everything Simon says? You do know he likes to throw people off and keep them interested. Hes a genius at promotion.

[MrDomDomenico]

@Prboi92 Not believing one one other than what Melanie herself is saying and doing. She already had one twitter account deleted for saying too much. See is clearly does not go through on Tuesdays night show.

[Prboi92]

@MrDomDomenico Was it a legit account? Was it really her? How can somebody just delete somebody's account like that? Something isn't right. And everybody keeps talking about spoilers. What spoilers? Nobody has seen Tuesday's show yet so what the hell.

[MrDomDomenico]

@Prboi92 They don't lock all the contestants in a room and don't let them out until the live shows. The word gets out on who has made it and who hasn't.

[thehurds1]

Just give it to her now!! WINNER!!

[MrDomDomenico]

Spoilers have been all over the net the last few weeks. Follow their twitter and Facebook it's very easy to see if they made it or not.

[MrDomDomenico]

Sorry people she does not make it.

[kaylonmitchell14]

@MrDomDomenico how would you know? 

[Prboi92]

@MrDomDomenico I just saw X Factor. And please remind me: Did she make it through or not?

[bailey61088]

@Prboi92 At first he denied her, and sent her home... Which really pissed me off... THEN he relized he made a HUGE mistake, and personally went to her house, apologized, and asked her to be a part of the now final 17!! Winner of X Factor 2011: Melanie Amaro!! Yeah Buddy!!

[Prboi92]

@bailey61088 I know. My question was directed to the MrDomDomenico who said she wasn't going to make it

[MrDomDomenico]

@Prboi92 I said that Simon would not put her through at the judges houses which he didn't. It was clear from the editing bungle they did on the Canadian airing she was going to get a NO and she did get a no.

[goddessevez]

love it <3

[timpest]

I was waiting to see Melanie's performance all night but glad they saved the best for last! I'll be heart broken if she doesn't make it. Wish the best for Rachel too.

[golo1955]

Amazing Talent, should go all the way.