See, the thing is -- just about anybody can attempt a weirdly-paced song in 'rubato' time (that is, no fixed time signature or beat except on the choruses) -- but it takes someone like Brian to pull it off and make it so amazing --
and are you like me: Do you mentally fill in the words "She belongs there..." from Wonderful just after the final bars of this?
this album is totally insane......and that's probably its genius. I like good vibrations on this album but the others are underrated. I like to think of it as Brian's concept album of songs sung to the tune of nursery rhymes or kids songs (if that makes any sense). It is definitely concept at its extreme.
Here's why this song is such a bother to so many people: It's got all the inner turmoil of SMILE but none of its optimism. This is the sound of a mind on the edge (Brian's) about to teeter over. It's got a kind of scariness to it, and represents the exact moment things started to go wrong. So, not for the surfin' and cruisin' crowd. Fits on the album, though...
@YearOfCam That's a good way to think of it. This album is clearly an under-produced, under-thought out work that was shat out because brian's bandmates were unsupportive squares. But you do get a real honesty from it... you unfortunately get the first cracks in brian's beautiful voice. shame to hear it just a few years later. totally shaved off the top 2/3 of it.
PLEASE READ: IF U WANT TO HEAR SMiLE by THE BEACH BOYS, NOT BRIAN WILSON, GO 2 MY CHANNEL AND GO TO MY PLAYLISTS AND SELECT THE ONE THAT SAYS "Smile 1967(SMiLE)" it contains original recordings by the Beach Boys
@iPL2001 I think this album was Brian Wilson's artistic way of telling Mike Love to basically go fuck himself for torching SMiLE. Funny how the Beach Boys couldn't sell any more records after they ran out of Brian's songs (with the notable exception of "Kokomo" which pretty much sucks, buth they were bound to get lucky at least once in twenty or so years)...
rbrupbacher...You childish, inane comment demonstrates why I dislike writing on forums such as these. In most cases, the idiots and the cretins come out of the woodwork. It is obvious that someone cannot express an opinion without people with third grade educations calling you names and the like. Too bad...
My brother was a dj for a radio station in upstate New York when this thing was released on a single, under the name of Brian Wilson and Mike Love. The record wasn't selling well, so a rep from Capitol records called the program director and told him "We need a little help on this one". The PD said to to rep "This record needs all the help it can get." It bombed...and rightly so. Utter garbage.
@You're right...it is getting deep in here; but it ain't water. Somebody farts in a microphone and you call it art music. I'll stick with radio-rock bop any day thank you.
@russieross You are incapable of analyzing a piece like this because your sonic palette is limited to the pop song paradigm. You will never appreciate the classics of 20th century rock music, such as Faust and other groups you've probably never heard of, unless you learn to branch out.
Back during the early, free days of Napster, I found an .mp3 version of this track, same take and in true stereo and has a slightly longer fade!! This is one of my favorite Beach Boys tracks ever!!
good vibrations? heroes & villians? i know we are talkin opinion here but with this album its pretty much a general consensus those two are the only actual completed songs.
i personally love H&V but many find it too unorthodox and "out there"... i see where those ppl are coming from so that's understood.
But i just cant imagine anyone thinking good vibrations is anything but the best song on the album. just my 2 cents.
Excellent 2 cents !!! But I also think that these songs were made complete on this release. I realise they were made to be a part of the Smile project, but each of what were originally intended to be sections or movements come across as a whole songs herein with their own identifiable arrangements. thanks jhp
oh, and the original version of "wonderful" made for the unreleased SMiLE is far superior to the stripped down, under-produced track included on Smiley.
i like the smiley "wonderful" too but it does not hold a candle to the original SMiLE arrangement. if you really like the song you NEED TO hear how Brian intended it... there are recordings and demos of it on youtube, you should check it out.
not to mention the one Brian recorded for the newly released SMiLE, you can hear the same arrangement
Maybe now that he is with Capitol and once he gets TLOS out, that would be one interesting choice. Getting out more boxsets seems quite boring and the material on Smiley Smile is quite an interesting project, quite different from the commercial Smile project. Taking the POB and Bambu special edition as an example, I was blown by the new material and that could be something that could be achieve with releasing material that probably many people haven't heard from the original Smile sessions.
This is definetly non commercial effort, yet has great melodies. BW version of Smile some 40 yrs after is a commercial one. In between those tapes available, they should be worked on and put out. Please let "She is Going Bald" out or get it out instrumentally.
This Reminds me of The Beatles : The Continuing Story Of Bungalow Bill ~ The way it was the rithem was arrange Are Almost The Same~
isaacbateman76 1 month ago
This was also issued under "Brian Wilson & Mike Love" as a Brother 45,too! Its flip? "Devoted To You",from the "Beach Boys' Party!" Lp.
mrmjb1960 1 month ago
@mrmjb1960
how could one aske for a greater fail-single...
alexandertarangerkin 10 hours ago
I love the nervous feeling of this song! A better production and this would of been a classic.
paul7703 2 months ago
the intro has the heroes and villains theme in it
Levelride311 3 months ago
seriously this is a sad piece of shit. and this is coming from a fan of the beach boys music. so under-produced.
NEWGUY562 3 months ago
Comment removed
alliant 2 months ago
See, the thing is -- just about anybody can attempt a weirdly-paced song in 'rubato' time (that is, no fixed time signature or beat except on the choruses) -- but it takes someone like Brian to pull it off and make it so amazing --
and are you like me: Do you mentally fill in the words "She belongs there..." from Wonderful just after the final bars of this?
YearOfCam 4 months ago
I love this song
coolsweetgroovy 5 months ago
@coolsweetgroovy that was fun.. it sounds a bit like honeypie on the prowl.. goodnight and thanks D !!
FinallyunderstandU 5 months ago
@FinallyunderstandU you're welcome CC
coolsweetgroovy 5 months ago
this album is totally insane......and that's probably its genius. I like good vibrations on this album but the others are underrated. I like to think of it as Brian's concept album of songs sung to the tune of nursery rhymes or kids songs (if that makes any sense). It is definitely concept at its extreme.
ancientloredude 5 months ago
The beat is Dan Deacon-esque
oakasfan124 5 months ago
Here's why this song is such a bother to so many people: It's got all the inner turmoil of SMILE but none of its optimism. This is the sound of a mind on the edge (Brian's) about to teeter over. It's got a kind of scariness to it, and represents the exact moment things started to go wrong. So, not for the surfin' and cruisin' crowd. Fits on the album, though...
YearOfCam 7 months ago
@YearOfCam That's a good way to think of it. This album is clearly an under-produced, under-thought out work that was shat out because brian's bandmates were unsupportive squares. But you do get a real honesty from it... you unfortunately get the first cracks in brian's beautiful voice. shame to hear it just a few years later. totally shaved off the top 2/3 of it.
Benefit1970 4 months ago
gettin hungry, yeah from smoking all that weed
Abe91195 7 months ago 4
0:29 orgasm.
<3
tomas18081993 9 months ago
Comment removed
Imaxination1980 9 months ago
straight influence of Manson. All Hail Charlie
jesuswasakike00 9 months ago
i'm not sure why but the beach boys are so special. i love them so much more than the beatles, but they are good too
popp1nbottlez 9 months ago
I know I'll end up having a true fondness and seeking sanctuary for this album as many of my fave VU, Tom Waits, Chameleons UK albums.
7Plots 9 months ago
PLEASE READ: IF U WANT TO HEAR SMiLE by THE BEACH BOYS, NOT BRIAN WILSON, GO 2 MY CHANNEL AND GO TO MY PLAYLISTS AND SELECT THE ONE THAT SAYS "Smile 1967(SMiLE)" it contains original recordings by the Beach Boys
SmileySmileAM 10 months ago
@dorkhunter1
Dorkhunterhunter.
That`s me. Your comments are retarded!
clintmagnum1 11 months ago
My favorite song!!!!!!!!!!
sebillanox 1 year ago
0:00 to 0:16. wow....
francoboy100 1 year ago
I'm not a huge Beach Boys fan, but this is damn brilliant.
ThePaleCow 1 year ago 2
@iPL2001 I think this album was Brian Wilson's artistic way of telling Mike Love to basically go fuck himself for torching SMiLE. Funny how the Beach Boys couldn't sell any more records after they ran out of Brian's songs (with the notable exception of "Kokomo" which pretty much sucks, buth they were bound to get lucky at least once in twenty or so years)...
bogenrim 1 year ago
Thanks for sharing these!
woodsbike 1 year ago
This is what I imagine insects hear when experiencing their primal lusts.
tpmableful 1 year ago
great tune!
stanleysoldman 1 year ago
rbrupbacher...You childish, inane comment demonstrates why I dislike writing on forums such as these. In most cases, the idiots and the cretins come out of the woodwork. It is obvious that someone cannot express an opinion without people with third grade educations calling you names and the like. Too bad...
russieross 1 year ago
My brother was a dj for a radio station in upstate New York when this thing was released on a single, under the name of Brian Wilson and Mike Love. The record wasn't selling well, so a rep from Capitol records called the program director and told him "We need a little help on this one". The PD said to to rep "This record needs all the help it can get." It bombed...and rightly so. Utter garbage.
russieross 1 year ago
You AND your brother suck.
rbrupbacher 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
russieross 1 year ago
@russieross Too deep for you, obviously. Enjoy your commercial radio-rock/pop. The rest of us will listen to art music.
MelancholyDane 1 year ago
@You're right...it is getting deep in here; but it ain't water. Somebody farts in a microphone and you call it art music. I'll stick with radio-rock bop any day thank you.
russieross 1 year ago
@russieross You are incapable of analyzing a piece like this because your sonic palette is limited to the pop song paradigm. You will never appreciate the classics of 20th century rock music, such as Faust and other groups you've probably never heard of, unless you learn to branch out.
MelancholyDane 1 year ago
@MelancholyDane You're a huge douche. If you're reading this, russieross, I'm not defending you. In fact, you too, are a douche
connor4211 1 year ago
The naive beauty of this track is incredible.
DanVaccaro55 1 year ago
Damn this was ahead of it's time..
jwild611 1 year ago 18
@jwild611 They just weren't made for those times.
apolitikmusic 6 months ago
Mike Love shines here like almost nowhere else. What an amazing song! I've never heard this before.
borskyviolin 2 years ago
This is simply amazing.
AllTheNuttyBits 2 years ago 2
Back during the early, free days of Napster, I found an .mp3 version of this track, same take and in true stereo and has a slightly longer fade!! This is one of my favorite Beach Boys tracks ever!!
weenielongus 2 years ago
I love Smiley Smile...Brian is a genius & I love the odd little quirky songs on this album...Brian opened new worlds...
absoluteabsence 2 years ago 2
Wikipedia says the public was "confused" upon the release of Smiley Smile.
I can only imagine...
iPL2001 2 years ago 27
Comment removed
bogenrim 1 year ago
@iPL2001 Fuck the public, this album is genious!
harmike17 1 year ago 9
better version did the faces!!!
oficina666 2 years ago
The Faces did a wicked version of this, now available on the Five Guys Walk Into A Bar.
DaveBarlow 2 years ago
Probably just an odd setting on Brians baldwin organ
crinkleman123 3 years ago
amazingly good
Thanks
pacoenigmatic 3 years ago
love this tune
the beginning reminds me of the Little Girl I Once Knew
peaceric 3 years ago
This and Wonderful are the best tracks on Smiley Smile.
Sephiroth20066 3 years ago
good vibrations? heroes & villians? i know we are talkin opinion here but with this album its pretty much a general consensus those two are the only actual completed songs.
i personally love H&V but many find it too unorthodox and "out there"... i see where those ppl are coming from so that's understood.
But i just cant imagine anyone thinking good vibrations is anything but the best song on the album. just my 2 cents.
bobshenix 2 years ago
Excellent 2 cents !!! But I also think that these songs were made complete on this release. I realise they were made to be a part of the Smile project, but each of what were originally intended to be sections or movements come across as a whole songs herein with their own identifiable arrangements. thanks jhp
BeachBoysGuy1 2 years ago
Vegetables is the best song on the album.
cutuphalfdead 1 year ago
oh, and the original version of "wonderful" made for the unreleased SMiLE is far superior to the stripped down, under-produced track included on Smiley.
i like the smiley "wonderful" too but it does not hold a candle to the original SMiLE arrangement. if you really like the song you NEED TO hear how Brian intended it... there are recordings and demos of it on youtube, you should check it out.
not to mention the one Brian recorded for the newly released SMiLE, you can hear the same arrangement
bobshenix 2 years ago
Mellotron?
crinkleman123 3 years ago
Mellotron is recorded tapes. i don't believe we hear this kind of thing in here. i can't make my own idea of what we hear.
humanvynil 3 years ago
a mellotron is an instrument, an early synthesizer with a keyboard.
sethisawesome 2 years ago
not one of my favourites off SS - but I *still* find myself singing it in the shower ALL THE TIME. :)
PoprocksCk 3 years ago
not bad. not exactly single material, though
stamlove0708 3 years ago
Maybe now that he is with Capitol and once he gets TLOS out, that would be one interesting choice. Getting out more boxsets seems quite boring and the material on Smiley Smile is quite an interesting project, quite different from the commercial Smile project. Taking the POB and Bambu special edition as an example, I was blown by the new material and that could be something that could be achieve with releasing material that probably many people haven't heard from the original Smile sessions.
quad1951 3 years ago
This is definetly non commercial effort, yet has great melodies. BW version of Smile some 40 yrs after is a commercial one. In between those tapes available, they should be worked on and put out. Please let "She is Going Bald" out or get it out instrumentally.
quad1951 3 years ago 4
do so much agree with you.. would love to have an official cd from original smile-recordings
oproller 3 years ago
pretty easy to find online. bootleg versions of smile. the ones i found are in the same track list as brian's finished one
caats19 3 years ago
great cut
musicistheproblem 3 years ago