Hilary Duff vs Hayden Panettiere

[Enix2738]

Long live Queen Duff!

[MadaPisy]

Hayden deffinitely..I dont like Hillary

[eledwyn1]

hayden

[FerrovieInRete]

Hayden!!

[heatherly93]

hilaryyyyy =p <3

[dindinpark]

HILARY DUFF !!

[xRinat]

Hayden Panettiere is the ideal girl!

[donahuge15]

HAYDEN!!!!

[lena9i]

hilary duff

[KrazyKryptonian]

Why fight? I pick 'em both!! :D ...The only problem here is the Ashlee Simpson song...it's somewhat annoying.

[Jordiefan1]

Hayden all the way!

[MrsRememberDecember]

Hayden more talanted

[maliavang10]

HILARY DUFF TOTALLY WON THIS FOR ME

[soyotelo]

I think hilary is prettier!

[FishyRyder]

hayden is way more better

[sam3314]

HAYDEN!! duff sucks disney balls!!

[TheBopification]

Hayden is too childish looking. Hilary is b-e-a-u-t-i-f-u-l and always has been!

[HayleyJL1]

Hayden

[DudefromMaryland]

Hayden looks more ordinary to me. I guess she's classically prettier. However Hilary is more appealing IMO. Same with Beyonce and Rihanna. Beyonce is an ordinary beauty while Rihanna looks different but still just as beautiful.

[Cupcake5121]

They're both amazing, but I prefer Hilary :)

[cherry1620]

Hayden!!!!!

[bbsice]

hayden way beautiful than hilary

[AtlasUniverse]

Of course Hayden. There is no even competition. Hayden wins in look, talend, IQ, singing. Hayden can act everything while Hilary can act only in stupid comedy fairytales

[ElleRuxAndra]

sorry * but i like both of them :D

[ElleRuxAndra]

i think they're both great! in some pics hayden is more prettier than hilary but in other pics its the contrary...don't hate me but i both of them

[sk8erdude192]

hayden

[Lithium027]

Hayden is waay more beautifull

[lunatic8364]

both gorgeous!

[TheGjkcity]

Hilary

[piggiebytime]

Hayden is GORGEOUS!

But Hilary all the way!

[BritneyCrazyDay]

esa gorda adelgazada de hilary,jeje!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[misseverly2006]

son bellas las dos por favor no pongan a competir a dos chicas bellas porq las dos tienen con q

[Animefan1908]

Lol OMG once again there's no comparison here.. hayden wins this she's freakin gorgeous! and a great actress.. i really dont see how people think hillary duff is hot..

[britneyspears8838]

hil

[georgeread101]

hayden wins

[sirjohnrambo]

Duff wins but they are both smokin

[8r38r3]

i think hilary looks better

[rob3132]

you guys kidding me hayden is way better...but eveyone had there choices hayden won this but hilary would if it was someone else but hayden..

[blossomcandy01]

Hilary is beautiful and hayden is cute and very talented. They are both photogenic.

[ThickyThickgurl07]

Hayden..I think Hilary is ugly most of the time. Hayden is always beautiful. Not to mention my favorite actress =D

[volton34]

hayden.shes hot

[makcub]

hayden. for sure.

[Jaly92Denmark]

HILARY !!! :D

[Slevin988]

It's a difficult choise...but I prefer Hayden...more charismatic...and she did Heroes...so yes I vote HAYDEN

[KairaLee18]

Hayden, but Hilary looks nice with dark hair

[animefreak3755]

Hilary. nuff said.

[gmlkbl08]

hmmm. hilary, but only by a mile !

[sarah120890]

Hayden is short and squattie :/

Hilary is just plain beautiful :]

[koyuki45236]

HILARY!

[PiinkPriincessPolkaD]

HILARY!!!

[xXm0nkeiiluvaxX]

hillary duff. hayden p is great and all but hilary duff is like more sexyy than her.

[lnlgirl95]

hayden all the wayyy!!!

[PsychdellicShrimp]

hayden is much hotter hilary's body is like a piece of paper

[LhyJ]

BOTH!!

[4EverBallin07]

hayden P no questions asked bitches

[Kinder101]

HIL!

[LingLingRox]

hayden panettiere any day she can act better she is cuterher shows are better. she's great

[olgaole]

Hilary B)

[tashaaanahhlikee]

Hayden By Farr :D

[PansyMk]

I am going to say this ok.

Hilary duff models and acts better than hayden

But hayden's show is a huge hit show!!

SO i would pick Hilary her looks natural put posed

[taylorwootress]

my bro says Hilary duff big time all da way even though hell never have or meet her

[luvmyboo26]

uhmm of course hayden shoot man it's not even a hard decision 4 me

[dannyb123321]

both equally as gorgeous

[amrl7]

i say hayden

[kaygabb]

hilarie is ugly. hayden is gorgeous!

[LordRockman82]

Both of them look good to me. But I prefer Hilary before she lost some pounds. Then she would be on Hayden body level.

[iilubhiimsomuch]

I LOVE BOTH OF THEM SO I CANT CHOOSE.

[captaincookiedo]

I say Hilary all the way.

[Godwill3]

hayden

[carmenfiorella]

they are both really gorgeous, but Hilary has more of a natural beauty & she doesnt have to try to look freakin amazing in every photo! XO

[chickuhchickuhyea]

i disagree completely....if u look at hilary duff without makeup, she doesn't compare to how Hayden looks...Hayden definitely has more natural beauty....

[BooHaha123]

hilary is a natural beauty but hayden is still growing so you cant actually assume that hilary is has more natural beauty yet anyway.

[Petukene10]

Hayden Panettiere is my fav. actress and she's so so beautiful .. i think it's defenittly HAYDEN PANETTIERE!

[ParisBoo00]

hilary

[fsuballer3]

no question its HP

[gothprincess31]

HD or HP. HD definetly

[theone4youu]

I like hayden better but the pics of hilary when she was blonde were hot.

[chanchan97]

probley hillary but if u look at them closly u can tell that hayden is giving hotter looks and is wereing hotter close and lots of people say i look alot like hillary duff! but thats not why i chose her well it sordof is why!

[sophiabushfan4eva]

i trully love hayden and she is a very good actor but hilary duff is more pretty..

[mandutz90]

hayden of course

she's much more talented in role

plus, she has that friendly aura (like danb3a said)..we just love to seen her...

she's pretty, kind.

hilary is pretty and kind too.but i think she's too thin now, look at her face, sometimes it's made me scared, cause sometimes her face has this "skull" look(i think it's because her cheek so thin}

however, ilove hilary too

but for hayden vs hil, i choose hayden

PLUS:hayden's boyfriend (a.k.a Milo ventimiglia) is SOOOOO HOTT

[srs955]

The reason she looks skinnier is because she grew up and she lost her baby fat. She's not too thin.

[namtab17]

HILARY!!

[najoob12]

hayden is much more beautiful than hilary duff

[supercrazy616]

hilary duff for sure, no doubt

[laktosinto]

Hayden

[rebelmememe]

what.....HAYDEN is soooo much more talented, prettier and sweeter!

[paulina81407]

HILARY

IS SO MUCH BETTER

=]

[mydogmilley911]

go hayden!!!!!

[johnyvie]

oh its hayden

[cate11795]

Hilary All The Way

[bhotpepper]

hayden!!!

[shariahshea]

Hilary!!

[98324116]

Hayden but it's a close call.

[leedsfreak08]

Hayden, but not by a long way.