@Musicmaster182 seriously. you can tell he just thinks of conor as just another guest that he doesn't know shit about and probably doesn't care either.. oh well there's more bright eyes fans than letterman fans anyway
In my English large group at school the teachers played this song for the poetry unit, they didn't check the sound first so when it came on it started LOUD, and everyone jumped a little. Made me proud to be a Bright Eyes fan
Also, LETTERMAN YOU'RE HOLDING IT UPSIDE DOWN YOU IDIOT!
@314aloneinthedark314 If it makes you feel better, many many people are waking up to the higher reality Conor sings so much about. I wonder, too. Do people know what he's talking about when he says "I'm happy just because, I found out I am really no one," "The world waits for an explosion, a burst of light to wipe the slate clean," "You will be free child when you have died to the shackles of language and measurable time." He's always writing about enlightenment. Very beautifully.
People asking "what is the girl for!!?!?!?" are dumb. She's part of the touring set-up of the band - she plays/sings on other songs and adds a bit of vocal depth to this one. She's part of the band, that's why she's there.
I dont like this... :/ I mean i love him he is an amazing musician and he was pure i know the message is still there but this has just lost the personality and the depth of his music :/ oh well still got his old tracks to listen to :)
Watch any of the Letterman appearances. You can get hints from every appearance that Letterman does NOT like Conor Oberst or Bright Eyes. He's just rude, goes out of his way to be apathetic, and has that "I'm going to pretend I care, but only barely" attitude. Then again, I guess he's like that to a lot of his musical guests.
You don't have to be excited or like every band that comes on the show, but there's some professionalism in putting on a smile and being respectful to your guest, right?
@missxcaliforniaa I know she isn't playing much in this song but they are a band so I think it's cool that she is there and play her little thing in the end. I don't think she is the one who wants to be there because it must be kind of awkward being on stage when you don't play anything most of the song.
@TimmyDerrick yea i dont think letterman knew what was going on like theharmon232002 said "grunting" then "thats it?" letterman just became a douche in my book. reno band? wtf?
@emmaexile let me reiterate, I am not trying to sound like a douche. Just an observation :) am I wrong with anything I said? The fact that she's famous doesn't exempt her from criticism. @missxcaliforniaa I agree, she's very pretty :) @awholelotofheart I do sing in a band, and when I duet with my guitar player I try to emphasize the harmony because it produces a richer and more beautiful sound. I couldn't even hear her voice against conor's. I just didn't see any need for her to be there. :/
At the risk of sounding like a douche...what is the girl even doing there? She's standing behind the keyboard, not playing it till 3 minutes in when she does a one-handed solo, and when she sings you can't even hear her. Could be the fault of the sound guys but all she seems to be doing is dancing awkwardly...
@pokerbabe779 are you not a musician? i'm just curious, because if you are you would know she doesn't need to be the most dominant sound, it's the balance of her voice against conor's. it's a tone color thing.
@whatcoulditbe98 I just got into them, saw them open for conor (and she played the keys as well during his set). I had yet to purchase or look them up yet. To be honest Mynabirds is a wonderful name for a band. It is always nice when an opening act surprises you.
This reminds me of "old" Bright Eyes so much: the song, the lyrics, the "jam" feeling that comes with a big group, even the way Conor is dressed and coiffed, haha. Don't get me wrong-- I love just about everything he's ever done-- but "The People's Key" also has that added element of nostalgia (at least for me). Can't wait to see them in June... I scored pre-sale tickets in Philadelphia. Totally worth the 6 hour drive, as I've only gotten to see him with the Mystic Valley Band. :)
I saw bright eyes on thursday. At the end of their set Conor said that the girl on stage was Laura Laurent. Now everyone can stop talking about this mysterious person. She's a woman who is still alive.
so what's the big deal about the new Vintage Vibe keyboard? I couldn't hear it at all - sounded like a synth. I thought it was supposed to be an electric piano a la Rhodes/Wurly.
I don't want to be one of those annoying fans who only like a band's old stuff and write off anything new or musically different. But with this being their last album, I don't know, I'm kinda disappointed by the new direction and I think they could've done a lot more/better :( But I will always love them and hopefully come to like Conor's new music.
I'm guessing that this is the national television debut of the new Vintage Vibe electric piano, which is based on Rhodes tine/tonebar engineering. A beautiful instrument, it's a shame that its sound wasn't featured more prominently.
It's hard to watch performances on Letterman. The performances are great, but I get annoyed by his hardly-disguised "I don't give a shit about this crap" attitude toward musical guests.
@takingbackchance what's a vinyl? I just thought it was some sort of novelty-sized CD, perhaps an audio laserdisc. I had no idea what a vinyl was, I was merely pointing out to PULCHRITDUNOUS that it seemed to be larger than, say, a normal CD. But thank you for making me aware of this "vinyl".
@nadca2 'retarded' is a bit offensive but honestly its just that in situations like these god loves to fuck with me and ensure somehow, someway that i dont flip back in time or something and really i think it was more of a joke regardless. 'retarded,' wow. id always thought bright eyes fans were more or less nice ish people specially when it came to a little joke about their band.
Andy LeMaster, Clark Baechle, and Laura Burhenn in the backing band?!? Hell yeah, that's like a Saddle Creek all-star cast. If only Jenny Lewis and Jason Boesel were playing with them. Then they'd be unstoppable.
4:03 Letterman blows a load for Conor.
StevenHartley7 1 week ago
"Reno owned" god letterman is annoying it's renowned you prick. Conor is fucking amazing as usual.
candyberried 3 weeks ago
Mogis owning the day again!
08hosavp 3 weeks ago
go listen to kodachrome
facefullofgreatness 3 weeks ago
was he nervous?
drcroc2 1 month ago
this was the one time i watched letterman and i discovered a new fav band
drvonfrie 2 months ago
im tired
4everamystery 2 months ago
this video/song makes me do the Carlton dance
drcroc2 2 months ago
LOL don't head bang conor ,its just not you
AvelFantasma 2 months ago
That diamond shirt again.
brownteal21 2 months ago
Comment removed
TheNeptune47 3 months ago
I hear Albert Hammond Jr on guitar but i don't see him..
randypaysan 3 months ago
That's Laura Burhenn you idiots, and she's perfect ok.
uniqueindying 4 months ago
I'd hate to put some negative vibe in this incredible performance but, fuck letterman...
Musicmaster182 4 months ago
@Musicmaster182 seriously. you can tell he just thinks of conor as just another guest that he doesn't know shit about and probably doesn't care either.. oh well there's more bright eyes fans than letterman fans anyway
fly55556 3 months ago
Is that CC on the drummer bass kick stand for Chastworth???
DrivenBlack 4 months ago
@DrivenBlack his "drummer bass kick stand" (kick drum head) is C&C for C&C Custom Drums
megadeth773 4 months ago
@megadeth773 Ahhhh okay thanks. It just looks exactly like my high school logo
DrivenBlack 4 months ago
David Letterman is the least funny person alive. How is he still on television? Reno owned? My word, that's lame.
TheUnicorn4711 4 months ago
What does Laura Burhenn actually do?
brightredrain 5 months ago
@brightredrain little beeps and boops
SuperBatman900 3 months ago
@brightredrain everything. she is the queen of all.
awholelotofheart 3 months ago
I wanna run my fingers through his hair. Looks so soft. Oh I'm so in love. xD
JennaLove163 5 months ago 2
I'm going to see Bright Eyes tomorrow night! I'm so excited! Conor, his music, his mind, everything about him is just so damn beautiful.
jcreate8 5 months ago
i love his shirt.
vintagefaire 5 months ago
these guys sound so incredible playing music
AtomicAtari 5 months ago
I might have found my new favorite band.
greendaythebeatles 6 months ago 4
@greendaythebeatles Best band everrrrrrrrrrr
charias72 5 months ago
prettyloather: changes taking place spiritually in humanity.. look up the sumarian tablets
314aloneinthedark314 6 months ago
Was that a good performance?
justadreammmm 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why are they so amazing?
FrozenCompass 6 months ago
Comment removed
FrozenCompass 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
out of all the perverted youtube comment people nobody pointed out how really pretty the keyboard player is?
venturaproductions 7 months ago
In my English large group at school the teachers played this song for the poetry unit, they didn't check the sound first so when it came on it started LOUD, and everyone jumped a little. Made me proud to be a Bright Eyes fan
Also, LETTERMAN YOU'RE HOLDING IT UPSIDE DOWN YOU IDIOT!
SidewaysIsDead 7 months ago 6
I love when Paul says "Aww. Too Bad.." TehehehehehefhehehfeWIHJSADLKFpoot
JustinSoileauMusic 7 months ago
LOOK AT MIKE GOOOOO
aperfectsonnet123 7 months ago
oh man... letterman in 1080p?
no Bueno...
thankyou4thevenom8 7 months ago
damn the girl probobly feels extremely awkward nodding her head while everyone else rocks the fuck out
ACleverName17 7 months ago 3
<3 yes
BloomingWithJoy1 7 months ago
i dont know if people are even aware what he's singing about
314aloneinthedark314 7 months ago
@314aloneinthedark314 If it makes you feel better, many many people are waking up to the higher reality Conor sings so much about. I wonder, too. Do people know what he's talking about when he says "I'm happy just because, I found out I am really no one," "The world waits for an explosion, a burst of light to wipe the slate clean," "You will be free child when you have died to the shackles of language and measurable time." He's always writing about enlightenment. Very beautifully.
windykian 7 months ago
@314aloneinthedark314 what is he singing about that you think ppl are missing?
PrettyLoather 7 months ago
i dont know if people are even aware what he's singing about
314aloneinthedark314 7 months ago
he's not the dylan of our generation. he's conor oberst and that is equal.
mils0r 8 months ago 28
@mils0r damn right mate.. i love dylan but conor?? at least his equal, at least :)
dazzfunster 3 months ago
@mils0r Spot on
TheNeptune47 3 months ago
@mils0r Dylan doesn't have shit on Oberst, lyrically.
TXTGX 2 months ago
People asking "what is the girl for!!?!?!?" are dumb. She's part of the touring set-up of the band - she plays/sings on other songs and adds a bit of vocal depth to this one. She's part of the band, that's why she's there.
Masteryre 8 months ago 2
what a great lyricist....the Dylan of the new age... poet....AND incredible in a live performance!
kcDakota 8 months ago 2
Still Love you, conor~
TomSplasky 8 months ago
hahah i like his shirt i wish i could be conor oberst for a day
xghost0fyoux560 8 months ago
The instrumentation sounded like The Bravery or something. Odd. I love how Conor still looks like a kid.
TearsAmongAshes 8 months ago 2
I don't know if anyone has said yet or not, but the keyboardist is laura burhenn, she is playing with them on this recent tour
TheBear64507 8 months ago
I dont like this... :/ I mean i love him he is an amazing musician and he was pure i know the message is still there but this has just lost the personality and the depth of his music :/ oh well still got his old tracks to listen to :)
MaK9123 8 months ago
I feel bad for Conor. He must hate being there.
Musicmaster182 8 months ago
what is exactly that girl for?
ikomplex 8 months ago 3
who is this mystery keyboard girl? its very important because we are getting married
MrReverendgreen 8 months ago 40
@MrReverendgreen Not if I get there first my friend.
Darce223 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Darce223 we can share
MrReverendgreen 8 months ago
Comment removed
charias72 5 months ago
@MrReverendgreen I think she's the lead singer of the mynabirds (sp?).
PrettyLoather 2 months ago
@MrReverendgreen Her name is Laura Burhenn from Georgie James
audrey60hepburn 1 month ago
Watch any of the Letterman appearances. You can get hints from every appearance that Letterman does NOT like Conor Oberst or Bright Eyes. He's just rude, goes out of his way to be apathetic, and has that "I'm going to pretend I care, but only barely" attitude. Then again, I guess he's like that to a lot of his musical guests.
You don't have to be excited or like every band that comes on the show, but there's some professionalism in putting on a smile and being respectful to your guest, right?
xBradums 8 months ago
I was about to comment on how Im pretty sure that Dave isn't a fan, then I read all the other comments. I'm glad I'm not the only one that noticed.
Chasingtailsmusic 9 months ago
laura get out you're not even doing anything aldfkhakdfh
missxcaliforniaa 9 months ago
@missxcaliforniaa I know she isn't playing much in this song but they are a band so I think it's cool that she is there and play her little thing in the end. I don't think she is the one who wants to be there because it must be kind of awkward being on stage when you don't play anything most of the song.
soCtra 9 months ago
@soCtra at least she and conor match- lol
missxcaliforniaa 8 months ago
Letterman definatly does not have Bright Eyes on his Ipod. Look at how quickly he shunned them off the stage.
roastbeefdj 9 months ago
I wish he didnt grow his hair out again. i figured he grew out of that shit. he looked his best in MoF era
enjoyinxy 9 months ago
@enjoyinxy he probably needed to get laid again
MeesterCrumpet 9 months ago
The Album Was Upside Down.
Damn Letterman!!!
TimmyDerrick 9 months ago
@TimmyDerrick yea i dont think letterman knew what was going on like theharmon232002 said "grunting" then "thats it?" letterman just became a douche in my book. reno band? wtf?
nofxb182 9 months ago
How about Letterman grunting when they finish (4:05?)
TheHarmon232002 9 months ago
till all that remains is a staircase of misinformation
THElluis1 9 months ago
@THElluis1
favorite line <3333 conor's a genius
BobbyLeshinski 9 months ago
we are jejune stars
THElluis1 9 months ago 2
wow he sounds good!
iknowme 9 months ago
click 3:59 repeatedly for lulz
nunrgtrance2 9 months ago
he's bad live
Desolyt 9 months ago
@Desolyt What? Fuck no.
He's better live if anything.
ShawnGeeMusician 9 months ago
@ShawnGeeMusician
his voice shakes and he can't hold a pitch :/ don't get me wrong i love his studio work
Desolyt 9 months ago
@Desolyt Ah I can see how that would turn you off, I do like the unique-ness but i understand and respect your point of view :)!
ShawnGeeMusician 9 months ago
I saw him a week before that in Berlin, it was unbelievable.
jouetdudestin 9 months ago
I'm so glad I bought the vinyl version. It's S-W-E-E-T!!!
TheIncredibleBAGMAN 10 months ago
love his shirt.
parodypertiki 10 months ago
I watch this like once a day. Is that a problem?
V1NTAST1C 10 months ago 4
did anyone hear letterman's little grunt at the end? it almost ruined the ending!
BrightEyes10003 10 months ago
@emmaexile let me reiterate, I am not trying to sound like a douche. Just an observation :) am I wrong with anything I said? The fact that she's famous doesn't exempt her from criticism. @missxcaliforniaa I agree, she's very pretty :) @awholelotofheart I do sing in a band, and when I duet with my guitar player I try to emphasize the harmony because it produces a richer and more beautiful sound. I couldn't even hear her voice against conor's. I just didn't see any need for her to be there. :/
pokerbabe779 10 months ago
@pokerbabe779 a bit of eye candy and for detail. whats your band called i wants to see if your any good
mguygh 10 months ago
damn mike mogis got nuts on guitar
gen6k 10 months ago
@pokerbabe779 that's laura fucking burhenn, who the hell are you?
emmaexile 10 months ago
At the risk of sounding like a douche...what is the girl even doing there? She's standing behind the keyboard, not playing it till 3 minutes in when she does a one-handed solo, and when she sings you can't even hear her. Could be the fault of the sound guys but all she seems to be doing is dancing awkwardly...
pokerbabe779 10 months ago 2
@pokerbabe779 well... at least she's pretty anyway :p
missxcaliforniaa 10 months ago
@pokerbabe779 are you not a musician? i'm just curious, because if you are you would know she doesn't need to be the most dominant sound, it's the balance of her voice against conor's. it's a tone color thing.
awholelotofheart 10 months ago
@pokerbabe779 She sang some pretty rockin' solo work when I saw them last week. Seriously, this chick rocks.
TheSim1derful 8 months ago
pure gold, as is the album.
Braatwurscht 10 months ago
@oitoy i didnt say that i didnt know what he was doing or i found it weird or anything like that. i said i wouldnt know how to RESPOND to it
BrightEyes10003 10 months ago
does anyone know the chords?
IsItNotEnuff2BJustMe 10 months ago
@TheEtaCarta
hahaha!
best possible response
fa sho
Crystalbug07 11 months ago
CONOR AND THE KEYBOARDIST'S OUTFITS MATCH!
BrightEyes10003 11 months ago 34
@BrightEyes10003
thats jenny lewis silly
MrPohnpeiboy 9 months ago
@MrPohnpeiboy no it isnt, and the patterns are similar,but different
MeesterCrumpet 9 months ago
@BrightEyes10003 Probably his new girlfriend :P
sexyandybbz 7 months ago
i love that chick from the minor birds
iSmkoeBluntsToMyFace 11 months ago
@iSmkoeBluntsToMyFace Mynabirds. And yeah, she is great!
whatcoulditbe98 11 months ago
@whatcoulditbe98 I just got into them, saw them open for conor (and she played the keys as well during his set). I had yet to purchase or look them up yet. To be honest Mynabirds is a wonderful name for a band. It is always nice when an opening act surprises you.
iSmkoeBluntsToMyFace 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out TOMORROWS REALLY YESTERDAY . Good new band. Youtube.com/user/trymusicvids/
trymusicvids 11 months ago
@skary also tim kasher wouldnt hurt
anelephantsroom 11 months ago
Conor looks like he's struggling to reach the mic. Aw. Favorite song from The People's Key most definitely.
eveningkitchen 11 months ago
as much as i love conor, i wouldn't know how to respond if he did to me what he did at 2:51....
BrightEyes10003 11 months ago 2
@BrightEyes10003 do it back!
TheEtaCarina 11 months ago
Bright Eyes was amazing at SXSW! Its too bad it had to end.
dizzane00 11 months ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This guys is a weak singer in real life
fallenpumpkinhead 11 months ago
what kind of guitar is mike playing? It's driving me crazy. He always has the best guitars.
SKExies 11 months ago
This reminds me of "old" Bright Eyes so much: the song, the lyrics, the "jam" feeling that comes with a big group, even the way Conor is dressed and coiffed, haha. Don't get me wrong-- I love just about everything he's ever done-- but "The People's Key" also has that added element of nostalgia (at least for me). Can't wait to see them in June... I scored pre-sale tickets in Philadelphia. Totally worth the 6 hour drive, as I've only gotten to see him with the Mystic Valley Band. :)
kate81585 11 months ago
that guy is like 8 different people and they are all awesome.
jordanhackney 11 months ago 59
@jordanhackney im not sure what u mean when u say he is 8 different people
getup2727 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this actually isn't very good
floorbands 11 months ago
@floorbands youre actually not very right
BrightEyes10003 11 months ago
This isn't their last album.
doitinasubmarine 11 months ago
I saw bright eyes on thursday. At the end of their set Conor said that the girl on stage was Laura Laurent. Now everyone can stop talking about this mysterious person. She's a woman who is still alive.
sshizzzam 11 months ago 4
I vote Conan gets Bright Eyes as a musical guest..
leighxcore11 11 months ago 5
@leighxcore11 yes, that would be more than awesome!
cherrymonarch85 11 months ago
so what's the big deal about the new Vintage Vibe keyboard? I couldn't hear it at all - sounded like a synth. I thought it was supposed to be an electric piano a la Rhodes/Wurly.
dude999998 11 months ago
@dude999998 He's got it running through the effects pedal on top
derfsup 11 months ago
I don't want to be one of those annoying fans who only like a band's old stuff and write off anything new or musically different. But with this being their last album, I don't know, I'm kinda disappointed by the new direction and I think they could've done a lot more/better :( But I will always love them and hopefully come to like Conor's new music.
branflake95 11 months ago
Wow, I cant wait for them to fuck my earholes into an audio ecstasy of delight in Chicago with Mynabirds. Jumba Wumba, Batman...
danimal150 11 months ago
i love this band lol
drvonfrie 11 months ago
Seeing Them today in South Beach, Should be a fabulous show.
mannyvash 11 months ago
If I was there I would be FREAKING out...I don't understand how the audience can watch Conor Oberst play and clap so unenthusiastically.
laurahop27 1 year ago
Comment removed
ItsFlod 1 year ago
Does anyone else see Letterman wondering off to the side at 1:56?
ItsFlod 1 year ago 3
@ItsFlod can you blame him?
scrollandkey 11 months ago
Laura Burhenn is so beautiful. listen to her band Mynabirds
MilleniumKing13 1 year ago
Solid performance! new record is a great chance of pace
wook523 1 year ago
I'm guessing that this is the national television debut of the new Vintage Vibe electric piano, which is based on Rhodes tine/tonebar engineering. A beautiful instrument, it's a shame that its sound wasn't featured more prominently.
aarfeld 1 year ago
Is she just there to look pretty?
doitinasubmarine 1 year ago
@doitinasubmarine ... she's playing keyboards and backup singing. Stop being sexist.
derdriui 1 year ago
@derdriui How am I being sexist? I could apply the same comment to a guy. I'm suggesting that she doesn't look like she's doing very much.
doitinasubmarine 11 months ago
@doitinasubmarine
Pretty obvious she's there to wear that dress so Conor's shirt doesn't look so bad. I love Nate all quiet in the back kickin serious ass.
Waxinasss 11 months ago
So glad Conor's hair is back.
leighxcore11 1 year ago 3
@leighxcore11 I know the music sounded horrible when he had short hair.
doitinasubmarine 11 months ago
i've replaying this all day, everyday sine the 24<3
sherinaNikkie8 1 year ago
looks like they didn't rehearse enough for this
drcroc2 1 year ago
I got hit in my face by the Telecaster guitar that Conor's using here. LOL
DrenthMaurice 1 year ago 5
It's hard to watch performances on Letterman. The performances are great, but I get annoyed by his hardly-disguised "I don't give a shit about this crap" attitude toward musical guests.
xBradums 1 year ago 6
I love how Conor grunts into the bass mic at the end lol.
link182ava44 1 year ago 4
good luv that synth man yeah u outta see him in austin city limits looked crazy
TheBerserkpanda 1 year ago
Holy shit Conor is rigid when he plays.
sonorpaiste702 1 year ago
@sonorpaiste702 His movements remind me of older videos I've seen of Tom Petty.
whereartesteban 1 year ago
@whereartesteban Yeah. I don't know, he's just so tense it makes me cringe trying to think of playing guitar like that.
sonorpaiste702 1 year ago
looks like mike is playing some sort of custom fano guitar
pikopanda1 1 year ago
where the fuck did that shirt come from dear god my eyes
robotbears49 1 year ago
i cant wait to see him this summer in omaha! home town shows are always the best
hcfillman 1 year ago
@takingbackchance what's a vinyl? I just thought it was some sort of novelty-sized CD, perhaps an audio laserdisc. I had no idea what a vinyl was, I was merely pointing out to PULCHRITDUNOUS that it seemed to be larger than, say, a normal CD. But thank you for making me aware of this "vinyl".
mfwilkens 1 year ago
Great performance, is he wearing Macbeth shoes?
DrummersNVRSAYDIE 1 year ago
Get to see them March 16th
twigj93 1 year ago
I love bright eyes with all my heart. im so happy they're back!!!!
CrystalWTHS 1 year ago
mike is so cute
lasofia13 1 year ago 3
@nadca2 'retarded' is a bit offensive but honestly its just that in situations like these god loves to fuck with me and ensure somehow, someway that i dont flip back in time or something and really i think it was more of a joke regardless. 'retarded,' wow. id always thought bright eyes fans were more or less nice ish people specially when it came to a little joke about their band.
ixainsophaurxi 1 year ago
It's all about December 21st 2012
7MRsilkgrow 1 year ago
Get learned jerk's your all going to come into a consciousness or die if your a terrible person. Let's face it you probably are.
7MRsilkgrow 1 year ago
does anyone know what kind of guitar mike is playing?
boonetip00 1 year ago
@boonetip00 looks like an old fender jaguar not positive though
weross95 1 year ago
Andy LeMaster, Clark Baechle, and Laura Burhenn in the backing band?!? Hell yeah, that's like a Saddle Creek all-star cast. If only Jenny Lewis and Jason Boesel were playing with them. Then they'd be unstoppable.
skary 1 year ago 24
This is love.
Emericanization 1 year ago
nice job
frankk1979 1 year ago
Comment removed
pbird83 1 year ago
@pbird83 When she couldn't get any cuter... she transforms into Laura Burhenn.
deliax1 1 year ago
@deliax1 Shit.. oops.
pbird83 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Chicago next month! can't wait @_@
erikauntitled 1 year ago
I'm in love.
cowsrock14 1 year ago
i like his bowl cut
kelseycarrollable 1 year ago