Added: 2 years ago
From: livelovemusik42
Views: 1,009,888
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,719)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Ofcourse in the album...Jesus of Suburbia forget her name..but in real life...Billie's knows it's Amanda...Billie's is so fucking Genius

  • SAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HAPPENED TO ME :(

  • This song always reminds me of a best friend I used to have. She introduced me to Green Day, her and me were like sisters, she told me she would be moving soon and I got upset and tried to help her with changing her parents minds, then near the end of the school year she suddenly decided to start hating me, she said mean things did mean things, then when summer break started her family moved away. Since then she keeps in contact with all of my friends that were also her friends.

  • How did he forget the name? Even I know it's amanda!

  • i asked this girl out but she said she wasn't allowed, she doesn't want to tell me if she would go out with me if she was allowed, is that a bad sign?

  • @BardotBB17 probably... if i were you i would probably ask again

  • this song is to fucking short... why can't all the songs on this album be 10 minutes long or longer???

  • @Zdravkocar good luck (:

  • I really love this song!! :)

  • I'm going to learn how to play guitar and sing this at the talent show

  • I think we all come her to listen to this song and remember the times we had with that someone. For me, it was my former best friend who i was in love with. She didnt feel the same way and out of anger, i threw her out of my life. My greatest regret.

  • Sooo close to a million for this video. I made it in time

  • Guys.... her name is amanda. it's been confirmed by billie-joe.... life complete

  • Looking at all these comments...I think we can all relate to this song in some way or another :)

    We hope to post our own cover of this song soon :D Peace!

  • I just figured out that the bitch who rejected me actually likes me, but still won't go out with me.

  • @Pinhead224 Wow wtf that sucks dude :( that happened to a good mate of mine recently

  • This could've been a great single!

  • I heard this because of Lil Wayne belee dat, and I think its a great song brr

  • I remember the face but I can't recall the name

  • Dis song always pops into ma head whenever dat special female r on ma thoughts ,damn

  • The best Green Day song, why wasn't it released as a single?

  • this song deserves more than a million views..

  • The bass at 3:10 is incredible

  • justin bieber fuck him green day are real music

  • iv literly heard every green day song like sweet children and everything exept for this song.......today i listend to it.......musicgasm

  • Should I sing this to a girl who rejected me? I need suggestions.

  • @Pinhead224 yeah it fits because you were friends then she rejects you now she's away and you have to take a different path and the regrets are useless in your mind cuz she's in your head jajaja i'm in a situation like that and i have listened to this song and it fits

  • @eddrums666 Nice.

  • @Pinhead224 no, keep your dignity.

  • @Pinhead224 If She Rejected You , She's Obviously Not Worth You Singing Such A Beautiful Song To Her .

  • @alwayslovingjbx3 I'm going to first tell her my feelings.

  • I re-wrote this song (w/ a happy ending) and covered it (vocally) and plan on giving to who I hope will become my girlfriend. I knew her from school, but after graduation, I lost contact with her. I recently caught back up with her through work. I remember listening to Green Day around the time we were in High School and this song in particular was my favorite at the time. This song kinda speaks about losing contact with someone, which is what happened with me. I'm hoping she'll like my cover.

  • @yoshi8869 best of luck to you man

  • @yoshi8869 Upload it :)

  • @yoshi8869 Post it and post if she does!!

  • @yoshi8869 Please, let me know how your story finish

  • @guekman Technically, the story's not finished. She turned me down on Valentine's Day, saying she didn't want to ruin our friendship. But, her friend texted me saying that she made a mistake turning me down. I want to trust her friend, but I don't know how to ask her out again. I'm gonna try again when I see her on Tuesday. I'll post the video after she says yes. Since you guys seem interested, I'll let you know on this video when it's posted.

  • @yoshi8869

    Tonight I will tell my friend that I know 12 years ago, that I love her.

    I'm just crazy because of her. Last year, I found out that I love her but I didn't have a strenght to say her that. But I can't live with it anymore, I must show my feelings or it'll be too late.

    Now, I'm so afraid.. I don't want to ruin our friendship. She means world to me. :(

    Tomorrow I'll tell you what happened..

    Wish me a luck!

  • @Zdravkocar how did it go im dying to know

  • @yoshi8869 own thts soo sweet I bet she will love it, where are you gunna sing it to her?

  • @yoshi8869

    put your cover on youtube? :3

  • @yoshi8869 wow it will be really awkward if she doesnt like it

  • @PS160895 She liked it. We're a couple now :) I'd release the video, but I lost it on my computer. Just know all went well in the end. Thx for top comment. Don't know if I was really deserving of that. I was just commenting. I wasn't posting "first" or "kill the dislikers". I was doing something most people don't do on YouTube anymore. I commented.

  • Damn, this comment above me Really sets out from the old from new youtube

    

  • And in the darkest night

    If my memory serves me right

    I'll never turn back time

    Forgetting you but not the time

  • Anyone wanna hear some good music, check out NIM VIND...search bitter end, killer creature

  • She broke me down. Im 26, been through hell for over 3 years. joined a spiritual group for alcohol, helped myself every way I could, quit smoking,

    ate healthy, took medicine, cleaned up every fuckin area of my life I possibly can, LEARNT a lot about life, im 26 years old, moving on, truly dont love her anymore, completely sober 12 step person whos recovered from poor health addictions and everything, not that anyone cares but I aint dying for her...or anyone...gonna go have my 5 star meal!

  • @frumpify good for you ;D

    congratulations!

  • i remember listening to this song with my friend Tyler on our way home from a roadtrip, we were basically listening to Green Day the whole way back, haha. American Idiot is a favorite of ours, and we basically bonded over Green Day in the first place. i learned a lot about punk from the guy, he's learned more than he'd like about metal, haha. good times, good times. haha

  • Nikki, she currently is my girlfriend...Idk why, she's cheated on me more times I could remember, I quit weed and she wouldn't, I ask her to not do things but she's lies about it...its hard for me to break up with her because I feel so attached to the one who took my virginity

  • Finally listened to the entire American Idiot album in sequence without stop. All I can say is, "huh." Nice little story of most every person who moves from the religious suburbs to a larger city. Each song played to a small, but important story of Jesus of Suburbia.

    It's interesting to see how everyone replied to each song like it was its own.

    As for this final one... it's the resolution of the album and finally closing off that last tie (whatsername) to the rest of the story (album).

  • Her name was Lexi, I went to Michigan for Spring Break and met her, we talked and messed around all of spring break, we got each others numbers. Every spring break I went up there, she kissed me more times then I could count, she never mentioned her boyfriend. He walked in on us kissing, I didn't know how to react when I heard her say to me "Ew, get away from me creep!" and jumped into his arms, He broke my left arm, right leg, and 3 ribs, I broke his nose, she broke my heart...

  • @blindgamerz125 I feel you man, I've been there :/

  • Her name was Emma, Soon after she met me we became really close, texting and talking everyday. She had been closer than any Girlfriend I ever had. But she had told me she couldn't love me cause she had a boyfriend, even after all of the Dirty Talk and Kisses I got. She fucked me up.. Emotionally. We shared a lot of memories and I'll never forget them, she now attends High School, Smoking all the weed and drinking all she can.. While I'm here left with the memories of who she actually was...

  • I can't listen to this without crying... I keep thinking if my ex thinks it when he's with her... Wonder if anybody remembers me...

  • Fuck your dubstep! This is real music!

  • @Mikaila1O i like dubstep and i like this...problem?

  • @themorganator4 and what? Am I supposed to care or something?

  • @Mikaila1O That's What I Told My Boyfriend Too ;p

  • @Mikaila1O well I do love both green day and dubstep, I have almost every single CD of green day and that doesn't means that dubstep sucks. They won't judge you if you don't judge them bro

  • @theguyofmexico I'm just not a fan.. compare the two & you'll see my point, green day is real music with lyrics & instruments & a bit of passion! Dubstep is just someone sitting a computer mixing a loaf of beep noises together.. you're telling me that's music?

  • @Mikaila1O of course it music, but by their style, don't get me wrong, green day its my favorite band, but there still tastes, every kind of music is good.. except for bieber of course.

  • @theguyofmexico its just my opinion, dubstep & skrillex don't even compare to the likes of green day if i'm honest! & judging by the thumbs up, 35 people agree.. we can agree there anyway!

  • @Mikaila1O ok, its seems that you wont understand so I wont insist. I was just giving my opinion, but im respecting yours, is that ok for you?

  • @theguyofmexico I respect your opinion but I just disagree, I didn't ask for thumbs up but i got it, obviously I'm not alone in thinking modern day music like that is shit, I sound like my dad or something.. but I'm 15.

  • @Mikaila1O Sometimes I feel like that too! well yes, you're right theres a lot of shit on the music studios right now, but well at least green day is still alive and I don't know if you already know but they're recording a new album!!! FUCK YEAH! btw I'm 15 too, good music for the young people! l..l

  • @theguyofmexico YESSS! Glad to hear that! That'll hopefully keep Flo Rida off the top for a while, it's just annoying how we grew up as children listening to good, decent music, soon as we hit the teens it all turns into that?

  • @Mikaila1O Totally agree! the diference between green day and those "artists" is that we got REAL lyrics, not bullshit.

  • Seth.......</3

  • I can actually relate to this song in a different way... When I was younger, I used to be happy, confident, and cool. Everyone liked me and I was never alone... Now I'm older and always sad and lonely. It seems like I almost imagined that period of time where I could be happy. It's like I'm a different person, and the one I used to be has gone away.

  • @BleeperTheGreat I know what you mean...It's like Whatsername is the old me. That's crap, I know.

  • @LoveSpike93 I don't know where the other half of me went. I wonder if she's having a good time. -Sigh-

  • Actually my bf broke up with me and I literally collapsed. Now today he told one of my friends to tell me that I was annoying, I hadn't even talked to him until that day. My friend said he calls me whatshername. :/ Funny how everything he said, he actually lied about to me. Now he's just somebody I used to know

  • @zelda1OOO1 is he calling you whatshername in relation to this song?

  • Her name was Jessica....I think it was anyways, I was 17 and she was 16. We met on the beach whilst I was playing guitar...The 8 months we spent together were amazing. I forgot everything but her face, I ripped all the pictures up when she moved away. I wouldn't turn back time but I'll never forget it either.

  • I like it I like it I want moer of of itt if I l ilke i t I li ke the song song thie soin s is great iff This song is the best song in so ng oij ff l thiss song

  • 39 people remember the face but they can't recall the name

  • I think this song is in the point of view of tiger woods

  • @fictiobfodder in ur moms ass : ) ..

    This song is fuckin amaiziiiing!¡!¡!

  • Awesome song

  • The best song of American idiot .-.

  • blink 182 stockholm syndrome

  • Tu Polacy. przejmujemy ta zajebista piosenke! :D

  • After I failed as a best friend and failed as making her my girlfriend, this song is all the consolation I had back then. But, the regrets are still useless, it seems like forever ago

  • Where did the rock ballads go?

  • I always thought Whatshername was Gloria. They both wanted a revolution. *shrugs*

  • Click like on this comment if your tired of the fucking "Top comments"

  • Comment removed

  • @GreenDayFan3811 Wow you got to the top comments by bitching about the top comments. I know that wasn't your intention...or was it? :)

  • I FORGOT WHAT THE 38 PEOPLE'S NAMES ARE! Oh.. i remembered! Douchebag-dicknozzle!

  • best. punk rock band. EVER anyone who disagrees should hear at least 1 of their songs

  • Whatsername made 38 accounts and disliked this video XD

  • @41CLA

    homo

  • Her name is Maria.

  • Her name is Paula :(

  • i cried the first time i heard this song at the end of american idiot. so beautiful <3 ilove green day

  • i think this sounds better live

    thats not something you can about many bands

  • it's 3:30 in morning and damn I keep having what if dreams about this girl I liked in primary school, damn it man pull yourself together you're never gonna see her again, move the fuck on

  • tu POLSKA, przejmujemy wszystko, przejmijmy i ten!

  • @hasajazdoprzygu

    i like cake too

  • awesome

  • 2:04 for one of the best parts of the song.

  • Her name is Kelsey, the first time I've talked to her was about Greenday, from that moment we realized that we shared everything in common, and that I wouldn't be able to get over her. As we got to know eachother I just saw more and more that we were perfect. Unfortunately, she has been dating some asshole 4ever for as long as I've known her. Everyday when I see her I fall in love again but she can only see him. I've spent nearly a year waiting and I would wait so many more because shes worth it

  • I love the part between 2:50 and 3:10..

  • @NashuanCookie I love the part between 0:00 and 4:13

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby Please... do me a favor. I made the same mistake with a few guys I've liked. Don't let her get away. If her boyfriend is really like that, I see no harm in telling her how you feel. Maybe she feels the same way about you. Just.. please dont let her get away.

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby I had a girl I liked go with a guy who sexually harassed girls at my work. I told her how I felt about her and how he was worthless, and it got spun around so it looked like I was the bad guy. Then another girl I liked, when I was 19 and she was 15, her mother didn't want me seeing her, but she was fine with her seeing a guy her own age. Then he raped her and got her pregnant, she has a kid now at 17. I totally feel for you bud.

  • @Geforce2187 This is life. Some girls aren't worth it though; mostly the ones that don't use their heads. 

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby I know the feeling bud... One day they'll break up with the douches and see that the decent guys are there for them.

  • @doctorug55

    Harsh much?

  • @doctorug55  How is he gay for wanting to be with a girl....grow up, kid.

  • @doctorug55 gay

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby

    Girls like to be treated like trash for some reason. Some day she'll get sick of it, he'll go too far, and she'll look for someone to save her. Make sure you're ready for that.

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby Cool story bro. I really mean it.

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby forget it...no girl is it worth. stop wasting time.

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby you go get her fuck that dude just go up and say it out loud and remind her what she is missing out on! dont let time be your boss time can be changed and you where made to go get her

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby I got sort of the same problem, except instead of an asshole, it's my best friend about to date her -__-

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby keep waiting man, you'll get her eventually. *pats back*

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby

    Stop waiting - seriously - it's not worth it!!!

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby i hear ya, same with me

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby dude, you're awesome. that's real love ;)

  • @TheFuckingJungleBaby * Green Day

  • Green Day can make you feel happy in a way no other band can. Truly inspriational and, of course, awesome as f**k XD

  • everyone writes they get depressed about this song. guys I'm in the hardest period of my life I've been under some hard kind of depression and THIS SONG MAKES ME FUCKING ALIVE!

  • @dememusic i know what you mean, when I was in the lowest point, i listened to this song the most, it makes you so fucking happy, but when you're happy, it does the opposite effect, this song reaches the hearts of everyone, happy sad, bored entertained, lonely and with company, this song is my favorite, it reaches to that one sad part in my life and reminds me of it and how to move on so that's how it works just saying :)

  • My boyfriend and I broke up over 4 months ago and I still can't get him over. Now he likes a chick who doesn't like him.

    What's the point in this?

  • Her name is Bethany...

  • Comment removed

  • her name is Karyme..

  • burning all of the photograophs. Good idea :D

  • remember, whatever, it seems like foreverr ago..

  • her name is amanda

  • Soo sad!!

  • This song makes me cry .. :/

  • This is the perfect song for guys with a broken heart...

  • @therockerfan amen bro, amen

  • 38 people doesn't know her name

  • Érika ♥

  • Damn, I hate it when I bump into really beautiful girl and I leave without asking "Whatsername" >_<

  • she is a transvestite so her real name is jonathon

  • Gabrielle :) great times

  • I could really use this song right now.

  • amanda

  • fuck the 37 people who dislike this song,.

  • @Fafe117 because they all knowername but don't wanna say cause they're pussies

  • love this song<3

  • One of my favorite songs :')

  • Priscila ♥ 

  • Whatsername is what you true name ?

  • This became one of my favorite songs the day American Idiot was released... Not much has changed in the last 87 months.

  • Sories of my life

  • Whatsername is Haushinka from nimrod.

    if you have the american idiot lyrics booklet that came with the CD, then go to the whatsername lyrics, he scratches out a name, the first letter is H, and the last letter is A

  • Story of my life. :'( -/3 c

  • god this song is heartbreaking but gorgeous

  • reminds me of one headlight by the wallflowers

  • best song ever! *-*

  • This song is great when the snowflakes are falling :P

  • This is one of their absolute best songs...always makes me think of me and this girl, seems like we're drifting apart, this song just explains it

  • This reminds me of my ex boyfriend , SO BAD!

  • Greenday= a better mooded me!

  • fuck whats her name?