Awesome, I've always known this as a guitar song because of Andrea Segovia and only recently found out that it was originally written for piano. You did a very good job playing this, as it doesn't look like a very easy piece for either instrument.
Thank you so much for posting this you play flawless. I have never had formal lessons but, I do not let that stand in the way. Odd as it may seem you have inspired a burning desire in me to take the challenge and learn this...I thank you for that. Namaste!
this piece is amazing!!!! i admit that a guitar gives it a romantic and seduecing sound but she plays it lovely with elegance and noble way that no guitar can achieve
@WaterBender02 Actually, you're wrong. It was originally written for piano. Maybe you should look up on your music history before making a fool out of yourself.
@WaterBender02 Yeah he is. Also, seeing as how he was a pianist and not a guitarist, I find highly unlikely that he would compose a song on the guitar. Which is an instrument he does not play. Maybe you need a new teacher.
Katrina, I thoroughly enjoyed your interpretation, I'm learning this piece and I'm up to page three. imo a very good effort well done.
fwiw thought the pace was really nice, a couple of errors along the way but still very nice to hear and thankfully not robotic as some of the other you tube stuff I felt there was feeling in it.
If you get the chance try and listen to Yoko Suzuki play it, imo the best I have heard yet
I like how Alicia Delarrocha plays it a lot better. This woman does not play it with feeling...at all! It does not come through. I play the piece myself and I do not know if it is the recording equipment or what but I detected some false notes here and there, did anyone else detect that?
Après avoir écouté ce morceau joué sur guitare, j'ai voulu la jouer sur piano. J'ai trouvé la partition originale (Leyenda), mais j'ai trouvé que cette version était plus agressive que la version sur guitare (trop aiguë). Je l'ai donc transcrite dans la tonalité de la guitare ! Il faut enlever 1 ton et demi à chaque note, pour que la musique soit plus douce... Par ailleurs, très belle interprétation, même si je préfère une tonalité plus grave !
My favourite piano version. Well delivered. Some errors but soon forgiven and made up for by the great jumper! I love this on guitar also. Unfair to compare the two. They are both beautiful in their own ways.
Asturias wrote this for piano with the intention to imitate the sound of the flamenco guitar. Albeniz played also guitar, but at that time, guitar was considered a folkloristic instrument and wasn't studied in musical universities or in conservatories ( Francisco Tarrega, the greatest composer for classical guitar, was principally a pianist and played guitar as a self-taught). With Andres Segovia the classical guitar became a classical instrument, and Asturias became a famous repertory piece.
Hat's off to those who can also play this on the guitar. I too just turned 14 and can play this, It's great to see musicians on youtube and not haters, but anyone who thinks justin beiber has talent is either deaf, retarded, or female...
@cookiev12 I can only play the first part on guitar. When all the chords come in, especially the C7 part (D#7 on this piano version), it becomes a bit too tricky.
It's said that Asturias was strongly inspired by the Granaina, also in 6/8 and in Eminor, the middle part inspired by it's the free phases. I've often heard flamencos play Asturias or similar for Granaina - the question would be who inspired who. Think of the Malagueña, which is closely related to the Granaina. That repetitive tremolo seems so much more typical of a stringed instrument. It would suprise me if this piece wasn't somehow inspired by the guitar.
@Freddran Don't get me wrong. This song is very tricky, but I just turned thirteen and I can play this song. I will put up a video of it in a month or so. It's not as hard as it looks.
the hardest thing to do is keeping the rythm the same troughout the whole song. On the piano as well as on the guitar, ow, and Freddran, on the guitar you also have to make high velocity jumps with a lot of precision... i personally like the composition better on guitar but thats just oppinion ;)
@Freddran lol of curse it's not, you have to put much more effort on making barres with left hand and movements with right hand, in piano you just have to press the keys ¬¬
super, man hört deutlich, dass eine Frau am Piano spielt. Sie spielt sehr mit ihrem Herzen. Wenn ich das so gut kann, können Sie es auch von mir hören. Das braucht aber noch seine Zeit. Musik ist ein grosser Reichtum, aber man erhält nichts geschenkt. Machen Sie so weiter!!!
Really well done, even if I prefer it with a bitvmore pauses between the accords in the first and 3rd part, and also between the bass note and high notes in the same part. But you did really well for the middle part, very nicely balanced and the tremolos were really well realised. Bravo
@ZuccheroFornaciari95 It was originally written for the piano, and I believe it gives the composition more power and creates an unique atmosphere, which you wouldn't get if it was played on the guitar imo.
@godra051 Please never try to compare whether it's easier on the guitar or on the piano or on the clarinet. It's an pointless discusion, as is your comment. It's like placing ''Matt Bellamy plays better!!'' at an Andres Segovia-video..
very good posture , think i had an audition of this song in the 6th grade but i`m a lot rustier now gona try to upload a version of my own , good work by the way !
@ takhirniolinest: les répetitions sont dans le morceau donc tu ne peux pas juger la pianiste sur ça ... en revanche je dis: EXCELLENT (je suis guitariste et j'essaye depuis 1 ans de jouer asturias... en vain)
I thought it was guitar music, now I understand
mightyhacker123 3 days ago
I like it
mightyhacker123 3 days ago
Awesome, I've always known this as a guitar song because of Andrea Segovia and only recently found out that it was originally written for piano. You did a very good job playing this, as it doesn't look like a very easy piece for either instrument.
propyro85 1 week ago
complimenti! bella esecuzione!
rickyc852007 2 weeks ago
ok so that was disgustingly amazing... seriously, awesome
MarkJiSung 2 weeks ago in playlist Uploaded videos
Thank you so much for posting this you play flawless. I have never had formal lessons but, I do not let that stand in the way. Odd as it may seem you have inspired a burning desire in me to take the challenge and learn this...I thank you for that. Namaste!
Ev~
medicalteacher4u 3 weeks ago
I'm learning this song on guitar!!!
AnThoNyAlcANtArTv 3 weeks ago
i am learning this song right now!!!!!
TERMINATOR760 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hey, great performance! I played asturias with guitar prety fast :P if u wanna check it out here is my video >> /watch?v=OyQV6PxgYiM
gitarfuc 4 weeks ago
this piece is amazing!!!! i admit that a guitar gives it a romantic and seduecing sound but she plays it lovely with elegance and noble way that no guitar can achieve
the3genny 1 month ago
Jolie performance!!! Bravo!!!
marucoLille 1 month ago
it is bool sheet, guitar rules
SweetRAXAT 1 month ago
youtube.com/watch?v=o1aBu2KzcMc
opustenzy 1 month ago
@opustenzy fuck you
SweetRAXAT 1 month ago
Une petite erreur à la 0.43 (on l'entend quand même un peu). Sinon, c'est parfait !
Moikuri 1 month ago
Even the movements at 4:26 and the "waves" formed during the refrain are much more beautiful to see on the piano.
fiifine 1 month ago
I think it is so much better on piano. It sounds more solemn and pure.
fiifine 1 month ago 2
J'adore ! La sono' est excellente !
Juste une petit erreur dans les 1.10 à 1.50 mais rien de flagrant :p
Continuez comme ca !
Moikuri 1 month ago
you got to tell me how to do that O.O
bloodymoon420 1 month ago
Her hands are so beautiful!..
Natalie6Mezzo 1 month ago
amazing :)
dumhumdrum 1 month ago
Where their any "song" written for guitar...you know.. back in the days
FlyingVSnow 2 months ago
Comment removed
laskarinion 2 months ago
Quick question is it supposed to be played with staccato? ???
FatalFistFury 2 months ago
it was originally written for the piano, but it's become way more popular for the guitar.
The7vendeadlysins 2 months ago 29
@The7vendeadlysins Idiot, it was originally written for guitar, dumbass
WaterBender02 1 month ago
@WaterBender02 Actually, you're wrong. It was originally written for piano. Maybe you should look up on your music history before making a fool out of yourself.
MaDmExIcAnBuRiToS 1 month ago
@MaDmExIcAnBuRiToS So my professor at the conservatoire of Paris is wrong? I highly doubt it
WaterBender02 1 month ago
@WaterBender02 Yeah he is. Also, seeing as how he was a pianist and not a guitarist, I find highly unlikely that he would compose a song on the guitar. Which is an instrument he does not play. Maybe you need a new teacher.
MaDmExIcAnBuRiToS 1 month ago
asturias.... i love this suite, but sometimes i think it might be played with a bagpipe! it would be funny, at last
anais558 2 months ago
nice dynamics on notes!!!!!!
Malaperdoklis 2 months ago
Great interpretation, indeed!!
I'm trying to play it, and, damn, it's not easy at some parts...
My respects to you...
kruktskia 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
Katrina, I thoroughly enjoyed your interpretation, I'm learning this piece and I'm up to page three. imo a very good effort well done.
fwiw thought the pace was really nice, a couple of errors along the way but still very nice to hear and thankfully not robotic as some of the other you tube stuff I felt there was feeling in it.
If you get the chance try and listen to Yoko Suzuki play it, imo the best I have heard yet
Look forward to seeing more of you playing
love the jumper :-)))))
jcfd55 3 months ago
I was pretty enthralled - this is fantastic. Translates to piano a lot better than I expected. :)
adammerlinsmith 3 months ago
@adammerlinsmith erm, it was originally piano.
TehTyg13 3 months ago 4
@TehTyg13 Well, shows what I know. :P
adammerlinsmith 3 months ago
Comment removed
jmichelsen4 3 months ago
more suited to the guitar.to me it loses its spanish fire on piano.thats only my humble opinion.jose medina
joseph62042 4 months ago 4
This performance is impressive because there is not a lot of rubato, and because the touch is well adapted to the different parts of this piece.
Just at the conclusion, I would prefer a fortissimo, but this is subjective.
laurentjutier 4 months ago
die sprünge klappen nicht :D
pianoamigo 4 months ago
I like how Alicia Delarrocha plays it a lot better. This woman does not play it with feeling...at all! It does not come through. I play the piece myself and I do not know if it is the recording equipment or what but I detected some false notes here and there, did anyone else detect that?
susanpreston777 4 months ago
Avis aux joueurs de piano :
Après avoir écouté ce morceau joué sur guitare, j'ai voulu la jouer sur piano. J'ai trouvé la partition originale (Leyenda), mais j'ai trouvé que cette version était plus agressive que la version sur guitare (trop aiguë). Je l'ai donc transcrite dans la tonalité de la guitare ! Il faut enlever 1 ton et demi à chaque note, pour que la musique soit plus douce... Par ailleurs, très belle interprétation, même si je préfère une tonalité plus grave !
Icnapak 4 months ago
beautiful composition but i prefer it on classical guitar
Nattligkorp 4 months ago 2
Congratulations, superb performance, I wish I was that good.
Lots of character in that piano.
Cabinessance 4 months ago
i still believe it sounds better on the guitar
j3d1m4st3r1 5 months ago
soft imaginations, techniques ... bravo
rayYT100 5 months ago
Schön und auf einem Piano mit Wiener Mechanik, das hat etwas, weil aus der Zeit...
Und nicht auf Höchsttempo gedrillt, sondern entspannt und locker! Gefällt mir.
paulheinrich13 5 months ago
que alucine que bien toca XD :p
daniso123 5 months ago
This is not asturias... Asturias is the Andres Segovia's Guitar Arragment.... THis opus is called LEYENDA!
Sanotaru92 5 months ago
your fingers are so cute, what´s yout name, and where do you live?
BEYEN29 5 months ago 2
Comment removed
BEYEN29 5 months ago
sound much better on guitar though
TheAnubis211 5 months ago
this piece was my final exam but on calssical guitar :)
TheKnochengesicht 5 months ago 3
you can say whatever you want, it will always sound better on the classical guitar.
Rad1ated 5 months ago
browny points for you sir
afwas3 5 months ago
guitar version sounds better.
MrZaf12 6 months ago 44
@MrZaf12 you got to admit that she is pretty good
bloodymoon420 1 month ago
@MrZaf12 is that the recording is of poor quality.
CarlosEdaurdoSamuel 1 month ago
@MrZaf12 indeed
333Arber 1 month ago
rachmanioff prelude op 23 no 5
FingerMyFinger 6 months ago
My favourite piano version. Well delivered. Some errors but soon forgiven and made up for by the great jumper! I love this on guitar also. Unfair to compare the two. They are both beautiful in their own ways.
dcartelle 6 months ago
Great music !
LaurentziuRo2010 7 months ago
it is absolutely beautiful! So well done! Do you think you could do a tutorial??
servantofchristfree 7 months ago
Nice! :D
keysuke123 7 months ago
Meu Deus, eu não conhecía essa musica e realmente, é muito bonita, parabéns pela sua interpretação...
Victorpianio 7 months ago
this piece sound SO much better on guitar :)
01GuitarGuru01 7 months ago 2
la la la laaa la la aaalaalaaaa !!!
antoineapa59 8 months ago
I can not see their hands while her tits are bouncing
guicortei 8 months ago
Bravo!!
cuoylyf 8 months ago
Asturias wrote this for piano with the intention to imitate the sound of the flamenco guitar. Albeniz played also guitar, but at that time, guitar was considered a folkloristic instrument and wasn't studied in musical universities or in conservatories ( Francisco Tarrega, the greatest composer for classical guitar, was principally a pianist and played guitar as a self-taught). With Andres Segovia the classical guitar became a classical instrument, and Asturias became a famous repertory piece.
bachinblack94 8 months ago
congrats! wish i could play this so amazing!
Daphne386 8 months ago
Hat's off to those who can also play this on the guitar. I too just turned 14 and can play this, It's great to see musicians on youtube and not haters, but anyone who thinks justin beiber has talent is either deaf, retarded, or female...
cookiev12 9 months ago 2
@cookiev12 I can only play the first part on guitar. When all the chords come in, especially the C7 part (D#7 on this piano version), it becomes a bit too tricky.
bananatree25 8 months ago
Justin Bieber songs are better than this!
- A quote from a musically retarded person.
johnlalala23 9 months ago
It's said that Asturias was strongly inspired by the Granaina, also in 6/8 and in Eminor, the middle part inspired by it's the free phases. I've often heard flamencos play Asturias or similar for Granaina - the question would be who inspired who. Think of the Malagueña, which is closely related to the Granaina. That repetitive tremolo seems so much more typical of a stringed instrument. It would suprise me if this piece wasn't somehow inspired by the guitar.
Great playing, by the way!
JohnOpheim 9 months ago 2
@Freddran Don't get me wrong. This song is very tricky, but I just turned thirteen and I can play this song. I will put up a video of it in a month or so. It's not as hard as it looks.
drp3pp3r23 10 months ago
the hardest thing to do is keeping the rythm the same troughout the whole song. On the piano as well as on the guitar, ow, and Freddran, on the guitar you also have to make high velocity jumps with a lot of precision... i personally like the composition better on guitar but thats just oppinion ;)
koenie166 10 months ago
Wwwwqwds "!=, iib.ji@€€j,,ay&€ b-a
Chintow2000 10 months ago
aaawesome
princy170 10 months ago
Preciosas manos y precioso sonido.
28jadufer 10 months ago
it sounds so much better on guitar :)
TheAlexlovable 10 months ago
very very nice
SAFIR27 11 months ago
it sounds much better on guitar
ChristinaZchrk 11 months ago
@ChristinaZchrk Well it's easier to play it on guitar
Freddran 10 months ago
@Freddran Never said it's not!
ChristinaZchrk 10 months ago
@Freddran lol of curse it's not, you have to put much more effort on making barres with left hand and movements with right hand, in piano you just have to press the keys ¬¬
ricardohernandezosun 10 months ago
@ricardohernandezosun hm sure, but with high velocity, lightness and with long-distance jumps at once. That's tricky.
Freddran 10 months ago
@Freddran nope:D
YouKnowItByThis 10 months ago
do they have a grand piano on the kitchen?! cuz she's a woman rigth?
BenjaminTheHolyDiver 11 months ago
@BenjaminTheHolyDiver So...? women... men... I don't find the fucking difference here...
GloomySeason 11 months ago
@GloomySeason i suck dont i...
BenjaminTheHolyDiver 11 months ago
Beautiful! Thank you for the upload.
universoeterno1 11 months ago
It is originally for piano. But it sounds way better on guitar.
13olivas 11 months ago
@TheMusicalManiac buy the book
bowloficecream422 11 months ago
super, man hört deutlich, dass eine Frau am Piano spielt. Sie spielt sehr mit ihrem Herzen. Wenn ich das so gut kann, können Sie es auch von mir hören. Das braucht aber noch seine Zeit. Musik ist ein grosser Reichtum, aber man erhält nichts geschenkt. Machen Sie so weiter!!!
Costamarzili 1 year ago
maaaan wtf is that "tsst" sound that happens every goddam second its so annoying...
ScarletMagenta 1 year ago
It's for classical guitar but he played it on the piano.
ArtemisApollo26 1 year ago
Comment removed
maideixaremquetornen 1 year ago
Perfect!
kutsakos 1 year ago
Asturias is for piano than transcritted for guitar
toutadesqueyroux 1 year ago
Nice Fingers...Wonderful Perfomance,,.Marry Me????... :-D
pouria1361 1 year ago
sin palabras excelente tu ejecución. lenta pero bien armada, expresiva y ecxelente técnicamanete. seguí adelante
horacio220 1 year ago
I watch this everyday for inspiration. Fuck you chords. Honestly, fuck you.
qwertyuiop46853 1 year ago
bravo! I'm learning this and the part with the chords is a real challenge!
lePistolero 1 year ago
this video would be perfeck if it wasnt for that skweking sound in the back :(
milosdmann 1 year ago
people have to be mentally sick not to like this
624Seaturtle 1 year ago
unbelivable, 5*..
DunklesWasser23 1 year ago
i can do that... -.-
jonathepianist 1 year ago
Really well done, even if I prefer it with a bitvmore pauses between the accords in the first and 3rd part, and also between the bass note and high notes in the same part. But you did really well for the middle part, very nicely balanced and the tremolos were really well realised. Bravo
Leviathan1200 1 year ago
My girlfriend has to play this for her upcoming test, she's really good but worried about it
she's been playing since 4, but she's 14
and she you need more tension between notes, but you have good control of sound and accuracy
Aldurnamiyanrandvora 1 year ago
Comment removed
Aldurnamiyanrandvora 1 year ago
fantastic, but for guitar that's most beutiful...
ZuccheroFornaciari95 1 year ago
@ZuccheroFornaciari95 It was originally written for the piano, and I believe it gives the composition more power and creates an unique atmosphere, which you wouldn't get if it was played on the guitar imo.
AmgNoWai 1 year ago
Some mistakes, but, there's always mistakes in this piece... Awesome work ! I can't play it that fast, with a touch like yours !
blazzor80 1 year ago
is that a cricket on the background? or is something wrong with my computer?
hallowedbeeddie 1 year ago
Genial.
andbarfer 1 year ago
@bigbosscod2 yeah but i still enjoy the guitar one a lot more, of course its a matter of perception.
Guitarpipi 1 year ago
this is so relaxing
NoldyJay 1 year ago
Its so much better when played by a guitarrist. The piano arrangement does not sound so good.
Guitarpipi 1 year ago
@Guitarpipi you know that it was written by Isaac originally for the piano right? :P
bigbosscod2 1 year ago
@Guitarpipi This originally On Piano! man. And Piano Verison Rocks!
DHcello 1 year ago
i love ur shirt.
secretdarrylsd 1 year ago
@secretdarrylsd lol me too
bubelebu 1 year ago
@bubelebu hehehehe...You know what I mean?
secretdarrylsd 1 year ago
@secretdarrylsd hahaha yes!
bubelebu 1 year ago
@bubelebu though the song was good. hehehe . so as the shirt
secretdarrylsd 1 year ago
@secretdarrylsd yep very good, but the shirt is than the song =D
bubelebu 1 year ago
this song requires a lot of accuracy and skill to play it right
daphnie528 1 year ago
braaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaavooo
I can't play it in guitar in this way ha ha ha ha
GuitarstBaghdad 1 year ago
I can never play it that well!
Parasomnia93 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
¡Olé tus cojones chata! ¡¡asi se toca!! =)
That means I luv'd it... the song's beautiful!! gr8! Albéniz was a genious...
CrUithNee 1 year ago
¡Olé tus cojones chata! ¡¡asi se toca!! =)
That means I luv'd it... the song's beautiful!! gr8! Albéniz was a genious...
CrUithNee 1 year ago
amazing !!! 5* !!!
electro422 1 year ago
On guitar is extremely-extremely!-difficult!
As it is on piano.
It's just the nature of the song.
Every instrument has its own difficulties: it's not fair to underestimate either.
nasiaser 1 year ago
do we get to see the face?? all i see is small titties
wparo 1 year ago
that piano sounds awful :(
fumanshu888 1 year ago
so many dumb comments regarding the difficulty...tremolo parts-harder on guitar, chord parts- harder on piano, end of discussion
qwertyuiop46853 1 year ago
Love it *O*
BoxterMusic 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
well trained middle finger :D
brainjerk 1 year ago
well trained middle finger :D
brainjerk 1 year ago
bobbie....this is made for piano....and actually, it;s easier on a guitar!
godra051 1 year ago
@godra051 well,it's not easy on guitar actually
bobiee36 1 year ago
@bobiee36 doubt you can play it to since you dont know even how to read! Didnt say it's easy but easier than on piano! It's hard to play on anything!
godra051 1 year ago
Comment removed
HitokiriDiaz 1 year ago
@godra051 Please never try to compare whether it's easier on the guitar or on the piano or on the clarinet. It's an pointless discusion, as is your comment. It's like placing ''Matt Bellamy plays better!!'' at an Andres Segovia-video..
HitokiriDiaz 1 year ago
@godra051 and I didn't see any videos of you playing it so you can't tell it's easy ..
bobiee36 1 year ago
@godra051 trust me it is much more difficult on guitar
IMRezpected 1 year ago
Bravo!
InterBrian 1 year ago
I´ve c this video a million times and i still love it
eduardochief 1 year ago
Great!!
criticism1000 1 year ago
Bravo!!
princesseblue1 1 year ago
Yeah me toooo , i play guitare but i don't like this dance
houmanna 1 year ago
very good posture , think i had an audition of this song in the 6th grade but i`m a lot rustier now gona try to upload a version of my own , good work by the way !
ToniCristianTanase 1 year ago
I would like to see you play this on guitar :) :D
bobiee36 1 year ago
Impresionante!
sergiojove 1 year ago
Don't listen to the naysayers. Beautiful fingers. Your playing is excellent and heartfelt. Horowitz made a few mistakes and he as the best. Bravo!
BigJiggety 1 year ago
i will soon put a vid of me playing it.
Ovsanna01 1 year ago
very slow tempo and lots of mistakes... it should be at 132... left hand need to hit the right octaves.
Ovsanna01 1 year ago
Playing this piece in piano must be tougher than on guitars... I'm pretty much sure...
signupsanj 1 year ago
@signupsanj perhaps the chord parts, but the tremolo parts must be definitely harder on guitar don't you think?
qwertyuiop46853 1 year ago
@qwertyuiop46853 I am learning this song on guitar... Yeah; it is tough... It retards my speed... Hopefully i may learn it within a year :)
signupsanj 1 year ago
@signupsanj
haha you have no about idea about guitars.
AngLunas 1 year ago
damn, i can't imagine my fingers dancing like that on both guitar and piano.
Blade15 1 year ago
its hard to play those chords at the first part.. i know :S
wamadeus 1 year ago
hi! you're an amazing piano player, i'm impressed! congratulations :) p.s. do ya have the music sheet of this song?
Scribak94 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
why you do this for me?
aminexk8 1 year ago
wow!the tempo was perfect!
Shylphido 1 year ago
Nice Play! The chord parts are the hardest, some fails but still great! Congrats!
DarkXxXNightmare 1 year ago
I can almost play this piece, the only part I can't get are the chords in the two fast parts. This was really well played though ^_^
PlanetLuvver09 1 year ago
I have a video with sheet music for this so you can follow along
pianoaddict06 1 year ago
My applause. Great job! Great performance!
Arainlike 1 year ago
@ takhirniolinest: les répetitions sont dans le morceau donc tu ne peux pas juger la pianiste sur ça ... en revanche je dis: EXCELLENT (je suis guitariste et j'essaye depuis 1 ans de jouer asturias... en vain)
lawliet13010 1 year ago
This is great, I have heard this a million times on guitar and never on piano for which it was composed for. You do great justice to it.
zarapico 1 year ago
Tres jolie musique =D
lepianistedu51 1 year ago
repetition et pas bien...
takhirviolinest 1 year ago