Added: 4 years ago
From: leopoldbastard
Views: 155,473
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (351)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Did Mel C say "she could have really fucked things up for us" @ 8:50? Damn Mel C, tell 'em how you REALLY feel!

  • I always though that Mel C would be the first to leave!

  • Thanks Girls for giving us ur Girl Power!!!!!!!

  • 8:55 it always sounds like she's bagging on Geri

  • Geri leaving = :'(

  • I think it was selfish of Gerri's part to leave from nowhere. I mean, i really think about it, and I believe that if she didn't leave, They would still be successful to this very day, even making new albums videos and stuff!

  • @7oxMISSYxo7 Maybe they would still be successful, but if you're not happy you can't live your life a certain way just to please everyone else around you. Otherwise you'll end up even more unhappy then you were to begin with. Yeah, her leaving definitely put a lot of pressure on everyone but she must have had strong reasons to leave something so magnificent behind.

  • at 6:53)

    Man, is that insecurity epitomized or what?

    Such a shame.

  • This is really sad when Geri Halliwell left the group. I didn't know they left the group until three months ago. Like Prince Charles said, the Spice Girls would never be the same without Geri.

  • Geri does not tell the truth in this doc. Watch the Piers Morgan interview with her. It comes out then. In Mel B's Autobiograhy-Mel startes to notice how Geri becomes withdrawn from everyone and she starts to worry about her. Geri suffered from depression and bulimia and would never acknowledge it to the public or the girls-and broke thier "Pack" which they had made among the five of them-that they would tell the group if they planned to leave.

  • Sorry but in my opinion Geri was VERY selfish. Maybe she did feel all that she said but she had no reason to as Geri was probably one of the most important girls in the group, and the most popular etc. Like Mel B said If any of the girls had left it would have died, and I think at the back of her mind Geri knew that the girls would fail without her, but she believed she was going to be the next Madonna so she didn't care! It's sad she left when she did they would have done SO much more.

  • I still don't think it was much of an explanation from Geri, a bit cliché. I feel like the attention was spreading to the other's and she didn't like it. Mel B is one who will hide her emotions, there is no way she wouldn't of been distraught, the girls had been together for around 4/5 years and people forget that. There is no way you would not be upset. Silly.

  • i don't get it.. why geri leaves the band? i need ur help people :D

  • Posh is skinny but she's not anorexic and doesn't have any other eating disorder for that matter. Anorexic girls wont have a frame like hers. Her neck and shoulders are just fine. Also, she's had 3 boys and has a girl on the way. I think I speak for every woman when I say that once you're pregnant your relationship to food changes. You don't care about what you eat - you just want to give the baby the best start possible.

  • @antionidept I have to disagree. I know many girls who've had babies and then gone straight back to their eating disorder. I'm not saying Posh *is* anorexic, I'm just saying that unfortunately some women are so sick with their eating issues that having a baby can't always change everything. x

  • Spice Girls: two words that, together, will always drum up insanely awesome memories of a VERY special time. The fab five were, and are, amazing. Geri, Mel C, & Emma were always my faves, but I adore them all. This documentary is fantastic; their story is powerful, beautiful, & sweet. They were an ideal group of loving, loyal friends & talented bandmates to look up to. I have faith that there'll be future Spice reunions & activities; they'll never stop being who they are; long live girl power!

  • This is why I can't stand Geri. She is such a drama queen. She was stupid to leave the group, they could have leasted more years if it wasn't for her.

  • @Romeu021 shut the fuck up she lelft but she came back so shut the fuck up fuck face

  • @tricksshomagic1

    Yeah, she came back only for money you retard.

  • i strongly believe that they would go on for several years more if geri did'nt leave...they kept doing their thing but still it wasn't the same..and finally they gone their own ways...but i think it would have happened the same thing if any other of them had gone...they're the spice girls for god's sake! "the power of four needs one girl more"... god bless you for growing up with me...god bless you for being there...always spice...

  • I remember Geri leaving the spice girls as a 12 year old girl. God, that was a sad day in my life :p

  • I don't mind.. cause I really Love SPice Girls...

  • a lot of people say the master mind behind them was simon

  • what was Geri talking about that the rest of the girls didn't needed her?, or just they accomplished a lot with her?, come on Geri,we all missed you like crazy out of the Spice Girls & I was very happy when you all 5 reunited.

  • geri was mad cuz nobody cared about her! she wanted to be the justin timberlake of the spice girls and she couldnt handle that what a lame

  • @1IAMUTURN shut the fuck up you dont know what you are talking about geri was one of the most like spice girl of them

  • @tricksshomagic1 did you reply to everyone dang get a life.....i bet your geri with no life mad at everyone your a lame

  • @1IAMUTURN your a dick do  you even know what your talking a bout

  • @1IAMUTURN  fuck you your lame fuck face

  • @tricksshomagic1 shut the fuck up you dont know what your talking about fuck face get that dick out of your mouth

  • Comment removed

  • I can't understand. Why did Geri think that girls didn't need her anymore?

  • I don't think Mel B was being a bitch either in the documentary or trying to be mean. She was just telling it the way it was, keeping it real, whatever little saying you want to insert. Yes Geri left but her leaving was not the end of the world or the end of the Spice Girls at that point and you have to keep it together, not ball up in the corner and cry or lay down and die. No you get up you dust yourself off and you keep going because one monkey doesn't stop the show.

  • @victoriabeckfinat228 bull shit she was 2 being

  • Who can translate me , in italian, what the girls says from 0.00 to 1.10? thank you very much :*

  • That pink banner was couisn's I'm in there some where I think!!!

  • sans geri it was weird i know but moving on is always interesting but they did it, but they all got back together thankfully. wish i could have seen em anywhere! go ladies

  • I feel like Geri was more or so tired than really just wanting to go solo. If you see their appearance before she left, Ginger was not there anymore.

  • i do feel that Emma & Victoria gave a sort of softer feel to the whole situation as well as Mel C. However i dont feel that Mel B. was being a bitch about it, that was just her reaction to Geri leaving and her reactions i can relate to because I'm tough and i don't really show a soft side either.

  • @laserflip13

    I feel that way too about it. I think Mel B couldn't really let herself feel Geri leaving afterall the show had to continue and there was no manager to make decisions about who gets to take over singing what.

  • @fight4acause yes exactly. & i just couldn't imagine her reacting to it in any other way than she did so yeah.

  • aw poor Geri :|

  • I think they would have last longer if they did have enough rest or time for their own.

  • I think the whole breast cancer thing was an easy way out!

  • The breast cancer thing sounds like a mere excuse, not sure if that was a heavy reason to leave the spice girls...knowing geriu might think it really was because of doing solo career...

  • @slolove06 no but that was the last straw. she was actually just tired, exhausted and severely depressed. she had to get out to feel better. she never fully mourned her fathers death which was 6 months before meeting the girls and then her eating disorder. it was just too much. i totally understand her cos i've suffered depression and lost my dad too and sometimes u just have to get away from it all.

  • @YourOasis97 I agree. We know that now-but she still doesn't admit it in this vid.

  • @justwatching190 well she implied that that wasn't the sole reason. you can hear it in her voice.

  • @justwatching190 and she wrote about it in her books.

  • At 5:36 they already look as a four piece band and Mel C is so sweet lying about Geri not being at that time!

  • I think Simon Fuller was the SAME reason why the SG didn't continue their Reunion Tour - that he had PUSH the girls TOO FAR! They didn't really have a break - imagine doing LIVE concert NON-STOP for 17 NIGHTS!! That was absurd actually! And it ended up with the Girls couldn't continue their tour anymore coz they have CHILDREN now, who are schooling & everything..& in the end it's the fans all over the world being the victim! I think 5 or 6 concerts in UK was enough, then go to other countries.

  • hello!!!! they got paid!!!!!! it's a show, not construction or something heavy...

  • LOL.. how ignorant you are.. *roll eyes*

  • fuck you pig

  • Wow, poor Geri, you can tell that the wounds stil haven't completely healed... I think she felt really bad about leaving the Spice Girls, but at the same time, I think she did the right thing. When something doesn't feel right anymore, it's time to let it go. And she was wrong when she said that the girls didn't need her anymore, because after her departure, it all went downhill from there for the group.

  • I think was hurt me the most was the word SPICE is five letters( one girl per letter) and with geri gone, you just didn't have the full flavor you know??...she brought a certain comic and naive vibe to the group which was fascinating. I know she may not of been much of a "singer" at the time, but heck its been said thats not what the spice girls were about in the long run. It's their message of life and friendship!!!

  • Victoria is so mature and real..

  • This may sound pathetic but i remember hearing he news of Geri leaving & crying soo hard!!! Spice Girls were my life & Geri leaving was devasting. They had a huuuge impact on many lives & mine was one of them. I love the spice Girls though as a band & as indiviuals

  • Me too, i cried for days!!! But the sad thing is geri broke the news on my birthday!!! I just couldn't believe!!!

  • I remember hearing from my older sister, a friend, or my mom saying the Geri left the Spice Girls. I was like shocked and wondering if this was true. Then later on Entertainment Tonight (ET) told all the viewers including myself that it's official Geri left the Spice Girls. I felt sad but not upset. That year in August, I went to my 1st concert of seeing them. During the show, the songs made me happy but looking at the stage was different because their is one person missing. I still love them.

  • as a child, i preferred the spice girls without geri, but now, knowing what amazing people they are and how talented they are in their own ways, i appreciate them all for themselves :) <3

  • I now see that Baby Spice for Emma is perfect. She's so cute! She's so like "I love everybody, let's hold hands." XD

  • c'mon you silly cow wha you doin

  • I think Victoria really is a genuinely sweet woman. A pity she has such low self esteem. She's now playing around too much with plastic ops. She's a good looking girl, she should stay away from all that. And eat something for god's sake.

  • @Domzdream she eats 4 gosh sakes! pls don't think she doesn't eat.

  • @svhwdwnut

    Er...we all eat. Thus why we are all still here typing our thoughts.

    All I'm saying is, is she looked better when she wasn't exposed to the fashion arena. Looking at all those skinny (young) models must take toll on one's ego.

    To be honest. If I were surrounded by male models in my work place, I'd also hit the gym 24/7 and live on cellery sticks and carrots.

    We're talking about peer pressure, and it's everywhere. Repleat.

  • (scene from Zoolander)

    Methilda: 'I'm bulimic'.

    (pause)

    Derek: 'You can read minds?'

  • 9:25 - 9:45 LMAOO BEST PART EVER!! i LOVE Victoria!!!

    "we did everything together... even taking pregnacy test and then sharing the uraine with the entire room" bwahahah

  • They still had problems with eachother at this point. Stuff went on they wont talk about which they aren't over.

  • mel c got great looking eyes

  • i agree with u siriusblack4ever, geri wasnt what made them the best girl band, but geri was a big part of them, when she left the spice girls weren the same because it felt like something was always missing it would of been the same if any of the other girls left them all together is what made th spice girls all of their individual personalities

  • how did geri fell when she left???

    i didn't understand the word

    re...

  • i love emma so much x

  • Geri = Podge Spice.. yeah, i remember her as "fat" during the 90's.. but she became so ripped/sexy when I saw her "Raining Men" video

  • yea,, i wish she (geri) did'nt leave the group....

  • I really give Victoria props in this segment for what she said about Geri leaving, and how them being able to do more dance moves or sing more parts didn't matter, because that wasn't what they were about; they were about being together, and without Geri, it just wasn't the same. That was a really touching segment, and I really appreciated that, especially in comparison to Mel B's attitude toward the situation.

  • I 100% agree :) Shows the caring & geniune nature in Victoria <3

  • @SiriusBlack4Ever I agree, it was good of her to say it. But you know the strangest thing - I read Victoria's biography, and in it she talks about Geri leaving and says "it made things easier from a choreography point of view - any dancer will tell you it's easier to choreograph a routine with 4 dancers than it is with 5"

    So its kinda the opposite to what she says here. But maybe when she wrote the book she was still angry with Geri or something?

  • @spider23000 How is that opposite? Here, she says nothign was that important than Geri leaving the group. In the book she just states the choreography was easier vecause it's harder to make it for a 5 member group. This is not opposite, it's just different aspects.

  • @LeoGonWild What I meant by opposite is that in this video she says something like "other group members would tell you the choreography was easier after Geri left", whereas in her book its actually her that says it.

    Either way it was never the same once Geri went

  • @SiriusBlack4Ever i agree that is true friendship.

    

  • @SiriusBlack4Ever you have a point, but everyone has their own point of view..

  • @SiriusBlack4Ever

    Emma's reaction was the same!!! The show must go on! They had two hours to do a show!!

  • aw that was such a sad day when Geri left the group ):

  • @airickahhh When my sister heard about it, at first she mistakenly thought that Geri passed away because it was just a couple of weeks after my paternal grandmother died.

  • mel B comes across as a bit of a hard bitch in this documentary?

  • @tricksshomagic1 Please, Mel B has stated in her autobiography that she was destroyed personally by Geri leaving as she and Geri were best friends (yes they fought, but they also clicked the best). But Geri left in the MIDDLE OF A WORLD TOUR! They had time to figure out the Geri situation, they had mere hours to figure out the concert situation as they still had a few shows in Europe.

  • they should reunite from time to time and go on with their solo careers, but they could record something else in the future. something more mature and professional :P

  • i still dnt understand why geri left the spice girls

  • I kinda get it. If you look at Britney Spears now compared to then, she has lost that spark. She doesn't seem to be having as much fun and seems like she just does it because she has too. I think Geri felt that way.

  • @Antoinette1793

    No one does!

  • I had no idea they left Simon Fuller.

  • Since the "main voices" were Mel C., Emma, & Mel B. I think Geri was, indeed feeling "redundant" (6:59). Interesting though that the band was based so much on chemistry: though vocally and dance-wise, Geri was the most challenged, her personality was a big factor in why the Spice Girls worked. I think Mel C. probably didn't feel fully appreciated for what she was contributing to the band (i.e. her voice being essential to the band) and hence the somewhat negative comments from her.

  • She was not going through a nice time at the time.

  • omg!! someone who doesn't see or understand eating disorders!! how much of a twat r u!! do u know how hard it is to deal with that sorta thing? NO!!! that was prob ver yhard for her to talk about something like that n to finally talk about it after such a long time must've been a relief for her! get a life n get over urself!!

  • i've actually had an eating disorder :) so get over yoursrelf pal ;)

  • u talk so much crap. If you have u must have aot of jealousy then and a bad attitude problem. People who have eating disorders r more understanding of things like that, i doubt u have!

  • Love when Victoria was talking about the wee all over the room!!

  • Wait im confused. Who had the eatin disorder?

  • Mel C has the eating disorder!

    Love the Spice Girls!!

  • GERI WAS ALSO BULEMIC

  • From what I understood didn't Mel B and Geri get into some huge fight on the plane?

  • i was in 7th grade when they were huge and 4 of my friends and I dressed up like them for the talent show and sang wannabe. we are boys by the way. i was geri and the teacher made me take grapefruits out of my bra and replace them with oranges. haha God I feel old now.

  • I remember when the Spice mania was happening, I was a huge fan..I was an eight-year old girl, how could I not love Emma who also like pink and was "baby" spice, etc..And I remember a friend of mine showed me a magazine which said that the SG may be breaking up because Geri may be leaving, and me and my other friend literally dived for it to see what the article would say..It was so crazy, I was crushed when Geri left; but I understand her and love her still.

  • I got tickets for their show at Riverbend in Cincinnati and it was after Geri quit. I was so angry, i was a crushed little kid!

  • Hey I live in Cincy! I wish I could've gone to that concert! :(

  • poor mel c =-((

  • their the biggest 90's act..i wondr how it would be if geri never left..it wuld totally be different..if they have stayed longer i bet their status as a music artists wuld be leveled to beatles..although they are considered as 90's icons now..well spice girls forever anayway..no matter what hehe

  • Victoria is so down to earth and real, i love her. About the whole Geri leaving the group situation, i was CRUSHED when i heard about it when i was younger. While i love their music after Geri left, the whole vibe of the group was different after she left.

    <3 Marissa

  • Mel B is NOT a bitch, so stop talking garbage

    Geri left because she wanted to move on

  • victoria so needs to go to her old looks... she looked so much better. she's a good person but she looks a bit fake these days

  • victoria is so sweet and smart

  • she looks fake though. genuinely lovely, sweet girl. but completely plastic.

  • Is Victoria's look matters much? Isn't it enough that she is sweet, kind, nice, honest and so on? At least she is not Jordan or any other horrible, fake people, like Joan Rivers, right? Or are you just loving people's look, and not people's heart? Maybe this was why Geri and Mel C had eating disorders too - coz people only care about their look..not what's behind it!

  • mel c looks better than ever

    and geri does too!!!!!!!!

  • Noooooo!!! Geri, don't cry!! You'll always be together in each others hearts!

    And in ours.

  • Love Victoria

    soooooo lovely

  • Mel B: "Everybody in the band's needed, god, it wouldn't be able to function without bla bla bla..."

    ♪I wanna make you holler♪

  • I like Geri's interview attitude. It's so sincere... I like all of their personalities actually. Baby is so sweet, Mel B doesn't bullshit, Mel C is honest, and Posh has great analysis

  • didnt geri use to have big lips what happened

  • i just relized that too.lol. maybe surgery...

  • it was probably how they used the make up back then. she used red lipstick remember. ;)

  • i have poor melanie c for keeping that secret for so long and then after wards dealing with it.

    sporty spice 26

  • there was wee flyign everywhere!

  • Geri was viewed as fat!? Was she supposed to have a little boy body like Nicole Richie? Every guy that I know thought Geri was the hottest and better looking back then, when she weighed more and had bigger boobs.

  • no stevienicksfan,

    its simon FULLER

  • is That Simon Cowell at 2:39??!!??!!

    lmao

  • hi im from philippines.,. hoping they come visit here bcoz there a lot of spicy fan here.,. love them from then til now!

  • Excuse me?

    I need help because i'm not obsessively stalking the SPICE GIRLS?! looool.. my bad if i choose to watch stories on the news like.. i dunno- wars, suffering, or politics. I SHOULD stay "on top of the news" by counting how many sold out shows they performed this year.. if thats your only hobby, good on you mate. But i'd rather watch things that make a difference.

    Dude, "Get Help"

    =D

  • ohsotrashy was merely replying (and correctly so) to your question: "What audience would they appeal to at the age they're all at?" He/She pointed out that contrary to what you think, a lot of people still want to see the Spice Girls.

    There's no need to get all haughty about knowing about "wars, suffering, or politics." And there's certainly no need to stereotype Spice Girls fans. They come from different backgrounds and walks of life, from high school dropouts to Ph.D. candidates. :-)

  • i dont think it'll ever be the same again if the spice girls returned.. they were the best of THAT time (mid nineties) like they said, there were predominately boy bands.. nowadays, single artists are valued more..their time is just up, but i loved them! Their image was young, fresh, funny, little girls.. but they're too mature now. What audience would they appeal to at the age they're all at? But they were amazing, and i absolutely adore their songs, GENIUS!

  • The audience they appeal to are the fans they had 10 years ago. If you were on top of the news, you'd know how many sold out shows (47) they performed earlier this year.

    Get help.

  • I love Geri's accent!!

    She is still very Ginger!!

    Especially with straight hair!

  • come to australia soon, we miss u!

  • i love this giving you every thing documentry.

    I love when melanie c swears and they block it.

    sporty spice 26

  • My mom went to Dublin 2 buy SG tickets but they were sold out! Isee it on TV.

  • what did mel c say at 8:49

  • she cussed and they blocke it out

  • she used a swear word and they censored it.

  • 9:28 is the best that i have ever seen posh.

    She looks really nice in that scene and she puts all of her fashion knowledge aside as she talks about....um....wee.

    LOL

  • lol. i love her when she acts like this.

  • Yeah she has a huge sense of humor... i tihnk she is 1 if not the funniest spice girl :D

  • what's wrong with gerri???..shes so emotional

  • Geri was always emotional, i think back when she was in the Spice Girls her emotions got the best of her and IMO she couldn't control them so that's why she left.

  • yes well said. thats what she said/tried to anyway, and what i think as well.

  • no days off for a year!!!!!!???>...omgosh

  • I love Geri, she was the best and she became the most successful outside the group, 4 UK number ones !!!!

  • ummm, that's wrong. have you looked at melanie c's career? she's still going on to this day with her music. she's the most successful female artist in the UK.

  • She's not a big seller and how many big top hits has she had?? I like Mel C. but I know the charts and Geri's been more successful in that regard. Of couse the biggest talent lies in Mel C. I'm not a hater just saying what I think!

  • 3 million for NS, 1.5 million for BI, 500,000 for Reason and 300,000 for This Time. So that's like what 5.3 million records not too bad I wouldn't think.

  • PLEASEE COME BACK AGAIN SPICE GIRLS, I LOVE U SOO MUUCH!!! HUGE FAN!

    if you want the spice girls dvd, join this group on facebook, we can do it! "release the return of the spice girls"

  • aww poor melanie c . she is great no matter what she looks like 00:20

  • ''sharing the urine with the entire room''

    posh so isnt what everyone thinks she is

  • so true!

  • i remember when it happened...how geri said "bye girls" and that was it.....omg i was so sad i cried for a week =(

  • I was in elementary school when the Spice Girls were bih [I'm in college now]. It was horrible when Geri left. I cried so much. I couldn't believe it!

  • was in elementary school when the Spice Girls were big**! LOL Sorry.

  • @DoITakeANumber It was just about a month before I turned ten when that happened. I guess I'm not the only one who felt that the group was incomplete without here because of how difficult it was to continue my fandom for them over the next year or so. I was quite surprised when I found out about a couple of years ago that they reinformed, which believe it or not was right around the time I graduated high school like I mentioned in the first part.

  • LOL

    "What are you doing, you silly cow?!"

    That's nice! xD

    I remember when Geri left... I cried a little bit. And in my mind, she was "the big leaver" :P I'm so glad she came back!

    I saw them on Feb 24th! OMG it was the best night of my life!

    GIRL POWER!

    (GO MEL B! )