David Ben Guriyon proclaims the State of Israel, May 1948

[sam3188ful]

Cant wait to watch the erasure of Israel on youtube.

[hoeryong]

@sam3188ful i love u israel kill all ur enemies!

[Monaelemam]

for all i know its not ben gurion's right to declare the state of israel especially on other people's land!!!

not to mention murdering civilians and innocent people

what te hell is wrong with you people, don't you have any mercy on this nation. They too deserve to live you know

Oh wait, yes we're talking about israel here, the word mercy didn't happen to be in your dictionaries. I disgust you :S

you guys are going to be fucked sooner or later anyway :)

God bless PALESTINE <3

[EternalIntelligence]

@Monaelemam fuck you terrorist bitch. fuck you and your disgusting wasteland that you called palestine.

Israel blossoms! while you and your wretched "land" decay in dismay.

Look at our land and look at yours - Clearly we are smarter, cleaner, and are more deserving than you are.

You get money from international governments and yet you still cant build an efficient economy...let alone a damn building. You waste it all on bombs.

Go bomb yourself bitch! The US is ALWAYS on Israels side.

Die.

[AllTehPrettyHorses]

@Monaelemam We screwed the Palestinians over and we know it. But Israel does have the right to exist. Every nation which exists today, including all the Arab-Muslim nations, exists as the direct result of a war in which they fought and won, Israel is no different.

At some point the Palestinians are going to have to accept living as peaceful citizens of the State of Israel just as millions of Arabs do today. It's either that or the Gaza strip and the wall.

[Monaelemam]

@AllTehPrettyHorses I know wars existed and still going to, but lets be honest they're brutal and again they don't have mercy. This has been your way for the past 100 years or so. And i'm not going to mention Egypt, Syria, or Lebanon. This isnt a right to exist, they're simply expressing a right to destroy! :S

and that's actually the worst part.

[AllTehPrettyHorses]

@Monaelemam No it's the right to exist and defend your own existence.

If the Arab armies had managed to conquer Israel in any of the wars they fought against us, then Israel would not now exist, but that is not the case: Israel won and so does exist and has every right to do so based on the virute of our military victories.

The Palestinians need to decide if they want to peacefully live in Israel with us, or remain stuck in the Gaza strip and the West Bank.

[10022nyc]

Israel forever ! ♥♥ Yom Ha'atzmaut sameach ! ♥♥

[hoeryong]

@10022nyc thank u god protect u

[DarthZimmeris]

Whether anyone likes it or not, Israel is Israel. It's not up to you to judge whether that's "right", or "wrong". In fact, there really isn't any clear "right" or "wrong" in this, or indeed most any, situation. It's never that simple, and certainly isn't here.

Israel has fought three massively bloody wars against overwhelming odds and a united, multi-national enemy. And Israel has won. That's better validation than any discussion, or debate, or politically correct dribble could ever be.

[zobielamouche1]

what if the hungarians establish their state in the ural region (and at the cost of the locals) because their ancestors have lived their about 1500 years ago? btw, the origin of the modern jews in palestine is everything but undisputed

[DarthZimmeris]

@zobielamouche1 You're not appreciating the size of the territory under discussion, or lackthereof. These "local" Palestinians, as you call them, are Jordanians, Lebanese, and Syrians, that simply moved a few miles further south, and ONLY a few miles. It's not all that far. But that's not the issue. The issue is: why can these people NOT live happily just a few miles from their so-called "ancestral home", or even within it (as many still do), and why can they not do so peacfully? Answer that.

[DarthZimmeris]

@zobielamouche1 You really cannot compare whatever issues the Hungarians have had with the larger nations of Europe to the situation in Israel, it's a completely different region with different cultures and a different history. Furthermore, in the modern age there is NO point in even entertaining ANY discussion of "is it RIGHT for Israel to exist, or not?" That's over. The country is 60 years old, and has fought for, and won, its independance many times over. So it's Israel, not "Palestine". :)

[zobielamouche1]

@DarthZimmeris the "israelis" as you call them are jewish russians, poles, lithuanians, bielorussians who moved to palestine in the last phase of the ottoman rule. the question is why they established a statehood in a land in which most of them have no roots, no ancestors. and even they had 2 or 3000 years ago, would that them? palestine is a completely different region with different cultures and a different history. there was no need to give the jews a spa ressort to cure the holocaust

[DarthZimmeris]

@zobielamouche1 Israel was and is not, in fact, a "spa ressort to cure the holocaust", not at all, and if you can't see that, then there really isn't any point in talking with you any further.

And you didn't bother to address any of the points I made, which are clearly valid and highly relevant, so I don't see why you're being so evasive.

Israel is Israel, and anyone who is STILL whining about that needs to either grow up, or go join Hamas and lets get this over with; you complete tool. :(

[zobielamouche1]

@DarthZimmeris well, i didn't see any need to talk with you from the beginning and i wouldn't have done so, hadn't i had some minutes w/o something better to do, darth vader :)

[DarthZimmeris]

@zobielamouche1 But you did come in here and basically say to every Jewish person who might watch this video: "Your country sucks and doesn't have the right to exist." -- and you had to intend something by that, and you had to expect, and/or want, some sort of response. So pardon me for replying to you on behalf of my fellow Jews who happen to LOVE the country you so carelessly deny.

And what is it to you anyway? What has Israel ever done to you? Did she run over your cat, or something?

[DarthZimmeris]

@zobielamouche1 What about all the Sfaradic Jews who currently live in Israel? (Millions of Moroccan, Yemenite, Tunisian, Syrian, and Egyptian Jews) What about them? They and their families were kicked out of their respective Arab countries after WWII and the creation of the State, so where do they fit into your account? You're choosing to ignore a lot of reality in favor of a wholly anti-semitic hardline opinion, and that's just simplistic hateful garbage, and you shouldn't be selling it here.