Added: 3 years ago
From: majakcz
Views: 59,579
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (148)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I believe one day, maybe 50 years from now some of you eho don't like geffen's voice will

    appreciate him, his voice is full of emotion

  • Not gonna bash on Geffen, but let's just say I probably wouldn't listen to Blackfield if it wasn't for Steven Wilson...

  • Steve Willson is so SEXY

  • aviv geffen is not gay he has a 4 year old son and was married to a women u would of never be able to get for yourself he has preforming for more then 20 years and he is not nervous thats the way he sings , u don't like it so get out of the vid.. peace

  • and your point is???

  • Good music is a Western thing.

  • wow this solo is so great. and i really don´t think aviv sucks. it gives blackfield a character, the way he sings "piictures" or "wiindou" :)

  • plus he looks gay .. fuck this budy

  • @daskfighter do you got a problem how he looks?

  • @BritishKid925 yessss he's gay

  • Geffen's vocals sucks :s

    wish if i could see this video without him in it.

  • We need to find the 2 people who disliked it. We can do that together!

  • Wilson should've never hooked up with those hook-nosed Jews ... i mean the 'singer' can't even pronounce fucking basic English words let alone sing 'em ... it's EPIDEMIC not 'EPEEDEMEEK' which is what the cocksucker sounds like ... oh fuck'em

  • @oxytrebor trolololololol

  • @oxytrebor Stop being a hater. So he doesn't talk like you? Get over it and try to embrace another culture. Stop being such a close minded little insecure prick and get over your self-righteous shit headed self.

  • A Epidemic in my heart!!!!!!

  • An Epidemic in my heart!!!

  • Yes, whyyyyyy does he do that sheep vibrato thing? If you don´t have a natural vibrato, don´t even try to do it... Steven Wilson doesn´t have it so he just maintain the tone without it and that is SO much better than the sheep vibrato that Aviv have... Aviv is a brilliant song and text writer, bad in pronouncing english words but it´s OK. But please, I hope he stops the vibrato thing... :P

  • LMAO

    why the hell does he do that sheep thing?!?!?!

  • I like Stevens "thank you"!!

  • awesome song and I love the vocal harmonics

  • Aviv. 150% of expression.

  • love this on the album but I do agree the sheep thing is not good. Leave it out Aviv...or try some other animal....

  • @zedmanZ9 like a human? lol.

  • I just LOVE the YEH YEH YAHOOO thing :D

  • Just started: 2hrs listening B. daily... Waiting for you in Rome!! 

  • lol couldnt help but to giggle after reading the comments about sounds like a sheep, and then listening to it. He really does sound like a sheep!

  • i am obsessed with this song

  • They harmonize really nicely when they sing together

  • This is my favorite song on the album, but live Aviv's bleating kills it for me.

  • Steven...

  • i saw aviv geffen in greece with placebo,he is a very good singer!! :)

  • amagad! there's a freakin sheep on the stage.. WTF O.o

  • Sheep vibrato ftw. It's unique. Stop whining!

  • @bestrader wowww...baaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhh :P WTH???

  • Ehm, at 0:26 you can see a laptop running cubase. why is that?

  • @ThioNeal Samples maybe? I don't know much about Cubase so I don't know.

  • aviv has a great voice tooo

  • Don't get me wrong people, I totally love all the Steve's music, but I've just watched the whole concert and in my opinion Aviv can't sing FOR SHIT!!! I mean, not to hate on the guy, but his voice nowhere close to anything good. Maybe it's because singing next to Wilson would make anybody - or almost anybody (credits here for John Wesley) - sound lame, but it totally ruins the show. You can judge the singer by his live performance, and to my mind Aviv fails here miserably...

  • I love this song =)

    Steven Willson is the best!

  • This band is my new fav band....I was listening to Opeth religiously and thru interviews I started seekin out music by Steven Wilson

  • Pretty sure I dig the supposed Sheep baaaaaaaaaaaah. Unique and such.

  • Amazing !!!

  • Amazing song, i love it!

  • I know the majority of the people here hates de "baahh" sound of Aviv, but this song is the only one where it sounds strange :S By the way, Aviv was famous in his country before meeting Steven, since 1994!!! (If I'm not wrong), so don't say that he would be nothing without Steven u_u

    Finally: Search & listen Zerak Halev Shecoev, Our Song, Im hazman, Or Hayarech & Love song (rock version), these ones show his real talent

  • They would be nowhere if it weren't for Steven Wilson.

  • i love stevens solo and then aviv's scream awesome!

  • Good song !!!

  • great song!

  • Yeah Aviv annoys me but Blackfield 2 is such a good album.

  • Awesome!

  • When i heard steven wilson was in blackfield i had to check it out but i never felt it like a another porcupine tree

  • Aviv sounds like goatboy. M-M-MAAA-AAAA-HHHH

  • To those who never heard Aviv Geffen sing in hebrew, believe me he does a much much better job in English even though the accent obviously is somewhat annoying when he sings live. in the studio though it is less apparent and he surprisingly sounds pretty good. geffen is a brilliant songwriter. Please stop comparing him with Steve wilson who is one of those unique trifecta talents.

    He's a great singer, songwriter, & guitar player. They compliment each other nicely making Blackfield a great band

  • to superalex: just heard aviv`s it`s cloudy now hebrew version. nothing to compare with blackfield`s! i do think that they complement each other. he`s a good songwriter, but aout interpretation, after hearing both i really have some doubts about competing with stevie`s on interpretation

  • @MrJasonroy Aviv did the hebrew version when he was - like - 17 or so, on his first album ever, painted as an israeli Marylin Manson. Since then he grew up and developed much better than anticipated. A modern interpretation by him would sound much better than the originl raw stuff.

  • @SuperAlex2504 Yea don't compare him to wilson

    But you gotta know that wilson is Awesome :P

  • @SuperAlex2504 But AViv sometimes do sound like a sheep. BUT love his voice otherwise

  • @SuperAlex2504 fuck yeah

  • @SuperAlex2504 what fuckin' ever . this kike has no business singing in English ... plus he looks like a goddamn faggit ... he looks like one of those fags that think they're sexy ... glitter-lookin-bitch ov a snatch .... hope he gets AIDS

  • Why does aviv do that? At the end of every lyric he does this sheep sounding decent in his voice. Hes got a pretty good voice but that kinda ruins it.

  • The heroin fucks him up I guess

  • @tannerdrummer48 Too many Cocteau Twins records methinks!!

  • @tannerdrummer48 I like his awkward vibrato!

  • @tannerdrummer48 lol idk man

  • @tannerdrummer48 nice dude....lol....m just speechless dude...u rocksss.. \m/..!!

  • @tannerdrummer48

    That's his style of vibrato, and I agree it's grating.

  • @tannerdrummer48, absolutely don't agree with you. I thing that scream was awesome!

  • @tannerdrummer48 Trying to impersonate a vibrato I think :S

  • @tannerdrummer48 Yeah, he goes a little too hard on the vibrato.

  • @tannerdrummer48

    Aviv means sheep in jewish?

  • @Waynestock100 I don't think Jewish is a language bro.

  • @tannerdrummer48 test he sings like that because he is nervous and can't hold the high note at the end of the lyric.

  • @tannerdrummer48 As a singer, I think he just does it kind of as a stylistic thing. I personally love his voice. When he voice shakes is shows a little emotion.He does it too much live though. haha

  • @tannerdrummer48 I love it.

  • haha stupid arguments.... um.... blackfield rocks. hoping to get the dvd.

  • Cock joke

  • ey people let's ignore bajsebob because he think's he is mr. I know everything and people who don't are stupid motherfuckers... WELL BOB YOUR THE BIGGEST FUCK UP HERE

  • Aviv sounds like a sheep in the beginning. :3

  • LOL xD

  • J'irais pas jusque la mais c'est vrai qu'yé décevant en show

  • tbnk ke Aviv chante comme une osti de queud... on dirait un mouton en train d'se faire enculer

  • aviv kinda sucks. hate to admit it

  • ^^ you're absolutely right. He really has to work on his singing, doesn't he?

    ...sometimes he sounds like a goat...

    but what do I say, I can't sing either ;-P

  • he's like not a great song writer, his singing is kinda obnoxious and often very shitty, and he has fucking glitter on his eyes. enough said.

  • Actually, if u would take the time to listen to HIS music, (aviv geffen), and check out his records , you would realize he IS a great song songwriter and a lot of blackfields songs were composed by him....

  • that's what i'm saying. i have taken that time, and i do know that a lot of blackfield songs were written by him. i think a lot of blackfield's songs are composed amateurly (or whatever the word is). his singing is really pretty annoying, and his writing is unimpressive; simple and repetitive. I listen to blackfield for steven wilson--he's one of the greatest musicians out there.

  • Ignorance is a bliss, isn't it?

  • yeah i think v can ignore fuckups and appreciate the awesomeness which each of those guyz up on stage have in them... \m//....(but yeah its a little funny when aviv is totally nasal and does the sheep spoof... :))

  • @am115936 actually most blackfield songs are written by him, steven has a bigger role in the arranging and mixing process.

  • seriously a great song.

  • I listen to this song like every day. Its to great

  • AVIV's bleating voice spoiled everything

  • he sounds like a fucking goat

  • Is that guy wearing glitter in his eyes? i knoq i saw some. in his over vids to..the man from blackfield lol not steven.

  • I think that, at least from my perspective, the hook for this song is when the first verse ends and Wilson comes in with the really low, powerful guitar notes that totally overpower the ones the piano had been offering. It's like, "alright, now we mean business, bitch." Hah.

  • great scream from Aviv Geffen!!!

  • <3

    amazing song..

  • yeah the stupied vibrate ruins it but it is still a great song

  • it's an awesome song but why does aviv sings like a sheep? :']

  • i Love it...

  • Coooool. Fantastic performance. Thanks for my bebe coz gave this song. Luv Luv Luv

  • Blackfield or PT? PT wins

  • projects completely different!

  • they are different but still PT is better, (imo) more developed, sophisticated and more establish, different in genre, but still one is going to be better

  • I totally agree with you when you say that PT is more developed and sophisticated and do you know why? PT do progressive metal, BL do pop! Simple!! And the pop isn't sophisticated...well dude...this is only an opinion at the end..peace:)

  • absolutely agree!

  • Uh...Have you ever heard "Less is more"? Some people actually appreciate the fact that the 5 gallon can isn't filled with 10 gallons of crap. Don't get me wrong, i love prog ang PT...but that statement was just ignorant...it's all just a matter of taste.

  • Porcupine Tree doesn't play progressive metal. They play psychedelic rock. There's a huge difference. Listen more to them, and you'll see.

  • I think you're stupid..It's so hard to understand what was the aim of my first message god damn?! I say they are 2 DIFFERENT band, I don't care what kind of music the poeple think they play! And yes, the do psycadelic rock (voyage 34, up the down stair ecc) the play rock/hard rock (shallow for example) the play pop (listen to light bulbsan) and some song has progressive part into them. So they play more different kind of music if you want to talk of this

  • And another thing...you don't know with who you're are talking...don't write me "Listen more to them" 'cause I play in one of 2 more big Porcupine tribute band from Italy and I know Porcupine 1000 times better than you.

  • You don't know anything about them just because you play in a tribute band. You're just another shitty musician.

  • Don't cry ok?:)

  • haha i saw in your channel 3 different people write you are fag ahaha

  • no they used to play psychedelic rock. now they play more progressive rock/metal. nothing about their last three albums is psychedelic. their older stuff has that psychedelic piece though.

  • @znoahmarhoadskill:

    everything about their last three albums is psychedelic - the latter the more. you need to check out what they are about and even what psychedelia is, because you don't seem to know any of it.

  • hey it'd be great if you stopped accusing people of being ignorant and knowing so much less than you. who the fuck dubbed you the Expert on psychedelia and Porcupine Tree? at least i can hear the difference between prog and psychedelic rock. just chill out and stop being such a pretentious douche

  • well i didn't dub myself an expert, but you dubbed yourself a noob

  • oh did i now? because you think i'm wrong? dumbshit,

  • @ bajsebob:

    DUDE! this is NOT pscychedelia!!! this is way more like alternative pop or space rock! Dude, you're stupid man! You should listen to the first floyd album, piper.. Now this is psychedelia! Know what you say when you critisise someone. Btw I don't say this is no good music, because I think it is. It's just NOT PSYCHEDELIC... goddamn

  • @Bottengooier

    Have you read what I've been saying? We were talking about Porcupine Tree, not Blackfield. That's what you get for interfering with a discussion that you're not a part of. Now STFU, idiot.

  • Ey Bob, I WAS talking about PT fuckface.. and either I was talking about PT or BF doesn't mather.. you don't understand what psychedilia is dude, and you're being arrogant, you think you know shit about music.. well you don't.. so die! buttsniffer

  • NO U

  • I think Incredible Expanding Mindfuck and No-man is better lololololololol

  • But the funniest thing is that you think of Porcupine Tree as psychedilia :D

  • no-man is soo bad. i cant take that singer

  • @bballanimals333 yea i think dudes a fruit cake lol

  • Aviv really sounds like a sheep, live -_-' Really, I'm seriously, my ears are bleeding now... But don't get me wrong, I'm just an honest fan! =D

    They both rule! Blackfield rules! ^_^ (Though Wilson is still so much better than Geffen...)

  • I recognise you are very right... Aviv sounds like a sheep, lol

  • well,his voice is not an angel voice..but his writting is something special..and most of blackfield songs was writtin' by him..

  • Comment removed

  • En epedeemikkk in mmaiiii haaarrrrttt

    as much as i love blackfield I cant help but find his singing funny.

  • Haha! everytime i hear this song, i laugh at that part.

  • dont say everything's ok!

  • I love this song sooooo much... <3

  • Actually, Wilson is the best musician i think.

  • Amazing song! Setve Wilson rules!!!... and Gefen to!!! Balckfiel Ruuuules!!! jajaja

  • great song

  • Para Jenny que es la mas fan de esta banda jeje

  • q gran tema !!

    Grande Wilson

  • Wilson is the King

  • aviv gefen <3

  • magnifique piece magnifique duo

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more