Added: 9 months ago
From: DAGCMEDIA
Views: 49,596
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (75)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Sundor

  • 5 people have hearing impairment problem. Lets not be rude to them :)

  • khub bhalo laglo. khubi shundor geyechhen.

  • like the modification of rabindra sangeet....

    atleast new generation will now listen to this type of songs...

    Good Work....

  • The best of the best composition by Anjan Datta... !

  • 5 people are idiots !!

  • nice blending

  • notun kore robindronath thakur ke khujer pabar ekta darun sujog for the new generation. Oshadhanor gaan ta....

    THANKS ANJAN DA and his TEAM......

    Odbhut cinematography & video editing...every moment is so touching !!!!!!!

  • I love this, brings a completely new whiff to this legendary song. And I dont care what the so called purists say about it. If I like something, I should have the liberty to express it. Interpretations & adaptations are a common thing across world literature. I I think ppl should consider it as a type of freedom of speech. If some people derogate this in the name of liberty, ppl will surely reject it. Have faith in their intellect. Kudos to Neel Dutta for the song.

  • joss

  • oshadharon..............nice song

  • HAWA....buira vam gula kochi maia loya moja neu.....

  • PEOPLE SHOULD UNDERSTAND THEY ARE MAKING THESE SONGS FOR NEW GENERATION OR NEXT GEN OR PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT IN TOUCH WITH RABINDRA SANGEET ITS FAR BETTER THAN NON-SENSE BENGALI COMMERCIAL MOVIES , THOSE SONGS R BULLSHIT , THIS SONG IS REALLY GOOD , I LOVE IT :) THUMBS UP TO ANJAN DA :)

  • U know I'm a purist and 99% of the times I'll rebuke such attempts...like the one made in bong connection....but in this case it's different...first of all well sung and music at no point overtakes the singer and most importantly it somehow radates the essence of Rabindranath....no holding back no half measures but artistic...probably credit shd be given to Kabir Suman and Anajan Dutta. Great.

  • Eta shune Kobi Guru swarga theke neme ashben ;-) ..... Jokes apart....nice rendition..... Nandan Bagchi in drums is awesome as usual...and the singer ....such a fresh tone....nice

  • beautiful rendition of this great song..!! i think neel is doing an excellent job in experimenting with old classics and giving it a fresh appeal for the youth...!! this is extremely necessary in todays time and age where people are almost forgetting rabindranaths songs... and thru ways as this he is actually bringing the songs forward 2 the club hopping, new generation..! its freaking awsum...! i love it..!! thank u neel..!! and get lost old schoolers u hav no ri8 to comment if u cant appreci8

  • Comment removed

  • words cannot express the praise i have for the singers and the great composer of this song.

  • wow

    

  • super like..Somlata is awesome and guys let's ignore the 5 who disliked it :)They are nothing compared to the ones who loved this song!

  • Comment removed

  • like it.. :)

  • The problem is that when someone is trying for new rendition he or she can't change the tone,voice,theme,diction of the music in such a way that it becomes inconsistent with the diction,and theme of the lyrics.then the musician is disrespecting his or her audience.becos the mood and diction of the song is melancholic.. and you can say ..come on this is new age music..still composition and arrangements are better(only if we did not consider the lyrics) than "pagla hawa" which was cheesy and cheap

  • @Ghoshup ...I support ur views ....

    but I want to add something......every type of experimentation should be welcomed...I support this opinion...even It is only allowed now..It should have been allowed long ago....just for an example.(only example... bob dylan's songs have been sung in thousand other ways by his contemporaries and by his predecessors also)...because if a musician can not get good lyrics or he or she want to interpret a song in a different way...then it's ok... but

  • How to watch in online this film?

  • recklessfreakful@ Fuck off.

    

  • @TheRandom2311 hiiiiiiiiiii just think about parents ..............

  • When I listen to it, it sounds fresh, it's vibrant, its got a very youthful appeal. it's time Tagore songs break barriers of a certain taste. and Neel has done it before and he does it again very successfully.

  • I did not have any opinion on Kabir Suman. Infact the song starts with a rhythm, then when Suman sings there's just a faint rhythm , more of the guitar and finally the rhythm comes back with Anjan Somlata and Suman together. But that's beside the point. It was the arrangers decision not ours.

  • recklessfreakful @ buzz off.

    unculturedperson@ the song has been excellently pepped up by Neel. If you have problems with someone dancing to Tagore that's completely your personal problem. The point is most of us are so stuck up that we have problems with any new thing. You don't have to like everything that a person does. But don't go on bad mouthing or mud slinging.

  • @TheRandom2311

    haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaa........" excellently pepped up" the rose water treatment thanks to your excellent suggestion..... Now It sounds like English! jokes apart you forgot to include the punch line.You bring to mind a quote from Josh Billing hope you will know it my Blunt tong friend which apparently looks sharp. LOL'z

  • good arrangement. keep experimenting and don't pay too much attention to the traditionalists. rabi thakur wouldn't have liked us to simply get used to "habits". we are free human beings in a free country. and nobody is stopping the traditionalists from singing this song in the old way.

  • That decision making can either make him or break him...and in this case its a thumbs down to his musical decision, or should I say an'influenced' decision.  I would agree that experiment is very much required in today's bengali music but it shd not be at a cost. With such a line up of Amyt,Lou,Nandan & Suman, I feel that hysteric helter skelter of ball dance could have been avoided. Except Lou none can dance :-) By the way what is your interpretation of Amyt's guitar piece in the song?

  • This song is a good easy listning one in the first section...its peppy,but it does not give me the feel of what this song should sound like. On the other hand in the 'antara' section, when suman steps in,the mood changes instantly. And there you go,the 'song' comes to its real life. Neel is pretty ok,but to become a good or a great composer, he needs to become musically more matured. Either he should not have included Suman in this song at all,or he should make Suman sing the entire song.

  • wow,this thread is now full of interesting comments..... @Therandon2311 - I would like to understand your perspective on how would it be if 'Layla" or ' Comfortably Numb' is sung in the structure of a Rabindrasangeet composition? I believe your answer would be 'AWEFUL'. And that is why the freedom of 'fusing' music is a very fine art.... listen to Jean luk Ponty or Pat Metheny and you will understand what I'm talking abt.

  • @bhaskar1970 Firstly if you have read notations or swaralipi then its needless to say that you'd realise that this song has not deviated an inch from the notations. If you think that it has then I'm sorry to say you're sadly mistaken. Secondly the swaralipi of Tagore mentions the notes of the song i.e the tune. There can be 1001 chords that can be put behind those notes. In this case it's simple pop rock feel.

  • F*** ur rules on ur back ...... who says about rule ..how can you read others mind ..... and in the name of no ruling you create one another pressure like Robi Mafia ..... which is purely conditional. :) lol

  • @recklessfreakful stop commenting in a global forum if you don"t know english. :) lol

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @TheRandom2311

    Asshole fuck your global English write in the ass locally, ie right in whole and who the hell is leading you by the nose ....... how much cheap you are ,step from nitpicking to correct / incorrect engliriiiii .... when you understand what I say then you show off how much incorrect (grammar ,,, syntax ...... etc etc ) 1/2

  • @TheRandom2311

    2/2 It 's only possible for retried bong like you who usually kick out from his own  local collage and free distributing your fucking correction with other( free cost .)

    Now I've a gap FREE COST I avoided ' OF' .... Because you can surly point out another mistake ..... Do you ever think about yourself how much pathetic loser you are ..... like veterran (Check the spell for me asshole.... because it's your only fucking duty ) LOL

  • unculturedperson@ the album which you mentioned is one boring album. Secondly Nachiketa should have sung the songs in his normal way and shouldn't have even tried to sing them classically. Seems like you'r e one Tagore fanatic. Hope you know what fanatics do. Give the young music people their dues. And try and understand the song before commenting.

  • @TheRandom2311 : the classical bits were sung by rashid khan.

    just coz ur taste doesnt match with someone else, u cannot go around calling that person fanatic. And yes i do understand the song,and no, i dont understand the unnecessary peppying up of it.

  • Neel has extraordinarily arranged this great song. Mt best wishes to him and his entries group of veteran musicians. Most of you guys don't even understand what Amyt Datta has played in this song and why.

  • I think the problem with you guys is that most of you like sitting there and picking on people who're trying to break rules and trying to do something interesting in this otherwise dead city of ours.

  • Similarly what Tagore had in mind or why on earth did he write this song or what this song is meant to invoke or how it has to be sung or arranged...nobody has any sole right on that.

  • I'm sure most of you who've been typing in views belong to the new generation regardless you are 35 or above. And it's sick how dated your thoughts are. No work of art can survive the test of time without being discovered or rediscovered. . Everyday thousands of people see Monalisa at the Louvre and get 1000 different feelings. What Da Vinci thought while painting it hardly matters.

  • well i have been listening to her music since "ichhe gulo" and to my surprise she keeps on bettering her vocal renditions with every new number she has to offer...and jagorane was no exception...the freshness and uniqueness of her voice is simply awesome...wish she does real grt in her musical career...keep it up!!!

  • Neel anjan's kid a nice performer not music director ...... is it call mix OMG . I'm not biased , I like some of the songs from kaya's " Rabindra Rockz" album . what what is it !? shit total spoil of time. thank God neel kept his hands off suman's part..... but total representation is so cheap .............

  • fuse rabindrasangeet and make modern arrangement to make it attractive,nice thought but WTH is this? people should listen to yatra songs by nachiekta to know how to fuse songs, go listen to the album mamo chitte ke je nache by various artists to know how to fuse songs,the saving grace is suman, who is the female singer i wonder. total wastage

  • @unculturedperson Nachiketa's Yatra is disgusting and who are you to judge the female singer? Did she sing anything out of Tagore's sur or taal? Rather I feel that Suman lost what he had. Though I am a die hard fan of Suman yet when I heard this I felt Suman can't sing anymore the way he used to.

  • @cdetc :i mentioned one more album too, in case u didn't read. And i thought we can state our opinions in a public forum without thinking if we r able to judge or not! going by that, who r you to judge my opinion i wonder.

    I agree with you on suman, this probably isn't his best , but still i think it has his flare

  • anjan dutt jindabaad..... \\m//

  • People are fooling around in the video Hysterically. The sogn was saved by Suman still. It is very important to popularize tagore songs but the question is at what cost? I would only say there are some great licks from Amyt and Suman..... there was no need of doing hybrid ball dance to this song.

  • except for Kabir Suman's singing the enitre concept and rendition is horrible.what's with a girl showing her cleavage and clapping in this song?

  • @bhaskar1970 Would you please get yourself checked by an ENT specialist and and also a Psychiatrist? What a sick mentality!! Did u use a magnifying glass to find her cleavage? I really pity men like you.

  • @cdetc i dont need any specialists to prove me wrong,ive been listening to Tagore from my childhood and i know what Rabindrasangeet is.in this movie its been murdrered by the singer and music director but what can u expect from a person who copies from other peoples music."tumi ashbe bole" is total ripp off /copy of FREDDIE FENDER'S -"BEFORE THE NEXT TEARDROP FALLS"

    ki je hocche ke jane

  • @bhaskar1970 u knw wats d problm wid guys like u is dat u cnt c or accpt to changes....here ppl r trying to make Thakur much more popular...Thakur's songs r now sung by bengalis from all around d wrld...n u still r clinging to dose old scholl thoughts...lstn to wats new n if u really dnt lyk den y do u search for dese songs on youtube...

  • @bhaskar1970 now a days, diverting from the main stream path be it for the better or worse is being termed as Change or so called Modernization.. Its no surprise that Rabindranath Tagore is the new victim of neo-age music.. .He has given a specific set of rules (read notations or swaralipi ) for a reason and not to be discarded at the slightest pretext.. This is to my opinion is no way a better rendition of the song rather a vile and cheap publicity stunt to increase coarse public attention.

  • @bhaskar1970 Well Mr. Bhaskar, now I feel sorry you. Do you know how many songs aof Rabindranath Tagore are influenced by western music, especially english and scottish? Tunes of some of the songs match exactly with their inspired western counter parts. Purano shei diner kotha, Phool-e phool-e dhole dhole , Kotobaar-o bhebechhinu are just a few examples of them. So I guess you consider yourself cultured and learned enough to criticize Tagore also for this...right???

  • refreshingly nice!

  • Awesome rendition...... Super Like ++++

  • This is a good rendition. People who still cling on to the Visvabharati sponsored archaic Rabindrasangeet tune need to look beyond antiquity and welcome the new. We must remember Rabindranath himself was an advocate of change and novelty.

  • Darun to a successful attempt... 

  • Anjan Rocks!! Thanks for reinventing rabindra sangeet...

  • aswaadhaaroN rendition... rabi thakurer gaan khaanchaay aaTke thaakaar jonyo noy... mugdho hoyechhi ei composition-ey

    onek dhonyobaad share kawraar jonyo...

  • The singer mechanically sings to tune. There is no feeling for what is being said. Rabindrasangeet is not so feeble as to need such 'smart' updating. Admittedly this one is less offensive than 'Pagla hawa', which is not saying much!

  • @hemantapagol the singer 'mechanically' sings??? kabir suman is onobodyo here... the feeling/modulation in his voice is awesome. the female vocalist is quite good too.

  • The proper effort to contemporaries Rabindra Sangeet must be encouraged. I emphasize on the word 'PROPER'. 'Pagla hawa' and 'Jagorone' definitely fall under that category. Thanks a lot guys. My daughter's name is Hiya and I owe you one for this unintentional gift.

  • khuuuuub valo

  • Just too good... bola jai na ki sundar, apurva, absolutely awesome !!! Simply loving this !

  • awesome composition...fresh and clean melody...anjan da rocks...

    please upload the other songs from the movie...

  • Nice one..

  • @sankhac how can i watch from online? bcoz im living in Indonesia.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more