Added: 5 years ago
From: HomicidalSerenity
Views: 229,396
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (544)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Watching this in 2011!

  • I liked them. They seem nice guys and I think they tried hard every week.Good on them

  • love love LOVE! <3

  • blimey they're a bit flat arent they?

  • my dad is there friend :D I HAVE SEEN THEN AHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!

  • low

  • I'm gigging with these guys tonight... decent singers.. nice charts... can't complain... not gonna be superstars or anything.. but as acts go... they're pretty decent...

  • They should have won

  • @heatty2008 i know me and my dad know them there our friends

  • I think this song is hilarious for some reason :D

  • they did great job with this song.

  • Perfect performance!! but if I can say something, it's pity Craig when you sing aloud such a 2:15 merely disappoints me the band of your singing voice's bit narrow. But I'm sure that it's up to your voice training!! Thank you guys showed me awesome singing!! : )

  • these were awful :p

  • Representing scotland! ;)

  • A real foot tapper !

  • I liked them and thought some of the comments over the weeks were too harsh.These boys seem civil and are decent singers

  • this show the true talent of the scots

  • i voted

  • all they 'wanna be' is gay fags

  • i love thesee boys my mum knows them well and they live in alloway and my mum works in alloway but they have sang this song better than this performance but they were really good "LUVVVV U BOYSSS <3 xx"

  • this is the best version of this song, they sang it better than the original

  • huh??? one of the "wanna be" please stop it ur killing the original artist "the Proclaimers"

  • shame all the words in the verses weren't right

  • i sang with them on stage at choices for life twice :) it was amazing

  • Hello related video! something to do with these guys. Nice one.

  • Shoulda won the hole competition. Those of you who know what im talkin about, know... what im talkin about.

  • the mcdonald brothers, currently working in a mcdonalds these days.

  • I heared them live at choices for life and they were really good :)

  • they are soo sweeet! shit, but sweet! i just wanna hug them lol.

  • this si such an epic version of this song! Love it.

  • they made the Proclaimers proud with that performance. good on them

  • Comment removed

  • great version

  • :D do u no :D is 2 short alone?

  • I remember these two getting a lot of stick from the media but that was a good cover version of 500 miles.

  • First positive comment from Simon ever

  • these are glasvegas.

  • i have meet the macdonld brothers and i got a cuddle off them and photos with them and a t shirt signed i still have it i love them

  • Boy, they're awesome. This song sounds AWESOME with a Scottish accent.

  • As opposed to the original?!

  • omg i love dem !!!!!

    i cried forever when dey were voted off !!

  • they were at the glasgow show and a met them and a wiz at the front love them :)

  • Good version!!!

  • Yeah same.. Ah saw them at choices for lifes

  • ive just been 2 Choices for life and they were there! Live on stage! whooooooooooooooooooooooo! you should FORCE your teachers to let u go!!!

  • Comment removed

  • these guyz sed hi to me after singing this song wen sung in shetland

  • IL THEM

  • I SAW THEM TODAY :D

  • when i go i am gonna be the man who wakes up next to youuuuuuuuuu

    lol i love the mcdonalds i meet them i have a video so i will put it on soon ok bye the way they are sweet when you meet them

  • I SAW THEM LAST NIGHT!!!!

    x xx

  • God I miss them!

    They were the best... Wish they were popular in Norway so they could have a concert. I would have been in the front, singing along to every song.

    Maybe I should move back to the UK just to be able to buy ther album, go to cencerts, etc easier..? *wondering*

  • They Shoulve Won =)

    Butt It Was A Fix Ti Get Them Owt =(

    There Great!!!

  • great pair of entertainers!

  • you cant beat the original.... go proclaimers.. :)

  • that should of bin close but no cigar!!! doh

  • close but cigar!! proclaimers version rules!!!

  • anno i saw them a few months ago they've got better at it but proclaimers are better

  • That is shit!!!!!!!!

  • good..but i like the proclaimer version much more ;-)

  • absolutely, the proclaimers are great

  • Way to go!

  • i am not scottish....ok i am one eighth scottish but these guys are good scottish peopl..................go scottland

  • loveeee these boys <3.

  • FREEDOM!!!!!!

  • i would walk 500 miles and i would roll 500 miles i love them they are so great

  • they were good

  • Aw, I think these two are adorable lol

  • they aren't right for this song. but they can sing all right

  • what are they doing now?

  • They're still doing their tour and promoting their 4th album, which is No. 8 in the Scottish charts! This song never fails to get the audience singing and jumping!!!

  • lol i love this song from british people i love ure accent dammit I WANT IT NOW! LOL

  • to JadeBx its nothin to do with them being scottish i like scottish people gonna be movin up dere soon its about them bein shit dats y sum ppl av a go at dem

  • As Louis Walsh would say

    I LIKED IT

  • Yay Brian and Craig!

    I was dancing to that song this time last week at their concert! :)

    I just had to watch this to remind myself of their XFactor days :D

  • lawl ma name is craig too

  • hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.... what to say. I guess it's flattering to "THE PROCLAIMERS" nice try, but NO CRAG and CHARLIE.

  • its not good. listen to there voices carefully, its rather shit

  • OMG....watching this performance just makes me smile

  • lol that was there bestest performance definately lol =D

  • yer they do look like ant and seb oh sorry ant and deaf

  • don't they know remind u of Ant n Seb ?? frm this yr show

  • really love 'em

  • oh dear god...

  • the majority of the time listining to these guys made me embarresed to be scottish

  • Your Opinion Doesnt Matter.

    If You Dont Like Them. Dont Watch Videos of Them :D

  • love them

  • If you live in North Lanarkshire, Scotland, they will be in ASDA Newmains at 10.00am on Monday morning (13th october)

  • absulutely amazing :)

  • the proclaimers sound better.

    still, good performance.

  • i Think They Are Awsome At This Songg :D

  • its gid but proclaimers are better :D

  • the proclaimers made this song the fuck r these fags

  • they own lol

  • whit fabb singers!!!!!

  • There not gays how I wish they were ;-)

  • fuck sake me get a life you tit cut them some slack id like to see you get up there and do it

  • love them met them at a cd signing nd there soo nice aswell

    brians actually reeli hot haha

    xx

  • See Aw Use That Hate The MacDonlad Brothers Yeez Are Probli English And The English Are Scum Anyway So Nobody Wants Your Opinion !! Weres Everyone Else Who Has Entered The X-Factor Eh :)):)) No Where Exactly :)) Whers The MacDonald Brothers :D There Still Doin There Thing :D:D There Still Out Touring And Stuff :D:D Soo There Yeez All Go :D As Sharon Sayd They Owned The Stage :D And They Still DO :D :-) The MacDonald Brothers Ruleeee :D:D x

  • I think theyr good so shut your mouths :) scots boys :D

  • The accomplishment is with The Proclaimers who wrote this brilliant song.

  • I don't suppose any of the people who view this performance in a negative light can imagine how much rehearsal it took to accomplish. Do you know what it means to sing in harmony much less be able to do it? I don't particularly care for them but this was a great performance. Of course the orginal rules.

  • god...they suck

  • what a crap...such gaylords

  • i bet ill b disliked 4 this, but everyones allowed an opinion, so... anyway, i think they suck. their performances are just wierd!!

  • i better go get my phone to vote!!! lol

  • The boys are great, everyone in there right mind loves the boys, and those who dont..well God help you.

    Luv ya boys x

  • we supported them tonight!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D:D

  • love it

  • could someone help me please.... there's a song that the mcdonald brothers sang on the xfactor one week, but i cant remember the name of it. The lyrics are something like - "I fell glad when you're glad, i feel sad when you're sad. If you only knew what im going through, I just can't (something) without you"..........thanks

  • yea that is sissy

    total toke the country scottish feeling out of it

  • they sound kinda sissy, no one can do it like the proclaimers...

  • FxXx.. i think its coz it makes him more confident to stand out maybe

  • why is he smiling all the time lol

  • what shit

  • i prefer the proclaimers!

  • Have you just learnt to swear?

  • his mummy told him it was rude :o

  • hahaha i like the random swearing at the end. sound like a paranoid schizophrenic just freakin' out on your multiple personalities.

  • They are scottish i saw them when i was on holiday a few years ago i had a chat with them and got there signitures "in case they became famous"

    then i switch the tv on one night a few years later and i see them on xfactor!!!!!!!!!!

    i was like OMG OMG OMG OMG

    but yer they ARE scottish

  • im a scottie nobody likes me T-T

  • shut up u lil ho

  • amazing singers... and i just can't get over how CUTE they are!!!

  • i was at choies for life in secc glasgow scotland and they sang this and flower of scotland my school is st johns blackwood and i going to high school holy cross high

  • they preformed this at the choices for life concert they were awesome.

  • im goin 2 meet the macdonald brotherz 2 dai a chices 4 life i soooo cnt wait

  • I like this version, but I feel like the Procs have more feeling too it.

    Alos, this one is good in it's own ways, it's a bit more poetic and such, but I'm a sucker for the origionals. <3

    But they're pretty awesoem too. ^^

  • he procs are better

  • good,

    but not as good as the procs!

  • i think they are better on two things they r cuter and r better at their job =singing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! by Cruella

    the mcdonald brothers are alot better at singing i think they should of stayed in till the last two or should of won it not gone out in the last three

    by loppy58679

  • btw, wow!

  • what are their names?

  • i think they have made it better than the origanal

  • An abosoloute asshole at ma school when this series was on sayed they where GAY! retard anyways awesome song wish people ould stop puttin us scots down we could squash England anyday.

  • i agree with u till the squash england bit, y add tht in???

  • they look different!and dont say there bad!!!there great!^^u have no brain if u think they suv=ck!there brilliant!^^:D

  • Possibly one of the best scottish singers to make it 5000 miles to the X Factor finals!

  • these boys are great i saw them supporting the back home westlife concert and was surprised how good they were .

  • They missed a bit they forgot when i come home ...... when i grow old after the working bit XD great vid

  • WHERE IS HIS FUCKIN TAMBERINE

  • That was better than I could do it.

  • OMG!!! Simon said it was very good!!!!

  • My thoughts...

    They Are Awesome!

    They Are Scottish!

    Don't Like Them? Don't Waste Your Bloody Time Commenting O Thier Vids Yeh? SIMPLE!

    If you haven't noticed, if they couldnt sing then they wouldnt have gottent o the live shows!

    It was not only the scottish who voted for them as i know a lot of fans who are outwith Scotland!

    If they are crap then how did they mnage to get a record deal? And have 3 albums?

    Answer me all of them..

    BACK I MACS!

  • yeah this may be true but i like the way the proclaimers did it

  • faredooz, am nae sayin that the proclaimers were shit, coz i like thier version ana, i was just sayin that the macs did it magic ana :)

  • shut up u scottish bastard

  • "shut up u scottish bastard " lol

  • Blondie is Craig (Y)

  • they rocked that song all the way

  • this song takes every one off the chair and jumping around with the arms in the air.

    great job guys!! love the way you two warmed the stage

  • hey unjaded2 i've got some advice 4 u

    SHUT UP

    Britain can do a lot of brilliant things- this was ok the original 1 is better but still

    Britain is NOT rubbish

    Best Music, Tv And Fish And Chips in The World

  • yeh u go

    unjaded2 obv hasnt heard good music b4

    and LIVE UN-EDITED MUSIC!!!

    the macdonalds rock the show

  • As an American, that unjaded2 twit obviously hasn't heard of Radiohead, The Cure, Joy Division, The Smiths, Muse, Goldfrapp, Basement Jaxx, FRANKMUSIK, Super Furry Animals, etc etc etc (I could go on forever).

    Amazing music isn't tied to a particular location on a map =3

  • maybe you should check out the winner, she may be the best singer in the whole world you know

  • ...And maybe you need a spell-checker, you illiterate twat.

  • FREAKIN SICK SONG!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • a play guitar nn a dont need 2 look at wat am doin nn ave meet them they stay in ayr nn so do I

  • shut up u dick u never met em before and stop making up shit. go fucking die twat!!!

  • I love how their accents resound in the song...

  • ya right

  • he doesnt actually play the guitar. they all hold instruments because they get nervous with their hands.

  • Really lol??

  • yup. they all can't learn to play guitars and stuff within a week. and they never look at the instruments to see what their doing