Added: 5 years ago
From: Rumspringa
Views: 8,399
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (26)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wow.......that is all!

  • Nary a dry eye in the room, probably.

  • I adore this arrangement. though i don't think Smog is the backing vocalist. it is usually the drummer Neal Morgan or else the accordian player Dan Cantrell.

  • For long time prforming on album songs on Live for my senses... if I was there I coudn't be seaten eraing this fantastic 'music party'... this harper it's captiving as the best Genesis epic stories during Peter Gabriel... because first of all she is an special story teller with a big personallity... hoping to see her in Barcelona

  • I prefer the album version, but this is definitely interesting.

  • Do you know who her backup singer is for the last bridge? The bass?

  • He was in a band called Smog. I'm sure it's on Wikipedia somewhere.

  • He is called Bill Callahan but he used to release albums under the name [smog]

  • Yeah the the backing band isn't all that good, but they do need it for the "all my bones" part.

  • well, the backing band only appeals to me during the ending bridge. cause it adds feeling and emotion.

  • honestly, it sounds better properly mixed, with a full orchestra behind it.

  • yes i agree. if i see her, itd be grand to her alone. by herself. but, if not, i would prefer the orchestra. the backing band just doesnt do it for me.

  • i kind of like it...and it's esepcially interesting with this song and others like peach plum pear for the live experience to be more than just her. i dunno, i enjoy the other guys playing with her.

  • to each their own. :)

  • I would have liked this better without the backing band, and I give her instant credit on just performing this 17 minute epic song.

    I love the song. And this is a great performance. But I ever see her, I'd rather see her without a backing group.

  • her barebones backing band are a bit lackluster, but with a proper orchestra, she sound amazing.

    I'm a bit disappointed about the final bridge in this version, because the studio had a much bassier male voice, and his harmony was half a beat faster than Newsom's, so it had this great bass/treble echo effect

  • Thanks for uploading!

    She's incredible

  • sends shivers down my spine everytime i hear this song, i close my eyes and im there in the audience at the sage, she is unreal live, what a talent.

  • Thank you for posting these...I am utterly enraptured by her music...

  • nice quality by the way. sound and video. it could've done without the cheesy editing ;p lol

    good video though. thanks :)

  • thanks for the upload rums.

  • Brings tears to my eyes every time. Wow.

  • great video, thanks.

  • i filmed 4 or so songs. her new songs are so long thats all i could get.

  • Nice clip.. just curious - did you film the whole show or just this bit?

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more