Tchaikovsky D major violin concerto comparison

[dziady1]

Granted they all have a good technique - how could one tell if they are great violinists by playing this raucous overblown schlock- as long as you saw away for

all you are worth you will please the circus crowd .

[DavidEppursimuove]

yo creo que el problema de las diferencias esta en el director

[thezxcv1234898]

這是我第一次看到有人直接把想法打在影片上XDD



[007TheViolinist]

only compare on music guys =]

never on the players

[AbsoluteZ3R0]

Way to go Vengeroc, you have that hot chick checking you out from the back of the section when you come in, you never should have cut your hair.

[Mecinimi]

Vengerov easily wins.. but, personally... my top picks for this are Heifetz and Perlman.. Vengerov ranks highly in my opinion, though.

[gnatural]

@Mecinimi vengerov over perlman..lol not a chance. but then again all music is a matter of taste.

[flamewitygulnyc]

Nikita Borisoglebsky 's part: soloist appeared too young and inexperienced while the orchestra was old and heavy by comparison.

[imbored1996]

Vengerov plays less douchy here xD

[frankcisyarmi]

que monstruos!!!!!obvio mi idolo es Maxim y Jascha, pero Nikita y Dmitri son ecelentes tambien .

[leona200102]

Translate it into English?

[Hachechulo]

@leona200102 Learn to read in Spanish.

[ihorpalyuch]

@frankcisyarmi охеенно

[elosito1999]

jasha heifetz is the best in the world , is unique ., vengerov and very all . no

[leona200102]

Yes, I do agree with you. But they are good enough for us to appreciate, right?

[1203456789]

@elosito1999 oistrakh is better than heifetz on this piece

[jackdiver]

vengerov was wonderful in his rendition here but nikita borisoglebsky was not bad at all. there was fire and agnst in his performance . . . not to mention a showcase of his technical mastery of this Brahms masterpiece.

[leona200102]

Yes, he was competent and great in that age.

[wblakesx]

on the slower bits the last guy is head and shoulders. the faster sections tend to less expression if competent.

[leona200102]

Maybe it's his way to show passion in slow movement and period?

[playhacker2005]

that's vengerov...you have to look at he's head movements and you'll recognize him...

[leona200102]

: )

[gnatural]

yep that's not vengerov at all.

[allfre2]

the last one!, i like his interpretation the most...

[leona200102]

He's really great,but is it possible due to the record effect?

[farzadvengerov]

that's not maxim vengerov,i'm pretty sure

[leona200102]

Wasn't it younger maxim vengerov?

[farzadvengerov]

no.i don't know who is him.but he is not maxim vengerov

[a1rb0rne101]

yes he is 16 he did this and a little of paganini in this concert. AT 16!

[sexyleeches]

No! You have to see the second player.

The first guy who perform is not maxim. I know.

But the second guy.....

He's Maxim vengerov for sure!

[rasammx]

This guy some times lost the rhytm and , it all souns a little up in tone and alike somo kind fast beyound its original rhithm

[doublewillow]

the comments didnt say much abt music. They r all fantastic player. there is no perfect violin player, so dont be such a critical person who is far away behind these musicians!

[Cranebird]

I think all musicians are fantastic violinists!And it is not right to say that Vengerov is better or anybody else is better. And of course so short exerpts don't show everything about any of violinists.I prefer Dmitri Berlinsky style.He plays completely different than Vengerov but everything is in his sound.You can hear all emotions, thoughts, feelings from his playing. Now many artists just go with their showmanship but sound is nothing! And it is awful!

[KWR01]

It is not fair to judge on short excerpts. You have to hear the entire three movements to get the artistic concept that each artist has for the work involved. One also has to consider the concert halls, the recording equipment, the orchestras involved. You can take 20 known artists on any small segment and find differences, as they have made individual decisions concerning interpretation. Listening to many artists helps one to understand that a piece can have many valid realizations.

[Loryos]

simply Vengerov. No more to say. He owns the two others.

[Seven12Stay]

The comparisons are a bit funky, but I think that vengerov takes this. It's not match. He is too great. :)

GO MAXIM!

[leona200102]

Thanks for your comment!

[rojaviva]

it´s maxim vengerov... not max...

[leona200102]

Wrong typing...Sorry!

[vanishingpunch]

錄音品質就差很多了 小提琴的音色未必是你聽到的 這種品質的聲音檔案 根本不適合拿來作因直上比較 不過其他方面倒是批評的沒錯

[leona200102]

感謝批評

一轉再轉的影音確實不盡客觀

[adidas01003]

not good, because you didn't use the same sections so how can we compare?

[leona200102]

Thanks for your opinion,but put same sections together would make it too long,so just compared focal points such as angle of bow、gesture or music texture...

[mariana2062]

Simply wonderful =)