Added: 2 years ago
From: CBS
Views: 19,128
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (219)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this is getting intense!!

  • so good??

  • this the goodest show in the world ?

  • i am sooo buying the dvd when it comes out

  • i love this show the ending was so shocking its a great horrer muder show i seen in a awhile . oh and if people feel the same way i want you to know that the dvd of the serces comes out the 8th of september !

  • dont read into it too much...lol

  • the doctor says "she had skin under her nails AND evidence she had sex" ... he didn't say they were related at all

  • scratching the back, etc...

  • No. *giggles* The skin under her nails could be considered DNA evidence, either from rough sex play, or trying to defend yourself. In all, coroners usually check for things like fiber, skin, etc. under nails, in teeth, and on the body when asked to asses cause of death.

    The doc noted she had sex by checking...down there...the skin under the nails really had no relation to it except for speculation.

  • cuz u scratch the other person its complicated

  • when she clawed him

  • abbie is sooooo hot in a bakini

  • Man thats sad, it used to be so peaceful, now its a graveyard

  • i think i can i think it is cuz he was trying to get the message a crossed that he john is alive and i think he got the idea with the one bear looking thing so it is like his mark

  • Can someone tell me why Kelly's eyes were red??

  • They explained that Wakefield put red ink on them.

  • Dude!!!!! This show is da bomb!!

  • my fav is sully (hot) i feel bad 4 him...haha

  • ok here there is a red ribbon on trish's wedding dress but in the final the ribbon is white

  • I think that she simply doesn't have the ribbon on in the finale.

  • thats what i thought at first but you can see theres a ribbon its jsut not red.

  • JD and kelly were probably the most important people in solving all this crap, but now they're both dead, and no one believed them *sigh*

  • I still dont understand why hunter and uncle marty were packing heat... I've seen all the episodes too (except for the last two, which havent been aired yet)

  • its actually a 2 hour finale tomorrow at 9

  • I LOVE CAL SOOOO MUCH!! HE PWNS!

  • You've gotta think tht Henry is the killer. First, when Richard was pressuring Henry during the shooting contest, he probably missed it on purpose because he doesnt want to be a Wellington. Second, the "M" on the "ME" in the article in Kellys house matched the "M" on the note Henry gave Trish. All things lead to Henry.

  • your right

    ill bet anything that somehow henry and wakefield are realated like brothers or cousins or something

    but hes obviously helping him

  • or father and son...

  • Henry is wakefeilds son, he killed J.D and mr wellington.....

  • SPOILER!!!!

    and richard and the Revrend and kathren and mabey uncle marty

  • -spoiler-

    He didn't kill his uncle but he killed Malcolm.

  • Spoiler

    i thought because he said "i wanted malcom to find the money" that he killed uncle marty so the money could be found

  • I LOVE CAL!!!!!!!

  • haha i thought hunter was the killer! what now?!?!

  • i think Abby is the killer. I think she is traumatized of what happend to her mother, so she is PHYSCO. ;)

  • ...I doubt it But that would be a twist.

  • Cal is so cute, I'm in love with him.

  • Gosh that was soooo funny when Sully got covered in feathers! He did kinda deserve it tho and i cant believe Hunter walked in on Trish when she was changing and trying on lingerie and that must b embarrassing wen that lady walked in on them! I cant c how Jimmy and Shane r friends i mean u have Jimmy whos all nice and all that and then theres Shane whos a jerk!

  • omg i dont want jimmy to be bad!!!!

  • I love Cal! He is scrumptious!

  • LMAO I JUST REALIZED THE BLACK GUY USED TO BE A POWER RANGER! lmao

  • I love Shane! He's a jerk, but he's not half bad in my opinion. Jimmy's gotta be best friends with him for a reason, right?

    Haha. Mr. Wellington's face when Sully runs by covered in feathers. I think he was secretly amused.

  • haha, funnny [x

  • 13:35 Dean Chekvala's eyes r a pretty shade of blue XD

  • hunter is a jerk... i mean what the hell you don't just walk in on a girl who is changing... and getting married 3 days later.... god i hate him

  • how could jimmy be frinds with sheane eww

  • shane but if you see episoid 11 you will feeling will change cuz he did something............awsome lol hope i helped

  • I love the scene when Cal dumps the feathers all over Sully... that was amazing!

  • IKR! haha

    it was funny when sully was like :

    "come here you peice of english crap" or something like that haha :P oh well i love cal...

  • its john wakefield he is alive

  • finally i hoped that hunter would die.....i dont like him ...oops i DIDN'T like him hehe

  • I think Hunter's the killer...

  • How could you think Hunter's the killer? He's dead!

  • i love this show.. the suspense is great except you can kinda predict a lot of this.

  • about time they got rid of that guy hunter. what a sleaze.

    and why in the world is the sheriff looking around in the dark? turn on the light! it's not like he has to look around in secret.

  • Lol I know they always do that in CSI too to make it look more dramatic. Seriously they never think to turn on a light.

  • yeah, right. the woman at the front desk would really give hunter's room key to that other guy. completely unbelievable.

  • Well...it IS a smaller town, and Henry DID used to live there, and he knew the hostess...so if you put it in context, it's not super unbelieveable.

  • Why do they keep making everything so dang dark! It's stupid!

  • Madison must know something. Look at her at around 3:30

  • WUTS WITH THAT GIRL!? SHE'S CREEPY!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • has anyone read/ seen 10 little indians? cuz the story line is kinda the same... people on island... people get murdered...... no one knows who the hell it is.....

  • Also similar to the A.C. book "And Then There Were None". The "And Then There Were None" computer game incorperated the poem as well, except it used sailors as a substitute for Indians.

  • i think its the ex boyfriend of the bride cause he is creapy and allways around when someone is getting killed

  • Comment removed

  • he got killed on the boat with the money

  • i think it's that girl of that guy from date movie because she knows everything about walkfield and when the guy from date movie was hanging upside down he didnt got killed

  • ok who's Shane?

  • kelly's eye lids were moving when they pulled the sheets off!

  • bad acting is all

  • i think the sherriff is the murderer

  • i change my mind i think Shanes the killer or maybe the little girl because they act werid at points

  • agreed with the music...its so cheerful.

  • IM SCARED!!

  • The knife in the barn scene looks really fake. I saw it wiggle when he swung it. Like rubber.

  • why the f*** is the music so cheerful.......

  • haha im wondering if henry asked mr. wellington for his blessing first. can you imagine that conversation

  • The little girl is the killer

  • I haven't seen the new episode. If you're guessing, you're awfully confident. If you're spoiling, you're an asshole.

  • lets say im a confident asshole

  • its not likely that the little girl could hack the old guy's body in two..... and think the bridge was pretty high, it would be difficult for her to reach.

  • she used stilts or very high stilettos

  • i'm glad hunter died he is an anying little prick

  • i think its the college guy, at the seen when you see "john wakefield" get shot with the arrows, everyone else was near the dock, (besides the ladies but they were all together) excpet him, he was with the groom but since the groom killed some guy alone, he went on and killed the other guy.

  • That's not John.

  • Although Jimmy is cute, i can say that much ;), i think he might be the killer. Someone said " The killer won't stop killing until he gets to you Abby." And Jimmy wants Abby.......

    ANYONE AGREE?

  • Mmm, yeah, I'm feelin your logic here. You might be on to something! We shall see in the end my friend!!

  • I kinda think it's the groom.

    There's just something about him..

    He was one of my first suspicions as to whom the killer could be.

  • I agree with you. In mysteries like this it is always the person you least suspect.

  • Comment removed

  • Is it just me, or is it SO scary when they show Kelly's red eyes?

    That really freaked me out!! D:

    5:32

  • I've heard of red eye flights but this is ridiculous! *rim shot*

  • OMG THANK YOU! i've been like obsessed with him since episode one and im like saying to everyone "Jimmy is soooooooo cute" and people are like hes okay and im like are you kidding hes SMOKIN! im so glad someone else sees it!

  • ME TOOOOOO!!!!!! : )

  • yes, yes he is

  • Abby's mom is not one of the 25 suspects. As promised, one of the 25 suspects are the killers.

  • think it was trish's dad he was wearing the same shoes as one of the leg shots in the killing

  • Hm.. but why would he kill his daughter's friends?

  • oh man. people are dropping like flies

  • nice

    xD

  • So what does everyone think happened to Kelly? You know, I was really disappointed that she was killed, because she was one of the cooler ones. I definitely think that JD did NOT kill her. But what does everyone else think happened?

  • I agree with you! Kelly was definitly one of the cooler ones and im sad she died!

  • Idk y but i LLLLLLUUUUUVVVV JD, he is so freakin kewl!

  • yea i liked kelly 2 :(

  • man i actually liked kelly... =[

  • why are Kelly's eyes red? Any doctors here to explain? Thanks.

  • because when you hang or choke someone the blood vessles in their eys bursts...which causes the red

  • watch to the end. they explain it's ink in her eyes

  • It's probably Shane

  • I love this show! This is replacing Moonlight, since some one cancled it!!!

  • cbs was going to continue this series if it did well, i have no idea how. let cbs know that we like this show because they're very close to cancelling the next installment

  • is it the brother?

  • I think its Abbeys old boyfriend or shanes brother

  • I didn't think Shane had a brother. Who is this brother?

  • hes the guy who likes abbey. I think its her ex-boyfriend and hes trying to hook back up with her

  • You're saying Jimmy is Shane's brother? First of all, no proof of that. Second, the last names are different: Jimmy Mance and Shane Pierce.

  • Oh sry i just assumed they were brothers. I thought that someone said they were. I didnt even know there last names. But i still think its Jimmy besides that.

  • I think there was someone else who said that they were brothers, even though it was false.

  • great show, but what's with the shitty ass titles? whap? crackle? ka-blam?! LAME!

  • I don't know...something with onomatopoeias and sounds of death?

    Whap - the sound of Marty's death

    Crackle - the sound of Lucy's death

    Ka-blam - the sound of Hunter's death

    Bang - the sound of Joel's death

    Thwack - the sound of Thomas' death

  • well yeah i know, but it could be way more creative :]

  • weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

    lol

  • I think the whole Wellington family is in on it tbh.

  • whos the killer???????

  • So scary but so addicting!

  • for real...

  • I love dis show BUT dey make it impossible to know who da killer is. every1 a suspect & every1 hav der own reasons for killin everbody.. still its classicly funny!!

  • This is a really great show and I don't know who the killer is either, that's what makes the movies great!!! I love this show

  • the style of the killings changed. probably means there are more than one killer.

  • I wonder who the killer is.. i am so into the show but i still cant get an idea who the killer is.. post a reply to who you think is the killer.

  • why don't the people on this show seem to make a big deal when the other's go missing.

  • i love this show but it takes forever to load! it makes me mad cus i had no idea that it changed to sat. and to 9:00 istead of thurs at 10:00! so i missed the third one

  • Actually, it was starting with the 4th episode that it was moved from Thursday to Saturday.

  • I think it is the bride's dad and a hit-man. We already know that the dad is a killer (he ordered the death of hunter, in the boat, and the grooms uncle, on the bridge)

    I think the dad is hiring "someone" to kill people so he can disrupt the wedding. But why kill Kelly? That was a direct hit to the sheriff. The sheriff has a common interest with Kelly. If you kill Kelly, he will be preoccupied with solving that murder, that he may overlook other things on the island. My theory.

  • I am still having a hard time explaining the murders of the old man from the scavenger hunt and the girl who was burnt in the pit.  If someone wants to add to the theory or develop there own, I could use some help with those two murders.

  • i dont think its the brides dad, its too obvious of a killer

  • I wonder why no one has noticed all the people who've died already..? And for those of you who dont already know, Harper's Island's moved to Saturday nights. Or at least it did this past weekend.

  • why does no one stranges the disappearance of the girl who got burned??

  • Yeah I know I brought that up at work, a girl got burned and then everyone is at that pre-wedding party! No one says "Hey, where is Lucy and her dog?" BUT it is sooo much fun to watch. And I am suprised no one has taken a walk on the foot-brige where Harry Hamlin's half-body is still stuck! HA! BUT IT IS STILL FUN TO WATCH! ODDLY addicting.

  • I guess that is half the fun: IT MAKES NO SENSE and it will be over by early July of this year. So just have fun and don't think so hard! :-D

  • That is so funny because my Husband and I were wondering if we missed something. We were all "HELLO ... no one notices the girl and the funky looking dog are missing??" They did show the bridge again and the body was gone and a text sent to Henry that the uncle found some girl he would be hanging out with & he would see him at the wedding. But .... the others? No one notices?

  • id the moms eyes open

  • best show

  • 11:27 his stomach is nasty!

  • at least hunter went out with a bang.

  • I'm thinking that Wakefield isn't really dead, maybe they killed the wrong person.

  • Ok, first off, Wakefield went to a high security prison after he was charged with the attempted murder of a police officer by Sheriff Charlie Mills. He then came back%2Proxy-Connection: keep-alive

    Cache-Control: max-age=0

    nd supposedly went on a killing rampage, after tracking Sarah Mills down, who he had an affair with. I am completely confident that Charlie would have r

  • Why does the killer have to be one of the characters already introduced?

  • Because there is a big wall of characters that was shown to people before the show began. After every episode they put X's on top of the faces of the characters that died, and once the show is over only one face will remain. All the characters on the wall have been introduced already.

  • Where is the wall?

  • On wikipedia

  • I'm not sure if this has already been answered, so sorry if I'm responding to an already answered question.

    It has been confirmed that the killer is one of the 25 suspects, and all 25 suspects were introduced in the first episode.

  • I knew Hunter was gonna die. That was a bit predictable. None of the groomsmen could die because their involvement in the plot line is as of yet nothing so it would be predictable to cut off useless charactes same with the bridesmen. Shane couldn't die and neither could J.D. because their storyline is too great. The main characters can't die this early AND Hunter was a complete loose end.

  • was there one yesterday? i was watching cbs, and it was criminal minds

  • no... saturdays 9pm

  • i'm never useing a red pen ever again

  • haha me neither

  • Richard Allen (Brother-In-Law) is John Wakefield.  What we do know about Wakefield is that he committed the murders after serving 17 years in jail (Harpers Globe) and that the current story takes place 7 years after. This means that he could not be less than 24 years old and likely to be at least 36, assuming he was put in jail as young as 12. This rules out all of the young people and leaves Richard Allen, Uncle Marty, Sheriff Charlie Mills, and Thomas Wellington as potential suspects.

  • But why would Richard want Abby dead? I'm not saying you're wrong...there's just more to figure out.

  • wow mr. dectective wel martys dead so that leaves him out

  • I know Marty's dead, but I ran out of room in that post to include the remainder of my initial hypothesis where I further narrowed it to Richard.

  • Yeah, because some little 12 year old is going to blow up half the body of Deputy Cole Harkin. That's probable. You go with that...

  • Of course the person would likely be much, much older than 12, and that's why I said "as young as". My point was to rule out the young suspects once and for all by using an extremely young age as a worst case scenario. Of course the more older he was when he went to jail, the more it would rule out the younger people and support my initial hypothesis back then.

  • Fair enough. I'll bet you think things through a bit. Have you seen the latest episode? I think it was called Splash. If so, what is your new killer theory?

  • Comment removed

  • The last two minutes are insanely intense!

  • Leave TV Shows to Hulu!!!

  • ok..does she not know that her friend is missing?? i mean really!!!

  • well u know uncle marty was the whole show when he died i knew this show could not get too many more views i mean he was the life and spice and sugar and im starting to sound weird ok well he wuz just kewl like a dad or a dog or a monkey that can juggle knifes

  • u know what makes me really mad this guy thats killing people again in the second episode he went for the priest i mean what posessed him to do that i mean he was old and friendly and liked scones how cud u kill that anyway i say the english dude is next to go

  • well, I think thats why the writers made the killer kill the priest to show how cruel he or she really is.

  • No, that's impossible. The killer killed the priest so that there would be enough time in the church to set up the trap which would later kill Trish's father, Thomas Proxy-Connection

  • cant wait till thursday cuz then we see new one then we get to see one of henrys best friends die and trish's bigger sister wait did i just blow it of course i did