Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (365)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Will Josh be making a Christmas cd? If anyone one knows.

  • @fearfullymade57 Josh's first album is expected to be out by Christmas this year. Josh says that himself. He does not say if there will be any Christmas songs or not.

  • I cried listening to him a lot of times over and over again, because, he's so amazing, that I just can't believe...He should have won

  • dat voice.. damn!

  • i cant beleive im listening to that song in loop in february.. but its so great that show cares if xmas is passed!!

  • There's no doubt that Melanie is a great singer, but I wouldn't buy her cd. Josh has that extra something.Freddie Mercury had it, Axl Rose has it, Louis Armstrong etc

    A unique richness and texture that is only his.

  • thnx dude!! I love You!!!! 

  • this is pure awesome. What a winner

  • Damn!! i want his fucking original record!! you make a fucking album or i will never hear to Music again!!

  • @seifbenarfa20 He have made 2 cd's before the Xfactor, and they rock :D go to grooveshark and seach for 'Josh Krajcik Band', there's about 25 songs, enjoy ;)

  • Hey Josh!! Love Love Love you! Next time you're in Wooster let me know....We'll jam!!! Keep rockin bro ♥

  • This guy is SO GOOD! Hope he has a great career. He didn't win but now he's just as famous. Anybody here who wants to try and reach for fame should visit MakeAStar. That website is always holding contests online for singers, directors, bands and comedians alike. You guys should check it out and win money.

  • All I want for Christmas is a Josh Krajcik cd!

  • Can't wait for the Christmas Album. What could be better than Christmas and Josh?

  • That day, 22 of december, I crashed with two cars. I was singing "Wild Horses" played by you, and I don't regret it. I can´t stop hearing your music, even if I have to crash.

  • "As a mom, having your dreams come true make my dreams come true"

    So beautiful :)

  • I wish the best to Josh and his wonderful family. How refreshing to see how much they love and support this talented artist. Waiting for your new music, Josh!

  • He as already WIN

  • he can sing anything, love him so much!!!!

  • he would be good at making songs for movies

  • Music doesn't get any better than Josh Krajcik!

  • I love that little kick he does with his leg when he's singing. I hope they never try to make that go away. This man is charm personified. I think it might just be impossible for him to ever sing badly or miss an entrance or be off key. Fantastic!

  • Josh I enjoy listening to your beautiful voice, but your humble spirit makes you irresistible! Best wishes Josh and family

  • @ebbygohard you don't know what is a real talent.

  • @ebbygohard F O !

  • @juajen2000 I do like Paula because she is always so honest. Hope he brings her back. Steve was OK & it took Ryan S. Severa years to fit in. Even Simon refused to talk to him when Drew left. Judges were extremely rude to him. Don't think anyone could have handled it Berger people falling to the floor geeeeze.

  • When musicality is deep in the heart and soul it just comes out in effortless, flawless brilliance like this and there is no stopping it. God bless you Josh, you are a channel of Joy to the World!.

  • @marc5lake I agree. It does seem so effortless. He's my guy and until we can get more of him, I'll keep listening to what we have. Does anyone think that Paula will stay fired? Could Simon have been jealous of Josh? The girls stood up for him at every turn. I thought it was just that the guys still have contestants they were mentoring, but Simon is crazy about Paula. Perhaps Paula will just need to play a waiting game.

  • @juajen2000 I don't like that the mentors compete: it would seem to add more stress on the contestants who have to compete against each other. They should also let the accomplished musicians/seasoned performers like Josh pick all their own songs. I believe Josh lost due to unfortunate choices his mentor made for him. My rule of thumb in these shows is "Who would I PAY to hear?" and in this case Josh was the only one. I knew after hearing about three notes. His sound is addictive!

  • @juajen2000 mmm... you i think ur right

  • @juajen2000 I don't like the format of having the judges be mentors too. Makes for bias, IMO. The Idol way of having guest mentors from outside the show works better I think. Also, if the judges are hired & fired by another judge, that is another factor that affects the show's integrity. The important thing is that in spite of all that, the show still gives exposure to talent like Josh and we all benefit.

  • Josh, your voice makes it feel like Christmas all year long. Your mom is right,, you are so cute and cool, you are the whole package!

  • Love this !

  • "Hopefully I can be there"

    "What?

    "You'd invite me"

    "Yes... NO"

    lol Nicole is da best!!

  • I love Paula, she is great, she told that stupid LA what a fool he is! Nicole, tells us how good Josh is!

  • I just love the Josh hop he does, he did it in Something too, love it, love Josh!!!!

  • I think he looks so comfortable and relaxed in this performance. His smile is infectious. and he is indeed going to sell a "lot" of records.

  • Love Josh, whats this liquid LOL

  • "my life is beginning to make sense" - the best one-liner in the entire series.

  • Josh mi Amor que talento........ Estoy enamoranda :)

  • He so loves to sing for us!!!!!!!! It shows so much!

  • Josh, tus fans del mundo estan esperando por tu album, tu talento es grandeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!

  • ¡¡¡Maravilloso!!! Excelente voz, dulce presencia y sonrisa encantadora. Josh, por favor tienes que hacer pronto tú disco.

    Buena suerte y que Dios te bendiga

  • luv you so much Josh! keep up the great talent! can't wait to get a hold of your music!!!! Hurry!!!

  • Just look at that laugh when simon says u are gonna sell records hahahaha ...!

  • OMG I think I just fell in love haha I can not believe Melanie won her voice is too generic there's to many whitneys and beyonces and Mariah time for new talent and new sounding voice

  • U make me cry too

  • Love this.

  • he should have won. melanie amaro is another CHARICE WANNABEE. Her voice hurts my ears and is so far from the real divas charice whitney mariah and celine

  • @kissfxckbang YES!!!!!! MELANIE STINKS!!!!!!!!!!!!! CHARICE WANNABE!

  • @kissfxckbang TRUE!!!!!!!!!

    

  • He has the most sexiest eyes,beautiful smile and gorgeous hair. Ok, I need to stop.

  • @Goodgirlgabby I agree with you! His HOT!

  • Oh my Gee his Christmas song is the only one I would buy. Don't know what guided people to vote surely not talent.

  • He's gonna be a LEGEND !

  • Ez a Josh egy imádnivaló, édes fickó. Lehet ezzel vitatkozni, de tisztára fölösleges!!!! Puszikl

  • He is so good... Such a relaxed performance. Good to see him enjoying the moment. Can't wait for a concert so he can be himself.

  • @Bev4sure Right comment, I feel the same

  • Production & set on this one OK liked the snowflakes but the snow globe should have had a snowman not a girl sitting down. How do they come up with some of this stuff? Love this!

  • I just love his music, awesome!!!

  • Amazing!!!

  • Such a great singer & story - no hype - just the total package.

  • Thumps up if the counter still says 117.006 !

  • @hausmeisterbanane Yep! It still says 117.006, ??????

  • @hausmeisterbanane Still 117,006????

  • he should have won, they did the same as with susan boyle.

    They stopped the counter´s telling the truth about views about a month or so ago.

  • Josh should have won. I hope he is as successful as Daughtry.

  • @MegaSilver200 OR MORE!!

  • Josh couldn't mess up a song even if he tried ! His voice is just intriguing ! Yes and lost of words and magical !

  • Still 117006

  • mine is stuck at 117,006 too. cant have more views than Melanie. LOL

  • Please Josh, never give up!!!!!

    Brazil loves u!!!!

  • THIS IS THE ONE WHO SHOULD WIN!!!!

  • Something wrong with the numbers not changing. Post if you are 117,006

  • @Gabegs 4 hours later its 117,006

  • Josh is so awesome, so totally a real person no plastic, he is what he is. He has so much heart and it comes across in his music, he is not afraid to show us neither. I am so praying that he will hit it big in 2012 and beyond. I know I will buy his CD's. Love this guy.

  • i am JOSH ....

  • It's gonna be exactly like it was with Chris Daughtry...... If anyone remembers...

    Sooo... Yeah, Josh won ;)

  • Can't believe this vid doesn't have more views. It's amazing & his voice is pure heart & soul.  The end slays me.

  • @59bjbrown Me neither. I listen to it daily two or three times; yet the numbers seem to stay the same. Don't get it. I really need the calming influence his voice gives me and I just don't get tired of anything he sings.

  • Que voz maravilhosa,torço para que ele grave um cd,muito,muito bom..

  • If the show started earlier, and the finale was in late October, I wouldn't mind seeing Josh sing a Halloween song! :)

  • @RebeccaBlackReligion Such a tasteless comment...

    Josh can sing any song for any occasion & nail it down...as well as fill it with the charm, charisma & soulfulness...

  • @silver449 I WAS COMPLEMENTING HIM!!

  • Miss seeing you on tv Josh. So happy to have youtube to watch. Can't wait for your first album!!Someone sign him immediately!

  • Nice to see him smiling and relaxed just performing for the joy of it. That's the sort of forum I would like to see him sing

  • GO JOSH GO!!!!!!!

    I WANT YOUR TSHIRT/HAT AND CONCERT TICKETS

    WHO RECOGNIZES TRUE TALENT????????????????????

  • I don't buy many CD's, but I can't wait for Josh's to come out!

  • Well I am waiting for this man's amazing talent so I can hear it over and over again on CD.

    What is taking so long??????????? The waiting is making me crazy due to the simple fact Josh can sing!!!!!!!!!!! Why are these recording ppl sitting around????????????????????????­????????

    C'mon This Man Will Be A Legend

    CD please

  • Hope we get a 2012 Christmas CD.

  • HE COULD SING JUST ABOUT ANYTHING AND IT WOULD STILL BE GREAT. CONGRATS JOSH ON YOUR 2ND PLACE FINISH...THAT IS EVERYTHING TO BE VERY PROUD OF. I LOVE YOUR VOICE AND CONTINUED SUCCESS IN YOUR MUSICAL CAREER. I KNOW YOU WILL GO A VERY VERY LONG WAY IN THE BUSINESS!!!

  • my new favorite christmas song, josh's way

  • He can sing anything & I'm spell bound!

  • great perfomance, i think he find the type of music that fits him the most with this one

  • tell you what, josh would do great as the lead singer in a rock/alternative band. keep singing josh!

  • Josh k is the true winner. Next year at this time SImon's pet will be forgotten. Josh k will be out shining all the other so called singers

  • @507dannyfe i agree with u completly!!! he had more heart to win this show than anybody else on that stage....he will definaty get farther than all these people even melanie amaro

  • Josh is a all around performer. That why he went so far. He is great live or recorded.

  • Comment removed

  • I really dont do the holidays any more but now this is my #1 x-mas song..WTG AWESOME

  • i'm still buying his record first when it comes out, he is unique and his voice gives me goosebumps all the time ! love you josh, you are the truth!

  • Ele é maravilhoso,tomara que consiga um contrato,é muito talentoso...

  • Paula is always doing whatever Nicole is doing.. She just imitates what she see's.. I laughed at her attempt to headbang with Nicole :/

  • @jaetor06 Jaetor, don't be too harsh, hate is such a powerful word for a very POWERFULLY BEAUTIFUL voice, don't know if your ears were completely tuned that time he sang this song. You are obviously a one way Melanie Amaro fan, and that's okay. Just keep your praises to Melanie, just don't be to insensitive and critical to those who tried their very Best in getting to the Finals ! PEACE to you.

  • Comment removed

  • @jaetor06 How can ANYONE hate this perormane? Any single of Josh's perofrmances is amazing & soulful...your ears & taste in music seems "tragic", not Josh!

  • @jaetor06 Melanie has a great voice, but is really nothing more than a clone diva. I'm glad she won in the end. Gives hope to all the fat girls.

  • The most soulful Christmas song I've ever heard, one I will listen to all year long. He makes you glad to be alive. He takes you to another place and time stops. At last a real artist! What a gift!

  • @peaceandcharity Yes! I feel the same way! 2Thumbs up ! ! ! !

  • What was the name of that girls Christmas song? lol

  • I honestly didnt know who was going to win. Melanie and Josh is amazing in their own genres. Best of luck to both!!

  • the host is terrible, I hope next year they change him

  • @mallymonkey hes not bad hes just annoying

  • i see a huge improvement in steve's charm and consoling skills.

  • he could have won if someone chose good songs for the competition...

  • He has the swag of a rock star and yet he's so freaking humble and normal. I haven't bought an actual "album" in years, but I'd buy his album in a flash.

  • This guy has so much swag! Go Josh!!!

  • Let us know when the concert is!!!!!!!

  • @ladiekawk YES! ! ! ! ! Please Count me in, I wanna know when.

  • epic fail host at the start is epic fail

  • I agree with Paula and Nicole... I've never heard a singer who puts all that emotion into a song. You can see it on his face and hear it in his voice. I'll be at your concerts Josh!!!! I hope you make a lot of money and win that Grammy!

  • "AS SURE AS THE STARS UP ABOVE". You are a STAR JOSH!!! The future is bright.

  • Sounds like..... Josh Krajcik

  • @hpbroncofan Thank you. That about says it all. Yes, it sounds like the one and only, Josh Krajcik.

  • Josh Krajcik..sooo much talent! Can't wait for your album, your band, your tour <3

  • @JanetParish48 She wants to become an artist. So she should feel this at least once in her life. Not that i enjoyed watching her have a meltdown trust me, I guess men educate differently from women :P I'm a father myself... Disappointments are a part of life(Mother died when i was 17 and father commited suicide). i would want my son prepared for the heartships he has to face in his life by experiencing something like this instead of losing me how would you be?

  • Držala som mu palce!! Je skvelý spevák ;)

  • Beautiful voice!

  • love you...

  • JOSH YOU'RE THE GREATEST!!!!!!

    IM FROM PHILIPPINES,,, IM GOING TO BUY YOUR ALBUM...

    COUNT ME IN NICE TO HEAR RASPY NERVE TINGLING VOICE,,,,,,

  • A song for the Christmas Classics! Best version of this song I've heard. JOSH you will make it big. Have no doubt in my mind and my heart. The best for a incredible 2012!

  • hahaha josh touching his tears saying "what is this?!" cracked me up. he's such a man. anyway... josh, if you ever see this, congrats for being runner-up! if it were up to me, you or chris would have won the competition, but i know you will make it far regardless. will be waiting for your album! :)

  • What is this liquid :-)

  • I was totally sure he was gonna win this competition... And I think he was the only finalist who didn't pretend anything - was just himself!!! And Everything about him says that he's a man!!! That is what's missing in Showbiz these days... People are fed up with all those feminine glamorous male singers... I'll buy your album,Josh - record one ;)

  • @IlgarAus I'm waiting to buy also. Wonder what he will record first?

  • @IlgarAus You are so right I'm gonna buy his album too he is the MAN..We love you Josh

  • i love Josh Krajcik

  • i love u josh ur such a good singer,,,Godbless u.....keep rockin!!!!

  • Loooooove you Josh!

  • omg those videos after performances... ugh, they broke Melanie, broke Chris big time, but they didn't break Josh, he's a toughie haha :D

  • His voice is a unique one...

  • This guy can sing itsy bitsy spider and put it on the top 40's if he had to. He made all songs his in the X Factor.

  • I think its funny how people say melanie sounds so flat, boring etc. But josh sounds just like that to some I bet...irrelevant comments and opinions...obviously she son bcuz she wasn't flat and boring....she touched others with her singing as josh did to some of his fans....I guess melanie was able to touch more people obviously resulting in her win...

  • Josh should've won.

  • both josh and melanie are good singers, but there's nothing in her singing, so flat, just keep showing off her skill. Josh is different, he really touches me...

  • I miss Xfactor because of you Josh!

  • Sorry Josh, I never missed voting for you every week but the night you need my vote I wasn't able to vote ); Well, no matter what your still my fav and I will indeed buy your album.

  • I would totally buy albums from Josh. He has a truly amazing voice...I hope to see him again in the near future or to hear his voice on the radio.That would be awesome!!

  • I want his album too because he surely has got Czech roots - the name Krajčík is surely Czech so I am proud to have someone like him in finally of Xfactor.

  • @rymicka Joo :) Škoda, že u nás asi originálku alba neseženem... :( Docela bych si ho i koupila :)

  • I wish there was a snowflake button!

  • Merry Christmas .................JOSH°°°°°°°°°

  • Article in New York Times liked Josh the best. Said theme weeks were ridiculous & curbed his talent he was capable of so much more. I agree. Loved his song seemed very relaxed, which was so nice to watch. I am a Josh fan forever!!!

  • Josh, the XFACTOR is over only a few days ago and my heart is already aching not to be able to watch you on stage every week. I miss XFACTOR because of you. LOVE YOU Josh.

  • @prodigy163 MEE TOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!<3

  • this man just makes me smile!

  • Comment removed

  • So true ! ! ! ! ! ! I was very blown away by his amazing voice, it even gave me goosebumps. I was shocked when someone else's name came out as a winner. Sure, Melanie's voice, just like a lot of people say, she's got a voice similar to many. Josh's? WOW ! ! ! ! ! ! WOW ! ! ! ! ! WOW ! ! ! !

  • Josh- Xfactor. Chris- Xfactor  Melanie- Great singer

  • @swede1one COULDNT AGREE MORE!

  • @swede1one Josh- Xfactor, Melanie- Mediocre Singer, Chris - Horrible Karaoke Bar Singer

  • @Farmboy7899 don't say that :(

    Melanie is an excellent singer, so is Josh. But I do agree that Chris sucks...

  • was that melanie in the bubble? lol

  • Thank you again, X Factor for Josh!! The best part of the show all season!! Cannot wait to see him make it big -- no doubt he will!

  • god... i didn knw he has a doughter .. he is jus 30 ,man..and she seems old.. like 13 years old or somthin... blesss his family

  • Melanie WON!!!!

  • I didn't know Christmas song can be this powerful!! 33333 josh