zakir naik debate with Syed Ali Raza jan Kazmi part 1

[hammad1976]

Tareekh e Kamil Volume 4 page 63:

"Ibn Abbas replied a letter of Yazeed saying 'I can never forget the fact that you forced the grandson of the Prophet (s) to leave Madeena and seek refuge in Makka, you sent soldiers on horses in his direction to disturb him, so you forced him to make his way towards Iraq, he left Makka through fear

[hammad1976]

Imam Hussain as said

By Allah! I will prefer to be murdered a step outside Makkah than to be murdered inside Makkah even its one step inside Makkah".

1. Tareekh Tabari, Volume 6 page 27

2. Tareekh Kamil, Volume 4 page 16

this means people were after him when he went to makkah even if he would have stayed there yazid people would have klled him there

[hammad1976]

al Bidayah Volume 8 page 231 Dhikr Yazeed:

RasoolAllah p said

Justice shall rule my Ummah until the first individual who shall destroy my Deen, from the Banu Ummayaa his name shall be Yazeed.

[hammad1976]

this was revenge of yazid for what Ali as killed his ancesters in badar

al Bidayah Volume 8 page 204:

Ibn Asakir in his history book states. When Husayn's head was brought before Yazeed, he recited the couplets of Ibn Zubayri: 'I wish my ancestors of Badr were here to see the fright of al-Khazraj (tribe) as the spears hit.

[hammad1976]

again bidaya nihaya

"It is already mentioned that he (Yazeed) killed al-Hussain and his companions through Ubaidullah bin Zyad" Al Bidayah Wal Nihayah, Volume 8 page 243

[hammad1976]

even ibne khaldoon writes this

Al-Muqadima by Ibn Khaldun, page 254:

It is impermissible to support Yazeed in the matter of killing Hussain, nay (Hussain's) murder is Yazeed's deed that proves him to be a Fasiq and Hussain a martyr.

[hammad1976]

we see in this book written against shaiz by shah mohaddis dehalvi even he didnt deny that yazid ordered the killing of imam as

When the cruel people of Syria and Iraq upon orders of impure Yazeed and due to the efforts of chief of hatred and fitnah Ibn Ziyad martyred Imam Hussain.. Tauhfa Ithna Ashari (Urdu), page 8 Published in Karachi

[hammad1976]

Tarikh Kamil, Volume 4 page 112:

He (Yazeed) wrote to Ubaydullah Ibn Ziyad ordering him to march towards Madina and surround Ibn Zubayr in Makka. He (Ibn ziyad) replied: 'I can't give both these things to this Fasiq, after killing the grandson of Rasulullah (s), I'm not now going to assault the Kaaba'

[hammad1976]

Imam Dhahabi records in Siar Alam al-Nubala, Volume 3 page 305:

Muhammad bin al-Dahak narrated from his father that he said: When Hussain marched, Yazeed wrote to his governor Ibn Ziyad saying: Hussain is marching to Kufa and he is a problem of your time not of other times, your state not of other states and you not for the other governors. At that time you might be free or be slaved. Therefore Ibn Ziad killed him and sent his head to him (Yazeed).

[hammad1976]

Yazid was hateful of Imam Ali a. s., arrogant, insolent, wine-bibber and sinful. He initiated his kingship by murdering Husayn, and he sealed it with the incident of Harra. People hated him and he was not graced with a long life

Shadharaatudh Dhahab by imam dhabi chapter 3 pag 69

[hammad1976]

contd..

He also writes about the comments made by the Head of this delegation, Mundhir bin Zubair, upon his return from Basra, where he had gone to meet his friend, the governor (Ubaidillaah bin Ziyaad), namely that Yazid consumes so much intoxicants that he misses prayers!

[hammad1976]

same book bidaya wa nihaya same chapter 4 page number 216

Ibn Kathir writes about the delegation, comprising three citizens of Madina, going to Yazid. He says: When they returned to Madina, they made public their grave findings pertaining to Yazids perversities. They said: We are returning from that person who is irreligious, who is a wine-bibber and who is surrounded by singing girls, entertaining him with music.

[hammad1976]

salafees your beloved ibne kathir writes in bidaya wa nihaya chapter four page 235 236

Yazid was notorious for his love of music and liquors his illicit friendship with singing boys and girls There was not a single day that he woke up not intoxicated

[hammad1976]

i thought you may ave some knowledge but you r worse than zakir naik ,this pharase we normally use for good people like shaba or tabaeen not for killer of sahaba or a person who was proven drunken killer

why plea for him may be you belong to same family bani ummaya yeah

there r other people to plea for why the killers of ahlalbait  as is that because you hate Ahlelbait as i think so what do u think? or just ur ignorance

[salafees]

if he only wanted to recite the shifaat part then why did he recite the initial part? what a moron you are and just on qiyas you are defending him, dont you know qiyas is haram in shiism, so dont practise it sweetie.

moreover can you plz provide me the video where zakir naik said that there is no shafaat at all?

[SayyedKhan001]

no brother i'm not a syed not a wahabi nor a shia I'M A MUSLIM!

yazid did not kill the son of Ali&Fatima(peace be upon them) today some1 say's so and so etc...go back to your book's do your homework then you will have the right to say he/she is Bad,but u cant just blindly follow anything,and keep on accusing ppl.

Peace be upon you and yur family

[salafees]

the irony of the GREAT LEARNED TEENAGED SCHOLAR THIRSTY FOR PUBLICITY IS THAT HE DOESNT EVEN KNOW AYAT UL KURSI. QUOTING IT HE MISSED SOME SENTENCES OF IT, LOL SUCH GR8T SCHOLAR HE IS.

HE FORGOT TO RECITE "لَّهُ مَا فِي السَّمَاوَاتِ وَمَا فِي الأَرْضِ" " lahu ma fee alssamawatiwama fee al-ardi" BUT JUMPED TO THE WORDS AFTER IT. NOTICE IT IN (8:40)

[dandannoodles]

Are this emails posted anywhere???

[hammad1976]

even it was done by him(as you say) quran is from Allah its not written by any one else

[hammad1976]

this is wrong it was done by Hazarat Ali as

[SayyedKhan001]

Long live Dr.Zakir Naik.

if he did any mistake's unkowningly so what?he aint a computer,u get me.

[hammad1976]

thats why he loves yazid

lol

[amirzubairmughal]

what!! which Quran they are talking about written by Usman,,

[amirzubairmughal]

Shia!!!

[TheAbbas3090]

I know that zakir naik is all known man about Islam but he is .............(big bad words for zakir laanti human) because he praised yazeed(son of .....)...

[hammad1976]

he ran away

[nash458]

I don't know why these people are so much reluctant,if these people are true in their faith then go and Debait Zakir naik face to face in open forum, why always debait with each other on zakir back go and talk to him face to face..

[MoShow3000]

MUSLIM!

[Sayyidah110]

mashallah hidayat should these 2 brothers more !!!!! and please put on english lectures!