Added: 2 years ago
From: seduff
Views: 44,941
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (510)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • does anyone know where 2:57 came from ? 'Rose' in the wedding dress?

  • Oh my gosh, how on earth have I never seen this before now? I am all teary from how beautiful this was. Thank you so much for doing such an amazing job! I'm gonna go watch it again now!

  • oh i so wish this was true, and there was a programme that went through the lives of the human doctor and rose and the fight for the earth in the other dimention with them getting married and everything oh how i wish!!!!

  • this is fucking brilliant. great work and really really one of the best fan videos I have seen so far for roes and the doctah. Brilliant.

  • It looked so familier and I realized I had seen the other one. Both are so great.

  • That was awesome! i am going to pretend that actually happened on the show. man, i miss them!

  • What are these clips from?

  • omg omg omg omg soooooooooo cute doctor x rose 4-ever<3<3<3<3<3

  • Awww I love both versions of this!!! Wonderfully done.

  • Hey what episode was the part at 2:07 from?

  • Can somebody tell me what episode is this?

    Or give me a link to watch it.

  • This is f*** amazing

    Thanks for the Video

  • How have I never seen this one until today? Your work is absolutely amazing as always!! Honestly, if I could have them on a DVD to add to my collection, I'd buy it!

  • how did you get the voice clip of him saying I love you Rose????!!!! That was great! Seamless, amazing!

  • @DNIKelly Quite a few years ago David completed a Radio Play in which his love interests name was also Rose. (how handy.) ;)

  • Love, love, love the editing on the wedding part! I mean, I love the editing on all of it, but that part just stands out as particularly amazing!!!!!!

  • That was really impressive!  I can't believe how seamless it was. Thanks for these videos.

  • great vids

    always love rose and tennant as dr who

  • Ok it's official, I'm in LOVE with your videos!! These AU ones are brilliant! Seamlessly worked together, it's simply ridiculous!!  I'm thinking Billie and David need to play opposites in another drama, separate from Dr. Who just to make all of us fans happy!! Thumbs up if you agree!!!!!!!

  • How did you get the "I love you Rose"? How did you get that? O.O I am in awe!

  • i am speechless...I really don't know hoe to say to you how much I love,not only this,but all of your videos! Genius!

  • Seduff please come back and edit doctor who vids again

    pretty please

  • *Gah* "The future is the future. Marry me." Just makes me heart go all smooshy.

  • You know how you know a vid is really great? When you forget it isnt real! Seriously, your vids are always so fantastic, I forget it's just that--a vid! Well done, top notch!! I always love your vids!

  • Ou juste me les écrire pour que je puisse traduire!!!????

  • quelqu'un pourrais me donner les traduction fraicaise de ce que rose et le doctor se dise s'il vous plait?

  • how on earth did you get him to say i love you rose!? wow. just wow.

  • WOW! superb editing! this is just amaizing!

  • wow! superb editing! this is amaizing!!!!!!

  • Wow. 2:13 marked the best bit of Camille's entire run of Doctor Who.

  • I love your videos! Normally clips from Secret Smile creep me out..but you use the good ones :)

  • I always love your videos:) Um quick question tho..When is the scene around 2:08 at in the series or is it something else entirely?

  • @immortaletternity it's a brilliantly edited scene from Doctor Who, Love and Monsters. Jackie's original line is "Let me tell you something. About those who get left behind. Because it's hard... But if there's one thing I've learnt, it's that I will never let her down, and I'll protect them both until the end of my life. So whatever you want, I'm warning you: back off." The genius of Seduff made it what we hear in the video. Brilliant, eh?

  • You are amazing, i love all your videos. Completely gobsmacked at how you make them, well done :) keep it up

  • does david actually say the last quote, "i love you rose" and where is it from??

  • very cool, well put together!

  • I'm curious as to which other shows billie piper and david tennant have played in now because I only recognized one scene of that to be from doctor who..

    I'll have to look it all up once I'm finished rewatching the new series of doctor who (I'm watching from season 1-5 while I wait for the new matt smith season to come out)

  • what is 3:01 from

  • what is 3:01

  • Hey what movie or show did you get David Tennants first quote and the ending what show is that from?

  • all of your human doctor/rose vids completely blow me away!!!! they are edited so perfectly it's not even funny.

  • WOW This is really really really awesome editing! Nicely done!

  • what is this from??

  • Besides call girl and Doctor Who where did you get your clips from

  • Oh gosh I loved it!!!

    "i love you rose" gave me goosebumps!

    oh how long i wished to hear that in the actual series... :(

    this video is a masterpiece and goes straight to my fav!

  • Aaaw! Loved this one too. Thanks so much. Just love Ten & Rose

  • Did he say "I love you Rose?" Rose??? How is it Rose if it's not from Doctor Who? Was he in something else with a character called Rose? Brilliant by the way.

  • Ahhhhhhh! I'm SPEECHLESS! *standing ovation*

  • I love you, Rose >> OMG so perfect, love it

  • is this like part 2 the previous one?

    LOVES IT <3

  • i love this video i cry Evey time i see this

  • @mrnotoe me too...

  • i cry every time i watch this i love the doctor and i think it was a good ending for the two even if its just a copy of the real doctor:) :(

  • Good stuff,

  • ok so u have to tell me where u got the scenes at 1:04 to 1:08... and 2:06 to 2:17... also at 3:48 to 3:50

  • heh, you've made me cry :-)

  • ok u have to tell me where u got the scene where dt says the future is the future...and the 1 where jackie says never let her down...and when she says "the doctors home isnt he"...u have to tell me exacly where

  • Absolutely seamless and beautiful!!! These videos are head and shoulders above any other Rose/Human Doctor videos I've ever seen. The wedding scene is especially flawless, and so satisfying. Thank you for giving this couple the closure and happy ending they deserve.

  • Hey there seduff, I'm a long-term fan of your vids and this is one of my absolute favourites! One thing I've never figured out though, where does that last line "I love you Rose" come from? Please tell me and put me out of my misery! Also, the wedding scene was brilliantly edited, as usual! Thanks for giving this Ten/Rose fan some closure on the Human Doctor and Rose's relationship. x

  • Hi there seduff, I'm a long-time fan of your vids, and this is one of my absolute favourites! But I've never worked out where that last line comes from: "Love you Rose". Please put me out of my misery!! Also the wedding scene is spectacularly edited as always. Thanks so much for giving this Ten/Rose fan closure on the Human Doctor and Rose's relationship. x

  • That was awesome!

  • bonne vidéo

  • Davids adorable, cute, amazing *shakes head and snaps out* accent is slightly ruining the ilusion

  • @toontoosh Maybe "John Smith" decided he liked the accent and strikes out using it as a mark of independence XD

  • What shows did u use? Ths vid mkes me want to watch em all! ^^ <3

  • i hope david and billie get to do that new movie together! i'm hoping!! love the vid!!

  • Which is the title of this music ?

  • thats a truly epic combo. congrats!

  • YOU ARE SO AWESOME!!!!! omg five-starred, playlist and favorited!!! brilliantly FANTASTIC!!!

  • @CrazyGood88 Wow, Thanks! So glad you enjoyed it. :) You may also like (and i prefer) the Alternate version of this cut entitled "Wait for Me" ... :)

  • I love your videos for these two. Just pure amazingness

  • all the different clips fit in together beautifully, amazing video :) i love it

  • lol ok you're right, it *is* rose...I think my cold medicine is making me high lol sorry.

  • Holy flip. This is amazing! Like WOW, I'm into really good video editing especially with clips cut from different shows and bring it into one to make it fit. Usually people screw up, and you just do it brilliantly. So amazing. It's very believable! Wonderful work! Great JOB!

  • AW, that is so CUTE! It had me in tears a bit round the middle, but at the end I was just....aw!

  • what episodes are these i never seen the human doctor and rose ones, i think i missed a whole season or something

  • Don't stress! You didn't. seduff is mad awesome at editing and has spliced, brilliantly, I might add, lots of clips from different shows.

    Gives us hardcore Rose/Ten fans a nice bit of closure on what might have happened next!

  • hehe...there's only a very small part that is from Dr Who..the rest is from other tv programs. although Billie Piper and David Tennant never played another drama together, except for Dr Who...

    ...the genius of Seduff

  • @kirstypang But they're doing another one together now!!! Yaay!

  • can someone please tell me what the clip at 2:07 is?

  • lovely feelgood vid!

    love the song too ,until i read the info though i thought it was a coldplay song.

    i have never heard of Mat Kearney !

  • Waaitt -- how did you get David Tennant in that wedding scene at like 3:05/3:06 ?

    Great video! I loved it! I've always wondered about those two ;)

  • I don't know how you do it but keep going!

  • where do people find these things

  • awhhh that was extremely adorable :( i wanna cry. it looked soo real..like it was an actual clip without mixing different vids togetha. to be honest, the doctor and rose in doctor who were so passionate and energetic, almost like a fairytale..in the parallel universe they seem so..wrong, like normal relationships and normal love. not saying i didnt like this vid cuz i loved it. thankyou and i hope people understand what im saying about this video. 10/10!!!!

  • "I love you, Rose."

    YES!!! Finally! I needed to hear him say that! Thank you seduff! I love all your vids by the way!

  • Hey from were is the scene where Piper is in a wedding dress and from where is the "Marry me?" David saying scene???PLS someone tell me :))) gret vid by the way xx

  • aLL0nsy: The Wedding Scene of Billie is from Much Ado About Nothing, and the "Marry Me" quote of David is from Casanova. =)

  • Warning: comment has spoiler - watch the vid first then read.

    You know...it was great. But *right* at the end in the audio, I can clearly hear David Tennant say "I love you" and then he says a name that I think might be "Lucy" ? ... I know you had to splice all this stuff from other shows the actors were in and all..but you should really go back in and cut that teeny bit of audio out - it shattered the fantasy of it hehehe.

  • araeshkigal : It shouldn't have really as David actually says: I love you ROSE. :D He did a radio play years ago where his love interest was also named rose. No splicing required. Sorry you felt it shattered the illusion. :)

  • where do u find this stuff

  • i really love how the clips from "secret smile" were used in this video to paint a different picture. it really makes you understand how how he could have fooled everyone when they weren't seeing the whole picture. well done, i am most impressed!

  • I need to ask, what program did you use to do this???

    Cheers

    lu

  • Amazing, love it. Thank you sooo much.

  • Amazing work =)

  • is this by any chance real?

  • oh lordy me... I could've sworn that clip at 3:13 is DT and Piper! It looks so much like them!

    Also, what's Rose's wedding scene from? And the way you edited it together seamlessly... I'm honestly speechless. YOU should be the no. 1 subscribed on youtube! :D

  • slitheenvsrose: Wow, your comments are always so wonderful, thankyou. =) The Wedding scene of Rose is from Much ado about Nothing.

  • @seduff ok u have to tell me where u got the scene where dt says the future is the future...and the 1 where jackie says never let her down...and when she says "the doctors home isnt he"...u have to tell me exacly where

  • slitheenvsrose: Also the bit at 3:13 actually IS DT and Piper. =) It s a manipulated image of David in place of another actor.

  • Absolutely amazing!!!!!!! Just wonderful!! Keep up the good work!!!

  • this is a brilliant video i wish i was as talented when it comes down to this

    good job

  • Well done.  You should cut for a living.

  • Lovely!

  • Amazing. You've answered some of my wondering questions about how those two worked out.

  • yeah, i know what you mean, because it was obvious that they were going to have to resolve some issues but at the end ltheir love was strong enough to get over the fact that the human doctor was not the proper doctor

  • beautiful put together! i love it!

  • great video mate very well done.

    for the ppl out there that dont know

    ofc this is footage taken from different movies/tv shows that billie and david have been in, it is done extreamly well i would hate to think of the time spent.

    @jimene89 if u look at the video and watch closly he doesnt actully say " i love u rose" u catch the last word in a sentence that his mouth is moving.

    but once again great vid

  • decks313 : Thanks for your comment, as this kind of video is indeed a time consuming process. :) Although the 'audio' of the final words from David, is indeed "I love you Rose" as Tennant has featured in an audio drama with "rose" as his love interest ... Thanks again.

  • I didn't know they had starred in different programmes together other than Doctor Who!? What movies were the clips from! Man, If you actually read that comment over again Its sounds like Donna (Noble) said it. =)

  • Great vid your a GREAT editor!

  • Where in the world did you get this footage!!!????

  • What?! How did you get it where he says "I love you Rose." Or am I just hearing it wrong. Lovely video. Wonderful.

  • Wow. I've seen a lot of the Human Doctor/Rose videos and this is, by far, one of the best and now one of my favorites. I love the bit with Jackie telling the Doctor off: "Let me tell you something. About those who get left behind. Because it's hard." It's so fitting. This is an amazing video.

  • I am addicted to your videos, you are truly amazing.

  • oh wow... Did you make this out of Doctor Who clips? Or do I have to go download something else? This is beautiful! You did an amazing job!

  • you do an amazing job at these videos... they can really help a person's day! Keep doing what you do.. because it's excellent!

  • raechaosface: Wow, thanks so much for this lovely comment. It's wonderful to hear that they can brighten your day just that little bit. Working on some new projects at the moment, they are just taking a long time due to 'real life commitments' =P Thanks again. =)

  • who is the actress?? shes gorgeous

  • infectedkoozer: Billie Piper =)

  • (= that was a fast reply :D..1:32 secs hehe thanks

  • *chuckles* ok, so i just happened to check my email. =P

  • hehe

  • i really thought that was real at first they shoud defo do it though coz the dr an rose really are made for eachother long live there love lol

  • i so agree and the good thing is this one never changes

  • OMFG. then you are SOOO BRILLIANT!!! amazing job on this vid! really good job!!! i couldn't believe that it was seperate and fake!!!!!!!!!! it seemed so perfectly real!!!!!!!!! way to go!!!! man that was fantastic XD

  • i think this is much more realistic than just expecting they will live "hapily ever after" anyway!

  • what about the part where its not doctor who but billie piper and david tennant are talking to each other??? starts from beginning to like 0:22

  • Kblackhole: Nope. All fake except the opening sequence on Bad Wolf Bay. =) Just tried to make it appear that they were in the same room speaking to each other. It's rather tricky... ;-)

  • What are these clips really?

  • Coleslayer9: These clips have been collected from David and Billie's other productions and edited together. Hope you enjoyed it ...

  • thank you for replying. :)

    that means a lot. and yes you did an amazing job on the editing!

  • really? wow! if so u did really really well! and i subscribed! :)

  • wait is this actually real from Doctor Who???

  • Kblackhole: No :) this is a collection of clips for their other work, edited together.

  • BLOODY BRILLIANT!!!

    Keep up the good work

  • i would love to see what the human doctor and rose's future would like, i would love to see a doctor who episode, where we see the human doctor and rose having a life together like living together, married, kids etc

  • nicely done, that was so wonderful and full of awesome. very good

  • Your videos of The Doctor and Rose are extraordinary. Brilliant editing. Thank you for sharing them.

  • Amazing... Did i tell you that you are amazing?? ... That was perfect editing and everything... I love it ten and rose.... Amazing

  • Where did you find these clips???

  • I've seen both versions of this.

    And I have to say they are both good :D

    Keep it up Seduff!!!

  • Oh, fantastic. I've seen many Human Doctor/Rose wedding scenes, yours was THE BEST.

  • Hers always are. :)

  • what?!!!!!

    where is this from?!!

    A mini series or something?

  • i think my heart stopped beating. Seriously. this is The.Best.Video.I.Have.And.Will­.Ever.See... You are a true genius. This should win every award there is created for movies!

  • did i miss an episode?

  • That was fantastic & just amazing.

    Your videos are incredible.

  • Wha--what is this? Where's this from????!!

  • Aw:)

    This is sooo beautiful!!!

  • agreed

  • WOW just wonderfully put together!

  • 3:20

    Did he just say:

    'I love you, Rose' at the end?

  • yes he did :D

  • ............... is it from an other show with by some weird coincidence has a character named rose in it as well? D:

  • elsatisbest: If you are eluding to the doctors final line... Answer is Yes. :)

  • Comment removed

  • Wow!! I agree with some others, this is REALLY well done!! I'm also interested (like the post before me) in knowing where the non-Doctor Who clips came from.

  • Wow. What a wonderful story. What are the non- Doctor Who clips from? This is great. Wonderful video.

  • I wanted to comment on your music as well. I'm a huge fan of your brilliant editting, but I wanted to let you know that you find the best songs that aren't necessarily mainstream where I am...so THANK YOU!!!!!

  • I feel stupid here.....did I miss some of the real series here??? Is there a half human doc??? And did he and Rose get together??? Seriously!!! We dont get some of the stuff you brits do...

  • They're clips from other shows the two are in mixed in with Doctor Who.

  • at the end of series four, a human doctor was created and he and rose got to stay together :)

  • was the best part of the episode in my opinion

  • It's the end of Season 4 (Episode name, Journey's End)

  • wow it's really good :)

  • How... Did you -do- this... ITS SEAMLESS!

  • That is really well done!

    Just wow!

    ^_^

  • Maybe the human doctor will turn out to be the Valeyard!

  • it wont happen because the doctor is human and he has rose to make him better as the proper doctor said

  • Brilliant Absolutley Brilliant... Just for this video i am subscribing with your channel...

  • awesome video!!!

    lol random thought, when the human Doctor and Rose got married here, would he have taken her last name or what?

  • Wow

  • Brilliance

  • you're amazing, absolutely amazing

  • wow

  • Wonderfully beautiful.

    Without doubt, one of the best videos I've ever seen, both versions are stunning.

    You're truly talented. Keep up the amazing work! :)

  • wow.....that was so good, im tearing up,( i watched the other aswell)......you are the master of video thingys!