shalla sonu nigam.. copied this song... he should bow down to gautam da.. what a composition.. and sonu nigam shouts... how will he know the essence of this song.. this is a pshychedelic song... does sonu the bastar know what it means?
Bukta hu hu kore uthe ai gaan ta shunle!!!! Gautam da is truely a magician!!! Unar perfect bebohar poshchime bongo korte pare ni!!! Sad but true! 70 s er band mohiner ghoraguli; jara shomoyke onneeek ager thekei dekhe felechhilo! Bangladesh a musician der musician hote hole- shobar age mohiner ghoraguli course hishabe nite hoy!!!! Kolkatar kotha bolte parbo na!!! But jibon jotodin achhe Amii gautam da k sharajibon srdhdha e kore jabo!!!! Valobashi tmy
Greatness of Bengali-Hindus is acclaimed worldwide......Tagore to vivekananda.....Jagadish Chandra bose to Amartya sen.....in arts Ravi shankar to Satyajit Ray........
Bong globalisation, Separate issues really, A) Collapsing system (education, jobs, work culture, industry, infrastructure) that force people to look out B) Adventurous and entrepreneurial sprit of Bongs, (opposite of Kupmondukism) which was Bengali culture - Dwijendranath Tahkur: 1st desi industrialist, Netaji, Sukumar, Mujtaba, all took the best frm West. Parochialism infected our culture in past 30/40 yrs, by those who failed on merit, & had to defend their inabilities
hello friends, this is original song...not paroma...actually..she sang it much later on.. anyway, this is much better than paroma's version.. some song demands voice which is not so soothing to ear, like paroma. Nothing doing, this one is much better. though this is badly edited...
comparison is obvious...I have liked Paroma's version more. May be because of Debojyoti Mishra's music arrangement..Is paroma's version available in youtube? paroma'r oi album e gautam chattopadhyayer arekta gaan chhilo - choitrer kofon...
You should use your brains a bit and reason out why people have been moving out of Bengal and Calcutta for higher education and/or jobs over the decades. If you cannot understand then you should better remain silent or rather ask instead of vociferously abusing decent people here. If you lack an education it is wise not to explicitly show that. Your comment stands out among 17 others thanks to its utter ugliness.
Nothing's there to ask, my man. I got the best education the country can offer in Bengal and never had trouble getting a job in Kolkata with comopensations more or less at par with what I would have got in other metro cities. May be thats why I never realized the need to leave. And do you mean the expletives were ugly? Well, maybe you missed it but they were meant to be. Do you even realize how people like you salvage, endorse and justify mediocrity..............
See you may be a genius but everybody is not. You may be great enough to get the best education and then work in Bengal but everybody is not blessed with such brain and intellect. People have to feed themselves and if that leaves mediocre people with no choice but to leave then it is not really their fault, is it? If they miss Bengali culture and music while being away, is that a fault? And also how come you are sure that people leaving Bengal are mediocre? I'm not too sure on that also.
Whatever you are saying is understandable, but the point is not just mediocrity. The point is people can leave their place of birth / hometown for whatever reason, and they have the full right to miss it. If you see the movie "Chalo let's go" by Anjan Dutta , there is a very interesting comment there "- jodi jewsra shudhu nijeder synagogue e boshe thakto tahole ki amra einstein speilberg ke petam ", and one more from Agantuk " konodino kupomoduk hoye theko naa ".
Thankfully modern bengalis are crossing the boundaries , and trying not to be the colloquial "kupomonduk". I mean look at gujjus they are so far away from their hometowns - yet they are in kolkata , uganda , united states with their businesses and their garbha. Why can't we do that too ? Bengal ar bengalider globalization ta ki kharap ? Well surely not - otherwise we might never have heard Vivekananda's speech at the Chicago religious congress, or there would have been no Bose.
Hey i have the same feelings every time ei gaan ta shuni,mon ta kemni jeno bhalo and kharap ek sathe lagte lage na? anyways, amio new york e, tumi kothay thako? :) (bangla'r taan r ki !!!)
Amaro mon kharap laage gaan ta shunle.. dur deshe thaki ... .. gaan ta shunlei .. sei tin er bus, bhir, gariahut er hawker... .cha... fuchka..eggroll...sab kichu mone pore jai...
bengal had everything going for it, an intellectual power house in itself, articulate, philosophical, perhaps the best, yet they had to be communists, dig their own graves and bid bye bye to the tatas, this does not sound like paroma does it?, hers is the best rendition of the song
onek din por ei gaan shune probash e mon bhari hoye uthlo....khub e bhalo hoyese editing....bhalo gaan er sahthe bhalo aekta still photos er mixing koreso tumi...khub e shundor
amar sahar theke eto dure theke gautam dar ei gan ta sune sotti nostalgic hoe porlam..chovigulo khub sundor bhave collage hoeche..gr8 job done..keep it up
ghore shobai phirbe, amio...gaan ta gaite bhulle cholbe na tokhon.....
creepymuck 2 months ago
@udit15121988 can please tell me the detail of the copy... kichhu loker mukhe jhama ghoshte hobe boss please janao.......
amarnamamit 3 months ago
shalla sonu nigam.. copied this song... he should bow down to gautam da.. what a composition.. and sonu nigam shouts... how will he know the essence of this song.. this is a pshychedelic song... does sonu the bastar know what it means?
udit15121988 5 months ago
ei gan-tar shonge amar ekta bishesh smriti jorie achhe... jokhoni shuni kandi...
12345678928072 5 months ago
trippy video . stoned .
avik8286 6 months ago
Thx for this upload...any bengali in any part of this world...hearing this...BARIR KOTHA MONE PORCHE...TAI NA? @piu070482....thanks
rajdeep45m 11 months ago
gaanta amar bhalo lage... deshe sobai jano bhalo thake...ami deshe phirbo nischoi.
bidyutsarkar3 1 year ago
Obak kara gaan! Amar proshongshata omboler moto uthe asche! Probashi bagangalider jonno. Thanks for being, didi
chandan2608 1 year ago
Bukta hu hu kore uthe ai gaan ta shunle!!!! Gautam da is truely a magician!!! Unar perfect bebohar poshchime bongo korte pare ni!!! Sad but true! 70 s er band mohiner ghoraguli; jara shomoyke onneeek ager thekei dekhe felechhilo! Bangladesh a musician der musician hote hole- shobar age mohiner ghoraguli course hishabe nite hoy!!!! Kolkatar kotha bolte parbo na!!! But jibon jotodin achhe Amii gautam da k sharajibon srdhdha e kore jabo!!!! Valobashi tmy
DaccaCalling 1 year ago
awesome song...
sumanpal1990 1 year ago
Greatness of Bengali-Hindus is acclaimed worldwide......Tagore to vivekananda.....Jagadish Chandra bose to Amartya sen.....in arts Ravi shankar to Satyajit Ray........
Bangalira shara hindu jaatir gorbo
FRETWORKER1288 1 year ago
@FRETWORKER1288 Ami Onek Jaatir num shunechi, Kintu Hindu Jaati prothom shunlam....Ektu bujie bolben ki???????????
souav 1 year ago
nostalgia, delicious nostalgia
plectumHand 1 year ago
Bong globalisation, Separate issues really, A) Collapsing system (education, jobs, work culture, industry, infrastructure) that force people to look out B) Adventurous and entrepreneurial sprit of Bongs, (opposite of Kupmondukism) which was Bengali culture - Dwijendranath Tahkur: 1st desi industrialist, Netaji, Sukumar, Mujtaba, all took the best frm West. Parochialism infected our culture in past 30/40 yrs, by those who failed on merit, & had to defend their inabilities
bhuto75 1 year ago
oh,heart touching...
Monyfoysal 1 year ago
This song is sung by CHANDRANI BANERJEE for God's sake!!!
she's uncomparable.she's the queen.Period.
getoutdamnu 1 year ago
amioo bari firte chai
suvajitmaity 1 year ago
kolkatatar moto sotti arr kono jaiga ney..amioooo bari firte chai....
suvajitmaity 1 year ago
great.
The2951979 1 year ago
this is the best version/no matter who sings/manida ..tumi kothai...shab kirakam palte jachche/we really miss you.
joygurutapash 2 years ago
This has an awesome haunting, melancholy aura to it. The other version is simply a song. But this one touches a nerve.
roneetam 2 years ago
moner gobhire pore thaka sriti bisriti kokhonoki bhola jaye...
shoishobe toh aar feraa jabenako ar..nei poth neyi hariye geche shey desh.
bideesha88 2 years ago
this one is obviously d original vrs n i m damn sure abt dat ! but paroma's one was an infinity times bettr 1 !!!!!!!
bipchk 2 years ago
hello friends, this is original song...not paroma...actually..she sang it much later on.. anyway, this is much better than paroma's version.. some song demands voice which is not so soothing to ear, like paroma. Nothing doing, this one is much better. though this is badly edited...
anirkol 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
sidchat 2 years ago
excellent .. no words to describe.. thx for the post
MrLibran 2 years ago
The original version is sung by Paroma Banerjee ( Mohiner Ghoraguli) - her rendition is superb - also posted on youtube
moon2deb 2 years ago 2
No original versn is this one - Paroma also sung this later....
piu070482 2 years ago
Comment removed
debmoon2 2 years ago
Personal choice may be - I like this one ... so I dnt wannna say anything bout Paroma's one ...
piu070482 2 years ago
nice song
aichrajib 2 years ago
ekhon porjonto kotobar shunciiii jani naaa .....
ashadharon
rasselraihan 2 years ago
comparison is obvious...I have liked Paroma's version more. May be because of Debojyoti Mishra's music arrangement..Is paroma's version available in youtube? paroma'r oi album e gautam chattopadhyayer arekta gaan chhilo - choitrer kofon...
kushalnandi1 2 years ago
Oshadharon...shotti oshadharon...r kichui bolte chai na
mjnuvan 2 years ago
You should use your brains a bit and reason out why people have been moving out of Bengal and Calcutta for higher education and/or jobs over the decades. If you cannot understand then you should better remain silent or rather ask instead of vociferously abusing decent people here. If you lack an education it is wise not to explicitly show that. Your comment stands out among 17 others thanks to its utter ugliness.
parachutes2005 2 years ago 4
Nothing's there to ask, my man. I got the best education the country can offer in Bengal and never had trouble getting a job in Kolkata with comopensations more or less at par with what I would have got in other metro cities. May be thats why I never realized the need to leave. And do you mean the expletives were ugly? Well, maybe you missed it but they were meant to be. Do you even realize how people like you salvage, endorse and justify mediocrity..............
reutersgateway 2 years ago
See you may be a genius but everybody is not. You may be great enough to get the best education and then work in Bengal but everybody is not blessed with such brain and intellect. People have to feed themselves and if that leaves mediocre people with no choice but to leave then it is not really their fault, is it? If they miss Bengali culture and music while being away, is that a fault? And also how come you are sure that people leaving Bengal are mediocre? I'm not too sure on that also.
parachutes2005 2 years ago 4
@reutersgateway
Whatever you are saying is understandable, but the point is not just mediocrity. The point is people can leave their place of birth / hometown for whatever reason, and they have the full right to miss it. If you see the movie "Chalo let's go" by Anjan Dutta , there is a very interesting comment there "- jodi jewsra shudhu nijeder synagogue e boshe thakto tahole ki amra einstein speilberg ke petam ", and one more from Agantuk " konodino kupomoduk hoye theko naa ".
shomnat 1 year ago
@reutersgateway
Thankfully modern bengalis are crossing the boundaries , and trying not to be the colloquial "kupomonduk". I mean look at gujjus they are so far away from their hometowns - yet they are in kolkata , uganda , united states with their businesses and their garbha. Why can't we do that too ? Bengal ar bengalider globalization ta ki kharap ? Well surely not - otherwise we might never have heard Vivekananda's speech at the Chicago religious congress, or there would have been no Bose.
shomnat 1 year ago
Ami kalke bari jachchi :)
rony358 2 years ago
kolkata amar porom bhalobasha
shaonsen12 2 years ago
amio bari jabo....
SOMS482 3 years ago 3
amio jabooo :( missng home ...
piu070482 2 years ago
thanks for uploading this video. really nice slide show.
parachutes2005 2 years ago
nice song. gaan ta shonle moonta kemon jani hoyejai.
rajibdasbd 3 years ago
nice song..
proshantor 3 years ago
My love to kolkata ..from New York...aaschi fire kadin porei...tomar kache..
siddharthailu819670 3 years ago
Hey i have the same feelings every time ei gaan ta shuni,mon ta kemni jeno bhalo and kharap ek sathe lagte lage na? anyways, amio new york e, tumi kothay thako? :) (bangla'r taan r ki !!!)
ananditachatterjee 3 years ago
Amaro mon kharap laage gaan ta shunle.. dur deshe thaki ... .. gaan ta shunlei .. sei tin er bus, bhir, gariahut er hawker... .cha... fuchka..eggroll...sab kichu mone pore jai...
prithvixlri 3 years ago
o god ! so true - ur words got 1000s of pics rolling in fronta' my eyes.... :)
ananditachatterjee 2 years ago
bengal had everything going for it, an intellectual power house in itself, articulate, philosophical, perhaps the best, yet they had to be communists, dig their own graves and bid bye bye to the tatas, this does not sound like paroma does it?, hers is the best rendition of the song
michaelarkengel 2 years ago
e jeno amar moner kotha....
fire jete chai...jaoar path khola nei...
rasselraihan 3 years ago
onek din por ei gaan shune probash e mon bhari hoye uthlo....khub e bhalo hoyese editing....bhalo gaan er sahthe bhalo aekta still photos er mixing koreso tumi...khub e shundor
smfluv 3 years ago
Very nice use of image/imagination with this lovely song - thank you!
decgame 3 years ago
My plsr ... :)
piu070482 3 years ago
Pritam has already copied it before in ankahee search ANKAHEE
debdina 3 years ago
amar sahar theke eto dure theke gautam dar ei gan ta sune sotti nostalgic hoe porlam..chovigulo khub sundor bhave collage hoeche..gr8 job done..keep it up
sourav2381 3 years ago
hey thnx...u have some nice vdo too....lol....beachwood park one....
piu070482 3 years ago