One day = 1000 year or 50000 years Contradictions in the Quran

[sususoos]

i dont think those verses have the same message.my opinion is agree with brother 1ma4ighter.

[killer4hire]

If this is valid then the word day becomes meaningless in the Quran. Every time a word has multiple meanings the word becomes subject to interpretation and therefore eventually it becomes opinion as the Quran is the only information from God the ultimate judge. As in the Arab language most words have multiple meanings some even over 10 this means the entire Quran becomes subject to human interpretation and therefore opinion. This makes it useless as command from God.

[1ma4ighter]

i am Muslim but he doesn't give a clear explanation.

In the first two verses found an exact extract reads: "is equal to 1000 of your years"

it explicitly mentions our earthly years, whereas in the latter verse it reads: "The angels and the spirit ascend unto him in a Day the measure whereof is (as) fifty thousand years" 50k of who's years? it doesn't say 50k "of YOUR years" as the others explicitly state

[blueray1969]

yeah yeah, the impression is to give its a lot longer in our span than gods. but, he doesn't explain why it is not consistent. it's not consistent because it's fake. so "1 period - 50 days"? what a charlatan.

[ahd200]

Nice

[babaob2]

very impressive knowledge of the quran thank you very very much ya sheikh dr zaik naik :)

[njfreddy]

i am 100% christian and i dont see the contradiction between 1,000 years or 50,000 years the point is that 1 day to us is like a blink of an eye to God..i just wonder why if the Bible says things like theses also musslims say its a contradiction in the Bible but not the koran

[viktermore]

Can someone explain this contradiction.

[41:11]

Moreover He comprehended in His design the sky, and it had been (as) smoke:

He said to it and to the earth: "Come ye together, willingly or unwillingly."

They said: "We do come (together), in willing obedience."

Quran says that Sky and Earth can talk. Believing this is like being born in year 0001 and not 2011. Guys, this is pure fairy tales.

[internev29a]

@viktermore Brother, indeed it is 2011 but your brain is in year 0001 lol. God almighty is the creator of the heavens and the earth he can make anything talk. Do you doubt his powers??? For Example on the day of judgement your body parts will talk.

"That day, their tongues, their hands and their feet would testify against them regarding what they used to do. (The Noble Quran, 24:24)"

[viktermore]

@internev29a Those type of verses make me question that God wrote Quran because they produce strange question answer to which I can't find.

One Example Why would God make my feet and my hands talk? To me it is just silly and I see no reason for it.

Another thing that i notice. Muslim claim that it is hard for them to believe that Gog has a Son. But on other side it is not hard for them to believe that Sky,Earth,Feet,Hands can talk. It just makes no sense to me.

[internev29a]

@viktermore The reason why you can not believe is because you have already made your mind about islam. Not even an ocean can fill up a cup that is already full so empty your cup.

That verse means Your body will testify against you so you have no excuses. Is there anyone better to testify against you but your own self?.

God has no son because (1)God does not beget. Begetting is attributed to humans and animals.(2)ch8v14

"For as many as are led by the Spirit of God, they are the sons of God

[viktermore]

@internev29a **Begetting is attributed to humans and animals.(2)ch8v14**

Genesis says that God made man in his image. Man can have a Son therefore God can have a Son as well.

[exposemyfoes]

@viktermore when a human has a son,the son is another human,so if a god has a son than that mean its another god,so do u believe in more than one god?,also the son is younger than the father,which mean the son has a beginning but god doesnt have a beginnin so the son can never be god,this was the position of arius at the council of nicea,IN PLAIN ENGLISH IT IS ILLOGICAL TO BELIEVE GOD HAS A SON

[viktermore]

@exposemyfoes Bible doesn't explain how Jesus happened to exist. It only states in OT that Jesus existed well before he came to earth in human flesh. Nothing is illogical because God is not restricted by logic. God has no restrictions. God is All Powerful.

[sususoos]

@viktermore ,where in the old testament ?

[viktermore]

@sususoos

Here Jesus clearly speaking in OT.

Isaiah 48:12-13

Read it and compare to John 18:6 and Revelation 22:12 where Jesus speaks using same words as in Isaiah 48:12-13.

[exposemyfoes]

@viktermore man can also have a daughter so can god also have a daughter



[viktermore]

@exposemyfoes If you believe that God is All Powerful then God can do and have what ever he wants.

If you claim that God can't have and do something then your God is not All Powerful.

[issamm]

Im afraid I can give a better explaination that Dr Naik: when it said 1000 years is one day Allah is Talking about when teh revelation came i.e approx 1400 years ago, and Where Allah mentions 50,000 years it is about the day of judgement, it supports the Theory that the universe is constantly expanding it is spreading that the scientist have recently discovered. Hence a Astro Physicist can predict when Qayamat day of Judgement comes

[jamilpopal]

haha what you got to say now

[SirRudy93]

Big up Mr. Naik.

He Seriously knows his islam! :0)

[livingonmyon]

@SirRudy93 so what's holding you to become one?

It's not HIs Islam but it's everybody's he's just ONE muslim in Islam's great nation.

[SirRudy93]

@livingonmyon well as a matter of fact. i am a muslim.

And when i say "his islam" i didnt mean it in the sence of islam being hism as in he knows alot about islam, obviously i kno that

[livingonmyon]

@SirRudy93 well then alhamdo lillah you're a muslim.