Mlb 09 The show : Safe or Out ?

[MrTobin8]

Doesn't the rule say that the runner has to "clearly" beat the tag at the base. Now some umps can have a very quick eye but I think this one was too close. Runner is OUT.

[TheCruikshanks]

in 2 fps it seems he is out by 0.5 inches

[BubbyChicky]

safe runner gets tie

[bigbossGA]

i love redsox but he was out

[zachishellacool]

unmpire called him out so i would say hes out

[mysuper64]

Safe! Go Red Sox!

[jcena2254]

wow if any of u knew how to play u would know that if it is a tie at a base then the runnner is safe

[TheJeffhardyfan5]

SAFE

[Zstrike205]

out by a sixteenth of a second

[imawesomelikepie1]

SAFE SAFE SAFE

[Doriano429]

it is definatly out

[Hank3666able]

safe

[iPwNLiTTleOneS]

safe

[yankees1cotton]

safe

[jameschris902]

out



[Welcome2daBAY510]

TIe goes to the runner ..... Safe!

[acenace24]

You have it backward, the tie goes to the runner

[DylnCox]

Out... No such thing as a "tie" and if you say there's a tie, then it doesn't go to the runner...

[MrKnice12]

@DylnCox if there is a tie at a base it goes to the runner safe LEARN BASEBALL

[DylnCox]

@MrKnice12 I should learn baseball HA. That's fucking hilarious, coming from the guy that thinks there is tie. Rule 7.01:"A runner acquires the right to an unoccupied base when he touches it before he is out." BEFORE he is out, not at the same time.

[1994fsu]

Out

[ps2dude13]

i have no idea

[Derek4524]

safe

[Kilian127]

A tie never goes to the runner I been upming for 7 years and everyrules has said in the event of a tie the runner is out. The call goes to fielder always has always will

[MrKnice12]

@Kilian127 well u ump wrong tie goes to runner

[akzakz777]

tie base goes to the runner

[AndzikD]

out because the empire said so (it matters on the type of empire)

[yankees1cotton]

He was safe Go Yankees

[GCPlayer82]

out cuz ur a red sox fan go yanks

[SpiderJason02]

its a tie

[HandbagMafia]

im an asshole for blowing this up and freeze framing it every 1/1000th of a sec, runner is OUT, i know i need a real job, i am a turd muffin

[renegadescrush]

safe

[POYAWESOME]

out

[sexycaliguy]

safe...tie goes to the runner, and from that angle any ump would call that safe

[sexycaliguy]

safe...tie goes to the runner, and from that angle any ump would call that safe

[MultiRockstar34]

safe

[ramprunner1]

tie goes to the runner



[FingerTVBoarder]

@ramprunner1 yeah youre right tie goes to the runner but the out makes the game more realistic

[THEALLSTARMLB2009]

well tie goes to the runner so safe

[jacknovozin]

safe if you go frame by frame you'll see it was an exact tie

[compaqRYAN1]

out

[Ryan61090]

safe,no out,safe,no out i don't know

[Mrphillsfan123]

hes just barely out

[TheUsarmy48]

@Mrphillsfan123 he was safe

[iKeyboard15]

safe

[1modernwarfaremaster]

safe tie to runner

[ps2dude13]

looks like a tie to me

[DuquesneSidle101]

safe tie goes to the runner

[cooleyotastic]

hes safe a tie goes 2 the runner

[haroboy11]

its out cuz sometimes the umpire calls it out if it is a tie

[respectthepuff]

tie goes to the runner. they came at the same time

[MrDemondeaconfan]

Out defense usually gets the edge on calls like this

[shermarful]

tie

[TheTigerfan99]

HES SAFE

[boringcats]

SAFE

[chaoschao2134]

SAFE! they touched the bag at the same time so he is safe, trust me im a walking baseball encyclopedia.

[boringcats]

@chaoschao2134

same here

[zZBBZz100]

good call the runner steped on the farther end of the bag. if he would have stepped on the front part he would have been safe. but very close play

[wtbates]

There is no such thing as "tie goes to the runner" except possibly in back yard whiffle ball games. There is only out or safe! If you don't agree, please, post the MLB rule for us to read (or any other level of baseball's rule). It does not exist. It is one of those false things passed on in life.

[Seth35696]

Safe, tie goes to the runner.

[nickh113x]

i say safe. what do u think

[mysuper64]

Tie goes to the runner.

[SwissCheese7724]

SAFE!! Tie goes to the runner.

[JohanSantanaRox]

SAFE!!!!!!

[laverde19]

out por un pelo de culo el picher llego primero

[JoEyRocks597]

OUT

[samellings]

out

[boomev1]

sry 0:07

[boomev1]

ya hes out cuz the heel hit the bag b4 the runner :07

[bor1cua100]

out!!! the oriole player tounch the basethant first

[nargudin]

lol hes out thats really close --====%#@!

[berepunk18]

is safe

[STEPOFF134]

at :39 u can tell hes safe

[lj23kb24AS]

hes ouut...hahah

[SolidGold1221]

OUT!!!

[iluvsk8ting777]

out

[joetodaro]

tie goes to the runner

[critter2]

no such thing as tie goes to the runner

[JohanSantanaRox]

@critter2 There is such thing

[jdsquarepants]

out

[bigpiggi]

safe tie goes to da runner

[ElPapi997]

Youre OUT!LMAO

[ElPapi997]

heres a tip:In mlb the show and mvp 04&05&03.The umps are always right.

[Oldmanjenkins123]

out

[tjat375]

the heal got him and the song is jerk it out

[gopadres7]

out by a heel

[r35h93]

out by a hair

[foreveryoungvideo]

out

[wady195]

out so out

[sparkman433]

yeah hes OUT!!! =p

[008sportsstar]

TIe means safe so SAFE!

[shinoku00]

out, fielders heel got their first

[grandmaphilips]

he was safe

[aaemericask8er]

wat is the song

[albanianboy94]

if you put the no ump mistakes option on, we would all no the true outcome.

[kiladelphia123]

out

[johncenabigfan1]

out but real close.just got his foot before the runner.closest play eva.

[videogame888]

guys stop with all the arguing it was a tie. and like all real baseball people know tie goes to the runner and thats final you cant say that they beat each other by a millisecond because the only way to figure that out is if it was going at regular speed which it wasnt so u cant tell who one unless u were 100 percent sure and even if u say u are no one can be 100 percent sure who won that race to the bag and if u notice the umps in a bad angle.

[ThatCompton20]

yeahh

its true!!

[14garrett14]

safe

[shoefame11]

out but definatley closest play ive seen in this game

[bvestationfan]

hes out

[Briansflim]

good song wats song is it

[Alexandrelavoie6666]

Jerk It Out - The Caesars

[alldayap281]

the oriols guy got him out by just a bit, his foot hit the bag a millisecond before the red sox guy

[krodfan75]

out

[jlog1000]

out

[Briansflim]

wtf !!!! he waz safe but he waz safe just by a little bit

[legpower87]

outtt

[milesthegreat805]

im an up and tie does not go to the runner that is a fake rule he was safe by a toenail if i did that game i would panic and call him safe

[xbuckwheat13x]

Tie goes to the runner... lol

[mikvitu]

out what was the actual call?

[Alexandrelavoie6666]

The Ref Call OUT

[jacknovozin]

@Alexandrelavoie6666 Not a ref an ump and he's safe

[krisdop]

@Alexandrelavoie6666 dude its out his heel steppedd on the base first

[JohanSantanaRox]

safe

[air13ek]

The guy with red sox has foot on first.