Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (151)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • @rulove99 I was thinking the same, she sings hero like an opera song, which doesn't really sound good.

  • Mariah's expression at 3:12 is like "wtf"??? LMFAO!!! p.s.That lady with red hair really makes me laugh out endlessly.She ruined the song by using too much falsetto even whole part .She was one of the finalists but why she sounds so horrible here??

  • omg..this performance just shows mariah's TONE is one of a kind! <3

  • somebody please shoot the producer who set up this performance. Poor Mariah.

  • MY GOD THOSE SINGERS BUTCHERED HER SONGS IN FRONT OF HER.

  • What the hell Lemar got to sing with Mariah?? He's like a one-hit wonder B-list celebrity in the UK.

  • She dont got no booty... lol

  • The girl that sang My All did REALLY well..she sang it EXACTLY like Mariah did! You could tell she practiced lots! Mariah's ad libs were cute! She was partyin on Heartbreaker! LoL.."why not?" ...she was even gettin her little two step on! lol...she was flirtin with that black dude lol, she had to catch herself...BTW, she sounds amazing! lol..the last two ruined Hero...Mariah saved it with that beautiful off the cuff LIVE sustained whistle, LMAO, her and the red head fought off the 'YOU's hehe

  • She was most enjoying herself singing heartbreaker <3

  • the 'hero' singers are horrible!

  • Congratulations Mariah! More number 1 albums and more number 1 singles for you!!!!!!

  • LMFAO! MARIAH IS OUT OF CONTROL.! HAHA "WHY NOT?" I HAVENT SEEN HER ACT SO FUNNY AND DANCE AS MUCH AS SHE HAS EVER IN A PERFORMANCE. LOL WERQ MIMI!!! AFTER YOU GIVE BIRTH CAN YOU GET BACK TO THAT WEIGHT? LOVE YOU!

  • i luv 1:35 mc so cute

  • Ew what horrible annoying singers, MC can't be beaten!!

  • Mariah was the only good thing about 'hero' here

  • HEARTREGGEA....

  • LINDA LINDA LINDAAAAAAAAA, MEU DEUS EU QUERO CASAR COM UMA MULHER ASSIMMMMMMMMMM. MARIAHHHHHHHHHH

  • The run from 3:42 to 3:46 was one of her very best

  • I love her.....she is so cuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuute...she always tries to be creative!

  • Comment removed

  • Mariah should BEAT the hell out of them.. Mariah stood there and let them tear them songs up!

  • Oh that black men is really good! What is his name???

  • @algie1234 lemur 

  • @algie1234 his name is Lemar, he has a couple of albums out in the UK

  • @algie1234 lemar

  • omg DEAD at that bitch in red, she's horrible... it's like mariah's thinking don't butcher my classic bitch. let me bring home lmao

  • what a pretty medley

  • the one who sang My All, I like her cause she did her own thing and she didn't ruined the song but the what the others did was just manslaughter,... love that C# note!!!

  • thay destroys mimi's songs hate them..ILOVE HER FALSETTO WHISLTE AT HERO

  • le massacre

  • i liked the heartbreaker part! the my all part was ok and the hero part was awful!

  • @iiAmitx3 i know,the girl in red killed the song

  • Somebody can tell me, what is the name of this women, who sings Hero...?

    Thank You :)

  • I'm glad she didn't outshine them, cuz you get to see they were a damn mess! And those thinking rihanna some how matches up, search for her singing hero and that will show you whos the boss. Even mariah at the inauguration kicks rihanna ass.

  • wow mariah held back and let the other singers sing, but she should have sang, becuz all four of them were all over the place!!!

  • If Rihanna is a Queen, Mariah is a Godess

  • @mimimariajudith  Mariah is the queen of goddesses :')

  • mc had a backing track on :/

    shes still fab tho

  • rihanna better singer than mariah? are you crazy? i mean rihanna is good but mariah.. well 5 octaves tell it all

  • pathetic, mariah cant sing

    queen rihanna is the best

    watch my video, queen rihanna vs mariah carey

  • @QueenRiRiRihanna hhAHAHAHHAHAA tell rihanna to go get her self 18 #1's then we talk buddy......

  • @QueenRiRiRihanna watch rihannas wonderful performance where she covered mariahs song "hero" at her high school. a must see!!!

  • Mariah is just unique, and Riahanna cannot compete...come on, we are not in the same planet! Let say we do not like the same music....Lets discuss this in 20 years, to see if Rihanna succeeds in 15% of what Mariah has already achieved.

    God bless Mariah for her music and sharing it with us, and all the joy she brings to people....

  • What the hell is going on in this video? Mariah, why did you let them do this?

  • mariah is still the best

  • lol

  • mariah ! best

  • Mariah put that bitch back in her place lozl

  • @theovanua haha you got that right

  • :D lol

  • Comment removed

  • lol....the girl who starts off the song shes like WTF when Mariah starts singing hahahahaha!!!

    OMG SHES SO FUNNY!!! i love her laugh..."WHY NOT?" LMFAO! That black guy is like Mimi you my girl!! DOUCHE!!

  • this Mariah Carey was pure hotness (after charmbracelet and before TEOM) not to thin (90's) and not fat (2009 - )

  • lol mariah was like i know this chick dont think she can sing higher then me lol jk

  • yeah like wtf she didnt even start singing when she was ment to!! Mariah showed her LOL and besides her voice was all over the place!

  • @lambs1989 haha ikr

  • ikr?

  • @lambs1989 lol it  means i know right haha

  • haha that makes sense now...i was like ikr? WTF?!

    I LOVE the butterfly fingers!! HEHE CLASSIC!!!

  • @lambs1989 hahaa yea lol i know she got me doing when i sing now i know i watch her that much lol

  • BAD!! i do that all the time now, even if its not to a Mariah song lol...i think in my head im doing like the whistle and i just do the butterfly fingers :P CRAZAZAY! my little sister laughs at me everytime :P

  • @lambs1989 im 2nd saprano not first so dont worry daughling i try to do it also lol doesnt really work

  • i love the red head womens voice...anyone know her?

  • ER SHUT THE HELL UP Nolwen - the first singer did pretty well with the falsetto

  • this sucks they ruined all of mariahs songs

  • the 2nd singer was great and the 1st one too but the last 2 hai mariah tried covering up 4 them they embarresed her song 1 of her best songs still

  • mais nimporte koi c la star academy epok 2002 pas american idol le titre est totalment a louest!! XD

  • @sweetheartattitude

    ah si punaize!! il ton tt copie de la sta ac truc de ouf on croirai nolween lol pff les copieur c pathetik ... *-*

  • where was that?

  • she used her falsetto in order to cover up the other singer's voices =P very clever, i must say =)

    Mariah I love you.

    signature : one of your lambs

  • when was this?

  • I thought that they all did amazingly well to have enough courage to stand and sing with the marvelous, awe-inspiring, flawless, and incomparable Mariah Carey, but to me, the second singer (the one who did Heartbreaker) was the best.

  • the second singer wasnt that good the first one was very good tho

  • omg the last two were like..no :P

  • yeeeeeeee eminem lovs maria ..........

  • OMG love the whistle note

  • Nobody compares to Mariah's pitch

  • Mariah Carey get u a nice dress not a sleeping one :/

  • the one who opened with the song great voice.

  • MARIAH was really feelin the black guy. lol she was flirting MAD HARD! lol

  • yeah she likes her some chocolate

  • The singers were a hot mess. Mariah was like WTF? lol

  • Mariah's voice kinda cracked at the end after her whistle note, she sounded good though

  • she didnt do a whistle at the end it was a falsetto !!! C#6

  • there's no such thing as falsetto in a woman's voice...it's a head voice

  • @deonzax same thing different name lol

  • Lemar is amazing but he didnt win the british one!

  • I'd like to forget this particular video.

  • As would I!

  • Who's the black dude?

  • lemar. he is a british singer

  • Thizanks!!!

  • Well this is my review:

    Mariah - Amazing

    The other 4 - unworthy to be standing next to the Queen Of Music!

  • lol mariah got a lil scared at the end when that opera lady came...she had to throw that whistle in there to show her who ruled!!! lol

  • LOLOLLL..

  • lol...

  • o my godd....that red headed girl won the show? sounds awful....or maybe it wasnt her genre..

  • the black dude was amazing!!!

  • mariah owned the red head girl...she sound so bad...mariah owned her with the whistle.

  • lemar is more known 4 actually being a sining not 4 being on fame academy

  • the first one is french and the second one english, apparently, but the other ones, don't know ;-p

  • someone shoot the bitch at the end - I cant beleive Mariah had to listen to her OWN song being ruined!

  • LMAO. i know right. esp. @ 3:12

  • you mean the bitch wearing the black suit at the end ?!! lmao !! Shoot em both then hang em , then drag em , hehehehe wow

  • wow these europeans are tall. i mean, Mariah stand's at 5'9 without high heels, and for sure she was wearing high heels here, but even so, these guys still looked taller than her.

  • They are probably tall but Mariah is 5'7" without heels, not 5'9"

  • kyararangitan si Mariah...kawto kumiyuriyak badun sa gya dowa kataw mga tanga!

  • The black dude pops a boner! hahahaha

    Your one time next to mariah and yu go up in flames! Well yo go bro! Lets face it. She's hot like F***!

  • oh my god Mariah blew them with her high notes..!

  • these are the finalists lol , mariah destroys them. its just karaoke for them, it takes an artists to make it music,

  • der not finalists der all frm different talent shows lyk da black 1 is frm a talent show called fame adcademy in england n da black 1's really luk him up his names lamer

  • what year was this?

  • Woo! MARIAH's high note is so amazing.

  • OMG Mariah threw them in the dirt!!!!!!!

  • Those four contestants were aweful and painful to hear. The zombies from World of the Dead sound' way better.

    I love you Mariah, but that must have bee torture hearing your tracks getting beat up by those four. Lol!

  • Mariah MUST have been payed a whole hell of alot of money to be subjected to this torture...on the other hand, MC's high note on "Hero" was amazing! very operatic

  • OMG I should've posted after I heard HERO...That woman was just AWFUL......She totally ruined one of my favorite Mariah's songs, like skinned it live or something...I mean, puleeeeeeeeeze.......

  • this should be around 1999 or 2000 right?

  • it was 2001 actually

  • Mariah must had alot of rest

  • hahaha ilove when mariah do the haha in heartbreaker!

  • Comment removed

  • who are these singers???!!! i mean they failed to give their best shot for mariah!!! they wasted the moment with mariah.. specially the lady who sung the last part of Hero... its a shame.. cant believe they're the winners.....

  • well da black 1's called lemar he won fame academy a show in england n he's good luk him up

  • OMFG Mariah just gave me goosebumbs when she started singing hero

  • Loving mariahs whistle and laugh at the beginning of heartbreaker!

  • The second guy was Lemar, one of the best british male singers at the moment

  • the boy version's so good in heartbreaker... MARIAH is soooo Hot in here... Very beautiful MC...She help the singers to make it so good about the songs...

  • very nice mariah

  • when was this?

  • that's a long whistle huh........ love it

  • lol. it's like a freakshow. mariah was very accomodating

  • the girl that sang the hero in the brown dress was so awful..omg..

  • The first girl; Nolwenn, actually sounded good when she sang in her deeper range. Her higher range was rather annoying.

  • She was singing backup. It was fucking awesome.

  • the second guy was the best by far aside from mariah of course. the last girl was just awful

  • his names lemar n he is good luk him up

  • they were ALL TERRIBLE ecept mariah and lemar!

    god the others were cringy particuallry the woman at the end singing hero.

  • LOL! I love how they try and compete with Mariah in the song Hero. That idiot in the red dress! Mariah gives her a look like bitch thats my part!! lol Go Mimi!

  • the black guy was looking at mariah very creepy eyes

  • wats the 1st song called?

  • my all

  • thtat was actually THREE SONGS

  • j'représente la france donc jvote pour nolwen leroy !!

  • oh my god hahahaha mariah and the black boy was the best the rest are all shit singing

  • Lemar was NOT on any version of 'Idol', in particular the original British 'Pop Idol'. He was on 'Fame Academy' - and he didn't even win that.

  • arme carey brrrrrrrrrr

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more