Who's in the lineup here? Billy and Jimmy, Jeff Schroeder on electric guitar... but who are the two ladies? I lost track between Melissa Aud der Mar and the current, Nicole Fiorentino.
jimmy chaimberlin is such a sick and dirty motherfucker with those fucking drums man. he's the peter north/ michael jordan/ babe ruth/ wayne gretzy/ brad pitt/ sasha grey of the drumming.
I have alot of respect for SP, love almost all of their shit. A big fan, but not a diehard and I gotta say this song bores me and Im surpised by that, but it does. I dont think I want to see BC playin a harmonica and his vocals are too stock which is unusual for him. I didnt quite catch the vibe on this one, certainly not like mabuhayguy below.
@dethmag Well you have to respect the fact that the same mind that That wrote songs as hard as Bullet With Butterfly Wings, and The Ever Lasting Gaze can write a smooth sweet song like this. I love this song it would have been perfect for Melancholy And The Infinite Sadness.
@nicholsjoshua15 It's funny u said that because earlier I left a comment on a Blank Page video saying real bands write song like Blank Page and F U Ode to No One. Like Metallica.. Nothing Else Matters and Dyers Eve for emample. I agree with you and get that. This song didnt grab me like alot of their softer stuff usually does, I was just surprised that it didnt. Maybe it will grow on me.
This is why the the Smashing Pumpkins are my favorite band in the world... One min you hear loud screaming guitars the next you hear something like this that blows me away... I would say this is one of the best songs they have ever recoreded :O)
still it leaves a particular feeling in my gut of ambitous curiousity if the orignal line up would fail miserably or succeed gracefully now a days and how they would sound together making new music. i guess we will never know.
@seasonsbleed Well, they would come back......but Darcy left and James left for their own reasons, but mostly because they had, had enough, whether thats of Billy Corgan who knows.
I do think maybe they would of if they were allowed to contribute more, but according to Billy they were'nt that interested anyway - and apparantly he told them what to play.
I don't know if thats Billy Corgan being the head controller or them being disinterested, but Billys pretty honest......
i actually like IF all goes wrong because its unique bands get sick of playing the same old shit so when i saw the pumpkings they had a 3 hour setlist and the only known songs were "bullets" "rino" "silverfuck" the rest were old and new lesser known material b-sides,covers and material they only play live they made up for playing lesser know songs by playing bullet with butterflywings 7 times in a row and twice at the end and they exyended a lot of their songs they are trully experimental
No studio version really exists right now, unless the band's recording it for "Teargarden by Kaleidyscope". This is probably the best version of it that exists.
@infinitesadnessbaby what year did it become Smashing Pumpkins 2? When Iha and D'arcy left? and if so what was the 1st album or EP Billy came out with without them it it? and btw i love this song also... so beautiful
@infinitesadnessbaby what year did it become Smashing Pumpkins 2? When Iha and D'arcy left? and if so what was the 1st album or EP Billy came out with without them not in it? and btw i love this song also... so beautiful
@muzicnub4life It became SP v2 in 2007 when Billy and Jimmy got back together without D'arcy and James and the first album they did as SP v2 was Zeitgeist. Sounds nothing like this though, Zeitgeist is pretty heavy a lot of the time..
the music sounds great, but anyone notice how shitty billies lyrics are getting?? i think that guy really has nothing more to write nothing more to say and it shows up in his lyrics... either that or he feels accomplished and therefore lacks the interest to develop great lyrics.
20anosdepois Of course i've heard james solo works dude and(perfect circle) Sorry I've heard his solo stuff not be a hater of what he does,it adds up to?Lets see NOTHING really.I don't have problem with melissa's solo works...good stuff.Fan's really need stop living in the pass really.Billy's making music get over it and SP is his.I do really miss jimmy tho...but like the old saying goes, stop living in pass and "ALL THINGS CHANGE".
@WhiteLotusFlower well, I have to agree that the last concept that billy adopt is very interesting.
about james, is a diferent way is choose to follow. I cheer him. just hope that billy can mantaine the good work pos tarantula (that was really a side shot).
Give me a break Billy has the right to the SP name.Many famous bands still tour with less then the original members ...BIlly is SP and always will be.Let D'arcy and James try to do SP without Billy haha never pull it off.Look at the crap band james was in and funny nothing really from him to make anything.Billy made both of them period.Billy can pull it off without them.Billy has always been the heart of the band.I love that Billy's moved from the pass and dropped the dead weight so to speak..
just one question,do you know james solo work, or his participations in other band (liek a perfect circle)? and melissa, his solo album? james is a diferente musician, but a great one to. it misses something in SP.
PS: if you were talking about the tinted windows, i agree thats not a band for james.
amazing song.. still hope that it'll be in the new album.. its hardly, but possible. I think... All those new tracks, which are not recorded should be included on 'Teargarden by Kaleidyscope'.
i respect his wishes because of how long hes been loyal although i think iha and darcy are more up themselves than billy. James WAS cool but wrote practically nothing but intros. If these so called stars had ANY real respect for the fans they would do what most other bands have always done, GIVE THEM WHAT THEY WANT and SEE if they want anything new you have to offer, but whats the point in STILL calling the band "SP" when almost everything associated with them is gone and couldn't care less?
I agree, it should be "The corgan Project", honestly I think BIlly its destroing the SP image that I and so many more like me love for years... By the other side I love the work at solo of james, and even melissa has some good songs... just cant find nothing from d'arcy.
I didn't like Zeitgeist much but songs like this are a great addition to the Pumpkins legacy imo. He had any number of names to call the band he puts out these new songs under, but obviously he feels that they're "Pumpkin" material, or hed have called them "Zwan" or "Billy Corgan" songs.
Explain how its over-indulgent? It's a great build up to a great song. Just because he solos it in the beginning? You mean like starla? He's starting you off on a ride... why not just enjoy the trip? ;) A great song doesn't need to be dissected, just enjoyed.
Wow, I wish there was a studio version of this.
If someone posts the whole "if all goes wrong" movie on YouTube, I will love you forever
duke1497 2 months ago
wow this configuration setting reminds me of the BeaTLes "Let it Be" inside the album picture (when u open the album cover) spread, cheers! x0]
tornmask1 2 months ago
I have this DVD. It's so good!!
Limie316 4 months ago
I really like the American Gothic era, with this kind of acoustic guitars, it's beautiful!
pollitorsiones 4 months ago
This is just... wow.
Who's in the lineup here? Billy and Jimmy, Jeff Schroeder on electric guitar... but who are the two ladies? I lost track between Melissa Aud der Mar and the current, Nicole Fiorentino.
bigstereo 10 months ago
@bigstereo They´re Ginger Reyes on bass and Lisa Harrington on piano
jockesv 8 months ago
Perfection
as usual ...
fieldpool 11 months ago
jimmy chaimberlin is such a sick and dirty motherfucker with those fucking drums man. he's the peter north/ michael jordan/ babe ruth/ wayne gretzy/ brad pitt/ sasha grey of the drumming.
anyghost 1 year ago 2
this song is sooooo good i hope its on the next album
kevinp1188 1 year ago
SP fans are so passionate with their comments........and our music...luv you guys!!!!!!
ghostchild336699 1 year ago
I have alot of respect for SP, love almost all of their shit. A big fan, but not a diehard and I gotta say this song bores me and Im surpised by that, but it does. I dont think I want to see BC playin a harmonica and his vocals are too stock which is unusual for him. I didnt quite catch the vibe on this one, certainly not like mabuhayguy below.
dethmag 1 year ago
@dethmag Well you have to respect the fact that the same mind that That wrote songs as hard as Bullet With Butterfly Wings, and The Ever Lasting Gaze can write a smooth sweet song like this. I love this song it would have been perfect for Melancholy And The Infinite Sadness.
nicholsjoshua15 1 year ago
@nicholsjoshua15 It's funny u said that because earlier I left a comment on a Blank Page video saying real bands write song like Blank Page and F U Ode to No One. Like Metallica.. Nothing Else Matters and Dyers Eve for emample. I agree with you and get that. This song didnt grab me like alot of their softer stuff usually does, I was just surprised that it didnt. Maybe it will grow on me.
dethmag 1 year ago
Comment removed
nicholsjoshua15 1 year ago
I love this so much...could listen to it all day, in fact I have...♥
chrislvsp 1 year ago
JESUS JUST AWESOME!
mabuhayguy 1 year ago
best thing they have done in almost 10 years.
Agreenego33 1 year ago 5
This is why the the Smashing Pumpkins are my favorite band in the world... One min you hear loud screaming guitars the next you hear something like this that blows me away... I would say this is one of the best songs they have ever recoreded :O)
moonchild118 1 year ago 11
where is the love button?
juMpman7866 1 year ago
still it leaves a particular feeling in my gut of ambitous curiousity if the orignal line up would fail miserably or succeed gracefully now a days and how they would sound together making new music. i guess we will never know.
seasonsbleed 1 year ago
@seasonsbleed Well, they would come back......but Darcy left and James left for their own reasons, but mostly because they had, had enough, whether thats of Billy Corgan who knows.
I do think maybe they would of if they were allowed to contribute more, but according to Billy they were'nt that interested anyway - and apparantly he told them what to play.
I don't know if thats Billy Corgan being the head controller or them being disinterested, but Billys pretty honest......
pleaseopenyourshop 1 year ago
Ugh there is so such thing as SP2 get your heads out of your asses it's just SP stfu k thx
kazalack 1 year ago
tthis shouldeve been a single fast fact the smashing pumpkins has 788 songs avalable for people
TheLosthigh 1 year ago
i actually like IF all goes wrong because its unique bands get sick of playing the same old shit so when i saw the pumpkings they had a 3 hour setlist and the only known songs were "bullets" "rino" "silverfuck" the rest were old and new lesser known material b-sides,covers and material they only play live they made up for playing lesser know songs by playing bullet with butterflywings 7 times in a row and twice at the end and they exyended a lot of their songs they are trully experimental
TheLosthigh 1 year ago 2
is there a studio recorded version of this song available on mp3 ... if so ... where can i find it?
muzicnub4life 1 year ago
@muzicnub4life
No studio version really exists right now, unless the band's recording it for "Teargarden by Kaleidyscope". This is probably the best version of it that exists.
PantheonLincoln 1 year ago
what key harmonica does he use?
Deathhawkgnar 1 year ago
this might be my favorite "SP2" song. Just great!
infinitesadnessbaby 1 year ago 2
@infinitesadnessbaby what year did it become Smashing Pumpkins 2? When Iha and D'arcy left? and if so what was the 1st album or EP Billy came out with without them it it? and btw i love this song also... so beautiful
muzicnub4life 1 year ago
@infinitesadnessbaby what year did it become Smashing Pumpkins 2? When Iha and D'arcy left? and if so what was the 1st album or EP Billy came out with without them not in it? and btw i love this song also... so beautiful
muzicnub4life 1 year ago
@muzicnub4life It became SP v2 in 2007 when Billy and Jimmy got back together without D'arcy and James and the first album they did as SP v2 was Zeitgeist. Sounds nothing like this though, Zeitgeist is pretty heavy a lot of the time..
urface102 1 year ago
@infinitesadnessbaby So now theres an SP 3...Its like fuckin "Play Station"
Yangmutt86 1 year ago
-> I dedicate this beautiful song to Filam Rodriguez...... Smashing Pumpkins 'til reincarnation!!!!!!!!!!
dignazzz 1 year ago
awesome song but darn it way too long....
pissant75 1 year ago
It's not long enough..
Reno9824 1 year ago
the music sounds great, but anyone notice how shitty billies lyrics are getting?? i think that guy really has nothing more to write nothing more to say and it shows up in his lyrics... either that or he feels accomplished and therefore lacks the interest to develop great lyrics.
kennykensworth 1 year ago
@kennykensworth I love these lyrics. 99 Floors is a masterpiece.
Porcelina777 1 year ago
@kennykensworth i like that song you wrote too. "take your dick out of my ass and put it in my mouth"..yeah that was a good one
meesterperfect 1 year ago 5
Is anybody here can tell me , what is the Taylor he play with ?
GA model ?
MAD1981full 2 years ago
It's a GS8 Taylor Model !
MAD1981full 2 years ago
HA you can see Lisa's g-sting at 7:31
KidMyxomatosis 2 years ago 3
@KidMyxomatosis
lol u got a good eye
immeohmyoh 2 years ago
I LOVE Billy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
aprilis6underground 2 years ago 3
20anosdepois Of course i've heard james solo works dude and(perfect circle) Sorry I've heard his solo stuff not be a hater of what he does,it adds up to?Lets see NOTHING really.I don't have problem with melissa's solo works...good stuff.Fan's really need stop living in the pass really.Billy's making music get over it and SP is his.I do really miss jimmy tho...but like the old saying goes, stop living in pass and "ALL THINGS CHANGE".
WhiteLotusFlower 2 years ago
@WhiteLotusFlower well, I have to agree that the last concept that billy adopt is very interesting.
about james, is a diferent way is choose to follow. I cheer him. just hope that billy can mantaine the good work pos tarantula (that was really a side shot).
cumps
20anosdepois 2 years ago
Give me a break Billy has the right to the SP name.Many famous bands still tour with less then the original members ...BIlly is SP and always will be.Let D'arcy and James try to do SP without Billy haha never pull it off.Look at the crap band james was in and funny nothing really from him to make anything.Billy made both of them period.Billy can pull it off without them.Billy has always been the heart of the band.I love that Billy's moved from the pass and dropped the dead weight so to speak..
WhiteLotusFlower 2 years ago 5
just one question,do you know james solo work, or his participations in other band (liek a perfect circle)? and melissa, his solo album? james is a diferente musician, but a great one to. it misses something in SP.
PS: if you were talking about the tinted windows, i agree thats not a band for james.
cumps
20anosdepois 2 years ago
Awesome!!! Thank you for posting..; )
squibblejack 2 years ago
I still love billy, lattely has been making some pretty cool versions and even some new song, that even diferent from the Great SP are very nice....
20anosdepois 2 years ago 3
Loving this....
mattmojo1 2 years ago 2
@5:25 you can see her thong! ahaha
Misfit105 2 years ago
amazing song.. still hope that it'll be in the new album.. its hardly, but possible. I think... All those new tracks, which are not recorded should be included on 'Teargarden by Kaleidyscope'.
lemonscure 2 years ago
It makes me sad that Jimmy is no longer with the pumpkins.
streetkarpftw 2 years ago
i respect his wishes because of how long hes been loyal although i think iha and darcy are more up themselves than billy. James WAS cool but wrote practically nothing but intros. If these so called stars had ANY real respect for the fans they would do what most other bands have always done, GIVE THEM WHAT THEY WANT and SEE if they want anything new you have to offer, but whats the point in STILL calling the band "SP" when almost everything associated with them is gone and couldn't care less?
TheLydianRocks 2 years ago
I agree, it should be "The corgan Project", honestly I think BIlly its destroing the SP image that I and so many more like me love for years... By the other side I love the work at solo of james, and even melissa has some good songs... just cant find nothing from d'arcy.
cump
20anosdepois 2 years ago
I didn't like Zeitgeist much but songs like this are a great addition to the Pumpkins legacy imo. He had any number of names to call the band he puts out these new songs under, but obviously he feels that they're "Pumpkin" material, or hed have called them "Zwan" or "Billy Corgan" songs.
rohiogerv22 2 years ago
got sick of looking
at the comment below for 3 weeks.
great song though.
meesterperfect 2 years ago 2
This song reminds me of my best friend. We're going through some tough times.
Billy Corgan never fails to make me feel like I have someone to relate to. His music is always there to catch me when I need it to.
kjenks174 2 years ago 5
i have never heard this before...what a beautiful song
turnnineteen69 2 years ago 4
just beautiful... no more word needed.
supermagnetron5000 2 years ago 5
that part he sings at 6:26 ....wow, im having faith in billy's music with this song
metalbeast7 2 years ago
the more you listen to it the better it gets.
and that's how you know it's both a good song and a good performance
ChooseRed 2 years ago 4
Ginger reyes's part on the bass is great, reminds me of Why Go by Pearl Jam
Gamagachee 2 years ago
Does somebody know the key of the harmonica in this song ?
Thx.
OrangeSpaceboy 2 years ago
G Major He says it on the DVD making the phone call
imacrazydude9999999 2 years ago
human beings, sometimes they're like trees, simple, complex, beautiful, innocent. billy gives music as they give oxygen, it's like an obvious miracle
spicchio 2 years ago 42
he's the Messiah
hambones444 2 years ago 4
@spicchio AMEN TO THAT!
mabuhayguy 1 year ago
has a zeppelin/floyd sound kinda
mymorningvodka 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
no faggot learn english
drunkfuck8 2 years ago
ae r t qergq ergw th ery wgwe rgry wth wtrh whwtrtyh wty ty wty tr htwy wtyw t wy wt eywty ewyqerywywt uyy wtuy wrtuy wrty wrty wtyw ywty wty wty wtyrt ywyt wty wryw rty wrtywrty wrtyh wrtuy wrty ert uywrtywrtywrtywtry wrty rwty wty wrty rt ywr ywty wrtywty wrtywrtywy wrty wrty wrtywrty wrty wrty wrty wrty wrty wrty wrty wrty wrty wty wrty wrty wrty wrty wtyrt ywyt wty wryw rty wrtywrty wrtyh wrtuy wrty ert uywrtywrtywrtywtry wrty rwty wty wrty rt ywr ywty wrtywty wrtywrtywy wrty wrty wrtywrty m
mymorningvodka 2 years ago
mm, is that a thong i see?
smapumpkin13 2 years ago
the keyboardist gives me a boner.
back2thefutre 2 years ago
A+
gfhs
back2thefutre 2 years ago
8 minutes and 17 seconds of video and not ONCE did they shows the bassists face
soapalot 2 years ago
Wow, you're blind. Watch it over. They show Ginger's face a few times.
GRSuperChris 2 years ago
4:52
christurkthebrave 2 years ago
this song is so marvellous...
fieldpool 2 years ago
Perfect example of how Pumpkins' sound can change, and still be Pumpkins, and still be awesome.
rohiogerv22 2 years ago 2
you are so right! you stole the words from my mind!i was just thiking that !thats why i love this band so much !
thepumpkins101 2 years ago
This song really takes off when the rest of the band joins in. I wish they joined in a lot sooner.
kellysp77 2 years ago
part of what makes billy a great songwriter is his ability to be patient and slowly build to an awesome crescendo
seaninboise 2 years ago 2
I don't disagree with you at all. Corgan is, and has always been, a great songwriter.
But the first four minutes of this song is WAY too overindulgent, and it's my feeling that he has no clue how to reel himself in anymore.
At one point, he had people around him who could set him straight. Slowly, yet surely, all of those people have parted ways with him.
It's a shame that he can't coexist with anybody because he needs people (like Jimmy) to bring out the best in him.
kellysp77 2 years ago
Explain how its over-indulgent? It's a great build up to a great song. Just because he solos it in the beginning? You mean like starla? He's starting you off on a ride... why not just enjoy the trip? ;) A great song doesn't need to be dissected, just enjoyed.
seaninboise 2 years ago 6
Jimmy will return. I already know. Billy just needs to focus on music and stop selling the songs for commercials. I mean 2 already this year.
GRSuperChris 2 years ago
I have to ask again, did he even sell Today? I thought Virgin still had the distribution rights.
rohiogerv22 2 years ago
This song is AMAZING! totally agree with porcelina777.!!
erikageijerstam 3 years ago
People who say Billy can't write anymore haven't heard this song.
Porcelina777 3 years ago 9
How eazy must it be to be mr billy corgan?
I mean when you have GOD playing the drums for you.
Koindrank 3 years ago 28
not God, ....JC
Outsiderlady 3 years ago
@Koindrank 2 right
drevpile 1 year ago
wonderful
fieldpool 3 years ago
long live the pumpkins!
fuzzyroes 3 years ago 6
i used to know you
i used to care
i used to know you
are you still there?
mywillyisfood 3 years ago
This is the best thing they've done since they've been back (the DVD and the song)!
rickyrockard 3 years ago 6