When I first heard this song after buying the album (I was fricken THRILLED) I was like "Hmmm, they may have been touring with Opeth a little too long..." The break in the middle of the song is gorgeous, and my favorite part of the entire album. Overall, though, I can see they're trying to be heavy too much, and it's affecting SOME of their progressive edge from IaW, SFaM, Octavarium, and SDOIT.
this album is not their best.. i really dont like it.. Count of Tuscany is really the only "wow" song for me.. and this is coming from a fan since 97.. I have all of their albums.. these last 2 albums for me have been a disappointment for the most part. they went from having melody with technical instrumentals in the song to pure heavy metal. Don't get me wrong. I love heavy metal. It's beyond me how this song charted at what 6? on the billboard, when Awake charted at 32?..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
-continued- only BCSL songs i like is Wither, Shattered Fortress, and Count.. But like i said count is really the only one that stands out for me. If they wanna do heavy metal, do something along the lines of Train of Thought (although after a few listens it kinda got old). I love DT, I respect them, saw them 14th row at Radio City at their 25th anniversary, but I'm really disappointed in their direction. =( here come the negative comments
It's not pure metal... it's still progressive, just listen to this song, it's heavy, but it still has very progressive elements. I'll agree with you with that it's not their best work, but it's not a disappointment, at least not to me. It's a wonderful work of art that is better than most other metal at the time. But you really have to remember that Dream Theater IS classified as Progressive Metal
@MikeTheDark001 no no i know its prog.. what im sayin is that its just their direction they went its like theyre trying new things to attract a bigger audience (kinda what they did with Falling Into Infinity) which i respect thats great.. but i just dont like the sound of the album..
O I see... well, there is a very Floyd esk break in A Nightmare to Remember and the solo after that has a bluesy feel to it. The Best of Times reminds me of hollow years a lot. And Count of tuscany is just wow. I can't really say they dived THAT far into metal sound/tone but it is a bit more metal that usual heh. It IS your opinion after all, and I have no right to try and change it, it's not like I am anyway, eh nvm, I just get your point.
I agree with you for the most part. I have been a fan since 95 when ACOS was released. I think a lot of it has to do with them signing with Roadrunner since about 95% of the bands with the label are heavy metal. I do think this album is better than the last one, but it still not my favorite by any means. Having said that I think JP's solo on the best of times is one of his most melodic to date.
the fact that you dont like the 2 last albums or the fact that your a fan since the begining of the earth doesn't mean that those albums are a disappoinment!!. Dream theater is a band that adapts and modernized their sound and none of their albums is like the previous one, they always come up with something new and fresh!!. i personally love the 2 last albums, except for one song of systematic chaos. I love all of their albums for diferent reasons especially since Jordan Rudess joined the band
yeah but they were a disappointment for me. I just don't like the BCaSL and SC. To me, nothing will be Awake, Scenes, and Six Degrees. I think BCaSL sounds like they were trying to go heavier than Train of Thought. Train of Thought was perfect when it came to being heavy. The entire album was heavy. But not to the point where it got repetitive (black clouds kinda got repetitive) BCaSL just didn't phase me. and Systematic Chaos i just can't listen to except for Part 1 of Enemies.. thats just me
@Rocka901 actually you did.. cuz it takes talent to, as you said make a 15 minute song and make it sound good.. does it not? hence your talking talent.. dumbass.. amazing when we use our heads.
I met labrie at the airport for the systematic chaos tour, he sat 2 seats away from me and we literally had a 45 min convo, such a legend and portnoy was just walking around looking for kfc lol
This song has me absolutely obsessed. Listening to it over and over again. Starts out spooky.. then gets scary.. then gets headbanging.. then gets mysterious.. then gets beautiful and very emotional. What a marvellous piece!!
i second that. he probably feels peer pressured by the other rockstars and thinks he's not quite fitting in. Also, most of time his "fuck"s are out of place so, doesn't add much to what he's saying, which defeats the purpose having a word like that in english language.
it's not the best song for performance, because it should have this dark atmosphere...but to hear it at home in a dark room, it's the best DT Song ever!!!
Fuck! James is so awesome here! I have to say unlike most of the people i was a bit disapointed of his performances this tour because he suddenly doesn't use vibrato any more. But here he sounds really cool!
Actually I think that he doesn't use vibrato that often anymore was one of the best things he could do..not that he sounded bad with it but you heard yourself that he sounds waaaaay better now without it! This tour will be brilliant!
Can watch the whole cause the audio. Greeting for your camera.
diezthegreat 1 year ago
wtf I expected them too be more.. LIVE? When they played, not a good stage performance.. :(
Rasmusmeda 1 year ago
omg i love this song this is there best album to me!
drummerboywunder 1 year ago
When I first heard this song after buying the album (I was fricken THRILLED) I was like "Hmmm, they may have been touring with Opeth a little too long..." The break in the middle of the song is gorgeous, and my favorite part of the entire album. Overall, though, I can see they're trying to be heavy too much, and it's affecting SOME of their progressive edge from IaW, SFaM, Octavarium, and SDOIT.
RaidonSama 2 years ago
U're wrong......
Even we being fans of DT, we can't say that's the worst or not album...
Change the stike or giving a new air for it its commom nowadays...
INdependent of the new songs, all of them has Dt's heart on it, and all of them are great....
these changes were natural to the band...they'd never made it once...
We hava just to enjoy....'
lawug09 2 years ago 4
this album is not their best.. i really dont like it.. Count of Tuscany is really the only "wow" song for me.. and this is coming from a fan since 97.. I have all of their albums.. these last 2 albums for me have been a disappointment for the most part. they went from having melody with technical instrumentals in the song to pure heavy metal. Don't get me wrong. I love heavy metal. It's beyond me how this song charted at what 6? on the billboard, when Awake charted at 32?..
stabileownzwow 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
-continued- only BCSL songs i like is Wither, Shattered Fortress, and Count.. But like i said count is really the only one that stands out for me. If they wanna do heavy metal, do something along the lines of Train of Thought (although after a few listens it kinda got old). I love DT, I respect them, saw them 14th row at Radio City at their 25th anniversary, but I'm really disappointed in their direction. =( here come the negative comments
stabileownzwow 2 years ago
oh and edit.. not the song that charted at 6.. the album my bad
stabileownzwow 2 years ago
It's not pure metal... it's still progressive, just listen to this song, it's heavy, but it still has very progressive elements. I'll agree with you with that it's not their best work, but it's not a disappointment, at least not to me. It's a wonderful work of art that is better than most other metal at the time. But you really have to remember that Dream Theater IS classified as Progressive Metal
MikeTheDark001 2 years ago 2
@MikeTheDark001 no no i know its prog.. what im sayin is that its just their direction they went its like theyre trying new things to attract a bigger audience (kinda what they did with Falling Into Infinity) which i respect thats great.. but i just dont like the sound of the album..
stabileownzwow 2 years ago
O I see... well, there is a very Floyd esk break in A Nightmare to Remember and the solo after that has a bluesy feel to it. The Best of Times reminds me of hollow years a lot. And Count of tuscany is just wow. I can't really say they dived THAT far into metal sound/tone but it is a bit more metal that usual heh. It IS your opinion after all, and I have no right to try and change it, it's not like I am anyway, eh nvm, I just get your point.
MikeTheDark001 2 years ago
@stabileownzwow
I agree with you for the most part. I have been a fan since 95 when ACOS was released. I think a lot of it has to do with them signing with Roadrunner since about 95% of the bands with the label are heavy metal. I do think this album is better than the last one, but it still not my favorite by any means. Having said that I think JP's solo on the best of times is one of his most melodic to date.
brosph 2 years ago
the fact that you dont like the 2 last albums or the fact that your a fan since the begining of the earth doesn't mean that those albums are a disappoinment!!. Dream theater is a band that adapts and modernized their sound and none of their albums is like the previous one, they always come up with something new and fresh!!. i personally love the 2 last albums, except for one song of systematic chaos. I love all of their albums for diferent reasons especially since Jordan Rudess joined the band
jfilizzola 2 years ago
yeah but they were a disappointment for me. I just don't like the BCaSL and SC. To me, nothing will be Awake, Scenes, and Six Degrees. I think BCaSL sounds like they were trying to go heavier than Train of Thought. Train of Thought was perfect when it came to being heavy. The entire album was heavy. But not to the point where it got repetitive (black clouds kinda got repetitive) BCaSL just didn't phase me. and Systematic Chaos i just can't listen to except for Part 1 of Enemies.. thats just me
stabileownzwow 2 years ago
@stabileownzwow omg shut up u have any idea how hard it is to write a 15 minute song and make it sound how good they make it sound?
Rocka901 1 year ago
did i ever say anything about their talent? learn to read i said they changed.. omg shut up do you have any idea how to read?
stabileownzwow 1 year ago
@stabileownzwow did I ever say anything about talent? No
Rocka901 1 year ago
@Rocka901 actually you did.. cuz it takes talent to, as you said make a 15 minute song and make it sound good.. does it not? hence your talking talent.. dumbass.. amazing when we use our heads.
stabileownzwow 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@stabileownzwow
''omg shut up u have any idea how hard it is to write a 15 minute song and make it sound how good they make it sound?''
:O pleeeeease highlight the word talent^^
Rocka901 1 year ago
people say they dont really like their new album. and i agree its kinda repetative of their style, but god this song KICKS ASS
FollowTheReaper93 2 years ago 3
I envy you DUCKPOOO.....I envy you
dillonnoilld 2 years ago
I met labrie at the airport for the systematic chaos tour, he sat 2 seats away from me and we literally had a 45 min convo, such a legend and portnoy was just walking around looking for kfc lol
DUCKPOOO 2 years ago 4
100% Dream Theater
DreadlockDrummer 2 years ago 3
this song is PURE EVIL!!!!
Rekepanda 2 years ago 2
When I heard at first time their new album this song just leave me stunned and crushed! Simply one of the mighty DT songs ever!
davidamarat 2 years ago
This song has me absolutely obsessed. Listening to it over and over again. Starts out spooky.. then gets scary.. then gets headbanging.. then gets mysterious.. then gets beautiful and very emotional. What a marvellous piece!!
dvsdez 2 years ago 3
I don't really know how it's possible but since black clouds la brie's been singing like god !
oxygen63 2 years ago 6
I agree dude!!
BaptisteClamence 2 years ago
Vocal training, and as time goes by he gets back to his voice pre-rupture...I personally believe he's better than '94 now.
RockRulez124 2 years ago
whats with the panning?
or is that just my speakers
mushroomzagain 2 years ago 5
i fot the speakers on my laptop wer broken for a minute there
NPFairyy 2 years ago 2
good quality....
mirkoroger 2 years ago
Yes... it sounds slower(portnoy) than the album.
First time I heard it I think about a black metal band....sounds strange but fine
bananamaoko 2 years ago
first time i heard it i coulda sworn i got punked. I thought it was Dimmu Borgir.
BloodReverence 2 years ago 4
lol,me too!!!!
metropolis02 2 years ago
agreed :p
same happened with me
pecwhist 2 years ago
Dam this band makes long songs.
Funeraljr 2 years ago
40+ min = long song (SDOIT, 12 step suite)
20-30 min = epic song (oct, itpoe, acos)
10-15 min = good song length
7-8 min = short but sweet song
5-6 min = wait...it's over??
under 4 min = blip of static
clawfootdrew1515 2 years ago 4
hahaha yup, that's pretty much it.
RDog4484 2 years ago
Did James just introduce the song as A Night To Remember??? LOL
sixxx85 2 years ago
Hmmm.. No
Xantt666 2 years ago
Nope, he said a nightmare to remember, for sure.
Kaoskadosk 2 years ago
haha lol fail James :DDDD
tumbee111 2 years ago
wow good audio quality!
andrewv42 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Huh, as far as I can tell, Portnoy didn't play the intro as fast as on the album.
dudleythemoose 2 years ago
You should've merged it into mono. That right channel cutout ruins the song :P
sniperGasMask 2 years ago 3
Yes , but in my original recording I do not have this kind of problem , it has apeared when I uploaded it. It is strange , but true.
ADprogrAM 2 years ago
this thing also happens to some of the videos that i upload
leugimigop 2 years ago
Díky for posting this! I can't wait 'till September, when I will see them in Berlin. It will be my 3rd DT concert and I can't have enough.
Hprog 2 years ago
awesome
glacier2win 2 years ago
1:16
Jordan Rudess Action Figure!
kingofloss86 2 years ago
1:13
I DIED x__x !!!
enkyler 2 years ago
the audio is shifting from left to right!
Dream Theater's powers are possessing my CPU!!
UnforgivingCritic 2 years ago 17
lol
b4mva7x 1 year ago
what does the pic at bass drum mean?
gnanti 2 years ago
hopelessly drifting bathing in beautiful agony
racer3001 2 years ago 14
Best part of the song
ReXIX2 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Best part :D
sniperGasMask 2 years ago
Can't wait to see them in Las Vegas on 8/28.
Stryk8r 2 years ago
Petrucci fucking rocks monsterous brutal badass @ this album
RevellAndRepend 2 years ago 2
2:00- 2:13 best part
kornrocks123456789 2 years ago
This sound fucking awesome.
Dream Theater better come to Melbourne, Australia soon!
Dreamang3L 2 years ago
This is my favourite song in that album!!
vera881 2 years ago 4
the way this audio worked makes me wana suicide x.X
iluvsystemofadown 2 years ago
There was so much awsomeness that it caused the audio to mess up. XD
ktoddk99 2 years ago 7
MMMMANNNN ! i cant FUCKING wait me too, the 12th august in montreal gonna kick some ass!!!!!
damenard123 2 years ago
Great video, except the right audio channel cuts out randomly all the time.
blakehess11 2 years ago 2
Sweet - I thought it was my computer!
sswio 2 years ago 3
ahha what?? the audio??
mayorde18 2 years ago
Lol ségřina ruka :D
rehtak 2 years ago
It feels like we're going to get a good, beautiful DVD in anything related to this guy behind the microphone...;)
RockRulez124 2 years ago
james sounds sooo much better
chickenandpasta 2 years ago 6
IN PEACEFUL SEDATION I LAY HALF AWAKE
RevStudios 2 years ago 4
Best part of this amazing song!!
TmacMerida 2 years ago
I cannot FUCKING wait.
gnargnargnar 2 years ago
james labrie is fucking back and is sounding incredible!!!
caressxofxsteel 2 years ago 9
You are abso-freakin-lootly RIGHT!!!! YEAH!!!!!
guitardork1 2 years ago
they need to rock out more on stage. even though theyre all like 45. i think jordans 50 sumit. but they still kick fucking ass
fluentinsound 2 years ago
its music people chill the fuck out fuck reli ant that bad
stone044 2 years ago
YEAAAAH
YEAAAAH
YEAAAAHHHOOO
ImNorthPole 2 years ago 2
He said fuck once...everybody calm the fuck down.
shredhead117 2 years ago 5
lol, yeah rly
PimpMasterT 2 years ago
I'm sick of James Labrie saying fuck.
cavemancraig 2 years ago
i second that. he probably feels peer pressured by the other rockstars and thinks he's not quite fitting in. Also, most of time his "fuck"s are out of place so, doesn't add much to what he's saying, which defeats the purpose having a word like that in english language.
deusAXEmachina 2 years ago 5
well at least he's not using it every 2nd/3rd word like some ppl :P
PimpMasterT 2 years ago
James, my friend is not some people. He's a role model for thousands and thousands and thousands
deusAXEmachina 2 years ago
i know...lol, i said hes NOT like some ppl
PimpMasterT 2 years ago
james sounds amazing here....fuckin amazing song....\m/
thecountoftuscany198 2 years ago
labrie is definitely better here than in most of chaos in motion. there's yet hope for him.
trongs01 2 years ago
FUCKING ORGASMIC! the slow part is likely the most beautiful dream theater shit i've ever heard!
LedZeppelin2143 2 years ago
The sound dissapear from Right Channel everytime.. So for all?
DonPetrushka 2 years ago 15
yeah it's happening to me. it's so annoying!
MetalMassacre45 2 years ago
yeah
pretty annoying
PhilCollins93 2 years ago
Thought it was just me..
demite 2 years ago
@DonPetrushka omg..., it's his fucking cellphone thats he is recording with, wtf is up with u guys.....think a little
zeechceez 1 year ago
wich was the setlist?
JumpMoFu 2 years ago
it's not the best song for performance, because it should have this dark atmosphere...but to hear it at home in a dark room, it's the best DT Song ever!!!
anyway awesome performance!
hammondplayer91 2 years ago 4
Awesome quality
But I couldn´t hear Rudess :(
AliothSenator 2 years ago 2
1:36 what a headbanger! xp awesom song
hking007 2 years ago
Fuck! James is so awesome here! I have to say unlike most of the people i was a bit disapointed of his performances this tour because he suddenly doesn't use vibrato any more. But here he sounds really cool!
Ironglovetube 2 years ago 7
Actually I think that he doesn't use vibrato that often anymore was one of the best things he could do..not that he sounded bad with it but you heard yourself that he sounds waaaaay better now without it! This tour will be brilliant!
lafree 2 years ago 3
DT is back with Black Clouds and Silver Linings. Just Awesome !
SpeechOfreedom 2 years ago 5
This is pure madness! Thank you so much for uploading it! one of my fav songs ...
lafree 2 years ago 3