不能說的秘密 - Secret (piano) 即場點歌考驗

[cleanmindedxd]

does responding in English makes your argument stronger? nice try, but no, if you wanna argue about the literal meaning, 即興 is directly translated impromptu, which means " a short musical passage that seems to have been made spontaneously WITHOUT advance preparation", it does not mean 'play by ear without sheets". Playing by ear without sheet ISSSSS called play by ear, not

impromptu/即興.

[kalton]

流行曲同古典跟本唔可以比吧..

流行曲基本上版本會很多, 除非官方出一個真實的版本吧..

而古典就會單一點...一彈錯就好清楚...

流行曲即興是很易吧...聽幾次大概都記得7-8成, 要彈番出黎一d都唔難..

覺得難既人只是沒有向和弦這個方向鑽研吧..

就算古典曲彈得幾勁都好, 都係點彈到吧...

所謂讀死書, 唔變通就會覺得難吧..

[cygnus0915]

這首一定是練過的好不好

不然也來即興幾首古典曲好了

硬要扯是即興 拜託...

[hkppa]

即興 means 'play by ear without sheets'.

You still need to practice.

When your aural skills gets better and better, you spend less and less time to learn a song and you'll remember it for years.

[sebastiantpb]

@hkppa 唔通學你幾堂就有perfect pitch.....一首secret代表5到咩,佢只不過音感­較強,認得melody,加上少少樂理知識......咁強咪即­興Beethoven moonlight sonata mvt 3囉......時間耐就分得傳統同即興分別...重有8級都5­識數拍子-,-"?

[963003060]

在我認為 即興就是把自己練過的東西 事前沒有set好，拿出來表演

即興 現在的人大部分都認為是隨意彈奏好聽的音符

所以，本人認為原本練好的東西(樂曲) 也可以拿來加在即興裡吧?~

就算與原曲一個音符也不漏的彈奏 也算是即興

[billych01]

開頭個段聽得出系採納左巴羅克時期既歌,　方格上唔應該踩腳掣, 因為個時無, 所以彈既時候應該有每一粒音都分明既感覺先叫彈得好

[Edmondemon]

@billych01 not really, because in the Baroque period there wasn't the invention of fortepiano or pianoforte, they use harpsichord. Sound produced on the harpsichord sustains more than that produced on the piano. So, playing Baroque music on piano indeed requires the use of pedal sometimes. But of course, it always depends on how u step on the pedal.

[PNE215]

can u plz explain how does 即興彈奏法 works? =]

is it like u listen to a song and u can play it right back out?

[hkppa]

For starters, you need to listen many times and you still need to practice.

When your aural skills gets better and better, you spend less and less time to learn a song and you'll remember it for years.

[rhecoy2007]

a nice play...u

[EdwardLaiPY]

紧张..........

[linke219]

有值得学习的地方就好，为什么总有人挑剔呢。。。

我觉得即兴演奏并不等于一次没弹过才叫即兴，每次弹时根据心情不­同，伴奏略有不同，也算即兴吧？

[hkppa]

至於背彈，如果你懂得運用和弦，就算不是刻意背譜，彈出來的效果­也跟原曲沒兩樣，因為原曲的伴奏部分是由和弦組成的。 換句話說，即興彈奏者是無需刻意背譜的。 試想想，用死記硬背的方法，可以背到多少首歌?

[hkppa]

謝謝你的讚賞！

坊間流行的琴譜，並非由原作者發佈的，而是由一些聽力佳的業餘人­仕製作的。 換句話說，如果你的聽力佳，你也可以做得到。 你可以從較簡單的歌曲開始試試...

[yatyufun]

說真的...我相信其他流行曲真的是即興的...但這首真的是他­即興的嗎?? 這個我有點懷疑....

除非他的聽力音準真的很好..又或者是他之前彈過的....

[hkppa]

即興彈奏 means playing by ear.

The key difference is: you don't need sheets.

Sometimes you want be creative.

Sometimes you try to match the original song as good as possible.

You'll enjoy the experience of both.

[hkppa]

即興 means 'play by ear without sheets'.

You still need to practice.

When your aural skills gets better and better, you spend less and less time to learn a song and you'll remember it for years.

[tangconst]

這是即興彈奏嗎?

可是為何演奏者彈奏的secret跟坊間流行的secret琴譜­幾乎一模一樣? 或許只有結束部份略帶幾個scale和轉音, 但就跟背彈沒兩樣吧.

[hkppa]

即興 means 'play by ear without sheets'.

He is trying to give the 'real thing' without sheets.

For other songs, he may want to be creative.

You'll enjoy both if you do 即興.