超級星光大道-盧學叡唱愛很簡單(電視版)

[jacky8114]

我不想嘴砲 我直接講 下面謀位 你勒 淦恁娘工啥小 妳爸淦你媽的機掰就很安靜?除非你老爸太小支 或妳媽機掰太大 沒感覺

[rs198812]

人都是會進步的 這是幾年前的影片 ?

想想好嗎?

[ss11311086]

他的聲音太吵了，不適合唱這首歌

[amankuo1]

雖說~小美的R&B的技巧不是很純熟..轉音也不很順暢..音質­音色也只算ok...而且應該不能唱太高的音調!

不過~以一個十八歲素人能唱這樣.....已經很不錯了!

但要說~~唱的比陶喆好?

ㄟ~~??或許真是Demo吧?

不過~ R&B唱法有很多半音滑音...練唱調整時..本來就很容易走音­!!

要看是什麼Demo

[ASDA6207]

盧學叡唱的比陶吉吉好聽! 

[iamacolahaha]

怎可能會比原唱好呢

原唱功力太強了

[treyv12345]

盧學叡 好棒^_^

[orange0925]

@nick32535 我听过陶喆原版Demo。。 真的是走音连连。。 所以他可能是在说这个吧。

[Wei01chen]

他唱整首歌就很輕鬆 游刃有餘的感覺

這絕對是他唱最好的一次

陶喆的版本太經典了 要超越真得很難

[Apple820910]

沒有一定的對與錯，只要好聽就是一位好歌手

有沒有比陶喆好聽那就是看個人的喜好程度，我覺得不要過度批評

只要enjoy就可以了!

[penril800326]

技巧陶喆比較好

[wuyb]

假音确实太轻了。。。

[song333poz]

不必比較，只要覺得好聽，能感受到那份感動便可以了！

[Goldtwo2]

這些評委太不像話了，時不時說比原唱好甚麼的，是為了加強氣氛嗎­

[keioiexex13]

認真聽下陶喆唱歌先la各位

假音 流暢度 比陶喆好

一睇就笑左la我

[hk8019]

我個人覺得比陶喆唱得好=]

可惜紅唔起..

[turtle791218]

真的要比的話比陶喆好多了＝　＝

不管假音　流暢度

都比陶喆來的要好

陶喆新專輯部也是賣得不好？

[Darko119]

科科............

你開心就好!

[Lemonnade]

不要再跟陶喆比吧

各人有各人的優點 :)

[mikeshinoda555]

他唱英文歌應該會幾好...

[Cantoner]

假音唱得太輕了吧...其他都很好

[22460171]

不管誰唱的好

總之

小美唱的就是很好聽辣

如果我是女生

我一定愛死他

[22460171]

專輯

並不能代表什麼

歌聲才是一切

[xcheeb]

歌声不是一切，歌声加技巧才是一切。

[babesiuching]

假音唱得好好!!

[kenny09654]

同陶喆比差多了

[amypeggy]

i think his voice is nice~ better than tao zhe, i'm tao zhe's fans too, but honestly he sang better tahn tao zhe.

[abcdefg1996219]

笑話

他唱得比陶喆好？？！！！

別笑死人了！！！

[bensonclone]

So enjoy

[nga0508]

很好聽.. 很浪漫的聲音

唱得比原唱更有feel

只是 I LOVE YOU 那句不夠誠懇

如果這一句再給多一點感情

那就是完美的演繹了 :)

[JICE0711]

嗯嗯 認同:)

[lobo0624]

認同~認同~

[ccue789]

真的十分好聽!!!

他的假音好好呀!!!

[bigdawgjd]

唱得不错

但是我绝对会听陶吉吉版的

[16NotEven]

Niiice. hehe.

Whats the song title and artist's name?

[chenxibei]

歌唱实力没话说，而且长得也很帅，可塑性强！！！小美最棒！！！­永远支持你！！！

[xboredBITCH]

[: NICEEEE

[chunichiryu]

陶喆比較好聽我覺得...

[r3lson]

那么多地方陶吉吉用真音他用假音

陶吉吉唱比较好

他对自己真音变假音没用信心

只好假音开始换真音

陶吉吉是真音换假音再换真音

比较有好听

[randbmoonwalk]

原住民 那些歌都是一直轉音-_-難怪他唱陶吉吉的歌那麼適合-_-

[cinderellie]

VERY WELL PERFORMED!

[noraacmw]

I think everything is good. But his head voice is too weak especially when he sings "I Love You".

[czllo]

the orginal one is better!!!!

[chenxibei]

他真的唱得很好，十八岁就有那么扎实的唱功，真的是难得。但有没­有唱得比陶喆好我就不知道，应该是各有各的好吧，不需要做比较。­

[LJliang]

a better rendition den david tao... onli he cant sing higher pitch den david tao..

[Hardbeez]

Do you know the song well in details and singing technique?

Are you qualifed for your statement. You sure commented so confidently & easily.

[jontyan]

The judges are like seeing a pile of giant shit infront of them...

hello?? let it go and enjoy the show!

btw, great singer!

rock on!

[terry119]

只能說唱得很好,若是說唱的比陶吉吉好...那就太over了

[nick32535]

@terry119

真的說的很對

張宇 竟然說唱的比陶喆好

我看陶喆比妳紅 唱歌比你好聽 作曲就不用說了!!!

音樂R&B教父 豈容你這樣亂說 來讓參賽者高興

真是聽到你這樣的話會吐血....

真假音轉換 對高低度細膩度的處理 差陶喆很多好麻!!!

[orange0925]

@terry119 因为他们听过陶喆的original demo。。

[muhammadaff]

abit flat lol

[c73807]

i luv u ~

u sing gud and ur hot

[hinyeah]

評審：唱的比陶吉吉還要好!!

不要耍我吧~

[Dynauiew]

還是覺得原唱的整體感覺比他好多了

[startingsprinter]

他是真的會唱歌

[mexonly]

I LOVE HIM!

i wish that he would come to hk and perform.

he should have won... but i'm glad he's the only one who got a sony contract (International) whereas all the other runnerups got some local deal... (which is still gd) but shows that he DOES stand out. whereas the winner.... doesn't even have a cd yet =.=

[LJliang]

i tink he and yang zong wei shld be in the final 2...the rest sux!!

[emiltsuimunsang]

的確真假音方面唱得比較差,

但真的唱得很好

[ginolai]

唱出了我的心聲.我喜歡這種感覺.你比陶吉吉唱得要好!

[apple970407]

讚啦

[apple970407]

讚到爆  超愛盧學叡的 !!!!!

請大家一定要去支持他的專輯喔!!!!

小美萬歲小美萬歲小美萬歲小美萬歲小美萬歲小美萬歲!!!!

[Beanbeanfive]

Good but not great - not impressed. The falsetto is pitchy and he does not have as captivating a voice as David Tao or Bibi Zhou.

[kimsuho]

真假音轉換明顯不及陶喆

唱假音氣不足,薄弱了一點

但以這樣的年紀來說真的很不錯

[chan808yuen]

比陶喆好.........

我相信陶喆十八歲時沒有他好

[Hardbeez]

You are praising the person who borrowed the song from another whom you criticise which

either your statment mskes no sense or you are an idiot in nature.

[spiritualtemple]

I watched this video again. The A Mei Old Tunes atill brought tears to me. It connects to you in s direct and intense way that Chinese music seldom does. I totally agree with the judges. The judge nicknamed "Little Bug" was absolutely right. When Lu sang A Mei Old Tunes, it was special, even at the level of world music scene.

[spiritualtemple]

When this kid sings A Mei Ancient Chant, it went through my spine...

Wholesome yet sexy. I wish he would focus on A Mei Ancient Chant, whose natural dynamicsm is a much better fit with R&B than the mostly half-sleeping, energyless Chinese songs are.

[GordonLabel]

他這次唱得很好, 感情很投入, 還能感染到觀眾~

我覺得...周筆暢, 還不及他這次唱得好....~

Good Work !!!

[verybigbeauty]

too commercial...i prefer david's. david possesses a magnetic voice which fits this song so well and he knows where to stress.

[startingsprinter]

我覺得詮釋的比陶喆好

[kurama627]

小美 is da best! ^.^

[daer3linging]

he sings david tao's songs, but sings i in a different style. so whats it about copying?

[dragonblade117]

o.O ... uhh they're just singing songs for this show. Most of them are copying songs from some famous singer. you can't really call them copycats. they're competing; do you expect them to compose for this competition, when they're tested for singing? of course not lol =) Yang zhong wei is always "copying" Gary Cao, but not really called copying.

[startingsprinter]

don't worry

Hardbeez is a loller

[chiut]

i love 小美! i like him singing this song better than David Tao.

[daer3linging]

i don't think he's proud. i think he's rather humble -.-

[dragonblade117]

wat the heck? how's he proud? I mean i can see his big smile, but think about it. when you hear such praise about you, then you can't help but have a big smile. i try to resist when someone praises me, but its really hard, it really is.

[seahorse333]

i like xiao mei's voice

[startingsprinter]

he has the best voice among the 1st season, excluding aska

[dragonblade117]

OMG I love this song and 盧學瑞!! he sings hella nice...

[wen00026]

我要小美的簽名跟抱抱就夠了

[ammaio]

小美，要加油加油

[ahfu2199]

老實說

職業歌手與這些比賽還是另一層次

[Taztan2020]

WTF!!

dun do such a fc thing here

we r here to enjoy xiao mei's songs

[muelsquared]

<3 afaleann

[unmovemover]

盧學叡的R&B很自己的風格

我在淡水線捷運裡見過他，有人拿相機要合照要簽名，他都微笑接受

覺得他好nice

陶喆聽說也是一個非常nice的人說^^

大陸的17大快開始了

聽說一堆論壇都封了

可以好好用網路的日子不多

[royalchy]

台湾的show，真是 俗 透了~~~~~~

[nikkoluvya]

盧學叡 sooo cute!! LOVE YOU^^

[lebledor]

i went to listen that 周筆暢 girl

no offense, but she does not sound better than joshua. she's stretching it. and i couldn't understand any shi t she was saying. juss because joshua is native taiwanese, you got something against him?

不喜歡就別聽嘛. 1個男的1個女的, 怎嚜能比嘞? 唱這種高音他唱就很棒了. 管他大陸的歌手, 這是台灣的節目耶! 幹嚜拿你們的跟我們的比 無聊死了

[elp05tlc]

i agree...i just listened to her...she is shit

[elp05tlc]

i agree..she is shit

[moonjessie]

每個人唱歌都有自己的方式和特色，何必比較誰好誰壞呢？

我覺得就小美的這場演出，歌聲很好聽，感情也很投入~

他那麼年輕，將來一定會越唱越好，前途無可限量~

那首阿美族的古調，有大加分喔~^^

[lebledor]

*不喜歡

[lebledor]

怎麼一堆簡體字 - -

若這麼喜歡台灣的show

那就別看

台灣的show就給我們評  - -

[producer0413]

Falling in love with this song.... I think he sing better than David did

[chiut]

i agree!

[gordonwu543]

請問周筆暢是誰呢

[ckmy30]

剛

[ckmy30]

聽了周的覺得小美唱比較好rnb部分強至少十倍不過周音質很有特­色容易沉醉

[solarbreath]

盧學瑞唱的很好,現場能唱成這樣已經很棒,何況他才19歲...­覺得大陸周唱的比較好,就去聽周的吧...沒人強迫你聽台灣小美­的聲音.

[moglin]

唱的很好^^~~

感情很投入 穩定性也很足!!

[ychang69yoyo]

Really enjoy 阿美族古調 as I close my eyes. Feel like a wind breeze as I stand on the top of the mountain.

[dinas2984]

陶喆詮釋這首歌的年齡，跟盧學叡這時候~其實有段差距

以小美這種年齡來說，把這種富感情的歌詮釋成這樣

而且!如果刻意去注意他的轉音技巧...其實不比陶喆差到哪去

當然~陶喆的功力~~也是沒話說....

[Hardbeez]

盧學瑞 sings this song good.

but the charm of David is the quality songs he composed instead of only singing.

[Micedis]

古調唱得不錯啊！

[RoxyTseng]

他也很不錯但還是陶喆比較厲害

[xingzhe410]

這叫比陶喆唱得好？口气不小，还没一个女生唱得好。

[xiaojia1984]

這叫比陶喆唱得好嗎？拜托，去聼一下大陸的周筆暢唱的愛很簡單，­高下立見

[lvy831110]

汗，还没周笔畅唱得好~~~~~~~

[vickieyaya]

.....还没有大陆的周笔畅唱的好 你们还是去听下她的~。。。

[startingsprinter]

我覺周筆暢的技巧沒有他好ㄟ

但是他沒有周筆暢穩定

因為他有時候會飄掉

[shbzg]

唱得比陶喆差太远了。。。

[lovetaoism]

本來想貼youtube上陶喆演唱會的視頻,可是好像comme­nt內不能貼網址?

有興趣的時可以search"David Tao 陶喆 - 愛，很簡單 Ai Hen Jian Dan"或"MTV: Love is simple (Ai Hen Jian Dan)"

[lovetaoism]

至於愛很簡單的重頭戲-RnB的ADLIB其實無須拿出來做比較­,因為對於才19歲的盧學叡這樣的比較實在過為沉重~

我個人很看好盧學叡啦~是有潛力而且能吸引人的好聲音,而最後唱­的古調氣足而嘹亮,才是讓聽歌有唱的比前一首好的聽覺上的主因 ^^

這麼認真的回,只是看不慣張宇這種淺薄的評語,聳動而取寵,不是­一個自稱是音樂人或專業藝人該有的言論與思維 = =

[lovetaoism]

盧學叡在這首歌假音部分明顯氣還是稍嫌不足,飽滿度做的不夠(所­以並非是張宇說的什麼要再更warm一點之類的,如果真的照他講­的這樣唱,整個副歌就會軟掉,而且跟這首歌要傳達的'堅定要愛你­的'情感不合= =lll)此外,陶喆擅長在一口氣之內做真假音的切換,但假音仍­保有力道,甚至真轉假再轉為真,一次在一口氣內做完,光這點比較­就很明顯了.

[lovetaoism]

其實我覺得盧學叡已經唱的漫完美了(對他印象漫好的),其實愛很­簡單這首歌並非是一首難度高的歌,而其最精采且重點的部分應該就­是副歌真假音轉換跟一整段讓歌者自由發揮的間奏吧~(而專輯的版­本是最不加技巧的)但單就這首歌而言,在真假音轉換部分(尤其i love u)盧學叡的流暢度還是不如陶喆

[lovetaoism]

張宇應該沒聽過陶喆愛很簡單的現場演唱吧~

估計張宇也許是拿陶喆專輯裡的那個版本來做比較(最basic的­版本)

[Hardbeez]

I agree with you.

[cloestine]

唱的比陶吉吉還要好? like real