i looooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooovvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee this song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The older ones had much more synthesizers and backing tracks. Pretty much everyone on stage plays keyboard on this song except Chris Vrenna (making for a total of 4 keyboard players on this version) plus the backing tracks. The newer version has only 1 keyboard player. A ton of synth parts were changed to guitars and bass, and plus the new breakdown which cuts out the whole middle section. That's why it sounds so different.
I think Some songs suck live with the new line up mostly Somewhat Damaged & Mr. Self Destruct off the top of my head compared to previous line-ups... and then some songs are fucking amazing live recently Like any With-Teeth Tracks or tracks like Heresy, Deep, Ruiner... IMO... I never leave a NIN show Dissapointed however... and I've been lucky to catch some GREAT setlists...
I thought sin was better with the earlier line up too. But terrible lie has never been better than on this latest tour. And i think josh is the best drummer nin will ever have (unless grohl tours with them)
the live band of the Self Destruct and the Fragility 2.0 are the best musicians to play NIN's music, I don't know, it seems to me that the actual band doesn't have the same feeling...
OMG, I love you even more. I've been looking all over for 94 era clips of Closer. Amazing how few of them seem to be circulating. That sounds kick ass. Thanks.
Thanks for this, I've been looking for a 1994 live version of closer other than the woodstock performance on youtube. Can't really hear the kick ass guitar line at the end too well unfortunately though
Damn this sounds good. Might even be better than the rendition from "And All That Could Have Been". They played this song as is, not a sped up tempo like they seem to nowadays.
always loved this song!!!!!!!!!!!!! great to fuck too!!!! good beat--tear that shit up in bed! lol! I always end up screaming my head off.
134679hun 8 months ago
Bondage, Leather, and whips music
william3231954 1 year ago
... And "happiness in slavery", when the upload?.
Greetings
PANDRIUX 1 year ago
... And happiness in slavery, when I upload?.
Greetings
PANDRIUX 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
He can fuck me anytime!
mickihotchick 1 year ago
i looooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooovvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee this song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Led94Zeppelin 1 year ago
i actually started thinking about the logistics of time travel while watching this
NappyHeadedHorse 2 years ago 2
lol wow you say fuck and kids get all excited jesus fuckin christ
hellchild65 2 years ago
1:19 some girl climaxed
NM162 2 years ago 20
@NM162 thats the sound someone makes when getting fucked like an animal
narutoabridgedfan18 1 year ago
This was the best version IMO, i don't really like the modern version with the guitar parts on the bridge.
castout85 3 years ago 4
in my opinion, aaron north's guitar replacing the synth sounded sooooo much better. but you can never truly get over how cool it sounds either way.
doodoodoodoodoodoo doodoodoodoodoodoo
kareeji 3 years ago
sound so much different in the 1990s than in the 2007 2008 version.
jeez123456789 4 years ago
The older ones had much more synthesizers and backing tracks. Pretty much everyone on stage plays keyboard on this song except Chris Vrenna (making for a total of 4 keyboard players on this version) plus the backing tracks. The newer version has only 1 keyboard player. A ton of synth parts were changed to guitars and bass, and plus the new breakdown which cuts out the whole middle section. That's why it sounds so different.
Laddil 4 years ago
@jeez123456789 they played the song as close as possible to the album version
narutoabridgedfan18 1 year ago
Sooooo awesome, this is my favorite tour, ever.
Trentholic92 4 years ago 2
Your favorite tour? U were like 2 or something then right? Thats cute! I guess it starts early, but yes amazing!TDS days.. terrific!
oliverclozesoff 4 years ago
Yeah, i was 2, lol... but still, theres just something about the TDS era... :)
Trentholic92 4 years ago
Totally agree!
oliverclozesoff 4 years ago
I think Some songs suck live with the new line up mostly Somewhat Damaged & Mr. Self Destruct off the top of my head compared to previous line-ups... and then some songs are fucking amazing live recently Like any With-Teeth Tracks or tracks like Heresy, Deep, Ruiner... IMO... I never leave a NIN show Dissapointed however... and I've been lucky to catch some GREAT setlists...
ac1dfr3ak1zback 4 years ago
I thought sin was better with the earlier line up too. But terrible lie has never been better than on this latest tour. And i think josh is the best drummer nin will ever have (unless grohl tours with them)
NINandNirvana 4 years ago
Sin was "BAD-ASS" during Fragility... But Terrible Lie with the new line is Awesome...
ac1dfr3ak1zback 4 years ago
I think you feel that way if you've never seen Vrenna play NIN.
Anyone who has ever seen that thinks he's the best.
No disrespect to Freese or Dillon, they're both still great drummers who gave us great music.
allmightantdawgs 4 years ago
@NINandNirvana danny carey would destroy souls touring with NIN
MikeyRGuitar 1 year ago
Dude, watch somewhat damaged at the july 06 irvine show. i was there and i thought it kicked ass
JCCOMMANDA 3 years ago
lol same here. and yes, it DID kick major ass.
HellishHeaven 3 years ago
@ac1dfr3ak1zback I've seen the band open with Somewhat Damaged 3 times and can honestly say its one of their best songs live.
hereticmagpie 5 months ago
the live band of the Self Destruct and the Fragility 2.0 are the best musicians to play NIN's music, I don't know, it seems to me that the actual band doesn't have the same feeling...
FeuerundWasser 4 years ago
OMG, I love you even more. I've been looking all over for 94 era clips of Closer. Amazing how few of them seem to be circulating. That sounds kick ass. Thanks.
Killaya 4 years ago
Self-Destruct Tour = best tour ever! Trent Reznor + Chris Vrenna + Robin Finck + James Woolley or Charlie Clouser = Best Band Ever.
allmightantdawgs 4 years ago
Sweet!More from the Downward spiral Era!Yay!
DanteSephiroth 4 years ago
Thanks for this, I've been looking for a 1994 live version of closer other than the woodstock performance on youtube. Can't really hear the kick ass guitar line at the end too well unfortunately though
Laddil 4 years ago
Damn this sounds good. Might even be better than the rendition from "And All That Could Have Been". They played this song as is, not a sped up tempo like they seem to nowadays.
gatesoftanhauser 4 years ago
cool 94 era!! tnx
RexXx10000 4 years ago