Thanks, a remembrance from a time when playing music was still about expressing the music itself. Forget todays impressive sounds and making yourself as interesting or odd as possible. We have two Lp:s with them, a treasure.
Merveilleux! When people try to make a ranking of violinists, Grumiaux is often forgotten. Heyfetz, Menhuin, David Oistrakh, Milstein, Isaac Stern, they are all different. Grumiaux har always been my favorite as benchmark for Mozarts concertos. Subjective of course. We all have preferences. The quality of his tecnique and vibrato, and the sound of his violin (Strad ex Grumiaux) and Haskil on piano. Thanks. Listen to Mozart concerto no 3 with Grumiaux.
Ich habe diese Aufnahme über 20 Jahre nicht gehört und bin erstaunt und froh, dass sie sich, trotz allen historischen "Erkenntnissen" immer noch als einer der schönsten und gültigsten Aufnahmen dieser Musik erweist.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Clara Haskil is always superb and her Mozart is incredible. Grumiaux was always extremely good, but given Haskil's skills I feel that she would have done better to recruit a better violinist. Still, as a pair, their Mozart is unchallenged. It's a shame that David Oistrakh and Lev Oborin didn't collaborate on this cycle - their boxed set of the Beethoven violin sonatas is the best complete set available. Some versions of individual sonatas may be better than one of theirs, but the set is A+.
This is nice playing. My favorite recording of this piece is with Thibaud and Long. Their performance is more energetic for my taste and their style is such that cannot be copied, imitated or reproduced.
Excuse me. Anne Sophie Mutter.--- Also, I'm just curious about what we're hearing: Is this recording out of your own collection? Is it an out-of-print LP? If so, that's awesome. I'm not familiar with these duos at all, as they are (perhaps) comparatively obscure. Are we being treated?
It takes one to know one! Clara Haskill was a quiet reclusive woman who intimated with no one, but Grumiaux. They admired each other greatly. Her tragic death deeply affected maestro Grumiaux.
I didn't know that, thanks so much! That is very likely, and musically speaking something obvious, two geniuses of the keyboard, from Romania should have made good friends. Best regards, from Quito, Ecuador, elufologo
For anyone in doubt (or not): this is not only the greatest of all violin sonatas there's also nothing more profound in all music than its slow movement.
btw there's a recording of K. 481 with Grumiaux playing both instruments (and I wouldn't be surprised to learn that he did it simultaneously). It would be nice if someone who has it could upload it too.
Thanks, a remembrance from a time when playing music was still about expressing the music itself. Forget todays impressive sounds and making yourself as interesting or odd as possible. We have two Lp:s with them, a treasure.
conaccento 1 month ago
Beautiful!!!
marian444 2 months ago
Danke, habe Link gesetzt
MrConvivator 3 months ago
Merveilleux! When people try to make a ranking of violinists, Grumiaux is often forgotten. Heyfetz, Menhuin, David Oistrakh, Milstein, Isaac Stern, they are all different. Grumiaux har always been my favorite as benchmark for Mozarts concertos. Subjective of course. We all have preferences. The quality of his tecnique and vibrato, and the sound of his violin (Strad ex Grumiaux) and Haskil on piano. Thanks. Listen to Mozart concerto no 3 with Grumiaux.
knubir 1 year ago
Fantastic performances
Deesade86 1 year ago
Ich habe diese Aufnahme über 20 Jahre nicht gehört und bin erstaunt und froh, dass sie sich, trotz allen historischen "Erkenntnissen" immer noch als einer der schönsten und gültigsten Aufnahmen dieser Musik erweist.
MegaBenoli 1 year ago
This reminds me of Margueritte Long and Jacques Thibaud recording. Both (Haskil and Long) are extremely good.
TokyoDoggyDog 1 year ago
Thank you so much for posting this . your work value is better than years of prayers . I often wonder what happened to that sound they had .
nicolotar 1 year ago
i love his performance, which is like a 'spring stream'.
NYASA1000 1 year ago
Fabulous recording - graceful, elegant, exquisite. What wonderful artists these two great musicians were! Thank you!!
violinhunter2 2 years ago 6
There is a difference between performers of the pre- & post-CD generations.
Pre-CDs are quite perfect plus not much more. Post-CDs are quite perfect plus JOY.
StephenChin1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Clara Haskil is always superb and her Mozart is incredible. Grumiaux was always extremely good, but given Haskil's skills I feel that she would have done better to recruit a better violinist. Still, as a pair, their Mozart is unchallenged. It's a shame that David Oistrakh and Lev Oborin didn't collaborate on this cycle - their boxed set of the Beethoven violin sonatas is the best complete set available. Some versions of individual sonatas may be better than one of theirs, but the set is A+.
gerryrains 2 years ago
Grumiaux for Mozart: nobody better.
moldyoreo 1 year ago
Arthur Grumiaux is the best violinst ever!
He always sounds elegant and modern, always!
jmgasto 2 years ago 2
exactly, well said...he's so "listenable"
jcfbell3001 1 year ago
This is nice playing. My favorite recording of this piece is with Thibaud and Long. Their performance is more energetic for my taste and their style is such that cannot be copied, imitated or reproduced.
dgmrrtt 2 years ago
thank you for loading this...2 brilliant musicians
canxbuster12 2 years ago 2
I'm sorry, I cannot answer your question about Sophie Mutter; but might ask, do you mean that maybe she recorded it ahead, for the year 2056?
comic4relief 2 years ago
Excuse me. Anne Sophie Mutter.--- Also, I'm just curious about what we're hearing: Is this recording out of your own collection? Is it an out-of-print LP? If so, that's awesome. I'm not familiar with these duos at all, as they are (perhaps) comparatively obscure. Are we being treated?
comic4relief 2 years ago
Look at 1:15. The Three Masters! (from left Menuhin, Grumiaux, Ojstrach.) (I wonder what they played?)
ellandelachapelle 2 years ago
It takes one to know one! Clara Haskill was a quiet reclusive woman who intimated with no one, but Grumiaux. They admired each other greatly. Her tragic death deeply affected maestro Grumiaux.
elufologo 2 years ago
Yes but she was a friend of pianist Dinu Lipatti too! (her compatriot.) He used to call her Clarinette! :-D
ellandelachapelle 2 years ago
I didn't know that, thanks so much! That is very likely, and musically speaking something obvious, two geniuses of the keyboard, from Romania should have made good friends. Best regards, from Quito, Ecuador, elufologo
elufologo 2 years ago
the recordings of Cho Liang Lin and Francescatti are equally sublime playing Mozart.
jreemer 3 years ago
For anyone in doubt (or not): this is not only the greatest of all violin sonatas there's also nothing more profound in all music than its slow movement.
btw there's a recording of K. 481 with Grumiaux playing both instruments (and I wouldn't be surprised to learn that he did it simultaneously). It would be nice if someone who has it could upload it too.
ernent 3 years ago 4
tanx
chad410 3 years ago