SHINee - Replay (2008 & 2011) Comparisons

[dhsdbwjwth]

I love Onew voice ^.^

[rockergirl2607]

LOVE BOTH, I really cant choose

[MrsAlmightyKey]

well personally for me i like the 2008 replay specifically because of the cloths and certain hairstyles like my baby Key's hair and definitely his outfit in the old replay and Onew's hair als. So basically the difference in style which makes me like the old replay better!

[xGwiyeoun]

Korean.

[ninod121080]

Why does this make me wanna cry?...

[Cutiebunnyable]

this video'z cute

yh taemin did change da most

key lookz beta in the new one

[polkadotkkkk]

Of course the one with victoria in it:p but actually I think the original one sounds better and the mv was..more original? I also preferred watching the ori one xD

[grupybee]

AWES, everyone grew up <3

I don't mind Taemin taking some of Jjong's line, but hey could it not be the opening line? ):

I mean that's like my favorite part of the song, + Jjong sounds hella smexy singing it haha~

[Tingting7817]

victoria <3

[kafu88]

i love Taemin but i love jonghyun more...:< They gave Taemin jonghyun's line cause they like taemin voice better in JP. Or atleast that what i hear. Dont matter, i love all of shinee!! <3

[xxsupershelbyxx]

Taemin and Minho look so much older it's ridiculous. I actually think they look better now :)

[msbudbud94]

they look different but they still look like boys.

[tsumori14]

i prefer 32476578798 times the original korean version over the japanesse version

[limedesi4]

what i got from this is that Taemin stole some of Jonghyun (and even a few of Onew's) lines and took the place of Jonghyun in the middle in some of the dance formations...which is not cool. but Key got more lines, and he looks super cute with glasses! Plus everyone's hair (especially Onew's) is looking fab in the newer Japanese version. --MVP and Locket (Onew and Key fan)

[Likasnmiba]

@limedesi4 he didn't 'steal'. sm changed whoo sung what lines because it appeared that taemin would be their 'face' in japan because he was more popular over there.

[mschikitayloca]

So pissed jjong didn't come up as much

[mschikitayloca]

So pissed tht jjong didn't come up as much

[kafu88]

@mschikitayloca ME TOO D:

[ThexShawol]

Key looks so different now.....But I still love him

[OMOhippi]

andddd... i really proud with the maknae taemin

he's has improved so much

[OMOhippi]

i dont know why , i almost cried by seeing thiss videooo :"(

how gladdd me to see shinee alreadyyyy have grown and being like now they are..

shineeee such an amazing group

im a new shawoll..

i really realize , more i find out about themmmm , moreeee i love themm

its no jokeeeee

i neverrrr love kpopgrup like this before



[lilcutie998]

This makes me realize how much Taem and Key have changed. And Minho looks like he had plastic surgery, he looks sooo different!

[ninacub]

@lilcutie998 he did, his nose :( Ikr? its sad they dont see themselves beautiful and awesome how they are!

[huanghuang96]

SHINEE PLEASE HAVE A COMEBACK SOON...

[LeeHongmeio7]

I think taemin have more parts in japanese ver than korean ver. O.O

[xhloveu]

I think, taemin changes the most

[nicoletok9]

Why does SHINee always look better in the japanese version?

[aggiebluengold]

I'm glad it's Yoona in the Japanese version! She's so pretty! AND she's actually SHINee's noona...Yoona the actual noona: perfect!

[MaxTripleKiss]

@aggiebluengold nope. yoona is younger than onew..lolol. and victoria is shinee actual noona. cause she's older than everyone in shinee.. ^^

[andLOVEDx]

Shows how little face time Taemin had in the korean music video

[aggiebluengold]

@andLOVEDx Seriously! Now that he's grown up and hot and all...

[CrazyFudgeBag]

Seeing Taemin's dance side by side almost made me cry. xD I fell in love with Shinee when this saw such a young man expressing true passion for what he loved. And after seeing this, I feel as though I'm falling for them and their music all over again.

[1MemiMikon1]

I love how Minho's like playing basket ball in both music videos ^-^

[cutelady96]

i prefer the Korean language , Japanese MV and Victoria :)

[Akikochann1994]

I Still Think They Should Have Used Victoria Again, Or A SM Japanese Trainee Or An Actual Japanese Female actress...Because Yoona Is so over used, I dun like her much :/ I Like their style for Korean and Japanese...but their looks changed so much since debut.

[aggiebluengold]

@Akikochann1994 But Yoona is sooo pretty! AND she's their noona! Yoona the actual noona, perfect!

[ryanross4ever01]

shows how much jjong disappeared in the japanese PV XDXD

[ILaughAtYourFailure5]

Gosh, I really can't pick between the two. So I'll just say I love them both for different reasons, SHINee forever.<3

[twyuan194]

we can see that SHINee grow up so fast, even tough they had the same dancing steps and the same song, but their performance had change a lot, they had become more confident!!~

SHINee forever!!!~~ Taemin, Minho, Key, Jonghyun, Onew! Keep up the good work!!! LOVE SHINee forever!!~xDD

[zpetiiii]

me gusta la version japonesa wuu mpero el hecho ke jonghyun se le quitooo la prtee de ell esoo no me gusto ...!!!

[yaoiinu08]

I love the fact that we get to see more of the boys in the Japanese Video!

[kpopaddict1998]

Haha. x3 taemin still has his fish move xD

[aleclis5892]

Taemin is making his dream come true of singing more parts..... shinee fighting 

[Nhiheomoi96]

The thing that dissapoint me is that Victoria was not in the japanese ver:(((

but anyway SHINee Daebak@@

[205argentina]

Does any one else here the boom track version??

[rawrmeans143indino]

They grow so fast *sniff * sniff* *blows nose* XDD

[Taeminnie100]

They are still the best :)

[TheVirgan11]

2008 when the people who are living in the SHINee WORLD was addicted to CUTE SHINee

2011 the year when the people who are living in the SHINee WORLD was addicted to HOT SHINee :3

[animelover1697]

@TheVirgan11

but its opposite in key heheh !

[aggiebluengold]

@TheVirgan11 You are so right.

[Ravenstar2296]

oh i never realised that the verses were sung by different people. O.O

[jamiahriotionko]

i love both versions. hahahaha what a cute mv of the Japanese ver.

[shorterthanedelric]

Can I have Taemin's shirt from the original, He made me love star wars more..

[FmaLover1234]

Can't believe how much baby Taeminnie has grown up! :O

[CynSmiles13]

Thank u for making yhis video cos for me, syncing the vids together manually frustrated me xD

I love the korean song but perfered the Japanese mv. I couldnt stop looking at Taemin's face! He looks so mature and those litte hair flips near the end -3

[kisshineeth94]

In all SHINee 5 members , I really like how Taemin changes in Japanese Version .. From Boyish looking to sorta-manly look .. ^^

[ZiggyYB3]

What? Why Taemin sings Jonghyun's part and Onew's part O_O?

[AzumyCath]

O.O TAEMIN!!!q cambio....(para mejor claro, si es q se podia... jejejejeje)

y Key tambien...(babas)

guapos todos!

gracias por el video!

[lilomeah95]

They grew so much. T^T I love the Korean version the best but love the video quality and video personally of the Japanese version. Both version are great because it's SHINee of course. But everyone knows nothing beats original. ^^

Lol, watching that was really hard for me. Especially when there was "two" Onew to watch.

[miilii362]

this remix is so cool !!!

[15pumpum]

i prefer the korean video because there's no yoona in it

[IntenseDarkness1]

Also, The roles that were given to The members made much more sense.

[IntenseDarkness1]

Aww.... I can't believe how much Taeminnie has grown!!! Cute baby Taemin to Attractive Romeo, to Sexy Lucifer, and now, Everybody's Heartthrob. Oh heck he was always all those things. Love you Taemin <3

[aquilapriest]

well my heart is beating so fast now D:

[KendrickLim]

I am a Taemin bias but i am quite upset that quite alot of lyrics from Jonghyun are given to Taemin. I know he is improving so this is a great chance for him. But, he is the main dancer & he got so many lines. The most screentime is Taemin too.

[animelover1697]

@KendrickLim

well pf course taemin is getting many fans now oh sorry not just manny gigantic many ! and comes hotter and hoter !

you know if you let me choose i love the !

first one cause all the parts are just in the right . they all sing unlike the jap. ver taemin is having more screentime than the others !

i think thats why i love the first one ! :))

[KendrickLim]

@animelover1697 Truetrue! Japanese one focus too much on Taemin (even tho i am Taemin bias but i prefer it to be more fair) Hehehe. Same sentiments! :D

[animelover1697]

@KendrickLim

yeah i know ! . my bias is key !

if i look at the mv of these two .

oh my god ! key change a lot ! he looks kinda gayish in the mv . but its okay thats why i love him !

and when he dances girlish thats when his charisma comin up !

[KendrickLim]

@animelover1697 Key is my 2nd~ I like him alot altho sometimes he is alliittttle gay. But thats why he is diva what! :D

[animelover1697]

@KendrickLim

yeah right girl ! but when i look at 2008 replay im just like oh my god !

[BabyIso]

i prefer 2008 :P

because i prefer taemin looking all innocent and pure.

[jim710323]

No matter what versions they performed we'll like all of them. :D

[KenziiProductions]

Taemin was more popular in Japan, so they gave him some of Jonghyun and Onew's lines. It's all for selling purposes. Trying to appeal to that audience. It's not that they just randomly decided to give them to Taemin. I love them both :) It's an amazing song to debut with. For both their first Debut, and their second debut in Japan.

[2PMHottestSNSDSone]

The funniest thing about the Jap version of replay is that YoonA isn't a noona(elder sis) to Onew and Jonghyun :D However, in the Kor version of replay, Victoria is confirmed a noona to all of the SHINee members. But no matter what, both the replay ver. are great :)

[squozenmango]

They seem to be more lively in the Korean version. Maybe just because it was their first music video... but I also like the Korean version too because I'm more used to it... and I like how they look in that one. There is such a strong emphasis on Taemin in the Japanese one. Any clue as to why? Is he just popular in Japan?

[chuforeichi]

@squozenmango isn't it because taemin was always the middle dancer and now he also gets more singing parts so it seems like there's more taemin in the jap version?

[ILaughAtYourFailure5]

@squozenmango they thought he was hot xD he's also the best dancer.

[keykitkat]

love both versions :D! shows how much they've matured over the years.

SHINee fighting ♥

KEYYY~

[Kristylim687]

一个是清纯，一个是帅气

[SHIRLEYYAN288]

Taemin Taemin Taemin Taemin!!!!!!!

Love u & SHINee~~

[BigBangAndSHINee]

Japanese MV is Way better. Sorry. Taemin looks weird in Korean Ver. lol

[nok299]

as i thought taemin will become very popular in Japan !

[MikanxChan]

I like victoria more as a "noona". I find her looking more mature

and i like the korean version more<3 choosing between mvs.. i like both but i think the korean vers still beats it~

[NoonaJuliette]

I like both versions but the only thing that is missed in japanese one is that there is no "noona" anymore)) =3

[ani0amira]

i'm not a fan at all~ but they seemed have matured, their dance skills has been sharpened and that's good!

[angelrule34]

I heard Taemin is in the Japanese version more since he is most popular of the five in Japan. I don't think that's fair though. He took half of jonghyun's lines and half of onew's line basically xP

[Ganychan]

It's a little disappointing how the look of the first one is very american...

[Chan3lprincess16]

@Ganychan why

[Ganychan]

@Chan3lprincess16 because they're not american and I'd rather see their own culture and identity.

[hellobabyshinee]

In my opinion, i think taemin and minho really changed ALOT. ^^

[2011kpoplover]

Am I the only one who don't see Taemins cuteness or appeal? Also, he doesn't give a masculine vibe at all..I would be surprised if he was straight..not that there is anything wrong with it. Not bashing or anything because he seems sweet. Now Minho on the other hand is gorgeous! I used to love him so much!

[xxxKissTheAngelxxx]

@2011kpoplover That's the same thing i thought about Taemin, until i saw him at abbey road. He looks really grown up and manly in person, I was really shocked, since then he's been totally invaded my mind. But Key will always be my No.1 xD

[lessthanthreeplease]

wow they grown so much and they got cuter lol well love u SHINee... Fighting!

[thatrollingstar]

I am not happy. That first line is Jonghyun's =C I remember reading from somewhere that this song meant a lot to him and now they just fucking took it away...ugh. I wish they would gave all the members equal screen time.

[JuliaNakamura]

onew oppa still keeps his lines, awesome! =) i think yoona is not so suitable as a noona as onew and jjong are older than her, haha... on the other hand, victoria is a noona to all...=)

[chuforeichi]

@JuliaNakamura I looked at the jap ver lyrics, and I think (not sure) but I think that the lyrics don't center around 'noona' anymore, so it's not necessary to have a 'noona' character in the jap video.

[JuliaNakamura]

@chuforeichi thanks for letting me know, i am just too used to the korean version of replay, haha...but yoona is good looking as well...just that i misunderstood the whole thing, no offence...=)

[chuforeichi]

@JuliaNakamura nope none at all :D i thought the same thing too before

[YooJaeJoon]

also , i think victoria definitely fit the role of "noona" better, idk maybe its the hair, but yoona seems like the cute girl next door (who is the same age) hahah.

[YooJaeJoon]

i really like the korean music video version more, even tho i think they have more style in the japanese version XD because in the korean one they have more simple and matching clothes whereas the japan pv is just random cool stuff haha. but really...why does taemin's hair in japan version look like he forgot to use conditioner or something kkkk XD

[cutelady96]

before people keeps saying that Taemin needs more parts and stuff , and now , people complaint about it -.-

[Jadeallheart88]

Key: Fashion Designer

Taemin: Dancer

Totally fits haha XD

[Fuzzball000]

Not only does the new one show how the group grew up in popularity, looks and voice but it also shows how much Taemin improved and Minho has opened up. They both seem very different. They all seem to have such personality in the new one which makes it better than the original. But I just love the original because it was the beginning of the best group of boys in the world < 3 (: SHINee FTW.

[dubujash]

2:16 I C NO DIFFERENCE :D

[sirusboost]

crying right now

[glyco21]

thanx for up!

i like both MV.

and i wanna see dance ver :D

[soccergoal39]

awsome nesss

[xSapporo]

I prefer the Japanese version since taemin sings more xD

[123bluy]

Wow there were so young especially taemin look him now all manly nd awesome he was before but know he's so awesome:)!

SHINee fighting:)!!

[totalanimefan98]

I like the song in Korean but I like video in Japanese...either way SHINee HWAITING!

[aggiebluengold]

@totalanimefan98 They sound more confident in the Korean version, and look HOT in the Japanese version, I think!

[TheOriginalSib592]

@melodyBAkey It's the commonly known logo for the rock band, The Rolling Stones

[sieleiyuai]

jonghyun and onew still shines the best among them :DDDD trololol

[sieleiyuai]

but taemin really improved a lot. haha. he's much handsome

[sieleiyuai]

haha. key is much cuter before than now :) i like his former image in the original

[TheHelloanna]

hate the girl!

[2011kpoplover]

@TheHelloanna Victoria is much better, but got to say that Yoona actually looks pretty in this video :D

[TheHelloanna]

@2011kpoplover yes, Probably true! i dont like how yoona acts.. :D

[BHD2004]

wowow there r similars n changes:)

yeah but always love SHINee

onewww:xxx

fightingggg!!!

[totalanimefan98]

How come Jonghyun's part in the Japanese version was sung by Taemin in the beginning?

[pinkomonkey88]

i love this! :D

[GerardHutchz]

THEY DIDNT GROW UP IN 3 YEARS

[ArLnkin]

Taemin and Key have changed a lot!!

[AnimeMangaFanka]

why yt don't have replay button? ;/

[SmileSwirly]

@AnimeMangaFanka Its at the end you click the 'Replay' in the top left corner :)

[AnimeMangaFanka]

@SmileSwirly I mean a button which constantly repeats

[BreakerDSX]

@AnimeMangaFanka It's called the number 0 button

[MeigaVM]

I think the original version is better, including the MV, but I like both xD.

[theasianKC]

o__o does anyone else notice that jonghyun still has the same face expressions...but i think both versions are great! :)

[TheHelloanna]

LOVE THE VIDEO OF JAPANESE VERSION BUT I DONT LIKE THE GIRL!! I LIKE THE KOREAN VERSION AND I LIKE VICTORIA!! I WISH VICTORIA WAS STILL IN JAPANESE MV..!!! love SHINee key!!!!!!!!!!!

[tRoM2dAbOne]

@TheHelloanna yoona hater? tsk tsk.

[MargaretMisfit]

onew <3

[Kmusicstuff]

2min changed the most ^^ They both look so so young now they look so so mature

[PrincesaLunardeKou]

I love the both version, I am so proud of them they are growing and growing =D improving their skill >//< I am so happy for their success!!

[manhkin]

cute... then... MEN :)

[shadowgirl5550]

It makes me cry happy tears, to see how far they have come and how much they have grown together T^T :)

I really love them, I hope they continue to grow and of course have fun and be happy

SHINee fighting~~

[girlofhell532]

Onew from some random guy to a sculptor

Jjong from a stalker(?) to a part time janitor (HOT one)

Key from a bball-er to fashion designer (jap one makes more sense :P)

Minho from a random person to a bball-er

Taemin from a skateboarder to a dancer.

Victoria swapped places with YoonA

The song remained nice to listen to no matter which language they sang.

Overall : Both are JJANG! :D

[melodyBAkey]

cool jonghyun is wearing a shirt with a mouth on both clips

[karapasi]

True. The Jap MV is better. They look more mature and seem to have more meat. Though I don't get why they kept on replacing Jonghyun's parts with Taemin;s.

[musicftTY]

@karapasi The parts sang by Taemin in the jap version are: 1st verse originally Jonghyun's and 2nd verse Onew's. So basically the hyungs each gave Taemin a part to sing, but it still doesn't change the fact that Jonghyun is still the lead singer, isn't it... I still love em no matter what=)

[Disorto123]

Look the korean one, I can sing. now I feel stupid, cuz I don't know the words of this one. Time for studying.. AGAIN xD Well looking at them, makes things much and much better

[Becca35treehugger]

key's look has changed the most ._.

[Music4211215]

Cuter*

[Music4211215]

Cute in 2011

[vxuwang]

To be honest, The original Replay song was way better, to me, but the MV in the Japanese version was better.

[Jejungi]

Taemin has more part in the singing in the japanese version ^^ Aaaww he's so cute and dreamy~~

[aurora2]

รักชายนี่ที่สุด ไม่รู้ทำไม ชายนี่ๆๆๆๆ XD

[VendelNatalie]

I've always wondered how they film that "spinning" effect (in the 2011 ver.) at 0:50 o.O does anyone know? :P

[Redstar95]

@VendelNatalie its done withtt he same type of cameras that are used in the matirx! Or at least thats what they said in the "making of Lucifer" video. the part where they're all jumping in Lucifer i think is the same effect in this mv. iv been seeing that effect alot in SM videos recently lol esspecially shinee :)

[TheOriginalSib592]

@Redstar95 Well, true, but that doesn't really answer her question. BoA used it in her MV "Game". I think she was probably the 1st of SM.E to do so.

@VendelNatalie Let me just add on to Redstar95's comment. Think of the space that Minho is filming as a circle. Now imagine small cameras being placed in that one fourth of the circle. While he does his scene, the film crew films that one fourth of his actions from all the cameras at the same time, giving the spinning effect. Pretty cool, huh? :D

[finleeful]

@magentaandpikachu THANK YOU SO MUCH!

[lolita4869]

i love both ! especially when victoria and yoona are in it :)

[roycelimsy]

More taemin!!! Great improvement taemin!! :D Saranghae!

[eileeane]

1. they've grown up so much in everything for last 3 years.. ^_^

2. they are still adorable,, :) even, much more adorable.. ♥♥♥

3. Taemin has more part in singing :) ♥♥

4. Still the same dance move.. ^_^

5. I LOVE THEM SO..SO..SO...MUUCHH.... ♥♥♥♥♥

[finleeful]

PLEASE tell me what version of replay is this?... i like it's beat...

[magentaandpikachu]

@finleeful It's the Replay Boom Track :)

[RandyHVu]

in the japanese one , i soooo need to know what color is taemins hair!!! please tell me!!!!

[PewPewPrincessCX]

@RandyHVu

red ?

[onlythebest24]

taemin had more singing parts in 2011 version... i like it

[onlythebest24]

2011 is better.... i like the camera angles better

[shatomi1]

i think teamin fits Japanese ideal and promotion concept than others so teamin's part increase^^ SHINee fighting!