American Idol - Season 9 - Top 11 Results - Part 3

[natemini]

WOW...she shows us why she's a huge star...hats off....incredible stage presence. She has a truly beautiful voice...there is a very special quality to her voice...and she pours so much into her performance. I've never listened to her music but I'm a Miley fan now for sure. She struggles to hit some notes but it's very admirable she didn't choose an easy song...she pushed herself like you're suppose to do on AI. The main thing is her voice, her charisma, and a certain magic she brings to the song

[kaitlynwithakayx]

she did amaaazing. <3 she's come far. i'd like to see half of you do what she just did. sure, she cracked a couple times, but otherwise, it was fantastic.

[IowaGirl721]

hahah she was their mentor? hah if i got voted off i would have blamed her. shes terrible

[ILoveKatieStevens]

great song...she sounded absolutely AWFULL

[viveca184]

it's a great song, but she's straining... it was just a horrible performance. my ears are bleeding.

[backwardsmirror]

Your right about the straining, but it wasn't really AWEFUL.

[ellaxcinderxella]

I love this song your a great a pretty girl keep singing strong love it. Hopes hi

[Country266Charliee]

fuck off and leave miley alone!

[slat13]

I am not a fan of Miley Cyrus but she did a good performance and definately better than Joe and Demi. The song is also great.

[MariahhSuzanne1]

uh, she's not good.

[superbinp]

Miley was OK it would have been better if she didn't move so much. But on the other hand this is a beautiful song she sang

[TicklesMeSillyYou]

miley was pitchy all over the place.. i bet the judges was like damn she's horrible LOL

[GottaFindYou54]

Plus the judges were probably wondering why she was picked to mentor the American Idol contestants

Joe and Demi on the other hand were amazing!!!!