War never solved anything, accept for facism, nazism, slavery, opression, genocide, and communism. The only wars not worth fighting are wars of special interests. There will always be hanus and cruel people on this planet that will not have problems rallying up lesser minds for their violent cause. Unfortunatly the only way to prevent these imorral people from harming us, is to exterminate them like the vermine that they are which unfortunatly is war.
@cubanator No humans are naturally born "evil". If it wasn't for all the attitudes, lies, predujizzm (dno how thats spelled), RELIGION (and fucking believe me, i know religion on the bottom line stands for peace, but it's also created for power, thus keeping human minds stuck), the whole friggin system itself TODAY creates these humans. We can either keep on doing this, or we can try to have an full understanding of what we are and what we want to achieve.
Seriously... We all have to die! There is no fuckin´ excuse for our savage ways. We couldn't be more evil if we tried. I will enjoy looking at the faces of those self-important people running in panic and screaming when the shit finally hitts the fan as we end our pathetic existence! All the good people get murdered annyway. Fuck this planet! I wan't to go home:D:D
war is the only natural predator of the human race... what a shame what we've done to the world, 'he' needs a relief. i guess that helps a little with overpopulation
@8lwc8 so you've never gotten angry and wanted to hurt something or someone?? that's violence, its in everybody's nature, some people just bury it well enough so it doesn't surface
The Einatzgruppen wouldn't believe you only those in control and never actually had to go and see their work being set worth could claim your statement to be correct I can guarantee it. The Einatz... killed Jews for the purpose of experimentation but b/c of the brutality of it all most ended up killing themselves because of the things they had to do....
Omg guys..War believe it or not is necessary..without war we wouldn't be able to walk out our front doors free because some dictator would be controlling us, I know the video is sad but thats life kids. People fight, People die
hah, war is absolutely NOT necessary, what if we all lived in peace like almost all the other species in the whole world does, no other species in the world fight like we do, we are on the way to selfdestruction so please dont tell me that war is necessary because it certainly aint...
Really? Tell me how long have the Isrealites and Palestinians been fighting for. Idk about you but i dont wanna live in a dictatorship because there are countrys out there who if we did not fight, they would take us over.
Sure you have a point there but it doesn't really seem like war solves anything between them or does it? thats why they have been fighting for so long, because it doesn't get solved and i believe they dont know what else to do but to continue fighting...
I trust you when you say that you hate to se young kids fight and die.. but when you say that we cant afford to be anti-war i cant really understand what you mean... being "anti-war" would save us million if not billions of dollars that we can spend on research or making all of the hospitals better equiped and so on...
What i mean is without war we would be making ourselves vulnerable to countrys who hate us. I dont know about you, but i do not wanna be taken over by a foreign country. That is why we cannot afford to be anti-war. And even though war is costly, there is still some left for hospitals and research believe it or not.
Your right about that but what i was trying to say was if we live in peace we would all be like "one" country and there would be no reasons to have war except for the very unlikely risk of aiens attacking us
Lol, this is my last comment to you bud. There will never be world peace, and we will never unify as ''one''. There are just too many bad people in the world.
I understand that this is Your last reply this discussion has gone a little to far, I know that there will never be world peace though i was just imagining what the world would be like if we had world peace and we all lived like one country. Your also right about the fact that there are too many bad people in the world as well and it certainly is a shame, you dont need to reply if you dont want to.
You don't even know me, how can you say I'm an idiot. Can you even define what an idiot is?
And the necessity of war is not a fact. It never has been. War is mostly a vestigial animal instinct. You should gather more information before making such bold and assertive statements. maybe then people like me wouldn't challenge your assumptions.
I beleive Cdigorg is right. Although you go into morality when you say there are just too many bad people in the world, good and bad is perception based on the person. But you are right, there are too many "different" people in the world, people with different idea's from one another.
The constitution is a piece of paper with ink on it.
And all those wars certainly have forced the government to abide the constitution haven't they? Oh wait, they haven't at all, the government violates the constitution daily.
Don't put the lives of real living human beings on the line to protect some sacred cow sheet of parchment.
oldbananas9 the US is nazi germany for the present m8 sry to crash your party but your ignorance is the reason for the suffering and fucked upness in the world. Open your eyes m8 you went to school and guess what you think just like they want you too. The stockmarket keeps us from finding the truth aswell as money. We arn't here by coincidence well there is a change but.. most likely we are being watched by our creators and they will not intervene. just hope they do before ts too late......
Morons, Don't be anti Military be anti the fuckin morons who control ur military and make sure to vote so we dont have anymore cunts like that in power
Fuck Bush, Fuck War, Fuck government we as the new generation should rise to look for peace...Nuclear bombs are going to be the genocide of human kind George Bush is evil in everyway someone needs to put an end to government But americans are close minded..the world is everyone needs to open their minds and stop violence
it sounds like you have a very large bias, you obviously hate america for whatever reason, but the truth of the fact is that america is the greatest force for good. it is the largest contributer of aid in the world. who do countries call on for help when its needed? its the people who kill thousands a day in africa in the name of god.
or the genocide commited in the balkans 10 yrs ago just for example. those are the true people who need to open their minds to stop violence. your hate for george bush makes your statement sound ridiculous and makes any comments you make not even respectable.
i liked the song and i liked most of the video, but the "no war" demonstrants in the end...i don't think they fit here. the song is about lonelyness, desperation and the popular anti-war movement doesn't quite fit this in my opinion.
So your trying to tell me that even Trent Reznor is wrong about the images he puts up on the screen at his own concert during this song. Im guessing you havent seen NIN perform this song live. The images he uses are all political in nature some of which is war footage. Come back and comment when your no longer a NIN rookie.
@5hutup I think the song is about him getting over things that were holding him back (drugs, social anxiety etc), but in the live performance he applies it to the wider context of human conflict rather than personal conflict. In other words I think you're both right, blah blah
What if humanity's continuing willingness to conduct war, despite the catastrophic costs is a part of what leads to that feeling of loneliness and desperation? What could be more lonely than looking around the world and feeling as if you're the only one who isn't willing to commit cruelty or violence?
Moving, chilling, truthful and the color technique added to the misery of America's invasion and occupation of a foreign country. Many of the photos used in your shoot I've seen on the internet; the main-stream media is still trying to keep American heads up their asses. God bless the world wide web; the only freedom and truth left in our country.
hey, thank you for this, if i ever have to do a report/project for GT (gifted&talented) for anything war related, bombs, nuclear weapons, or anything related, i'm gonna use this video, but only if you say i can, and i'll put ur name in the credits on my powerpoint i'd have to do. Thanks for this amazing video, as well as a song in the background one of the best bands ever. And it just makes the fact that Trent doesn't like Bush and all this war even more bitter and sweet.
that is our nature
ghghghghghghggggghgh 1 year ago
love mercy more than life itself
TheMiamifuentes 1 year ago
Ich finde das Lied passt ehrer zu einem Schizoiden als zum Krieg.
GeneralRedZero 1 year ago
War never solved anything, accept for facism, nazism, slavery, opression, genocide, and communism. The only wars not worth fighting are wars of special interests. There will always be hanus and cruel people on this planet that will not have problems rallying up lesser minds for their violent cause. Unfortunatly the only way to prevent these imorral people from harming us, is to exterminate them like the vermine that they are which unfortunatly is war.
cubanator 2 years ago
@cubanator No humans are naturally born "evil". If it wasn't for all the attitudes, lies, predujizzm (dno how thats spelled), RELIGION (and fucking believe me, i know religion on the bottom line stands for peace, but it's also created for power, thus keeping human minds stuck), the whole friggin system itself TODAY creates these humans. We can either keep on doing this, or we can try to have an full understanding of what we are and what we want to achieve.
bragehhh 1 year ago
Seriously... We all have to die! There is no fuckin´ excuse for our savage ways. We couldn't be more evil if we tried. I will enjoy looking at the faces of those self-important people running in panic and screaming when the shit finally hitts the fan as we end our pathetic existence! All the good people get murdered annyway. Fuck this planet! I wan't to go home:D:D
gooeish 2 years ago 2
(.) Good
{0} evil
Radonb0y 2 years ago
war is the only natural predator of the human race... what a shame what we've done to the world, 'he' needs a relief. i guess that helps a little with overpopulation
iamthebread 2 years ago
Killing for Peace is like Fucking for Virginity
8lwc8 2 years ago 12
@8lwc8 I tried fucking for virginity.
Guess the results...
Yosh997 2 years ago
@8lwc8 Sounds good to me:)
benner2000 1 year ago
war is just a natural extension of our own inner natures violence has always been a part of our nature period
jokerNIN 2 years ago
@jokerNIN
according whit you. Life is natural, death is also. Over moralistic expression and ethic tendences probably this is the truth.
abbacchioallabrace 2 years ago
Its never been a part of my nature. Its a byproduct of greed, greed of those in control.
8lwc8 2 years ago
@8lwc8 so you've never gotten angry and wanted to hurt something or someone?? that's violence, its in everybody's nature, some people just bury it well enough so it doesn't surface
crazyvoododemon 2 years ago
The Einatzgruppen wouldn't believe you only those in control and never actually had to go and see their work being set worth could claim your statement to be correct I can guarantee it. The Einatz... killed Jews for the purpose of experimentation but b/c of the brutality of it all most ended up killing themselves because of the things they had to do....
Anastasia467able 1 year ago
Omg guys..War believe it or not is necessary..without war we wouldn't be able to walk out our front doors free because some dictator would be controlling us, I know the video is sad but thats life kids. People fight, People die
Cdigorg15 3 years ago
hah, war is absolutely NOT necessary, what if we all lived in peace like almost all the other species in the whole world does, no other species in the world fight like we do, we are on the way to selfdestruction so please dont tell me that war is necessary because it certainly aint...
berra1432 3 years ago
Really? Tell me how long have the Isrealites and Palestinians been fighting for. Idk about you but i dont wanna live in a dictatorship because there are countrys out there who if we did not fight, they would take us over.
Cdigorg15 3 years ago
Sure you have a point there but it doesn't really seem like war solves anything between them or does it? thats why they have been fighting for so long, because it doesn't get solved and i believe they dont know what else to do but to continue fighting...
berra1432 3 years ago
Trust me man, i hate to see young kids fight and loose there lives, but thats life bro..we cant afford to be anti-war
Cdigorg15 3 years ago
I trust you when you say that you hate to se young kids fight and die.. but when you say that we cant afford to be anti-war i cant really understand what you mean... being "anti-war" would save us million if not billions of dollars that we can spend on research or making all of the hospitals better equiped and so on...
berra1432 3 years ago
What i mean is without war we would be making ourselves vulnerable to countrys who hate us. I dont know about you, but i do not wanna be taken over by a foreign country. That is why we cannot afford to be anti-war. And even though war is costly, there is still some left for hospitals and research believe it or not.
Cdigorg15 3 years ago
Your right about that but what i was trying to say was if we live in peace we would all be like "one" country and there would be no reasons to have war except for the very unlikely risk of aiens attacking us
berra1432 3 years ago
Lol, this is my last comment to you bud. There will never be world peace, and we will never unify as ''one''. There are just too many bad people in the world.
Cdigorg15 3 years ago
I understand that this is Your last reply this discussion has gone a little to far, I know that there will never be world peace though i was just imagining what the world would be like if we had world peace and we all lived like one country. Your also right about the fact that there are too many bad people in the world as well and it certainly is a shame, you dont need to reply if you dont want to.
berra1432 3 years ago
Because, yeah, I guess you can see the future, and shit.
Get over yourself.
Jcolinsol 3 years ago
Your an idiot, i'm not predicting anything..those are facts.
Cdigorg15 3 years ago
You don't even know me, how can you say I'm an idiot. Can you even define what an idiot is?
And the necessity of war is not a fact. It never has been. War is mostly a vestigial animal instinct. You should gather more information before making such bold and assertive statements. maybe then people like me wouldn't challenge your assumptions.
Jcolinsol 3 years ago
I beleive Cdigorg is right. Although you go into morality when you say there are just too many bad people in the world, good and bad is perception based on the person. But you are right, there are too many "different" people in the world, people with different idea's from one another.
XGodlessFaithX 3 years ago
War is never fought to protect an ideology like "freedom"
We have great freedom in this country, not because we fight wars to stop "dictators" but because of our constitution.
War is a profiteering scheme orchestrated by traitors and weasels. It always has been.
Read "The War Prayer" by Mark Twain.
Jcolinsol 3 years ago
what the earth need is an alien as enemy .. sad but true ..i think its the only way to forgett all the anger -.- *k i love si-fi* ..
WAR is A bitch !
Gr1Ng00 3 years ago
yes but the constitution had to be protected by war and even before, made by war.
killzonephx 2 years ago
The constitution is a piece of paper with ink on it.
And all those wars certainly have forced the government to abide the constitution haven't they? Oh wait, they haven't at all, the government violates the constitution daily.
Don't put the lives of real living human beings on the line to protect some sacred cow sheet of parchment.
Jcolinsol 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Good video, really hit the spot
SolusArmatura 3 years ago
Dam its real whe are only told what to do its shut up and obey or die for nothing
ianguillaume 3 years ago
oldbananas9 the US is nazi germany for the present m8 sry to crash your party but your ignorance is the reason for the suffering and fucked upness in the world. Open your eyes m8 you went to school and guess what you think just like they want you too. The stockmarket keeps us from finding the truth aswell as money. We arn't here by coincidence well there is a change but.. most likely we are being watched by our creators and they will not intervene. just hope they do before ts too late......
jimmycrackcorn1983 3 years ago
Don't hate the soldiers for what they do
Hate the people who make them do it
Devellish 3 years ago
is there an actual video done by nine inch nails
strangedudeman 3 years ago
yes
MartinBangens 3 years ago
plz tell us wot its called (its real name)
strangedudeman 3 years ago
Awesome video..this song is really growing on me
3ggh3ad 3 years ago
wow, that just about sums it all up...when the f**k our we going to have our own "Nuremberg Trials"?????? F**k the elections, I WANT JUSTICE!!!!!!
Dracanon26 4 years ago
evry thing were it belongs its all a dream and it is all you want to be
benNjenny43 4 years ago
I am in the military and I have a severe regret for ever joining. This was a well made video and it sickens me to know what I am a part of.
johnwhitehead88 4 years ago
Morons, Don't be anti Military be anti the fuckin morons who control ur military and make sure to vote so we dont have anymore cunts like that in power
Asfrina 4 years ago
just one word - GREAT!
thx
gibbcio 4 years ago
Great! Wonderful! A Favorite for Sure. I will spread this around as a great find!
funny4food 4 years ago
beautiful
simply beautiful
Andeism 4 years ago
Fuck Bush, Fuck War, Fuck government we as the new generation should rise to look for peace...Nuclear bombs are going to be the genocide of human kind George Bush is evil in everyway someone needs to put an end to government But americans are close minded..the world is everyone needs to open their minds and stop violence
shinragenesis420 4 years ago
it sounds like you have a very large bias, you obviously hate america for whatever reason, but the truth of the fact is that america is the greatest force for good. it is the largest contributer of aid in the world. who do countries call on for help when its needed? its the people who kill thousands a day in africa in the name of god.
oldbananas9 4 years ago 2
or the genocide commited in the balkans 10 yrs ago just for example. those are the true people who need to open their minds to stop violence. your hate for george bush makes your statement sound ridiculous and makes any comments you make not even respectable.
oldbananas9 4 years ago 4
Respect!
littlegreenwheels 4 years ago
great work
KafkasTurk 4 years ago
Masterpice, thank you !
mosconi 5 years ago
fuck war fuck bush
wretchedstarfucker 5 years ago
i liked the song and i liked most of the video, but the "no war" demonstrants in the end...i don't think they fit here. the song is about lonelyness, desperation and the popular anti-war movement doesn't quite fit this in my opinion.
thumbs up, though
ndes0532 5 years ago
So your trying to tell me that even Trent Reznor is wrong about the images he puts up on the screen at his own concert during this song. Im guessing you havent seen NIN perform this song live. The images he uses are all political in nature some of which is war footage. Come back and comment when your no longer a NIN rookie.
5hutup 5 years ago
@5hutup I think the song is about him getting over things that were holding him back (drugs, social anxiety etc), but in the live performance he applies it to the wider context of human conflict rather than personal conflict. In other words I think you're both right, blah blah
handofsutekh 9 months ago
What if humanity's continuing willingness to conduct war, despite the catastrophic costs is a part of what leads to that feeling of loneliness and desperation? What could be more lonely than looking around the world and feeling as if you're the only one who isn't willing to commit cruelty or violence?
DamianKarrasAAP 4 years ago
I love the last image! its perfect.
timsk0ld 5 years ago
Moving and interesting interpretation of my favorite NIN tune from that CD. Nice job!
wrinkledsack 5 years ago
Was intrigued. But your last shot. Your climax, what an M Night Shaymalan moment. Perfect due to how you ended.
littlehype 5 years ago
Moving, chilling, truthful and the color technique added to the misery of America's invasion and occupation of a foreign country. Many of the photos used in your shoot I've seen on the internet; the main-stream media is still trying to keep American heads up their asses. God bless the world wide web; the only freedom and truth left in our country.
scriptum60 5 years ago
this actually made me cry. Awesome job.
phuzehatz 5 years ago
hey, thank you for this, if i ever have to do a report/project for GT (gifted&talented) for anything war related, bombs, nuclear weapons, or anything related, i'm gonna use this video, but only if you say i can, and i'll put ur name in the credits on my powerpoint i'd have to do. Thanks for this amazing video, as well as a song in the background one of the best bands ever. And it just makes the fact that Trent doesn't like Bush and all this war even more bitter and sweet.
nineinchnails92 5 years ago
Damn.. that was great!.. and the final pic with Bush.. O_O
mad06sic 5 years ago
fantastic!
bluebirdie252 5 years ago
amazing. and if anyone possibly brings political opinions into the comments, delete them. That would just soil this perfect video.
ank0ku 5 years ago
just that song alone brings tears into my eyes, and plus that video..dude!
UchihaSaske 5 years ago
you can't be "anti death" without being anti birth because the man in the ground fertalizes it and a tree is born from the earth.
BobMcGreen 5 years ago
a hauntingly beautiful video for a gorgeous song
gmel2 5 years ago
Well done this is the best version on here, Im not anti millitary, just anti death. Good song to put this to.
Brysondixon 5 years ago
Nicely done. I would have preferred the version on the japanese import album, though. By the way, I AM anti-military.
9inchnail 5 years ago