Mariah Carey e Phil Collins - Against All Odds (Take A Look

[CyprusHot]

Mariah's version is better for me, touches the heart with the first and last and every note!

[frsh6272]

lalah hathaway's version is very good.

[kittyphilly1]

i luv phil collins music, i luv the way he sings it!

[Marcocucciolo91]

MARIAH IS THE BEST SINGER EVER!

[CyprusHot]

@Marcocucciolo91 i agree with you!

[ArgentaMom]

This is just WRONG!!!! & false advertisement to get hits!

[Booklat1]

she's not bad but... he's got a lot more "muchness"

[CyprusHot]

@Booklat1 obviously you do not know of Mariah as an artist to say such a statement.

[Crysimm]

See the video called Against all odds di Mariah Carey & Phil Collins

[divulsionbob]

yeah this kinda fucks the song up



[richyrm74]

They can't because Phill collings sings this song in a lower tone than Mariah C... pay attention when the piano starts with Phill and when Maria sings, she's in a higher tone

[vytildie]

I'm gonna VOMIT!

[RGLLance]

A cover-woman destruiu outra música.

Canta todas as músicas do mesmo jeito: gritando e tremendo a boca.

Mariah Cover Playback Carey!

[jackoherts]

Mariah Carey ruins this song!!!!!!!!!

[nandofrm]

I hate mariah --'

[Crysimm]

See this video mentioned below.... can't seem to copy & paste a link, so this will have to do!  This is them singing together...... actually TOGETHER!

'Against all odds di Mariah Carey & Phil Collins'

[Crysimm]

It is originally Phil's song, but being a huge Phil Collins fan, the original Duet they did TOGETHER was actually really nice! They both did it justice & it was the most beautiful song :-) I love them both but whoever put this video up has tainted the work that they originally did , as the voice tones don't even blend. They've obviously taken her & him singing the song individually & put them together in verses. Find a video of the real duet you'll love it equally.

[MrSammoran]

rubbish



[superstarcross]

Mariah Careya version is so much better

[Tom6093]

@superstarcross Why ? Because she can throw her voice around ? That doesn't make it better. Phil owns this baby !!!!! He sings it with class and with feeling. All Mariah can do is try to turn it into a screaming gospel song. Phil all the way.

[SuperPapi2009]

the original is the best but ... mix??? sound like SUCK

[elsino05]

aaaaahhhh!!! what is that???



[khmerb0diia]

mariah's verson owns phils

[Tom6093]

@khmerb0diia I love Mariah and her voice but cmon loser !!!!!! Phil wrote it and gave it a style all it's own. Throwing your voice around on a song doesn't make the song any better. It actually gets ennoying. It's Phils baby. Mariah did it well but be realistic..........not buyest towards a younger up to date star. You probably aren't familiar with Phils work.

[khmerb0diia]

@Tom6093 yeah maybe you seem to feel that way.. i can understand .. being that it is his song.. he brings some originality to it.. but mariah carey, although in this video her voice appears to be so unstable, has a more pure and angellic rendition of the song, which in my opinion, is better (for me anyway).. but yes, im not familiar with his work.. im not really into classical stuff.. so there you go

[boogoo28]

there both gd but this song is just bad togetherr

[defectedsi]

god dam is she fit

[Krisdominique]

me too...pfffff

[messi081890]

Great song

[HunnyLamb26]

Mariahs version is 100x better! Phill is boring and can't sing plus that old fart man is an eye sore!!!

[G3ABRAHAM]

IS SHET MARIE CAREY, JUST SCREEM,

[Saulenazz]

no one will sing better then phil!!! and this shit with 2 clips is worst.

[monkeypower420]

I like Mariah but she does not do this song justice

[Javichu80]

@monkeypower420

Phil said to MARIAH congratulations for the remake, because is much better the mariah's version.

[saleguacho]

muy alto llegaba

[eduzinhoxvre]

COMMON MARIAH IS SO MUCH BETTER

HER VOICE IS POWERFUL

phil ,,, poor phil

he can`t make a whistle MARIAH IS WHISTLE´S QUEEN

[Vampire666Lover]

DAMNIT! I was actually hoping they would be singing together! I think here Phil Collins was better. But the way she sounded on the album (Rainbow) i like more.

[civilhistoryfan1981]

phil collins is much better. mariah carey however the same song for mariah didn't even make the top 40 and phil did.

[VivaLasVegasBoy]

Phil Collins is so much better!!!

[franforest]

Mariah it's good, but Phil is way better

[babythug85]

i like mimi but phil's better

[qwert1446]

wowo mimi goes better

[sonnylegirl]

how odd!

[BlinginTom]

PHIL IS BETTER!

[marianogedisman]

I wanna see where they sing it together. You stupid cunt.

[lewistrickett]

oh yeah mariah, PUT YOUR HAND DOWN!!!

[lewistrickett]

phil collins is the one and only!! ;)

[ForzaStefan]

I think she screwed this song up, just like briank383 said; It sounds like she's wining. Phil made a beautiful song!

[snowdjagha]

oh... its just in that phill collins live version. i thought they would be singing together.

[lewistrickett]

yeah me too, thats crap lol

[Larhissapessanha]

Mariah Carey if you someday read this,know that i love you and my big dream is see you near me!I love you so much!thank you!

[gonnagetgunned]

phil made me like this song, mariah made me LOVE it

[krusfire]

WOO PHIL COLLINS!!!!!!

[briank383]

When she sings this it sounds like she's whining or something. Way to freaking raspy, that's a problem with a lot of today's singers, they think this whole raspy voice thing works. Seems like they sing part of a word

[911AmericanSoldier]

Like both versions, but Phil had more emotion in it, belted the high notes which are difficult in this song.

Mariah did a good version, but lacked the emotion and backed away from really showing anger, which some of this song is about.

[gonnagetgunned]

mariah lacks emotion...................most of her songs are about love, and shes written all of them except the covers shes done, mariah sings with emotion, she tells the story of a song with her amazing voice, and if u didnt notice mariah did belt the notes too.......................

[MMGSGG]

jaja es tonto e imposible comparar

[01NarutoKid]

Well comparing Phil and Mariah is a matter of opinion but i think Mariah's career in being a singer or vocalist is better than Phil Collins even though he is a Pianist, Song Writer etc. Anyways they are both really good at performing this song. And oh yeah i'm not trying to be a smart arse i'm just writing the same way you guys are.. lol

[rwrusselljr]

OK, and who can play it better on piano or drums? Comparing vocals on this doesn't even rate because Phil is a singer, songwriter, musician and Mariah is just a vocalist. If you want to compare her to Phil, let her try to hold her own against Philip Bailey.

[kimobo]

mariah writes and produces her own song for your information. both phil and mimi are legends.

[elie280838]

Mariah writes most of her songs and produces them. and the vocals she put into this song are incredible.

However, both were good, its a matter of opinion.

[jesusdouglas3]

On the hardest parts He put Mariah ( Not on the best performance of her of this song ) And on the Easiest parts he put Phil !

Ok! I Think that singing as he sings ! It's became too easy !

Mariah is the Best No doubt

[shadowcastell]

I don't think she understood what this song was about. She is a pretty good singer, but Phil wrote this about real heart ache. She is just saying the words, and it comes though when she sings.

[Willie4ever89]

phil is a LEGEND!!!! i'm sorry mariah

[Alessia1978]

Mariah is a legend too. Both are great singers

[elie280838]

phil is a legend , but Mariah is a legend as well ( dont forget that)

[CocoDyme]

I love the song but I love Mariah's Version more... there's just something about the way she sings that part of the song from 2:35-3:00 that Phil's version doesn't have. All in all great song but MC definately made it better with her version.

[miaka111]

XD wow people let people sing what they wanna sing, i love both but hey who are you to be a critic what if phil likes mc's version more then his own or what if mariah likes pc's more then hers? lol chill out o-o

[marleyj99]

beutiful

[farrieta123]

this vid is shit

[adrina911]

MARIAH SINGS TEN TIMES BETTER!

[Nevawake]

dickhead! your off your face if u believe that shit

[adrina911]

well I believe it faggot fuck you asshole!

[elie280838]

in fact, she does.

[VivaLasVegasBoy]

phil collins is 1000 times better

[gonzaloha]

Estupido!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[dazz404]

i love mariah but this song will always be phil collins song...

[marcieie1]

This is just a shit video!! PC is much better than Mariah Carey

[Glunddra]

Un peu déçu de voir que ce n'est qu'un duo "virtuel", alors que la chanson par elle-même est absolument merveilleuse.

[glittsbjork]

this sucks. i thought thy're gonna sing together

[TromboneDirk]

Yeah me 2

[slkcabriolet]

ils ont reunis la beaute et la classe

[sj1778]

Yes but this one she covered ! is one of her most popular .

[officialmacmillan]

no matter who sings this song, they both have touched my heart and that is the most important. both are outstanding artists!

[DonBringer]

mdannnnnnnnnnnnn toooo goooooooooooodddddddddd

[TheJosi82]

NICE!!!!

[Ueberbacker]

He's a great composer, this song is awesome, but her singing is much better! everytime I see people singing this song on tv they try to sound like her, because it needs a lot more ability in the voice... they should have done this together.

[lapskausmannen]

phil is playing it a bit deeper. sounds much better. but he would sound better if they played with the same tones anyway ;)

[DeLuIxCaRtErCaREy]

ela simplesmente arrebentou...vcs tao falanu da cantora do mileniu..ninguem ganha esse nome por ser "boa"...ela arrebentou na musik principalmente no final...é a melhor do mundo neah gente!!

[sj1778]

I think it's bad Mariah has to use others people's

"hits" and tries to make them her own . She has done this many times .

[officialmacmillan]

what are 4-5 times at a catalogue of 240 selfwritten songs? what?

[pinko7589]

Mariah Carey New Single "Obsessed" Available for Download on July 7 on ITUNES

[Youngcavalier]

Phil is a legend.

[smthcrmnl89]

I notice its mostly Mariah here . . .

Sorry, Mariah. You're cute, and you're very talented, but no one can do this song like Phil.

Sorry, but its true . . . . .

[salsichagrossa]

Phil is SO much better at this song!

[GessiCLuz]

SENSACIONAL!!1

[tampooshat]

carey rules here!

[tyler71717]

k she has a great powerful voice but she shows off way way too much ruining anticipated parts of great memorable songs, and making a perfect song your own is wrong, if it's perfect don't change it, i'm not saying she's not talented i'm saying i don't care for what she does at all

[tyler71717]

phil ftw lol

[tampooshat]

I hear u there, u have a point, somethings sometimes r just meant to be as memorable and good anticipated parts as u put it....

i hear ya there, because it's the same everywhere, some good original old song sometimes are ruined by the new popping performers, and they actually do a pretty good job, but with them those anticipated parts are really gone, sorry to disappoint u there with my previous opinion but i like them both and u r just right about what u say, because i feel the same way!

[sj1778]

People who say mariah owns this song are idiots . She has a very good voice but Without Phil she wouldnt have this song ! It's not hers

[DanielAvilaAGT]

tell us somthing we already don't know!

i mean come on... phil said that mariah did an amaizing job so if Phil loved it, why should his fans be bashing???

dumb botches!

[hazerles]

Phil is much better!

[Lucas91x]

phil sei il re :)

[kakabsovj]

esta música faz parte da trilha sonora da minha vida

[lucasoshea]

When Phil Collins sings you can hear his soul, I don't get that from Mariah Carey, it seems like she's always just worried about doing vocal tricks, I can't stand it.

[ukslythelin]

totally agree with you

[egm5432]

mariah owned it

[mestizala]

Mariah carey is the best .....=)

[jessica12mc]

I love both versions..but I'm a Mariah fan so I listen more often her version with West Life. And this song is amazing so everybody wants to sing it, that's all!

[matthewthomas1234567]

i hate careys version it makes me sick phil rules this song he wrote it and sang it first

[Ghechaingan]

For you info Stephen Bishop is the one who worte this song, thats why in the late 90's he do a rendition of this song the acoustic version.

[garssimple]

so they never sang together.

[stinglikeabee1]

mariah is a goddess... Phil is the king!!

[leo29tt]

Fatalne zestawienie, osobno sa swietni, ale razem horrible!

[boyzformimi]

no one owns no songs. who sings it better, gain it.

[jimbobmax]

deffo phil collins, he owns this song

[mikinhalingeron]

why did you put Mariah singing in the studio version at the end?

[mikinhalingeron]

I like both

[pililo2001]

??????????philcarey, stupidd video

[zwreckless1]

he has such a pure cutting thru voice and she just scrambles and mumbles it where as he snaps it he owns her she rattles it and he cuts like a knife sorry girl not your song try again

[Syrierster]

Mariah(L)

[divamario]

Phil may own the song but the song was better sang by Mariah!

[rrapmonmis]

fuck off.

[extrasouth]

Give it up Mariah, Phil owns this one.

[emufan23]

Oh, Phil definitely beat Carey on this one...Sure, Carey has a prettier voice and all, but Phil just owns this song...And i know it´s a cliche that the writer does it the best, but he really did.

[Physikerin2912]

Grandios, selbst M.C. ist da gut und die mag ich ansonsten nicht.

[felipeco20]

gostei da sua edição

[esther1208]

they should preform together

[PianoManKD]

That's not mariah carey on the video you moron. It's bridgette bryant

[kfpmadonna]

Clearly That it is Mariah Carey

[carreiranuno]

Of course it is Mariah!!! For sure!!!

[Kamenkuzan]

Editado, porém não posso negar que ficou bom.

Parabéns!

[kfpmadonna]

Obrigado vc tem q ver o Proximo vai ser Mariah Carey,Phil Collins e Whestlife

[Kamenkuzan]

OK. No aguardo.