Good video, thanks. They recite Al-Fatihah numerous times per day. Yet, it is commonly explained that those whose portion is wrath is the Jews, and those who went astray were the Christians. WE KNOW FROM THE QUR'AN HOW THAT HAPPENED, so avoid their behavior! Do not make gods out of the mullahs, sheiks, scholars, and man-made ahaddith by obeying their words. Not one of them will be able to ransom you, intercede for you, nor save you at the last day. The Qur'an is the Criterion- nothing else.
This video is perfect sense. Hadiths are filled with contradictions and not making sense.And this person said his brother saw Mohammad on the 2 nd Wednesday,bunch of nonsense. The Holy Quran, now that has a CODE to it they found out,many things like God being mentioned,Mohammad,and about 12 other things are all divisible by 19.So what 19? God placed 19 angels over hell that's why,In Quran says He fixed their number,sofelievers get stronger,and doubters realize it is the truth. Perfection.
This video cleared alot of doubts I had of hadiths as a new convert. I would read some great hadiths but then some very violent ones. I said to myself how could this man be a prophet of God? It was God who lead me to this video. I always doubted most hadiths that were 'authentic' but never rejected the prophet (saw.) Thank you so much for this video, it touches my heart and reassures me that I am not wrong for doubting hadith. I will follow Qur'an like Allah intended! Jazakallah Khier! :)
This is absolutely brilliant!!!!! I have nearly left Islam because of the bullying I have received for saying that the Qur'an is complete.... alhamdulillah there are people with brains out there who GET IT!!!!
so according this hadith prophet mohmmed was a big hypocrite
We were with the messenger of Allah, PBUH and he asked for a drink. One of his men said: "Oh Messenger of Allah, Can we offer you wine to drink?" He said Yes. He (Gaber) went out looking for the drink and came back with a cup of wine. The messenger (Peace Be Upon him) asked, “Have you covered it with a twig in a transverse manner” He (Gaber) said, “Yes” and he (Muhammad) drank.Sahih Muslim - Hadith #3753
@crappyhadith1 TheTsukiyomi69 said that Allah sent messenger to "explain" what was in Quran. I could not stop laughing. Quran says that Phophets job is to "deliver" the message. Message = Quran. That's it. But hadithers literally worship Mohammad. What if there was a hadith that Prophet's favourite color was yellow, and he disliked purple. They will "issue" a ruling that liking purple is "haram". Just like they made other things haram
@MegaMrname The Qur'an needs no deciphering IF you believe, ponder and understand. It repeats this countless times in the Qur'an. "we have revealed this to a believing people" or an understanding people. Unfortunately not everyone believes or understands or ponders about Allah's revelation. Especially this new cult known as "Quranists" who label all the good muslims who follow Allah and his messenger a "hadither". If being a muslim who follows Allah makes me a "hadither" then good.
@MegaMrname I can't believe you believe that Prophet Muhammad did not come to teach the Qur'an as well as deliver it. It says in the Holy Qur'an "Even as We have sent among you an Apostle from among you who recites to you Our communications and purifies you and teaches you the Book and the wisdom and teaches you that which you did not know." Surah 2 ayah151. As you can see it say ".. and teaches you that which you did not know." meaning that Muhammad taught the Qur'an and Sunnah.
@TheTsukiyomi69 Hey, What is wrong with you? I BEG YOU Please did you read the verse I sent you? 6:114? This verse is definitely against HADITH and other "narrrations". Please don't write emotional things. Just answer the verse. PLEASEEEEE
@MegaMrname It says "Shall i take a judge beside Allah while it is he who has revealed the Book explained in detail..." The hadiths come from the Prophet Muhammad. Everything he said about religion is divine Inspiration (Surah 53 Verse 3 and 4). Therefore The authentic hadiths about the Prophet Muhammad's sayings are divine inspiration from Allah. The Qur'an is divine revelation to mankind from Allah. Both are from Allah. There is my answer. If you disbelieve after this than i pity u
@crappyhadith1 Astaghfirullah many people have been led astray by this incorrect translation. In the Arabic "a cup of grape juice" but has been translated to say "a cup of wine". As we know grape juice is unfermented and there for not an intoxicant, where as wine is an intoxicant. Brother its not wine its grape juice. The Prophet Muhammad said that which intoxicates in small quantities is forbidden in large quantities. You are no where NEAR being better that Prophet Muhammad.
@crappyhadith1 I find it hard to believe you are a Muslim by the way you talk but nevertheless. The hadith was not fake, what you wrote was fake and changed but i have the real hadith with me. Look If you want to follow other than what the Prophet did than fine to you is your way and to me is mine. Allah will judge between us on the Day of Judgment. Than you will not find any escape. Please come to truth of Islam and don't be fooled by Youtube messengers. Peace .
The only sunnah (law) is God's sunnah (33:38,62; 35:43)
ll religious practices; daily prayers, obligatory charity, fasting, and pilgrimage come through Abraham (21:73; 2:43,127-128; 2:183; 3:43; 19:31-59; 20:14)
Believers are they whose hearts tremble with awe whenever Allah is mentioned, and when His Verses are recited to them they increase them in faith and on their Sustainer they depend." (Qur'an 8:2)
The Qur'an also says " Say: "Obey Allah and His Messenger.: But if they turn back, Allah loveth not those who reject Faith." Surah Ali Imran ayah 32. How can you obey the Messenger if you don't know him. Also how dare you insult the Sahabah. Allah gave glad tidings of heaven to ten of them while on earth. Zayd Ibn Thabit is mentioned by name in the Qur'an !!. How still can you insult them. You have little to no knowledge of Islam and twist they meanings of ayahs to suit your own agendas.
@TheTsukiyomi69 Obeying messenger doesn't mean obey hadiths. +Verse 6:114 says God revealed his message in a form of a book. Not hadith not narrations. This reason is enough not to believe in hadith. If you are willing to reply with "but"s and "if"s then you are going against Quran. Sorry. PEACE
@MegaMrname So what does obeying the Messenger mean? Rejecting what he said and did? In the Qur'an it says Allah sent Prophet Muhammad so that he could explain and and teach what was in the Qur'an. This explanation and teaching is the hadith and sunnah. And who told you its either one or the other. Your wrong its both or nothing. Its not the Quran or Hadith, true Islam is both the Quran AND authentic hadith.
Salam
P.s. I hope you see the error of your ways and repent. ;)
@TheTsukiyomi69 Error? I showed you an example from Quran, But you are not alone, every hadither behaves like they didn't see the verse. Read the verse 6:114, 39:23
They want to support themselves so they hate anything that goes against what they want. The hadiths tell us how to follow the Prophet by showing us what he did. The hadiths tell us how to make wudu, how to Pray, how much Zak'at to give, and how we should do Hajj. Without these we would have no knowledge of our religion. Allah says in the Qur'an that there is for us in the Prophet Muhammad an excellent example, but how can we follow him if we do not know him or what he did. CONT
"Nor does he say (aught) of (his own) Desire. It is no less than inspiration sent down to him:" Judging by this ayah the hadiths that are proven to be from the Prophet are divine inspiration. All the Ayahs that were displayed were not talking about the hadiths, they were speaking about the changed Bible and Torah and the Muslims that make their own version of Islam to suit their purposes. I believe that those who came up with hating the Hadiths are Shi'as and other Deviant sects in Islam. CONT
Anyone who says they believe in the Qur'an and not the Authentic Hadiths is (and Allah knows Best) not being a Muslim since the 6 fundamentals of faith are to believe in Allah. his angels, his books, his messengers, Judgment day and divine pre-destination. The hadiths are the recordings of the Prophets sayings, actions and decisions. Whatever he said concerning the religion is from God as it says in the Quran Surah An-Najm ayah 3 and 4 CONT
tell me why so many muslims cling to and defend ignorance and outrageous lies for the sake of tradition. the Qur'an speaks against following tradition blindly. are we to fear our dead ignorant forefathers, our parents and our ignorant little communities instead of reasoning toward truth? if we believe the Qur'an is perfect, then we don't need hadith. if the hadith were part of the Qur'an like so many sunnis claim, then the Qur'an would be 100 thousand pages long, but it's not.
Just to give an example of how outrageous the hadith are, the Qur'an says we should not approach women when they're having their period, yet a hadith says Muhammad fondled one of his wives when she was having her period. Think about the millions of muslims who want me to be stoned to death for noticing this kind of ridiculous contradiction. They'll call me a disbeliever for noticing the hypocrisy. And we wonder why so many non-muslims ridicule sunni islam...
"such are the Signs Of Allah, which We rehearse to thee In truth: then in what Exposition will they believe After Allah And His Signs?" (45:6) Abdullah Yousef Ali Translation
Islam is timeless, its about teh heart and intelelcts of the heart and actions combined adn more its about the beleife in ONe TRUE GOD, intereests destroyed before it destroys equity now, adn creates inflation, because richer richer adn poor get poorer, Hadith explained Qur'an before like with abrgation adn it does so now. ti teaches context, CONTEXT!!
6:89 They are those whom We gave the Book, Al-Hukm (understanding of the religious laws), and Prophethood. But if these disbelieve therein (the Book, Al-Hukm and Prophethood), then, indeed We have entrusted it to a people (such as the Companions of Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) who are not disbelievers therein.
THe whole revelation is in gud hands, ANgel Jibreil came down with Hadiths too, ALehas SAlem, they are divine, it is you who should respect Allah's words fool.
"Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah and those with him are harsh with the disbelievers and gentle among themselves. So that the disbelievers may become enraged with them." He then said, "Whoever becomes enraged when the Sahaabah are mentioned is one about whom the verse speaks." [Tafseeer al-Qurtubee, Soorah al-Fath.
sahabas represent beleif, fo you to question them and misquote teh use Arba, because there were alot of Arab pagans before, shows you are the contradicting liar.
@hbk711x with him here الذين معه mean "those who are with his side" and this will make the verse not historical like you claim, as for the Qur'an is not a book of stories or history...as the one who will be مع The prophet is the one who takes his side any time any where.
@hbk711x read the verse 3:31 and 3:32 both of them please in Arabic if you can...and ask yourself a question why in 3:31 he said follow you...but in the next verse follow the messenger?? why didn't he continue and say in once time follow you and those who refuse..to the end...??why did he say once You then The messenger?
Ask yourself what about when the prophet Mohamed was reading the verse 3:31 and 3:32 you will be Mohamed and the Messenger is Mohamed also??Then why it is repeated?
@DaFree0ne Say (Oh Mohamed) If you love Allah follow me...to the end and the next one Say (Oh Mohamed) obey Allah and the Messenger (Mohamed)...???Now Allah already said to Mohamed to follow him now why will he repeat it in the next aya ??
@hbk711x I read and knew and met scholars and the Hadith science, but I didn't find a Method a (Manhaj) simple steps and methods to follow while translating the Qur'an it was all mixed...some times they bring up a "mahzoof" from their brain to stick it up in the Qur'an, some times a (O Mohamed) and millions of times they use words in the Qur'an which has the same meaning of the other...while if this is God's words there will be no way god will put 2 words which has the same meaning...never.
in every language words ahve multiple meaning, science of hadith is grading its trustworthy ness comparing to teh TExts of Wur'an and seeing supporting hadiths and reliablity and biography of the speakers, and I know you don't knwo the biographhy of every speakler leared, so how could you tell, I hvae books on hadith science, on rpatice, but the elarning takes time like learning the biogtaphy emmoerizing Qu'ran, some I did, but barely, it is reliable.
@hbk711x yeah in every language...but not in Every Tongue...or language in the Qur'an is also tongue? so basically you want me to believe that God puts in a words with the meaning x and some others with the same meaning right? is that even Sane? even "Every" language has a lower degree of similarity between words, but since, MSA the Arabic language have 1,000,000 secondary words...it has the highest degree of similarity between words which destroyed the accuracy of the Qur'an...
Why will God give me this words that are equal to each other...what? doesn't he have enough words to refer to each word? and who had the power to say that these words are the same? when he tells me that his words are way more than a sea should I just say ok it is also having the same meaning..never mind...
DOn't follow teh ignorant shia who were fooled by teh JEws, who earn Allah's anger in teh explanation of the Qur'an's first verse.
the message is preserved.
Qur'an says verses are abragoated, but which ones, the hadith explains them and so does TAfseer,
Allah says he is closer to you then your jugular vein, and in another says he arose over his Arsh, so where is he, THe Hadith and saying of the scholars MAy Allah have mercy on them say, he is all knowing etc. from his throne. SEE
@hbk711x As for the biography of dead people.Well, what I know is We have technology they didn't...we have new discovered science they didn't...Mohamed didn't explain the Qur'an...and the only explanation hadiths are taken from Torah genesis verses and are narrated by Ibn abbass and transported by Albukhari.If Ibn abbas was super man, and the 5 or 6 GENERATIONS like 500 narrator. ALL OF THESE GUYS DIED AND GOD GAVE ME A BRAIN AND SELF RESPECT AND I WORSHIP GOD.I will choose my brain for sure.
You got it wrong 1st chapter of Quran: guide us to the path of those who earn your grace, (sahabas MAy Allah be pleased with them) not the path who earn your anger (jEWS) nor those who go astray (X-tians, pagans). Who other then Propeht Muhammad peace adn blessings be upon him would say this. you are following the jewish influneced group the Shia.
Qur'an says to follow hadith, Qur'an and HAdith explain advance sciences, revelation, both got sciences. You are blind to preservation.
Great video spiritualrebel . very well compiled and well made. But i do have a small request if its not too much trouble and i hope that you can fulfill it. It would be really helpful if you could mention the book and number for the 'ahadith' u have mention in reason 2. I can understand that putting them in the video will be hard work but u can put them in the description box. It will be very helpful. Thanks and peace
Finishing Point 2: (by the way: the reader should read last "mikrah" post first and work his/ her way up. I needed 3 comment allocations.The latest will be displayed before the earlier ones. To end: When the people submitted to the (contents of) the reports: they in fact did Islam or Surrender to Allah, since that is what they thought was Allah's guidance. It was a time of unavoidable ignorance. The modern generations (their descendents) NOW need to re-submit to the actual Guidance in Quran.
@mikrah Brother, I run into others that say that speak Arabic and read it but avoid the Qur'an and say things like, "I'm not Qur'an literate." I believe these people are afraid of the truth. It just hurts so bad to see people willingly choosing ignorance, especially since many 'hadith' are degrading, stupid and against God. This leads me to believe that many muslims that were born into it would've been the ones to oppose Muhammad if they lived in the past during Muhammad's time.
@mikrah You often get sour and hateful looks from muslims when you question things and when you challenge commonly held notions. The persecution that many receive for using reason and logic is just plain sad and damaging. I feel like muslims are now no different from the past mistakes of the catholic church. what's worse is the artificial love and absence of love in the muslim community. why is understanding and compassion treating like a sin? it's so crazy. it makes me feel like an alien.
@Acclivous1 : Leave the Muslims to Allah & go out & be an Ambassador of Islam to non-muslims. Give them pure Islam. Forget about fake love & no love. You be the instrument of love & go out there & invite folks to Islam, as best as you can. Check out Surah Kahf: Ayah 4: "To warn those who say Allah has begotten a Son". The Chistians are your 1st mission. It will take a lifetime. Stop wasteing time by preaching to Muslims who copy cat Christians. When OTHERS fully accept Islam THEN we will follow.
Continuing: Point 2 Now: Yes: the Hadith are unauthorised. Yet in what we can refer to as the 1st wave of the early estabishment of Islaam: the hadiths reached the outermost limits of the non-Arabic speaking Ummah at the time; BEFORE the meaning or translation of the Quran hit them. The hadiths were not necessarily in the format of being collated stuff like Sahih al Bukhari etc. They were simply travelers' reports of accurate & inaccurate heresay of what Muhammad SAS, did. Continuing Next:
Glad that there are folks that ACTUALLY read Allah's Message rather than "Guess" or "follow their Fathers". Just: 2 points However: 1.) We are MORE OR LESS directed in Quran to follow the the Messenger, SAS. Yet the only description of his CHARACTER IN THE QURAN is:"There hath come unto you a messenger, (one) of yourselves, unto whom aught that ye are overburdened is grievous, full of concern for you, for the believers full of pity, merciful"-(9:128). As for His Theology: See 2:285. Point 2 next
@SpiritualRebel..nice piece of work, and I dont feel as a muslim why some of the Hadiths should not be questions. If truly Mohammed(PBH) is the prophet of Allah, what is wrong in following his teachings? But the fact still remains that we are all humans and thus we make mistakes. Only Allah is perfect. Another fact is that we 'Muslims' have abandoned the 'Qur'an' and follow more our 'desire'. Allah Guides whom He want to. The title of this work would have been 'why muslims are not progressing'
I wish I have seen this video while i was arguing with this sunni muslim.He swore up and down he was right.When i sent him 6 pages of proof from the quran and do you know what this fool's proof was , a hadith video made by the imam.It disgusted me to know that he thought he was so much better than me.But God blessed you ,thank you for this video.It is very clear.Thank God for people like you.
APP(SA.W) ne QURAN ko kitabi shakal denay se bhi mana kea tha lekin aj QURAN kitabi shakal mei moojod hai.phir hadiths ka inkar kyun????????? hamari zindagi men kai masael atay hen un k solution hadiths se milta hai.PERVAIZ scholar ne bhi un solutions ka btaya hai lekin jo log APP(S.A.W) kay companions se milay wo ziada theek bta saktay hen.of course.A SILENT MESSAGE FOR ALL..............................................
@jinx0r When he is speaking to a hadither...he must uses hadiths because the hadither is the one who believe them...when the hadither speak to him the hadither uses the quran because he rejects the sunna....
You speak to people about what the believe, not what you believe....ABC logic.
@hannahr77 I wanted to know why you said that the Quran has been corrupted? I agree totally with Kavalec..It's the people that can be misguided and not the Quran..That was the true miracle..coz it cannot be corrupted..
@hannahr77 Certainly..So far no contradictions have been found in it..Then how come can it be corrupted?If there had been any contradictions, this will show that it had been corrupted..
Masha'allah! That's perfect. Believers, though, in the 'first reason' will accept Quran words and will make Tobah to listen to any hadith anymore. Since hadith is the word of human-being and can never be equalized to Holy Quran in any aspect.
@conglomerate8 It is slowing dawning upon many muslims, that they should reject out and out the fabrications called "hadith". And that all of us should resort to clear and rational thinking...
@conglomerate8 the hadith is also a recording of the prophet muhammed, quran only muslims dont get that following muhammed's teachings in this world and following allahs word to guide is to a better afterlife is the key
@conglomerate8 The battle of reasoning is not a new one. It has started long back.First rationalist was Umar Ibn Khatab who has the guts to tell the prophet that the book of God is sufficient for us..And the battle continued up to Mutazilism and up till now..It is unfortunate how despite people being so educated and yet cannot reason properly. Let us hope that this battle ends one day and the traditionalists see sense and truth.
Awesome video! I'm not Muslim, but I've been considering converting. Ever since I first heard of what the Hadith were, I found it ridiculous tht poeple would follow it.
It just defies all logic.
I've always felt that a question unanswered in the Qur'an, is an irrelevant one.
And although we are to obey the Prophet, as God has said, God has also let us know the duty of the prophet to decipher what is of the prophet and what is of man. But I'm still learning, so forgive any ignorance I may have.
@catalyst4change I truly respect your use of reason and discernment. A little over a year ago, I was in your position, and by the Grace of God, I did become a Muslim. I agree with all that you've said and continue to, even after all this time has passed. God has given us the fortune of being pardoned for things that the Qur'an remains silent on as a Mercy from Him. Circumstantial morality has always been a dilemma, but the stories of the prophets tackle this issue. May God continue to lead you
@hannahr77 Nowhere in the Quran does it say to follow Hadith. It only says to follow the Messenger. The Quran is riddled with the "doings & sayings" of Muhammad. The Quran is protected by God, your Hadith is not.
Where can you find the 5 pillars of islam in the quran where can you find the 5 prayers in the quran, do you still have the original manuscripts of the quran,
It is a pity that we do not have the faith to accept that the Qur'an is THE PERFECT guidance for mankind.
"This is the Book about which there is no doubt, guidance for those conscious of Allah" Q2:2
That being said, it is necessary to acknowledge that all of these occurrences were destined by Allah SWT and those who are guided or misguided, that is our destiny, as Allah wills. Ameen.
@hannahr77 The notion of the pillars was created by Bukhari, not God. That's why u won't find it in the Quran. And the prayers can be found in the Quran if u just read it without bias. The fact tht u ask for these things shows u dont have faith tht ur Quran is complete and without error. You also cannot find a recipe for Chicken Fajitas in the Quran, does tht mean tht every muslim is obliged to follow the Food Network? No. And whether I hve the original manuscripts or not is irrelevant.
So is the 5 pillars being practied by muslims today, if so then why? And the right number is only recorded in the hadith or should I say the story of how muhammad received the right number of prayers.
@hannahr77 Yes, most Muslims practice these 5 pillars. They follow them bc they rely on the authority & guidance of human beings & Hadith, rather than the Quran. U say "the right number", what makes tht number right? The hadith? Imams? The only authority 2 decide this is God & Muhammad. Their words can b found only n the Quran. U should realize tht n ur efforts 2 prove the authority of the hadith, ur poking holes n the Quran by saying it lacks this & that. In doing this u r degrading the Quran.
The Qur'an also doesn't say that we shouldn't watch pornography; does that mean it's okay now? And you're right about that verse from the Qur'an, where it says to follow the Messenger; that is a command from Allah, so how are you supposed to fulfill this command and follow the Messenger when he's dead and the hadith are corrupt according to you?
@jinx0r I advise u 2 read the Quran, or re-read it without bias, cos the quran speaks out against indecencies, but ur not going 2 find the exact word "porn". The best way 2 follow the messenger is to obey the Quran. The Quran constantly quotes Muhammad & it has commands of god 2 Muhammad 2 say specific things. Is tht not good enough 4 u, tht u hve 2 follow text created by men on the foundations of conjecture & heresay? I would hope you would hve a little more faith in the totality of ur Quran.
Masallah, great video. As you said; it is unfortunate that you had to use hadiths to counter hadiths. One would assume, to most right minded people that the Quran itself would be sufficient. But then again, look at the mess and injustices in the world today brought about by backward minded people adhering to these openly irrational and blasphemous fabrications they attribute to Prophet Muhammad.
due to these false and outdated hadith, Osama Bin Ladin fighting his false jihad by killing innocent, and he quoted a particular hadith several times during his speech to prove his point
Selamun Aleykum, Excellent video - I have learned over time that even when so called "muslims" are presented with the truth and shown directly that their way is not the path...they are prone to act very badly. Little do they reflect on the state and condition of their lives today - truly deaf, dumb and blind.
As soon as the Hadith were implemented into Islamic society thus started the downfall of Islam and the Muslims.
When we followed the Quran and only the Quran we were not only undefeated in battle (Khalid ibn al Walid) but we were unmatched in the fields of Science, Physiology, Technology and lead the world in every possible field. Then came the Hadith followed by the slow decline of the Muslims. The Hadith are sick. Any anyone who follows them will surely burn in the fires of Hell.
does not matter what SECT they belong to.. each group have their own set of HADITH .. and each sect forgets what the QURAN says about forming sects.. )anyone who identifies themselves with a sect. have left the folds of ISLAM)!!
The hadith are too many to count, the very Idea of being expected to read it all and apply it is ridiculous.
How many volumes would it fill? With the aid of computers it could be done, cross referenced by subject etc. BUT if thats the only way it can be delivered to mere mortals, it is definitely impossible people of Mohammad's time.
If you can, sum up the most important ideas and principles in a single, portable volume, do it.
i donno if your a shi3a but, i can tell you one thing, because shi3a are the retards who do not beleave in hadiths,
you should question the shi3a, if they are muslim, cuz they beleave that the quran is not completed so if you are, how dare you post quran senses here, and even then if you are a true muslim how dare you question something to mislead the people? and you dont even know the meanings of the ayat, why dont you go ask a imaam or sheich?
I agree with the poster most of our leaders are corrupt. What she is saying how ever is true. The hadeeth are not holy. They are historical literature. They divide Islam instead of uniting us.
If she was shi3a she her self would be a hypocrite like the ones she attempts to expose. Because Shi3a is not mentioned in Quran either.
Quran is the final word of God. Anything after is irrelevant.
I have a question. If two people who knows nothing about Islam or any religion were placed on two separate Islands and the first one was given the Qur'an and the other one on the other island was given the books of hadith, WHO BETWEEN THE TWO OF THEM WILL BE ABLE TO UNDERSTAND AND PRACTICE ISLAM PROPERLY AND CORRECTLY?
Don't get me wrong. The Qur'an is FAR FAR superion than the hadith. I'm simply saying that for us to understand the message of the Qur'an and what Islam is all about, we have to look at how Rasulullah (saw) lived his life according to the teachings of the Qur'an. How do we find out how he lived his life? We look to the hadith. If not for the hadith, we would not even know how to pray. when to pray, how many rakaa for particular prayer, how to make wudhu, rites of Hajj and many many more.
"The blind and those who can see are not alike, nor are the believers who do good deeds equal to the wicked; yet you seldom think."(Q. 40:58)
There are people who practice Islam without knowing it, just as there are people who believe that they are guided yet they in reality has chosen the devil as their protector.
The best answer I can give u is that God guides whom He wills.
without a DOUBT the QURAN.. it is the ONLY complete book! the only book without errors or ommisions.. the only book you are guranteed to understand.. all you have to do is ASK ALLAH..
there is NO NEED for Hadith.. they were coined / manufactured
@GoldieLP5 Actually, I was placed on an Island "figuratively" where I didn't know Islam, Muslims, of Hadith, but I found the Qur'an and began reading. I learned and now I am Muslim..
@GoldieLP5 im not a scholar but i would have to say the one who has the quran. "this is the book in which there is no doubt. it is a guidance to those that fear allah." and we know that in sura al-qadr that the quran was "sent down on the night of power." no hadith even the so-called hadith al-qudsi can make that claim. so it's up to each individual to choose the words of allah (swt) or the words of men(bukhari,muslim,abu daoud, etc,etc).
@GoldieLP5 The Quran is book of GOD, and hadith......maybe some people have translated it in wrong way bacause its over 1000 years since our prophets lived and much have changed since than.....ask yourself brother, Quran is enough!
@GoldieLP5 I think spiritual rebel is right. Think about it logically,and BTW your question was shocking to put the two in comparisson. Quran from GOD, hadith from MAN. The Quran is for the PEOPLE not for people already practising Islam, it is a book for every single soul, i think sometimes we forget this. Submission to ONE God and not associating GOD with ANYTHING/ANYONE else. The Shaitan will focus more on corrupting Islam then anyother religion because we already have submitted to ONE GOD.
whats the Shaitan done in the years to corrupt Islam ? Maybe the hadiths, because they have no control over the Quran. BTW how many times have people been dismissed from being credible ??? So the people before wouldve followed lies ?? Why would Allah set us on the right track with the Quran and then play with us with hadiths from BTW PEOPLE, you are following PEOPLE, thats haram. I think, this person is correct, i think that the Quran should be followed, there is no need for hadith.
you think practising Islam will come better from man made hadiths than the actual holy book? I may not be the sharpest tool in the shed but even an invalid like me grasps the basic meaning and requirements of the quran. Pray, fast, be righteous, give charity.
Woe to those who take the verses of the Qur'an out of context! These verses does not necessarily refer to what you are reffering to! Its imperative to read the verses before and after the verses you quoted. MashaAllah! I hope this is simply a mistake on your part and that you had no evil intentions in saying/stating the things you said on this video. Alhamdulillah I read the before and after verses! I ALMOST believed the things you said!
It's so much easier to say that these verses are refering to christians or jews. This way we don't have to point the fingers at ourselves, and we can continue committing errors and even take pride in doing so.
The Quran exposes different peoples wrong behaviour, and if we imitate them we are no better simply because we choose to carry another label.
alhamdulilah you cantt believe how happy i am that i stumbled across this :)))
i was just researching and reading about the authorities of hadith... its a bit sad that most people know more ahadtihs then they know quran verses. and the way you showed it, raelly helped reading them with that aproach..
whats so hard to belive that most people know more hadith than the Quran? thats how ALL other religions got twisted.. SOME MULLAH tried to justify his FETISHES and claimed that that particular fetish was also Mohammads..
Blaming .. insulting.. the Prophets has been the BREAD and BUTTER of MULLAHS since the first religion started..
why should islam be any different..
QURAN is ALL WE NEED TO LIVE A PERFECT LIFE.. the mullah can do better than the Quran
Finaly it entails th creation of a sect, something nt jst prohibited in hadith but also th Qu'ran.
The only ones who have created a sect are everybody else. We are actually the only ones getting back to the commun denominator thats going to one day destroy the labels shiaa, sunni, shia, deobandis, ahmediyas etc. once and for all inshallah, when there going to realise that they have set up idols next to Allah.
This video's problems lay in both its method & what flows from its assumptions.
Regarding method, the translations used of the Qu'ran have been selectively chosen, so things are implied in English that are not in the Arabic.
The 2nd is the conclusion that al Muslims since the RasulAllah sws hav been misguided, & Allah has allowed His Ummah to go astray (excpt ths persn & those who share hs view). Finaly it entails th creation of a sect, something nt jst prohibited in hadith but also th Qu'ran.
I wouldnt be able to comment on your first point since I dont speak arabic. But no one is making the argument that Allah has misguided the muslims in the sense that you think about it.since these things are you are seing now are the same that have been revealed back then. The prophet has done his job, but people fail to listen. You go to hell for kufr, not for not knowing. :D The sollution has always been right in front of them. "Dont set up idols next to Allah once you know" : )
The movement that bases everything upon the Qu'ran and neglects the Sunnah of the Rasul (sws) is completely absent in all but resent history. I am yet to meet a single follower of such groups that have any competency in Arabic, let alone Arabic on the level that is required to read the Qu'ran.
Essentially such groups posit that all Muslims since the time of the Prophet (sws) have committed disbelief, save themselves.
I was just wondering about something; in the reason two part of the video you gave some quotations from the Hadith(s). I just wanted to know what are the Volume,Book,Number they can be found. If you could supply this, it would be greatly appreciated :D
You are right, the references should be there. I had some problems adding them to the video after posting it, but since you made the request, I'll put it up in the video information box.
Thanks, I'm glad the logic of the arguments came through. All i want is to make people understand my point of view on this matter. My intention is not to step on peoples toes. I invite anyone who disagrees with me to share their perspective on things. There is no need for anger and rage.
i would like the book and volume to these hadith please and if its not much to ask could you give me hadiths that contradict each other mostly so called authentic ones that leave these guys speechless so i get ready for my counterattack chances are they might block or ban me but its worth taking the risk
What I think is really happening too, is as Islam has stretched to America where we are quite critical and do not mind questioning even our religious principles.. those who have reverted to islam and are american have questioned hadiths from those who are perhaps from a middle-eastern family they learned about islam from and have seen through the haze of hadith with fresh eyes that someone born and raised never thought to question.
I agree with u. if people just focused on the book, instead of their preconceived ideas about it, a lot of problems could be solved, but when conjecture is added to a religion and people believe it without questioning, the breedingground for hypocracy and falsehood is bound to grow.
Pride can be good, but accompanied with arrogance it will only bear rotten fruit.
The Quran teaches questioning and confirming over blind following and conforming.
@serenechaos2 I am an Arabian, and I totally reject these fake stories. These clerics of petrol and King Faisal and Saudi Arabia corruption has taken over Islam.
I have always stated that the Quran is the word of God and the hadiths are the words of man. But so many people seem to put more credence in the hadiths than the Quran. When you question the hadiths they label you a blasphemer and heretic.
please check out others right here on YT manicwild, whereistruth seems like every single day i find a NEW Brother / sister who is talking about the FALSEHOOD of HADITH
But No where in the Quran does it say how to pray, no where in the quran does how much zakat we should give etc..
Allah says in the quran "If you love me follow Muahmmad peace and blessings be upon him." Therefore we have to be careful and those hadiths that agree with the quran and are consisitent we will have to agree, but if some are against then we won't agree.
I hope no one takes offensive what I said.. Ppeace to everyone
The Quran describes itself as complete, fully detailed and free from contradictions. No offence, but YOU are the one creating the contradiction when u claim the exact opposite. Your argument "how would we know..." is a very classical one but it falls flat when examined.
I know the hadiths are full of universal wisdom but they are also full of false claims labeled as "sahih", and u need to be careful about what u associate and attribute to Allah and His teachings.
"Believe nothing merely because you have been told it. Do not believe what your teacher tells you merely out of respect for the teacher. But whatsoever, after due examination and analysis, you find to be kind, conducive to the good, the benefit, the welfare of all beings -- that doctrine believe and cling to, and take it as your guide."
There is not a single person on this earth that doesn't deserve questioning. I agree with u.
Good video, thanks. They recite Al-Fatihah numerous times per day. Yet, it is commonly explained that those whose portion is wrath is the Jews, and those who went astray were the Christians. WE KNOW FROM THE QUR'AN HOW THAT HAPPENED, so avoid their behavior! Do not make gods out of the mullahs, sheiks, scholars, and man-made ahaddith by obeying their words. Not one of them will be able to ransom you, intercede for you, nor save you at the last day. The Qur'an is the Criterion- nothing else.
NaturalRepublic 4 days ago
This video is perfect sense. Hadiths are filled with contradictions and not making sense.And this person said his brother saw Mohammad on the 2 nd Wednesday,bunch of nonsense. The Holy Quran, now that has a CODE to it they found out,many things like God being mentioned,Mohammad,and about 12 other things are all divisible by 19.So what 19? God placed 19 angels over hell that's why,In Quran says He fixed their number,sofelievers get stronger,and doubters realize it is the truth. Perfection.
LisaLisa2525ify 5 days ago
This video cleared alot of doubts I had of hadiths as a new convert. I would read some great hadiths but then some very violent ones. I said to myself how could this man be a prophet of God? It was God who lead me to this video. I always doubted most hadiths that were 'authentic' but never rejected the prophet (saw.) Thank you so much for this video, it touches my heart and reassures me that I am not wrong for doubting hadith. I will follow Qur'an like Allah intended! Jazakallah Khier! :)
JonnyBoy723 1 week ago
Where does the Quran tell the believer HOW to pray?
atwaterkent911 3 weeks ago
This is absolutely brilliant!!!!! I have nearly left Islam because of the bullying I have received for saying that the Qur'an is complete.... alhamdulillah there are people with brains out there who GET IT!!!!
Taggernuts 1 month ago 6
so according this hadith prophet mohmmed was a big hypocrite
We were with the messenger of Allah, PBUH and he asked for a drink. One of his men said: "Oh Messenger of Allah, Can we offer you wine to drink?" He said Yes. He (Gaber) went out looking for the drink and came back with a cup of wine. The messenger (Peace Be Upon him) asked, “Have you covered it with a twig in a transverse manner” He (Gaber) said, “Yes” and he (Muhammad) drank.Sahih Muslim - Hadith #3753
i am better than da prophet
crappyhadith1 2 months ago
@crappyhadith1 TheTsukiyomi69 said that Allah sent messenger to "explain" what was in Quran. I could not stop laughing. Quran says that Phophets job is to "deliver" the message. Message = Quran. That's it. But hadithers literally worship Mohammad. What if there was a hadith that Prophet's favourite color was yellow, and he disliked purple. They will "issue" a ruling that liking purple is "haram". Just like they made other things haram
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname
mate i follow quran beacsue i can understand it
found islam from quran
i just posted that below comment to show hadiths are crapp and junk
crappyhadith1 2 months ago
@crappyhadith1 And I just posted a reply to you that I support your views. Quran needs no deciphering
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname The Qur'an needs no deciphering IF you believe, ponder and understand. It repeats this countless times in the Qur'an. "we have revealed this to a believing people" or an understanding people. Unfortunately not everyone believes or understands or ponders about Allah's revelation. Especially this new cult known as "Quranists" who label all the good muslims who follow Allah and his messenger a "hadither". If being a muslim who follows Allah makes me a "hadither" then good.
TheTsukiyomi69 2 months ago
@MegaMrname I can't believe you believe that Prophet Muhammad did not come to teach the Qur'an as well as deliver it. It says in the Holy Qur'an "Even as We have sent among you an Apostle from among you who recites to you Our communications and purifies you and teaches you the Book and the wisdom and teaches you that which you did not know." Surah 2 ayah151. As you can see it say ".. and teaches you that which you did not know." meaning that Muhammad taught the Qur'an and Sunnah.
TheTsukiyomi69 2 months ago
@TheTsukiyomi69 Hey, What is wrong with you? I BEG YOU Please did you read the verse I sent you? 6:114? This verse is definitely against HADITH and other "narrrations". Please don't write emotional things. Just answer the verse. PLEASEEEEE
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname It says "Shall i take a judge beside Allah while it is he who has revealed the Book explained in detail..." The hadiths come from the Prophet Muhammad. Everything he said about religion is divine Inspiration (Surah 53 Verse 3 and 4). Therefore The authentic hadiths about the Prophet Muhammad's sayings are divine inspiration from Allah. The Qur'an is divine revelation to mankind from Allah. Both are from Allah. There is my answer. If you disbelieve after this than i pity u
TheTsukiyomi69 1 month ago
@TheTsukiyomi69 Again you are ignoring my comments. What about the verse where it says QURAN IS CONSISTENT WITHIN ITSELF? STOP ACTING LIKE A KID
MegaMrname 1 month ago 2
@crappyhadith1 Astaghfirullah many people have been led astray by this incorrect translation. In the Arabic "a cup of grape juice" but has been translated to say "a cup of wine". As we know grape juice is unfermented and there for not an intoxicant, where as wine is an intoxicant. Brother its not wine its grape juice. The Prophet Muhammad said that which intoxicates in small quantities is forbidden in large quantities. You are no where NEAR being better that Prophet Muhammad.
TheTsukiyomi69 2 months ago
@TheTsukiyomi69 yo fuck face when did i say i am better than him
u misunderstood me i said if prophet mo ever, drunk then that will make me better than him but this crappy hadith is fake (they all are)
u gay hadith readers are dumb so shut up mate
crappyhadith1 2 months ago
@crappyhadith1 I find it hard to believe you are a Muslim by the way you talk but nevertheless. The hadith was not fake, what you wrote was fake and changed but i have the real hadith with me. Look If you want to follow other than what the Prophet did than fine to you is your way and to me is mine. Allah will judge between us on the Day of Judgment. Than you will not find any escape. Please come to truth of Islam and don't be fooled by Youtube messengers. Peace .
p.s don't reply
TheTsukiyomi69 1 month ago
Comment removed
crappyhadith1 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@TheTsukiyomi69
one question did prophet followed hadith or quran
if he did follow hadith how, when they were written 2-300 years after him?
put the quran and those man made books with the quran
i do not car if hadith say they need to be followed
when quran says
The Quran contains everything that we need for guidance (16:89)
We have been commanded to follow the Quran alone (7:2-3; 17:46)
were did the prophet 5 namaz and shada from? quran
crappyhadith1 1 month ago
@TheTsukiyomi69
The best hadith is the Quran (39:23).
The only sunnah (law) is God's sunnah (33:38,62; 35:43)
ll religious practices; daily prayers, obligatory charity, fasting, and pilgrimage come through Abraham (21:73; 2:43,127-128; 2:183; 3:43; 19:31-59; 20:14)
crappyhadith1 1 month ago 2
@TheTsukiyomi69
God revealed the Quran to Muhammad, His messenger and last prophet (27:6).
The only book that the messenger delivered to the world is the Quran (6:19)
The Quran is easy to understand for believers; while it is impossible for idol worshipers (54:17,22,32,40; 17:46; 18:57)
hadith is idol worship
why is it a sin drinking water while standing up? it is in ur hadith u can explain to me
thanks
crappyhadith1 1 month ago 2
@TheTsukiyomi69
"Today I have perfected your religion for you and chosen surrender [to your Lord]: Islam as your religion." [Qur'an 5:3]
islam is complate what is ur point?
God's word is perfect (6:115). Those who follow conjecture are diverted (6:112)
why do they mock prophets?, the hadiths?
crappyhadith1 1 month ago 3
@TheTsukiyomi69
Those who are not certain about the hereafter, are not satisfied with the Quran, they want to amend it with other books (10:15)
when allah says it, we quran only followers allahs words we shall not bow to bukahari satan
crappyhadith1 1 month ago 3
@crappyhadith1 10000 thumbs ups from me :)
MegaMrname 1 month ago
@TheTsukiyomi69
Believers are they whose hearts tremble with awe whenever Allah is mentioned, and when His Verses are recited to them they increase them in faith and on their Sustainer they depend." (Qur'an 8:2)
thats what we quranists do
ur so dumb mate
crappyhadith1 1 month ago 4
Sorry i made a small mistake in my last post. Zaid ibn Harith is mentioned in the Qur'an not Zaid ibn Thabit.
TheTsukiyomi69 2 months ago
The Qur'an also says " Say: "Obey Allah and His Messenger.: But if they turn back, Allah loveth not those who reject Faith." Surah Ali Imran ayah 32. How can you obey the Messenger if you don't know him. Also how dare you insult the Sahabah. Allah gave glad tidings of heaven to ten of them while on earth. Zayd Ibn Thabit is mentioned by name in the Qur'an !!. How still can you insult them. You have little to no knowledge of Islam and twist they meanings of ayahs to suit your own agendas.
TheTsukiyomi69 2 months ago
@TheTsukiyomi69 Obeying messenger doesn't mean obey hadiths. +Verse 6:114 says God revealed his message in a form of a book. Not hadith not narrations. This reason is enough not to believe in hadith. If you are willing to reply with "but"s and "if"s then you are going against Quran. Sorry. PEACE
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname So what does obeying the Messenger mean? Rejecting what he said and did? In the Qur'an it says Allah sent Prophet Muhammad so that he could explain and and teach what was in the Qur'an. This explanation and teaching is the hadith and sunnah. And who told you its either one or the other. Your wrong its both or nothing. Its not the Quran or Hadith, true Islam is both the Quran AND authentic hadith.
Salam
P.s. I hope you see the error of your ways and repent. ;)
TheTsukiyomi69 2 months ago
@TheTsukiyomi69 Error? I showed you an example from Quran, But you are not alone, every hadither behaves like they didn't see the verse. Read the verse 6:114, 39:23
P.S I hope you will repent soon :-)
MegaMrname 2 months ago
They want to support themselves so they hate anything that goes against what they want. The hadiths tell us how to follow the Prophet by showing us what he did. The hadiths tell us how to make wudu, how to Pray, how much Zak'at to give, and how we should do Hajj. Without these we would have no knowledge of our religion. Allah says in the Qur'an that there is for us in the Prophet Muhammad an excellent example, but how can we follow him if we do not know him or what he did. CONT
TheTsukiyomi69 2 months ago
"Nor does he say (aught) of (his own) Desire. It is no less than inspiration sent down to him:" Judging by this ayah the hadiths that are proven to be from the Prophet are divine inspiration. All the Ayahs that were displayed were not talking about the hadiths, they were speaking about the changed Bible and Torah and the Muslims that make their own version of Islam to suit their purposes. I believe that those who came up with hating the Hadiths are Shi'as and other Deviant sects in Islam. CONT
TheTsukiyomi69 2 months ago
Anyone who says they believe in the Qur'an and not the Authentic Hadiths is (and Allah knows Best) not being a Muslim since the 6 fundamentals of faith are to believe in Allah. his angels, his books, his messengers, Judgment day and divine pre-destination. The hadiths are the recordings of the Prophets sayings, actions and decisions. Whatever he said concerning the religion is from God as it says in the Quran Surah An-Najm ayah 3 and 4 CONT
TheTsukiyomi69 2 months ago
tell me why so many muslims cling to and defend ignorance and outrageous lies for the sake of tradition. the Qur'an speaks against following tradition blindly. are we to fear our dead ignorant forefathers, our parents and our ignorant little communities instead of reasoning toward truth? if we believe the Qur'an is perfect, then we don't need hadith. if the hadith were part of the Qur'an like so many sunnis claim, then the Qur'an would be 100 thousand pages long, but it's not.
Acclivous1 2 months ago
Just to give an example of how outrageous the hadith are, the Qur'an says we should not approach women when they're having their period, yet a hadith says Muhammad fondled one of his wives when she was having her period. Think about the millions of muslims who want me to be stoned to death for noticing this kind of ridiculous contradiction. They'll call me a disbeliever for noticing the hypocrisy. And we wonder why so many non-muslims ridicule sunni islam...
Acclivous1 2 months ago
VERY INTERESTING!!!
nathitalinda 3 months ago
Comment removed
Abz90L 3 months ago
OMG! What is the name of the music in the video! Someone please tell me!!!!!!!
mahdidi96 3 months ago
I picked up the Quran and saw his reference was not true for (45:6) so I stopped watching
Shanwar01 3 months ago
"such are the Signs Of Allah, which We rehearse to thee In truth: then in what Exposition will they believe After Allah And His Signs?" (45:6) Abdullah Yousef Ali Translation
Shanwar01 3 months ago
I like the video a lot - but you rushed through it ; I was only able to read some verses in entirety.
Great work, though...
IslamNotMuslims 4 months ago
Excellent video. Nice music too!
e17jack 5 months ago
Get a MOhsin Khan Qur'an that will show you teh direct realtionship between Qur'an adn Hadiths.
hbk711x 5 months ago
Islam is timeless, its about teh heart and intelelcts of the heart and actions combined adn more its about the beleife in ONe TRUE GOD, intereests destroyed before it destroys equity now, adn creates inflation, because richer richer adn poor get poorer, Hadith explained Qur'an before like with abrgation adn it does so now. ti teaches context, CONTEXT!!
hbk711x 5 months ago
6:89 They are those whom We gave the Book, Al-Hukm (understanding of the religious laws), and Prophethood. But if these disbelieve therein (the Book, Al-Hukm and Prophethood), then, indeed We have entrusted it to a people (such as the Companions of Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) who are not disbelievers therein.
THe whole revelation is in gud hands, ANgel Jibreil came down with Hadiths too, ALehas SAlem, they are divine, it is you who should respect Allah's words fool.
hbk711x 5 months ago
"Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah and those with him are harsh with the disbelievers and gentle among themselves. So that the disbelievers may become enraged with them." He then said, "Whoever becomes enraged when the Sahaabah are mentioned is one about whom the verse speaks." [Tafseeer al-Qurtubee, Soorah al-Fath.
sahabas represent beleif, fo you to question them and misquote teh use Arba, because there were alot of Arab pagans before, shows you are the contradicting liar.
hbk711x 6 months ago
@hbk711x with him here الذين معه mean "those who are with his side" and this will make the verse not historical like you claim, as for the Qur'an is not a book of stories or history...as the one who will be مع The prophet is the one who takes his side any time any where.
DaFree0ne 5 months ago
Only those who walk teh path of the fooislish shia and don'ty know wbout Qur'an science adn Hadith science or there schoalrs question hadith
Ayah 3:31 states to folow the Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upn him to gain Allah's love, which is the hadith.
hbk711x 6 months ago
@hbk711x
upon*
hbk711x 6 months ago
@hbk711x read the verse 3:31 and 3:32 both of them please in Arabic if you can...and ask yourself a question why in 3:31 he said follow you...but in the next verse follow the messenger?? why didn't he continue and say in once time follow you and those who refuse..to the end...??why did he say once You then The messenger?
Ask yourself what about when the prophet Mohamed was reading the verse 3:31 and 3:32 you will be Mohamed and the Messenger is Mohamed also??Then why it is repeated?
DaFree0ne 5 months ago
@DaFree0ne Say (Oh Mohamed) If you love Allah follow me...to the end and the next one Say (Oh Mohamed) obey Allah and the Messenger (Mohamed)...???Now Allah already said to Mohamed to follow him now why will he repeat it in the next aya ??
DaFree0ne 5 months ago
@hbk711x I read and knew and met scholars and the Hadith science, but I didn't find a Method a (Manhaj) simple steps and methods to follow while translating the Qur'an it was all mixed...some times they bring up a "mahzoof" from their brain to stick it up in the Qur'an, some times a (O Mohamed) and millions of times they use words in the Qur'an which has the same meaning of the other...while if this is God's words there will be no way god will put 2 words which has the same meaning...never.
DaFree0ne 5 months ago
@DaFree0ne
in every language words ahve multiple meaning, science of hadith is grading its trustworthy ness comparing to teh TExts of Wur'an and seeing supporting hadiths and reliablity and biography of the speakers, and I know you don't knwo the biographhy of every speakler leared, so how could you tell, I hvae books on hadith science, on rpatice, but the elarning takes time like learning the biogtaphy emmoerizing Qu'ran, some I did, but barely, it is reliable.
hbk711x 5 months ago
@hbk711x yeah in every language...but not in Every Tongue...or language in the Qur'an is also tongue? so basically you want me to believe that God puts in a words with the meaning x and some others with the same meaning right? is that even Sane? even "Every" language has a lower degree of similarity between words, but since, MSA the Arabic language have 1,000,000 secondary words...it has the highest degree of similarity between words which destroyed the accuracy of the Qur'an...
DaFree0ne 5 months ago
@hbk711x so الذين هادوا= اليهود=بنى إسرائيل
النبى=الرسول
الله=إله
الذكر=القران=السنة=الروايات
الكتاب=الكتب=القران=التوراة=الإنجيل
Why will God give me this words that are equal to each other...what? doesn't he have enough words to refer to each word? and who had the power to say that these words are the same? when he tells me that his words are way more than a sea should I just say ok it is also having the same meaning..never mind...
Please man, respect God and his words :)
DaFree0ne 5 months ago
@DaFree0ne
DOn't follow teh ignorant shia who were fooled by teh JEws, who earn Allah's anger in teh explanation of the Qur'an's first verse.
the message is preserved.
Qur'an says verses are abragoated, but which ones, the hadith explains them and so does TAfseer,
Allah says he is closer to you then your jugular vein, and in another says he arose over his Arsh, so where is he, THe Hadith and saying of the scholars MAy Allah have mercy on them say, he is all knowing etc. from his throne. SEE
hbk711x 5 months ago
@hbk711x As for the biography of dead people.Well, what I know is We have technology they didn't...we have new discovered science they didn't...Mohamed didn't explain the Qur'an...and the only explanation hadiths are taken from Torah genesis verses and are narrated by Ibn abbass and transported by Albukhari.If Ibn abbas was super man, and the 5 or 6 GENERATIONS like 500 narrator. ALL OF THESE GUYS DIED AND GOD GAVE ME A BRAIN AND SELF RESPECT AND I WORSHIP GOD.I will choose my brain for sure.
DaFree0ne 5 months ago
@DaFree0ne
You got it wrong 1st chapter of Quran: guide us to the path of those who earn your grace, (sahabas MAy Allah be pleased with them) not the path who earn your anger (jEWS) nor those who go astray (X-tians, pagans). Who other then Propeht Muhammad peace adn blessings be upon him would say this. you are following the jewish influneced group the Shia.
Qur'an says to follow hadith, Qur'an and HAdith explain advance sciences, revelation, both got sciences. You are blind to preservation.
hbk711x 5 months ago
Allah commended Prophet Mohammad to do the 5 daily prayers, as stated in the Quran. How did the WAY to do the prayers taught to us???
iMFixer 7 months ago
Great video spiritualrebel . very well compiled and well made. But i do have a small request if its not too much trouble and i hope that you can fulfill it. It would be really helpful if you could mention the book and number for the 'ahadith' u have mention in reason 2. I can understand that putting them in the video will be hard work but u can put them in the description box. It will be very helpful. Thanks and peace
hamza2gud 8 months ago
This is a wonderful video and it is a real eye opener.
LittleQueenTudor 8 months ago
Finishing Point 2: (by the way: the reader should read last "mikrah" post first and work his/ her way up. I needed 3 comment allocations.The latest will be displayed before the earlier ones. To end: When the people submitted to the (contents of) the reports: they in fact did Islam or Surrender to Allah, since that is what they thought was Allah's guidance. It was a time of unavoidable ignorance. The modern generations (their descendents) NOW need to re-submit to the actual Guidance in Quran.
mikrah 9 months ago
@mikrah Brother, I run into others that say that speak Arabic and read it but avoid the Qur'an and say things like, "I'm not Qur'an literate." I believe these people are afraid of the truth. It just hurts so bad to see people willingly choosing ignorance, especially since many 'hadith' are degrading, stupid and against God. This leads me to believe that many muslims that were born into it would've been the ones to oppose Muhammad if they lived in the past during Muhammad's time.
Acclivous1 9 months ago
@mikrah You often get sour and hateful looks from muslims when you question things and when you challenge commonly held notions. The persecution that many receive for using reason and logic is just plain sad and damaging. I feel like muslims are now no different from the past mistakes of the catholic church. what's worse is the artificial love and absence of love in the muslim community. why is understanding and compassion treating like a sin? it's so crazy. it makes me feel like an alien.
Acclivous1 9 months ago
@Acclivous1 : Leave the Muslims to Allah & go out & be an Ambassador of Islam to non-muslims. Give them pure Islam. Forget about fake love & no love. You be the instrument of love & go out there & invite folks to Islam, as best as you can. Check out Surah Kahf: Ayah 4: "To warn those who say Allah has begotten a Son". The Chistians are your 1st mission. It will take a lifetime. Stop wasteing time by preaching to Muslims who copy cat Christians. When OTHERS fully accept Islam THEN we will follow.
mikrah 9 months ago
@mikrah
"Leave the Muslims to Allah & go out & be an Ambassador of Islam to non-muslims. "
how can a MUSLIM go out to NON-MUSLIMS.. when your OWN house is on fire.. your own house is being destroyed from within by the HADITHER TERMITES!!
I have invited 1000s to islam only to be embaressed by the current practices of these HADIHTERS.. which they pass off as ISLAM.
going out to NON-MUSLIMS will NOT be needed if the EVIL of HADIHTERISM is ELIMINATED which lies within
QuranVsHadith 8 months ago
Continuing: Point 2 Now: Yes: the Hadith are unauthorised. Yet in what we can refer to as the 1st wave of the early estabishment of Islaam: the hadiths reached the outermost limits of the non-Arabic speaking Ummah at the time; BEFORE the meaning or translation of the Quran hit them. The hadiths were not necessarily in the format of being collated stuff like Sahih al Bukhari etc. They were simply travelers' reports of accurate & inaccurate heresay of what Muhammad SAS, did. Continuing Next:
mikrah 9 months ago
Glad that there are folks that ACTUALLY read Allah's Message rather than "Guess" or "follow their Fathers". Just: 2 points However: 1.) We are MORE OR LESS directed in Quran to follow the the Messenger, SAS. Yet the only description of his CHARACTER IN THE QURAN is:"There hath come unto you a messenger, (one) of yourselves, unto whom aught that ye are overburdened is grievous, full of concern for you, for the believers full of pity, merciful"-(9:128). As for His Theology: See 2:285. Point 2 next
mikrah 9 months ago
May Allah swt bless you for your efforts in this video. I.A. Ameen
madmanmio 10 months ago 2
@SpiritualRebel..nice piece of work, and I dont feel as a muslim why some of the Hadiths should not be questions. If truly Mohammed(PBH) is the prophet of Allah, what is wrong in following his teachings? But the fact still remains that we are all humans and thus we make mistakes. Only Allah is perfect. Another fact is that we 'Muslims' have abandoned the 'Qur'an' and follow more our 'desire'. Allah Guides whom He want to. The title of this work would have been 'why muslims are not progressing'
onemenbody 10 months ago
I wish I have seen this video while i was arguing with this sunni muslim.He swore up and down he was right.When i sent him 6 pages of proof from the quran and do you know what this fool's proof was , a hadith video made by the imam.It disgusted me to know that he thought he was so much better than me.But God blessed you ,thank you for this video.It is very clear.Thank God for people like you.
robinvalentine09 11 months ago
Comment removed
fatimaaaable 1 year ago
APP(SA.W) ne QURAN ko kitabi shakal denay se bhi mana kea tha lekin aj QURAN kitabi shakal mei moojod hai.phir hadiths ka inkar kyun????????? hamari zindagi men kai masael atay hen un k solution hadiths se milta hai.PERVAIZ scholar ne bhi un solutions ka btaya hai lekin jo log APP(S.A.W) kay companions se milay wo ziada theek bta saktay hen.of course.A SILENT MESSAGE FOR ALL..............................................
fatimaaaable 1 year ago
It is ironic how you reject hadith, yet you use a hadith to support your own argument at the beginning of the video.
jinx0r 1 year ago
@jinx0r When he is speaking to a hadither...he must uses hadiths because the hadither is the one who believe them...when the hadither speak to him the hadither uses the quran because he rejects the sunna....
You speak to people about what the believe, not what you believe....ABC logic.
DaFree0ne 6 months ago
Yeah, "crusadah" some dude on youtube, and many many scholars over the centuries.
Yours is the usual understanding, but it ignores a dangerous an important fact:
Allah warns us that Iblis will be continuously out to divert us from the straight path Allah has given us.
Iblis CAN NOT corrupt the Quran.
He CAN corrupt and/or mislead human beings.
Human beings are the "science" and mechanism of hadith preservation and evaluation.
Kavalec 1 year ago
@Kavalec
you should know that iblis has already corrupted the quran
hannahr77 1 year ago
@hannahr77 I wanted to know why you said that the Quran has been corrupted? I agree totally with Kavalec..It's the people that can be misguided and not the Quran..That was the true miracle..coz it cannot be corrupted..
SorayaFreethinker 1 year ago
@SorayaFreethinker
So your telling me that the quran you have today is the same quran at the time of muhammad it's the original scriptures
hannahr77 1 year ago
@hannahr77 Certainly..So far no contradictions have been found in it..Then how come can it be corrupted?If there had been any contradictions, this will show that it had been corrupted..
SorayaFreethinker 1 year ago
so some dude on youtube thinks he knows more about islam than 1400 years of scholars and imaams. ok.
crusadah 1 year ago
Masha'allah! That's perfect. Believers, though, in the 'first reason' will accept Quran words and will make Tobah to listen to any hadith anymore. Since hadith is the word of human-being and can never be equalized to Holy Quran in any aspect.
conglomerate8 1 year ago 3
@conglomerate8 It is slowing dawning upon many muslims, that they should reject out and out the fabrications called "hadith". And that all of us should resort to clear and rational thinking...
AbdullahSerif 1 year ago
@conglomerate8 the hadith is also a recording of the prophet muhammed, quran only muslims dont get that following muhammed's teachings in this world and following allahs word to guide is to a better afterlife is the key
longlivereligion 1 year ago
@conglomerate8 The battle of reasoning is not a new one. It has started long back.First rationalist was Umar Ibn Khatab who has the guts to tell the prophet that the book of God is sufficient for us..And the battle continued up to Mutazilism and up till now..It is unfortunate how despite people being so educated and yet cannot reason properly. Let us hope that this battle ends one day and the traditionalists see sense and truth.
SorayaFreethinker 1 year ago
Awesome video! I'm not Muslim, but I've been considering converting. Ever since I first heard of what the Hadith were, I found it ridiculous tht poeple would follow it.
It just defies all logic.
I've always felt that a question unanswered in the Qur'an, is an irrelevant one.
And although we are to obey the Prophet, as God has said, God has also let us know the duty of the prophet to decipher what is of the prophet and what is of man. But I'm still learning, so forgive any ignorance I may have.
catalyst4change 1 year ago 3
@catalyst4change I truly respect your use of reason and discernment. A little over a year ago, I was in your position, and by the Grace of God, I did become a Muslim. I agree with all that you've said and continue to, even after all this time has passed. God has given us the fortune of being pardoned for things that the Qur'an remains silent on as a Mercy from Him. Circumstantial morality has always been a dilemma, but the stories of the prophets tackle this issue. May God continue to lead you
Acclivous1 1 year ago
@catalyst4change
if your a muslim your obliged to follow the hadith which are the doings and sayings of muhammad
hannahr77 1 year ago
@hannahr77 Nowhere in the Quran does it say to follow Hadith. It only says to follow the Messenger. The Quran is riddled with the "doings & sayings" of Muhammad. The Quran is protected by God, your Hadith is not.
catalyst4change 1 year ago
@catalyst4change
Where can you find the 5 pillars of islam in the quran where can you find the 5 prayers in the quran, do you still have the original manuscripts of the quran,
hannahr77 1 year ago
@hannahr77 As for number praying 5 times, the verses are clear , for your references:
1) The Dawn Prayer (Fajr in Arabic) given in 11:114, 24:58
(2) The Noon Prayer (Zuher in Arabic) , given in 17:78 and 30:18
(3) The Afternoon Prayer (Asr in Arabic), given in 2:238
(4) The sunset Prayer (Maghrib in Arabic), given in 11:114
(5) The Night Prayer (Isha in Arabic), given in 24:58
SorayaFreethinker 1 year ago
@SorayaFreethinker Masha Allah! thank you for sharing that.
It is a pity that we do not have the faith to accept that the Qur'an is THE PERFECT guidance for mankind.
"This is the Book about which there is no doubt, guidance for those conscious of Allah" Q2:2
That being said, it is necessary to acknowledge that all of these occurrences were destined by Allah SWT and those who are guided or misguided, that is our destiny, as Allah wills. Ameen.
maali72 9 months ago
@hannahr77 The notion of the pillars was created by Bukhari, not God. That's why u won't find it in the Quran. And the prayers can be found in the Quran if u just read it without bias. The fact tht u ask for these things shows u dont have faith tht ur Quran is complete and without error. You also cannot find a recipe for Chicken Fajitas in the Quran, does tht mean tht every muslim is obliged to follow the Food Network? No. And whether I hve the original manuscripts or not is irrelevant.
catalyst4change 1 year ago
@catalyst4change
So is the 5 pillars being practied by muslims today, if so then why? And the right number is only recorded in the hadith or should I say the story of how muhammad received the right number of prayers.
hannahr77 1 year ago
@hannahr77 Yes, most Muslims practice these 5 pillars. They follow them bc they rely on the authority & guidance of human beings & Hadith, rather than the Quran. U say "the right number", what makes tht number right? The hadith? Imams? The only authority 2 decide this is God & Muhammad. Their words can b found only n the Quran. U should realize tht n ur efforts 2 prove the authority of the hadith, ur poking holes n the Quran by saying it lacks this & that. In doing this u r degrading the Quran.
catalyst4change 1 year ago
@catalyst4change
The Qur'an also doesn't say that we shouldn't watch pornography; does that mean it's okay now? And you're right about that verse from the Qur'an, where it says to follow the Messenger; that is a command from Allah, so how are you supposed to fulfill this command and follow the Messenger when he's dead and the hadith are corrupt according to you?
jinx0r 1 year ago
@jinx0r I advise u 2 read the Quran, or re-read it without bias, cos the quran speaks out against indecencies, but ur not going 2 find the exact word "porn". The best way 2 follow the messenger is to obey the Quran. The Quran constantly quotes Muhammad & it has commands of god 2 Muhammad 2 say specific things. Is tht not good enough 4 u, tht u hve 2 follow text created by men on the foundations of conjecture & heresay? I would hope you would hve a little more faith in the totality of ur Quran.
catalyst4change 1 year ago
Bismillahirrahmanirrahim
Masallah, great video. As you said; it is unfortunate that you had to use hadiths to counter hadiths. One would assume, to most right minded people that the Quran itself would be sufficient. But then again, look at the mess and injustices in the world today brought about by backward minded people adhering to these openly irrational and blasphemous fabrications they attribute to Prophet Muhammad.
AbdullahSerif 1 year ago
whoever put this clip on here is very very wrong the propjets word is never wrong go and study more before you say all this
nazar111 1 year ago
due to these false and outdated hadith, Osama Bin Ladin fighting his false jihad by killing innocent, and he quoted a particular hadith several times during his speech to prove his point
asfar000 1 year ago 2
It is time for those who worship ALLAH ALONE to lead the way in this world toward for peace and salvation.
AbdullahSerif 1 year ago
Selamun Aleykum, Excellent video - I have learned over time that even when so called "muslims" are presented with the truth and shown directly that their way is not the path...they are prone to act very badly. Little do they reflect on the state and condition of their lives today - truly deaf, dumb and blind.
NormanMHamilton 1 year ago
Fantastic
Amazing
Shocking
Mind blowing
Eye opener
Jazakallah khair for this video. Loved every second of it. It speaks the truth and not nothingbut the truth.
szuberi 1 year ago
As soon as the Hadith were implemented into Islamic society thus started the downfall of Islam and the Muslims.
When we followed the Quran and only the Quran we were not only undefeated in battle (Khalid ibn al Walid) but we were unmatched in the fields of Science, Physiology, Technology and lead the world in every possible field. Then came the Hadith followed by the slow decline of the Muslims. The Hadith are sick. Any anyone who follows them will surely burn in the fires of Hell.
ReligionofAbraham1 1 year ago 8
sunni hadith followers are stupid
Quranists is original islam
jigglyfidda125 2 years ago
@jigglyfidda125 ..
does not matter what SECT they belong to.. each group have their own set of HADITH .. and each sect forgets what the QURAN says about forming sects.. )anyone who identifies themselves with a sect. have left the folds of ISLAM)!!
ALL SECTS are NOT ALLOWED..
QuranVsHadith 1 year ago 2
@jigglyfidda125 : now, don't just name people. We are Muslims and we follow the Qur'an. No Sunni, No Quranist.
bagh98 1 year ago
@jigglyfidda125 although u may not agree u should still show some respect do not call ur fellow muslims stupid please.
nathitalinda 3 months ago
keep up the good work!!! thank you
QuranVsHadith 2 years ago
Heyas, Atheist looking from the outside here.
The hadith are too many to count, the very Idea of being expected to read it all and apply it is ridiculous.
How many volumes would it fill? With the aid of computers it could be done, cross referenced by subject etc. BUT if thats the only way it can be delivered to mere mortals, it is definitely impossible people of Mohammad's time.
If you can, sum up the most important ideas and principles in a single, portable volume, do it.
kommissarw 2 years ago
and shi3a beleave in the imamah, and who do not follow them is KAFIR according to them, and more stuff, your video whats it about? come on
Obadajneid 2 years ago
i donno if your a shi3a but, i can tell you one thing, because shi3a are the retards who do not beleave in hadiths,
you should question the shi3a, if they are muslim, cuz they beleave that the quran is not completed so if you are, how dare you post quran senses here, and even then if you are a true muslim how dare you question something to mislead the people? and you dont even know the meanings of the ayat, why dont you go ask a imaam or sheich?
Obadajneid 2 years ago
I agree with the poster most of our leaders are corrupt. What she is saying how ever is true. The hadeeth are not holy. They are historical literature. They divide Islam instead of uniting us.
If she was shi3a she her self would be a hypocrite like the ones she attempts to expose. Because Shi3a is not mentioned in Quran either.
Quran is the final word of God. Anything after is irrelevant.
Islam is the product of the Quran
And a true Muslim is simply a Muslim.
Unity4allhumans 2 years ago 3
well said.. identifying with any sect.. does not matter how big or small is HARAM..
Quran clearly states that if you make a sect.. you have left the folds of ISLAM!!
a TRUE MUSLIM IS SIMPLY A MUSLIM!!! :-)
QuranVsHadith 2 years ago 3
who said that shias dont belive in HADITH.. they have their own set of HADITH.. just like every other group out there...
the only difference is that each group claims that their MULLAH slams his head harder on the floor that the others..
in the end .. ALL are MULLAHS.. and all have twisted the religion out of shape to forward their own personal gains
QuranVsHadith 2 years ago 4
I have a question. If two people who knows nothing about Islam or any religion were placed on two separate Islands and the first one was given the Qur'an and the other one on the other island was given the books of hadith, WHO BETWEEN THE TWO OF THEM WILL BE ABLE TO UNDERSTAND AND PRACTICE ISLAM PROPERLY AND CORRECTLY?
GoldieLP5 2 years ago
Don't get me wrong. The Qur'an is FAR FAR superion than the hadith. I'm simply saying that for us to understand the message of the Qur'an and what Islam is all about, we have to look at how Rasulullah (saw) lived his life according to the teachings of the Qur'an. How do we find out how he lived his life? We look to the hadith. If not for the hadith, we would not even know how to pray. when to pray, how many rakaa for particular prayer, how to make wudhu, rites of Hajj and many many more.
GoldieLP5 2 years ago
"The blind and those who can see are not alike, nor are the believers who do good deeds equal to the wicked; yet you seldom think."(Q. 40:58)
There are people who practice Islam without knowing it, just as there are people who believe that they are guided yet they in reality has chosen the devil as their protector.
The best answer I can give u is that God guides whom He wills.
SpiritualRebel 2 years ago 4
without a DOUBT the QURAN.. it is the ONLY complete book! the only book without errors or ommisions.. the only book you are guranteed to understand.. all you have to do is ASK ALLAH..
there is NO NEED for Hadith.. they were coined / manufactured
QuranVsHadith 2 years ago 6
@GoldieLP5
please read the HADITH.. they will confuse the hell out of you.. for nearly every Hadith saying one thing.. you can find one contradiction it...
and you will for sure die of food poisoning .. or malnutrition.. such as URINE is a cure for 100s of sicknesses.. eat LIZARDS.. dont eat GARLIC EVER..
MURDER at WILL both animals and humans. you name it..
PLEASE do read these HADITH .. without the 100s of FOOTNOTES ADDED (over the years) to jutsify each crazy hadith out there!
QuranVsHadith 1 year ago
@GoldieLP5 Actually, I was placed on an Island "figuratively" where I didn't know Islam, Muslims, of Hadith, but I found the Qur'an and began reading. I learned and now I am Muslim..
Teddy3inDC 1 year ago
@GoldieLP5 You are not muslim.
A true muslim would say Quran is greater than ANY Hadith.
Frenzy786 1 year ago
@GoldieLP5 .. answer to your Question is simple.. the person with the QURAN.. its a PERFECT document
QuranVsHadith 9 months ago
@GoldieLP5 im not a scholar but i would have to say the one who has the quran. "this is the book in which there is no doubt. it is a guidance to those that fear allah." and we know that in sura al-qadr that the quran was "sent down on the night of power." no hadith even the so-called hadith al-qudsi can make that claim. so it's up to each individual to choose the words of allah (swt) or the words of men(bukhari,muslim,abu daoud, etc,etc).
jamiirali1 8 months ago
@GoldieLP5 The Quran is book of GOD, and hadith......maybe some people have translated it in wrong way bacause its over 1000 years since our prophets lived and much have changed since than.....ask yourself brother, Quran is enough!
855FIGHTER 7 months ago
@GoldieLP5 I think spiritual rebel is right. Think about it logically,and BTW your question was shocking to put the two in comparisson. Quran from GOD, hadith from MAN. The Quran is for the PEOPLE not for people already practising Islam, it is a book for every single soul, i think sometimes we forget this. Submission to ONE God and not associating GOD with ANYTHING/ANYONE else. The Shaitan will focus more on corrupting Islam then anyother religion because we already have submitted to ONE GOD.
childishquestions 6 months ago
whats the Shaitan done in the years to corrupt Islam ? Maybe the hadiths, because they have no control over the Quran. BTW how many times have people been dismissed from being credible ??? So the people before wouldve followed lies ?? Why would Allah set us on the right track with the Quran and then play with us with hadiths from BTW PEOPLE, you are following PEOPLE, thats haram. I think, this person is correct, i think that the Quran should be followed, there is no need for hadith.
childishquestions 6 months ago
@GoldieLP5
you think practising Islam will come better from man made hadiths than the actual holy book? I may not be the sharpest tool in the shed but even an invalid like me grasps the basic meaning and requirements of the quran. Pray, fast, be righteous, give charity.
LittleQueenTudor 6 months ago
Woe to those who take the verses of the Qur'an out of context! These verses does not necessarily refer to what you are reffering to! Its imperative to read the verses before and after the verses you quoted. MashaAllah! I hope this is simply a mistake on your part and that you had no evil intentions in saying/stating the things you said on this video. Alhamdulillah I read the before and after verses! I ALMOST believed the things you said!
GoldieLP5 2 years ago
It's so much easier to say that these verses are refering to christians or jews. This way we don't have to point the fingers at ourselves, and we can continue committing errors and even take pride in doing so.
The Quran exposes different peoples wrong behaviour, and if we imitate them we are no better simply because we choose to carry another label.
peace.
SpiritualRebel 2 years ago 5
@SpiritualRebel
WELL SAID
QuranVsHadith 2 years ago
alhamdulilah you cantt believe how happy i am that i stumbled across this :)))
i was just researching and reading about the authorities of hadith... its a bit sad that most people know more ahadtihs then they know quran verses. and the way you showed it, raelly helped reading them with that aproach..
may allah reward you for your work ;)
salam alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh!
chinchillitac 2 years ago 2
@chinchillitac
whats so hard to belive that most people know more hadith than the Quran? thats how ALL other religions got twisted.. SOME MULLAH tried to justify his FETISHES and claimed that that particular fetish was also Mohammads..
Blaming .. insulting.. the Prophets has been the BREAD and BUTTER of MULLAHS since the first religion started..
why should islam be any different..
QURAN is ALL WE NEED TO LIVE A PERFECT LIFE.. the mullah can do better than the Quran
QuranVsHadith 2 years ago
Finaly it entails th creation of a sect, something nt jst prohibited in hadith but also th Qu'ran.
The only ones who have created a sect are everybody else. We are actually the only ones getting back to the commun denominator thats going to one day destroy the labels shiaa, sunni, shia, deobandis, ahmediyas etc. once and for all inshallah, when there going to realise that they have set up idols next to Allah.
seamr05 2 years ago
So everyone is misguided, except you, you being a minority not present until very recently?
Yet it is not you that are a sect, it is all other groups.
'The heretic never claims to be a heretic, he claims to transcend orthodoxy' - Abdal Hakim Murad.
SalehUddin1986 2 years ago
This video's problems lay in both its method & what flows from its assumptions.
Regarding method, the translations used of the Qu'ran have been selectively chosen, so things are implied in English that are not in the Arabic.
The 2nd is the conclusion that al Muslims since the RasulAllah sws hav been misguided, & Allah has allowed His Ummah to go astray (excpt ths persn & those who share hs view). Finaly it entails th creation of a sect, something nt jst prohibited in hadith but also th Qu'ran.
SalehUddin1986 2 years ago
I wouldnt be able to comment on your first point since I dont speak arabic. But no one is making the argument that Allah has misguided the muslims in the sense that you think about it.since these things are you are seing now are the same that have been revealed back then. The prophet has done his job, but people fail to listen. You go to hell for kufr, not for not knowing. :D The sollution has always been right in front of them. "Dont set up idols next to Allah once you know" : )
seamr05 2 years ago
The movement that bases everything upon the Qu'ran and neglects the Sunnah of the Rasul (sws) is completely absent in all but resent history. I am yet to meet a single follower of such groups that have any competency in Arabic, let alone Arabic on the level that is required to read the Qu'ran.
Essentially such groups posit that all Muslims since the time of the Prophet (sws) have committed disbelief, save themselves.
SalehUddin1986 2 years ago
I was just wondering about something; in the reason two part of the video you gave some quotations from the Hadith(s). I just wanted to know what are the Volume,Book,Number they can be found. If you could supply this, it would be greatly appreciated :D
DRoMeOG 2 years ago
You are right, the references should be there. I had some problems adding them to the video after posting it, but since you made the request, I'll put it up in the video information box.
Thanks for watching
SpiritualRebel 2 years ago
by far one of the most convincing videos so far but if you go to your local mosque and tell them that ...you better be armed to the teeth
apresado 2 years ago 12
Thanks, I'm glad the logic of the arguments came through. All i want is to make people understand my point of view on this matter. My intention is not to step on peoples toes. I invite anyone who disagrees with me to share their perspective on things. There is no need for anger and rage.
Peace to all
SpiritualRebel 2 years ago
i would like the book and volume to these hadith please and if its not much to ask could you give me hadiths that contradict each other mostly so called authentic ones that leave these guys speechless so i get ready for my counterattack chances are they might block or ban me but its worth taking the risk
apresado 2 years ago
@apresado The truth hurts though!
chiladin 1 year ago
Isa 8:20 To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.
If it doesn't come directly from God it is a reflection of man's own heart and should not be trusted.
ViciousKarma 2 years ago
Beautiful message!...I am not a 'submitter' but i totaly agree with the message!
jeezus22 2 years ago
Asalaamu Alaikum Wa Rahmatuallahi Wa Barakatu
What I think is really happening too, is as Islam has stretched to America where we are quite critical and do not mind questioning even our religious principles.. those who have reverted to islam and are american have questioned hadiths from those who are perhaps from a middle-eastern family they learned about islam from and have seen through the haze of hadith with fresh eyes that someone born and raised never thought to question.
serenechaos2 2 years ago
wa alaikum salam.
I agree with u. if people just focused on the book, instead of their preconceived ideas about it, a lot of problems could be solved, but when conjecture is added to a religion and people believe it without questioning, the breedingground for hypocracy and falsehood is bound to grow.
Pride can be good, but accompanied with arrogance it will only bear rotten fruit.
The Quran teaches questioning and confirming over blind following and conforming.
Peace & Patience...
SpiritualRebel 2 years ago
@serenechaos2 I am an Arabian, and I totally reject these fake stories. These clerics of petrol and King Faisal and Saudi Arabia corruption has taken over Islam.
DaFree0ne 7 months ago
Well its about time someone else spoke up.
I have always stated that the Quran is the word of God and the hadiths are the words of man. But so many people seem to put more credence in the hadiths than the Quran. When you question the hadiths they label you a blasphemer and heretic.
Well done with this video. 5 stars ***** !
mynewschannel 2 years ago 4
please check out others right here on YT manicwild, whereistruth seems like every single day i find a NEW Brother / sister who is talking about the FALSEHOOD of HADITH
QuranVsHadith 2 years ago
Thank you for the links!
mynewschannel 2 years ago
But No where in the Quran does it say how to pray, no where in the quran does how much zakat we should give etc..
Allah says in the quran "If you love me follow Muahmmad peace and blessings be upon him." Therefore we have to be careful and those hadiths that agree with the quran and are consisitent we will have to agree, but if some are against then we won't agree.
I hope no one takes offensive what I said.. Ppeace to everyone
afghan303 2 years ago
The Quran describes itself as complete, fully detailed and free from contradictions. No offence, but YOU are the one creating the contradiction when u claim the exact opposite. Your argument "how would we know..." is a very classical one but it falls flat when examined.
I know the hadiths are full of universal wisdom but they are also full of false claims labeled as "sahih", and u need to be careful about what u associate and attribute to Allah and His teachings.
peace
SpiritualRebel 2 years ago
all you need to LEAD a PERFECT LIFE as a MUSLIM is the QURAN! everything thing else are additions made my other people!
QURAN expalins ALL.. how to PRAY.. about ZAKAT and every other single item!
Unfortunately.. a lot of people have been brought up brainwashed and think that we need man made books to expalin things ALLAH has already EXPLAINED!
QuranVsHadith 2 years ago
Brother Mohammad Shaikh has posted some video- responses on the topic "hadiths" and "sunnah".
I watched them myself and recommend that u guys do the same.
Have a nice day in PEACE.
SpiritualRebel 2 years ago
SpiritualRebel I agree we need to question hadith. But you so called believers need to question your fake messenger WHEREISTRUTH
hpesoj8 2 years ago
A wise man once said:
"Believe nothing merely because you have been told it. Do not believe what your teacher tells you merely out of respect for the teacher. But whatsoever, after due examination and analysis, you find to be kind, conducive to the good, the benefit, the welfare of all beings -- that doctrine believe and cling to, and take it as your guide."
There is not a single person on this earth that doesn't deserve questioning. I agree with u.
Peace.
SpiritualRebel 2 years ago
5 star response you rock spirit
hpesoj8 2 years ago 3
MASHALLAH!!! THIS IS BRILLIANTLY DONE:-)
MASHALLAH!!!!!!! may Allah grant you djenna, inshallah....beautifully explained
seamr05 2 years ago