Added: 1 year ago
From: allaboutVGmusic
Views: 385,750
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (2,663)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This song and Bury me not in the lone prairie and the saddest songs in the whole game );

  • If a video game makes you cry or feel emotional it usually means that the game is a pretty fucking good one. I got attached to John during the game obviously and when he died and the game ended I got a little teary eyed, I can admit it.

  • Best game I've ever played and I've played all the greats. This is the gold standard.

  • This song is what my life is........

  • i got teared eyed at the end

  • i came here from the triggernometry song from the trailer O.o i havent even played the game and its obvious how good the soundtrack is

  • Full grown men actually cry because john Marston died I am 16 I beat this game it was one of the best games I have played but come on I did not cry when he died just a bit pissed of at Rockstar but that only lasted like 2 minutes you guys should man up ITS ONLY A GAME

  • People are just pathetic

  • Cisla est un fake:(

  • johns not really dead guys! somewhere theres a newb thats on level one... he will live forever

  • @MisterCuddlzWorth Heh...yeah:)

  • Best song in the soundtrack and a perfect one to end the game....

  • BORDEL!!! C'est qui les 17 débiles qui ont mit pouce rouge ????

  • @MarioslaceIII J'avoue ...

  • 17 people are chad warden

  • i'll miss you John :( R.I.P

  • First and only game I ever cried over. It's sad because I didn't cry when my dog died, or when my gf left me, but I cried when "Johnny boy" died haha

  • this and bioshock protects my virginity :)

  • This video makes me fly over the clouds,cry on the night,feel free.I cant understand how some song can be so awesome.Love you guys.

  • @111444000999 love you too buddy :o

  • john marston and ezio auditore r the best video game characters ever imo

  • @wwestunner81 So finally i'm not the only one who thinks so!

  • i thought of john marstons death to this song and it just made my sad

  • 17 dislikes, nice try Ross!!!! >:D

  • ... what can I say about this song?

    What can I say about this game?

    Best game that I've ever played... I just have no words to explain it... the feeling when playing this... all I can say is thank you, Rockstar Games.

  • Did anybody else kill all of Ross's family before killing him? I lassoed his wife and dragged her body through the towns..

  • @SaifAlIslam2012 As soon as i finished talking to Phillip, a wolf killed him! LOL

  • @RedRoboticRabbit Yeah same here Funniest shit ever xD

  • @SaifAlIslam2012 hahahahahahhah me tooo

  • @SaifAlIslam2012 Yep me to! I thought fuck it, Not my problem Ross is just a staright running asshole.

  • @TraGicJohnson49 is tgat all you saw? Pixels? That is seriously all John Marston was to you? You didn't see him as the character he was meant to be? And you think if they're not a rea

  • I made sure to kill Ross in a slow, painful manner. By that I used a Cattleman blew off his kneecaps and shot him the kneecaps until he couldn't stand.

  • @xTheCaptain97x I used the explosive rifle and blew his ass into pieces after i shot him in the FACE

  • I LOVE THIS GAME !

  • Well john marston is the best game charackter that i've ever played..

  • I didn't cry for this even if it was fuckin sad, but you people need to get over it, when i read your comments it really looks like all of you are depressed

  • @rossonnere1243 You poor soul...

  • @rossonnere1243 lol right? The end was type sad but he's not real he's a game character, he's made up of pixels

  • John Marston is the greatest father of all time

  • Manly tears cannot be contained

  • SPOILER ALERT. he is my favorite game character of all time, when he stepped out of the barn I was thinking "oh, i wonder how he'll get out of this one." and then he didn't and I almost cried. such an amazing character.

  • I didn't really like playing as his son at the end :/ I felt like I was cheating on John..lol

  • best fucking game ever made i cant believe the end!! glad edgar ross gets killed.

  • I'm proud to say this is the only game i've ever cried over. Bravo Rockstar, you people are fucken genius'

  • hands down one of the best video games ever made

  • This Song puts My Youngest To Sleep Before It finishes Lol =P

  • @DJKSWISHA this is the most adorable thing i have heard today. :)

  • Damn heat, my eyes are sweating again.

  • Did John lose all his dynamite while he was in that barn?

  • Comment removed

  • I can't believe that this is only a Games

  • @DerVonHintenKam1986 your username is funny as hell, friend!

  • I want this to be played at my funeral :)

  • i love this game but my friend made a point

    1) at the start john got shot by two guys

    1)he got shot in that mission with the bionakulars and got shot by dutch

    3)also on that mission he got attacked by a bear

    4)bear again when he was saving jack

    none of these would be as a epic ending though

    RDR is the best though

  • I can't stop listening to it, it is just so beautiful. =

  • I need to replay this game.

  • when he died, i forgot for a minute that everything was just a game...

  • John marston was the best kind of man.... All i can say is that i cried due to this sad death... R.I.P John Marston "Blessed are Peacemakers" :(

  • My dear brother we had a really good time together didnt we? :)

    we did alot together hehe hunting, killing etc you really touched my soul and heart and i really wanted you to come back with your family and you did :) and when the us army came with ross you touched my heart again but this time it wasnt love :(

    RIP John Marston we will meet again

  • Johns death was so unexpected. When he got out of that barn, i thought he´d shoot them all in the blink of an eye but instead he dropped dead filled with lead. ;(

  • i cried when i finished the game i cried during the credits i cried when i watched the soundtrack. my life is full of crieing ;(

  • I don't think I'll ever forget this game. Heartbreaking.

  • People don't Forget. Nothing gets Forgiven. -- John Marston

  • Outlaws till the end.

  • John Marston: The heart, mind, and body of a cold-blooded killer, but the soul of an angle.

    "We all need friends, otherwise we just live by men and die alone" - John Marston

  • RIP John Marston you will be forever missed. "Blessed are the peacemakers"

  • the first time if cried in about 8 years. im a 32 year old man. how the hell am i crying over a video game??? john was a hero.

  • :'(

  • where in the game is this song ???

    I <3 John

  • Comment removed

  • @GranTourismoPrO *SPOILER ALERT* This song is in the credits after Jack kills Edgar Ross

  • @GranTourismoPrO When jack kills Edgar ross. In the credits. The stranger task is named remember my family.

  • thumbs up if you cried at the end of the game. p.s. i did

  • Did this song make anyone else cry?

  • Beautiful

  • I'm Nearly Cry

  • @Fastfart007 Shit

  • @Fastfart007 did you say shit did you say shit you are a ****** prepare to die !

  • @killerkris9911 Wait!! I Mean Like Shit Im Gonna Cry and I Really Really Like This Song.

  • This track is on their CD American Sunshine, the rest of it is just as good as this, and it's really cheap on iTunes

  • Please Rockstar , makes another Red Dead Redemption PLEASE!!! The Best Games I And Every People's Around the World Have Ever Played.

  • Out of the hundreds of games I played RDR might just be in the top 5! Touching story, epic gameplay.. I didn't even know about the game 1 day before release and to date it's one of the best games I ever played. Thank you Rockstar, you guys are amazing.

    I'm also saying that RDR is better than any GTA to date. And I'm a big GTA fan!

  • After Max Payne 3 and Grand Theft Auto V, Rockstar needs to continue with the Red Dead-series. A Red Dead Revelations, perhaps? The game could continue Jack's story.

  • @CookieTheEpic Should be "Red Dead Redemption's Jack Marston Revenge".

  • @rafarodriguesful That name is way too long, has no zing whatsoever, doesn't connect to the first two RD-games, and you are stupid.

  • @CookieTheEpic Stupid is your mother you piece of shit!

  • @rafarodriguesful Wow, mom jokes! You're so original. When I grow three years younger, I want to be just like you.

  • @rafarodriguesful Should be Red Dead Revenge

  • Saddest game in history? Just mabey.

  • This is REALLY a 10/10, simply a masterpiece, absolutely amazing

  • john marston forever!!!! its a shame that he died,but it made a great emotional ending,bravo rockstar. give us another red dead in the future please :)

  • R.I.P John Marston :(

  • Im never selling this game ever!

  • I cried like a bitch when it showed John's funeral. But when I killed Ross and the credits started rolling with this song playing, I cried like a bigger bitch. RIP John Marston :'(

  • These 16 people who disliked are fat fucks who have no idea about good games.

  • Red Dead Redemption is in my opiniom the best game ever made. The plot is great, characters amazing, music is fabulous and this touchy moments when we were riding horse while listening to this awesome songs. And the end of the game is a masterpiece. One of a saddest moments I experienced in the video game ever.

  • this song is so beautiful, and this game is so amazing in every way, and when they go together..... well that's just heaven.

  • So incredible. When the family gets their revenge, and the credits roll with this song.A 'Man cry' moment right there.

  • The best game ever made!

  • I have beat the campaign to this 5 times and you know what IT NEVER GETS OLD !!!!

  • this game made me FEEL like i was in the past

  • You know, Old Fashioned next to you and this song. You kinda feel complete.

  • just bought ps3 and this game couple weeks ago,and just finish yesterday,and come here to listen nice song,yes i know lil bit too late,but who cares,,yeah u guys right this game is awesome,nice story,nice song too :-)

  • this is the only video game i have been proud to say i cried at. John was such a believable character and i felt like a real cowboy when i finished it :'(

  • @wilko202 me too man. my favorite game of all time. so perfect in every way

  • Comment removed

  • third best game ive ever played next to gta 4 and mass effect

  • @hellfire6028 Agreed 100%.

  • I love more old ps1 or sega games... but first time i play this game... i love it since the first minute after get it at release day... It is the best game EVER! I love the missions, i love all characters (but i hate sath^^) I love the details in the world from RDR... I Love the animals, the people the life in Armadillo or other towns... i cant say how great it is... Multiplayer is awesome... Soundtrack = Masterpiece. Story Awesome... Rockstar make the best Game in my lifetime

  • Good.

  • Wow, the best game of all time. Ive commented on at least 1,00000000 red dead videos in my lifetime, just because this game is a work of art. Anyone who doesnt have this game or have never played it get off of your lazy ass and PLAY RED DEAD DAMN IT!!! Do it for John Marston!!!

  • @InsaneSnipesIZI Which Red Dead? lol jk Yes I like Red Dead Redemption

  • @NoobZoneVideos Red Dead Revolver was a great game too but Red Dead Redemption was the and will ever be the best game ;-) I think i play first a little bit red dead revolver and afther that i play redemption, maybe see ya in the multiplayer xD

  • @OpiumSteve never thought anyone ever would have played revolver then this !! do you know by any chance red dead revolver on original xbox works on the 360 ?

  • @jordanrammy95 no sorry, i got revolver for ps2

  • @NoobZoneVideos lol i do too. as you can see

  • Begging reminds me of Let it Be.

  • such a sad but yet fitting song to john marstons end. *( damn you ross and archer.

  • @SuperJohnyboy6 thats why i kill ross! And Damn... it was a great feelin!

  • @SuperJohnyboy6 archer fordham did not arrive when ross kill john

  • RIP :'(

  • Anyone else cry when they finished this game?

  • @JackThaGamer Yeah, Me. :((

  • @JackThaGamer gotta be honest. i did. this game is THE best storyline i've ever seen. there might be games like final fantasy, skyrim and so on, which have longer and more complicated stories. but this game just shows you how life sometimes can be. you feel like a real john marston when you finish the game.

  • @JackThaGamer if u finish the game you dont cry, you feel awesome... i hope u know what i want to sa cause i dont want to spoil here ;-)

  • @JackThaGamer

    I Swear When I Finished This Game I Didn't Sleep For Whole Night ...

    Rockstar Thumbs Up For U ... :)

    Love U john <3

  • Wow.

    I was playing Liberal Crime Squad with this song on.

    I stole a car and I was being chased by the police.

    First my left arm was hit and I tried to stay calm

    Then my right arm was hit and I prayed to my mother

    then I died and my car flipped

  • Reminds me of my dad :( I cry everytime I hear this :'(

  • Video games are art, here is one of the best examples.

  • John Marston became real to me. Thank you Rockstar Games. The best game I've ever played, bar none.

  • Comment removed

  • ;.(  i miss john this, game has drama, great graffics, a story... that actually makes sence, unlike GTA 4 all u do u do 4 money, this is a great example of what all the games should have, becouse when i got RDR i was amazed! shoked! becouse if u agree, this is the game of the century no other could top it... unless GTA5... we'll see.

  • This song touched my heart when i finished the game im 17 and cried at this.

    This is an example of a game with a good taste in music when it comes to drama.

    WE MISS YOU JOHN!!!!!!!!! (thumbs up) (original end when u kill edgar look it up).

  • Red Dead Redemption Forever!

  • Swear to god Marston is my physical clone. Only, I'm about 15 years younger. Of Scottish decent also.

  • @jackdoldseven ewww the Scottish are terribly ugly!

  • @esowaych Depends on what you consider ugly I suppose. I've never been called ugly myself.

  • It was one of the best endings. And one of the most athmospheric games.

  • 15 people can't kill edgar ross

  • We need Red Dead Redemption 2

  • @Lerm53 there is one is called undead nightmare well its an expansion but its AWESOME

  • @Lerm53 Red Dead Redemption: Redemption?

  • @jlafloe619 doubt it would be direct unless they want to completly change the game style as it was already set at the end of the wild west . personally id like a prequel showing exactly what happened with john and the rest of his former gang

  • THANK YOU ROCKSTAR;

  • This game made Chuck Norris cry.

  • Comment removed

  • @SammyProductions2009 this is the reality

    ;D is the best game like the story and the playgame is with assassinscreed the best game :)

  • @SammyProductions2009 then Steven Seagal beated him after he was crying on this song.

  • @NikoBellicSerbia30 "beated" = not a word

  • @jayjay042298456 *beaten. Pardon.

  • @NikoBellicSerbia30 Its alright. I can see English is not your first language.

  • @jayjay042298456 yes. I learned long ago english words when i was in school. In university here is another story. You feel just professors want to take you away to speak english words correctly. Thats why now my english is bad.

  • @SammyProductions2009 This song make Chuck Norris cry too.

  • ***BOARDWALK EMPIRE SPOILER***

    I'd love it if they played this song in Boardwalk Empire as Harrow slaughtered Nucky and his goons for what they did in the Season 2 finale.

    Doubt it would happen though.

  • I've never played RDR just cause i'm a pc gamer :(

  • John Marston was a honor man. He sacrified himself for save his family.

  • Im Super Glad I Got This Game, Because It Show's You The Life You Would Have Lived In Years Ago! The Soundtrack, Online Mode, Campain, All Rock. One Of The Best Games I Have Ever Played. Five Stars.

  • the only good game i ever playd the music is so awesome

  • Outlawkiin

  • @TestdeNalo thanx

  • dude seriously Rockstar makes the best fucking games, red dead, grand theft la noire... seriously whats next? I sold red dead cause i bought undead nightmare and for an expansion pack that was such a great game. I still have the game and plan on keeping it cause online is just too much fun!

  • They do need to make this into a Movie.. There is alot of gamers in the world.. But this Story needs to be shown to the world at large. This story, Everybody should be told. An Epic Moment of Gaming History. Now we need to make it shine in Hollywood.

  • @stormdcw they did its a short movie by machima called "The man from Blackwater" you can go to thier wep page to whatch it i think youll have to go to wikipedea and look it up

  • Although i miss john marston as much as the next guy, I think ;that his death was an essential part to the game. It shows the harsh reality of a criminal's ife which rockstar show in alot of games. You live the high life, get pushed into a world of insane bloodshed and then the bullet catches up with you.

  • Outlaws to the end...

  • I save the game in the las mission when you are jack and you have to killo Edgar Ross and I kill him every day when I am angry .I kill him all time..........

  • John's death at the hands of Ross is a poetic end to his life. He sacrifices himself to save his family so they could lead a better life - the reason he sought redemption in the first place. By his death, he knew that Ross wouldn't persecute Abigail or Jack any longer, allowing them to start life fresh, allowing Jack the chance to grow up without the brutality and violence that shaped John's early life

  • @monsieurbunn Yup... you pretty much nailed it.

  • I think the game's absolutly great, but if you play it the right way and don't rush it and just enjoy, you will be fed of everything the game is having, so the ending came the right time, I don't think it would be better for the game if it continued longer or had another ending. When you enjoy every little aspect Rockstar is giving you in their games you will notice that their games is enough for you to be satisfied. Sometimes things need to end, and RDR did it just the right time.