I think Lea and Christy interpret it in different ways. Lea is a belter, so she belts it. Christy sounds more like a young girl asking for answers, like somebody said.
Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU for singing this song THE WAY IT WAS WRITTEN!!! Beautiful timbre, great musicianship, NOT oversung, and overall one of the best versions I've heard.
I have never heard Ms. Michelle sing this song as clearly and cleanly pitched as this version - particularly since it is almost impossible to find a "live" version that has not been technically enhanced for Lea
and for those of you that keep saying lea is better, unless you've seen her on Broadway, which i'm guessing most of you haven't, remember that her voice is auto tuned on the cd. i'm not saying she's not good, because she's amazing. and your all entitled to your own opinion but give Christy a chance ;) she's amazing live.
lea is more commertial. this is artistic, and keeping in mind that both girls are very talented, i think that for voice, christy is more fit for wendla, but for looks, lea will allways be wendla to me(: but, as said before, both girls are amaizing, and have diffrent takes on this complex role, as it can be played many diffrent ways.
I used this song to audition for Robin Hood. lol :) christy altomare and lea michele are uncomparable because they sing it soo much differently. i love how christy uses SO much emotion/expression while singing this song.
Okay, everyone. Get over it. She's not Lea Michele, she's Christy Altomare. They may have played the same character but doesn't mean they have the same approach. This video is for people to enjoy her performance not to critique it to bits. I personally love them both and can appreciate both performances. Try it next time.
There is no way for this play not to be good but I am in love with the version that has Lea Michele and Jonathan Groff. Just personal preference. I have seen this one and another one too (with that guy from degrassi I think) and the first is still my fave.
how come she couldnt have sounded like this when i saw her?! this is amazzing! when i saw her, she was clearly having an off day... which is fine, it happens... but it makes me wanna see her again so she can redeem herself in my head.
i think lea is great but honestly christy is more "belivable" her voice is more raw and sweet which crates the effect of her sounding very innocent and young, dnt get me wrong i love lea she is amazing at whatever she does but her voice to me is too mature for wendla its beutiful just too mature to belive she is only "15", i saw christy and she was breath taking like i said before she was very belivable and being a teen myself it tuged to my heart more
i'm starting to like her more...I still think I prefer Alexandra (above all) but Christy is by no means a bad Wendla. I wish her Reprise were a bit stronger though
I saw the tour in Pittsburgh and she sings this very well and plays a more youthful innocent Wendle than lea but I think out of the whole cast she was the weakest.
i totally agree with u she plays a very well wendla gives her a more innocent and realistic take but she did seem to be the weakest vocally for me from the cast but still the less she was great
@sandee12341 Weakest? There are weaker links in the cast than Christy Altomare. Just my opinion, but Christy is one of the strong links in the cast, who all are amazing.
@sandee12341: Weakest vocally? The last time I saw it, Jake was the weakest (vocally). Anyways, Christy doesn't have bad singing moments (lets face it, ShiShi's TM solo isn't always consistently good), and in my opinion, as long as the voice isn't cringe-worthy (and maybe in some cases, if it is), acting is more important than singing for the leads.
i totally agree with u she gives wendla a more youthful and innocent feel which makes it a more realistic and huanting feel to the story i really enjoyed her wendla compared to lea who is amazing too but her wendla for me is a lil to older sounding
She does a amazing job as Wendla, I saw the show 2 times in Sacramento, I wish I could have gone more. Jake and her are amazing also! Lets face it, its an amazing touring cast!!!
@wickedlylovely15 really well honestly i think her voice is more pure than leas idk christy voice has a sorta of innocent naiive feel to it and leas has a more haunting feel like shes a lil more older and been thru more things idk but both of them r great
I love her voice for this... It's so pure. <3
tulipstokissyouwith 1 week ago
This girl went to my high school and sang in my choir!
crosie2820 3 months ago
i like christy's younger / less developed voice for this role. it's perfect.
TenayaG10 4 months ago in playlist Spring awakening 4
Good, but Lea's better
winterguard1497 5 months ago
voice not as developed as Leas. Very very different take
b05620 5 months ago
While I do love the original cast, I wish I could swap out Christy for Lea. I love her voice so much more.
WritingFreak13 7 months ago
@WritingFreak13 Do you mean swap Lea for Christy? ha
Kylezilla 6 months ago
khm-khm 0:20 xd
anyway, it's beautiful.
kocdori95 8 months ago
She is realllyyy pretty
janeandalec 9 months ago
If I saw christy first she would be my favorite wendla but since I saw Lea on broadway first I like her more
Alicenightmare69 10 months ago
I think Lea and Christy interpret it in different ways. Lea is a belter, so she belts it. Christy sounds more like a young girl asking for answers, like somebody said.
merryhappymeg 10 months ago
Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU for singing this song THE WAY IT WAS WRITTEN!!! Beautiful timbre, great musicianship, NOT oversung, and overall one of the best versions I've heard.
PerformerDiva 11 months ago
I have never heard Ms. Michelle sing this song as clearly and cleanly pitched as this version - particularly since it is almost impossible to find a "live" version that has not been technically enhanced for Lea
MissFluffsDad 1 year ago 4
and for those of you that keep saying lea is better, unless you've seen her on Broadway, which i'm guessing most of you haven't, remember that her voice is auto tuned on the cd. i'm not saying she's not good, because she's amazing. and your all entitled to your own opinion but give Christy a chance ;) she's amazing live.
MusicalRose23 1 year ago 4
i love christy :) she's by far my favorite wendla.
MusicalRose23 1 year ago 2
Of course the OBC will always be better, but I saw the tour on November 4th and It was amazing. They did such a good job with it :)
olivianicolexo 1 year ago
i like the original cast WAAAAYYY better..with Lea and Johnathan
angiehercules2011 1 year ago
Lea seems to have a stronger approach in this song, but Christy sounds more like she's asking for answers.
weirdo53 1 year ago 12
I like Lea SO much more.
sierracadilha 1 year ago
Lea Michele sings it much better
MichelleOo93 1 year ago
I saw the show with her cast too! It was SOOOO amazing!!!
thisisme0708 1 year ago 2
Christy ftw!!! such an amazing approach to wendla and she will always be my favorite. so believeable and when i saw it she was amazing
laughpro3 1 year ago 5
i love christy... she is absolutely amazing. she's my 2nd favorite wendla - right under lea, of course :)
Sophieste163 1 year ago 2
lea is more commertial. this is artistic, and keeping in mind that both girls are very talented, i think that for voice, christy is more fit for wendla, but for looks, lea will allways be wendla to me(: but, as said before, both girls are amaizing, and have diffrent takes on this complex role, as it can be played many diffrent ways.
DramaQueenAllDay36 1 year ago 7
I used this song to audition for Robin Hood. lol :) christy altomare and lea michele are uncomparable because they sing it soo much differently. i love how christy uses SO much emotion/expression while singing this song.
ridgedalerocks 1 year ago 7
Okay, everyone. Get over it. She's not Lea Michele, she's Christy Altomare. They may have played the same character but doesn't mean they have the same approach. This video is for people to enjoy her performance not to critique it to bits. I personally love them both and can appreciate both performances. Try it next time.
Kylezilla 1 year ago 10
i met her in person :) she's so incredibly nice :)!
surfbillabong498 1 year ago 8
There is no way for this play not to be good but I am in love with the version that has Lea Michele and Jonathan Groff. Just personal preference. I have seen this one and another one too (with that guy from degrassi I think) and the first is still my fave.
sarikaris 1 year ago
how come she couldnt have sounded like this when i saw her?! this is amazzing! when i saw her, she was clearly having an off day... which is fine, it happens... but it makes me wanna see her again so she can redeem herself in my head.
starpiggy777 1 year ago
@starpiggy777 No I saw her yesterday she wasn't too good.
kirbyazn 1 year ago
i like leas voice more and christys voice isnt anything really compared to lea but her voice fits wendela
choirgeek822 1 year ago
Lea's better yayyy
pentra1962 1 year ago
i think lea is great but honestly christy is more "belivable" her voice is more raw and sweet which crates the effect of her sounding very innocent and young, dnt get me wrong i love lea she is amazing at whatever she does but her voice to me is too mature for wendla its beutiful just too mature to belive she is only "15", i saw christy and she was breath taking like i said before she was very belivable and being a teen myself it tuged to my heart more
sandee12341 1 year ago 8
lea michele is still the best wendla for me.. they all have unique styles..but i like lea's version very much..
gosh1111 2 years ago
That was the most high energy/exited "Wendla?" Mama!" i've ever heard.
dancerprincess715 2 years ago
i'm starting to like her more...I still think I prefer Alexandra (above all) but Christy is by no means a bad Wendla. I wish her Reprise were a bit stronger though
Fermata125 2 years ago 4
she's got a beautifully pure voice.
louisawhat 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
NO one tops Lea Michele...
Vvalerie123 2 years ago
I really like her voice, and how simply she sings it. It's lovely.
operagirl89 2 years ago 6
I love how she sings it :) I loved the touring cast, they were so amazing, I got chills.
lessthanjake23 2 years ago 35
I saw the tour in Pittsburgh and she sings this very well and plays a more youthful innocent Wendle than lea but I think out of the whole cast she was the weakest.
mamone92 2 years ago 3
i totally agree with u she plays a very well wendla gives her a more innocent and realistic take but she did seem to be the weakest vocally for me from the cast but still the less she was great
sandee12341 2 years ago
@sandee12341 Weakest? There are weaker links in the cast than Christy Altomare. Just my opinion, but Christy is one of the strong links in the cast, who all are amazing.
ohjawillkommen 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
sandee12341 2 years ago
@sandee12341: Weakest vocally? The last time I saw it, Jake was the weakest (vocally). Anyways, Christy doesn't have bad singing moments (lets face it, ShiShi's TM solo isn't always consistently good), and in my opinion, as long as the voice isn't cringe-worthy (and maybe in some cases, if it is), acting is more important than singing for the leads.
ohjawillkommen 2 years ago
i totally agree with u she gives wendla a more youthful and innocent feel which makes it a more realistic and huanting feel to the story i really enjoyed her wendla compared to lea who is amazing too but her wendla for me is a lil to older sounding
sandee12341 2 years ago 2
She does a amazing job as Wendla, I saw the show 2 times in Sacramento, I wish I could have gone more. Jake and her are amazing also! Lets face it, its an amazing touring cast!!!
kylemaples 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
didn't like it. she doesn't have soul to her voice, like lea does. She has a lovely voice, but nothing compared to lea. sorry
wickedlylovely15 2 years ago
@wickedlylovely15 really well honestly i think her voice is more pure than leas idk christy voice has a sorta of innocent naiive feel to it and leas has a more haunting feel like shes a lil more older and been thru more things idk but both of them r great
sandee12341 2 years ago 4
I absolutely love the way christy sings this. She's amazing.
inthemoonlight 2 years ago 4
the best I've heard her. Wow!
blckrocker 2 years ago
she sang it a lot differently than how i've heard it sung previously.
kittylove5555 2 years ago 3
L O V E
igocrazy4maroon5 2 years ago 4
i saw this in philadelphia. christy has a pure voice!
dariayang 2 years ago 24
I want to see the touring cast so bad!!! I love all of them!!!!! <3
ilooooooovewicked 2 years ago 4