I'm a singer and cellist, and I am learning the cello part for this whole series for a performance in a month. I hope I can play this movement even half as well as this excellent cellist is!
The conductor looks like he has a mute button in his hand. The organist and cellist cut off simultaneously with the little "flick" of his hand. nice timing.
@1banders OK, but why are they tuned to that pitch when the organist is simply playing this in A Major, as opposed to the G Major that it's written in? I could understand if the organ was pre-tuned to be a whole step higher than the original key, and tuning it lower would be impossible, but in this case, I saw the organist's fingers and they are simply playing the aria in A. This entire rendition of the cantata is a whole step higher than the score. Why?
@vlnvlaclogbaerhpno The historically correct pitch for this early Bach cantata is A465. Therefore, the aria, which is written in G, should sound at G@A465. For convenience in playing most late Baroque works, this portable organ is probably tuned to Baroque chamber pitch (A415), which is a whole step lower than A465. So in order to sound in tune which the rest of the ensemble, the organ part must be transposed up a whole step, to A@A415.
@vlnvlaclogbaerhpno While the custom in Weimar had been to tune to the organ (A465) and transpose up the parts for winds that could only play at chamber pitch (A415) or French chamber pitch (A392), by the time Bach moved to Leipzig, his predecessor there had established the custom of tuning to chamber pitch (A415). But since the organ was still tuned at choir pitch (A465), the organ part had to be transposed down a whole step.
@vlnvlaclogbaerhpno It would be more accurate to say Baroque organ pitch was around A465, sometimes higher. The pitch of older Baroque organs was based on the tuning of Renaissance winds.Whereas, the later Baroque chamber pitch (A415 and lower) was based on the tuning of late Baroque winds. A440 tuning was not formally adopted until the 1950s, and then only after decades of lobbying by American winds manufacturers. So you can see how the tuning of winds has influenced pitch standards.
Besser geht es nicht mehr. Begleitung super harmonisch miteinander und Christine Schäfer singt wundervoll!
Muggafatz 1 year ago
amazing :) i'm 14 years old, but i love it!
MissDouwes 1 year ago
@MissDouwes Why the "but", then?
Atlas2Atlante0 9 months ago
@Atlas2Atlante0
ya, i also wonder why there are so many poeple who mention that they are 13,14,15... ''BUT'' or ''they dont know why-BUT'' they love it...
i hope that they honestly love it more than a praise.
paranapoleon 5 months ago
I'm a singer and cellist, and I am learning the cello part for this whole series for a performance in a month. I hope I can play this movement even half as well as this excellent cellist is!
aseretkavon 1 year ago
Una ayuda...qué afinaci'on tienen los instrumentos aqui? Estàn a 440Hz? o menos...
lalindatita 1 year ago
@lalindatita They are tuned to Baroque organ pitch (A465), which is a 1/2 step higher than A440.
1banders 4 months ago
@1banders Gracias por la ayuda!! :)
lalindatita 4 months ago
The conductor looks like he has a mute button in his hand. The organist and cellist cut off simultaneously with the little "flick" of his hand. nice timing.
nowhereman0918 1 year ago
what is the real pitch of this aria?
marce0ssa 1 year ago
@marce0ssa The aria is in G. The ensemble is tuned to Baroque organ pitch, which is about A465, which is about a 1/2 step higher than A440.
1banders 4 months ago
@1banders OK, but why are they tuned to that pitch when the organist is simply playing this in A Major, as opposed to the G Major that it's written in? I could understand if the organ was pre-tuned to be a whole step higher than the original key, and tuning it lower would be impossible, but in this case, I saw the organist's fingers and they are simply playing the aria in A. This entire rendition of the cantata is a whole step higher than the score. Why?
vlnvlaclogbaerhpno 1 week ago
Comment removed
1banders 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@vlnvlaclogbaerhpno The historically correct pitch for this early Bach cantata is A465. Therefore, the aria, which is written in G, should sound at G@A465. For convenience in playing most late Baroque works, this portable organ is probably tuned to Baroque chamber pitch (A415), which is a whole step lower than A465. So in order to sound in tune which the rest of the ensemble, the organ part must be transposed up a whole step, to A@A415.
1banders 1 week ago
@vlnvlaclogbaerhpno While the custom in Weimar had been to tune to the organ (A465) and transpose up the parts for winds that could only play at chamber pitch (A415) or French chamber pitch (A392), by the time Bach moved to Leipzig, his predecessor there had established the custom of tuning to chamber pitch (A415). But since the organ was still tuned at choir pitch (A465), the organ part had to be transposed down a whole step.
1banders 1 week ago
@vlnvlaclogbaerhpno It would be more accurate to say Baroque organ pitch was around A465, sometimes higher. The pitch of older Baroque organs was based on the tuning of Renaissance winds.Whereas, the later Baroque chamber pitch (A415 and lower) was based on the tuning of late Baroque winds. A440 tuning was not formally adopted until the 1950s, and then only after decades of lobbying by American winds manufacturers. So you can see how the tuning of winds has influenced pitch standards.
1banders 1 week ago
Fantastic. Magical.
damondarkwalker 2 years ago 4
Who is the beautiful cellist?
wcbroccoli 3 years ago
Good question.
He plays beautifully, too:)
mlutheri1 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Good question.
He plays beautifully, too :)
mlutheri1 2 years ago
This piece of music is Very touching! O wie selig werd Ich sein!
Gueguense2008 3 years ago 2
Es ist eine sehr nette Interpretation. Una interpretacion muy bella.
Gueguense57 3 years ago 4
Es ist eine sehr nette Interpretation.
That is nonsens what you talking.
It is a great Interpreation.
Young and have a good voice,that is it.
Chief
chiefci 3 years ago 2
Thanks for this piece of heaven!
8491angel 4 years ago 4
Absolutely exquisite!! Thank you!!
shanderawx 4 years ago 8
Beautiful voice! I can feel the flow of movement of her soul and a rare state of peacefulness within myself. Thanks for posting!
janedickie 4 years ago 13