Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (368)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Roger Water's facial expressions totally make this video

  • i think that gilmour is a better guitarest then white . snowy white suck s

  • why in the middle of the video the audio just all of a sudden got better...the transition between happiest days and another brick in the wall is swapped from the video to the live cd (Is there anybody out there)????

  • 6 dislikes, probably Justin beiber with 6 youtube accounts...bad boy

  • 6 people can't have any pudding....

  • @johninfl never heard that before

  • @TheIllegalKind 6 dislikes.....lol

  • saw this at madison square last yr, and it carried the same intensity

  • Long you live and high you'll fly and smiles you'll give and tears you'll cry and all you touch and all you see is all your life will ever be.” Eyemadreamer

    <3 pink floyd

  • Pink...so much better than P!nk.

  • my fucking 6th grade sinc. techer (if she was) try to made us vote for the techer pay

    increes like saying "o well we dou't get pay good enough'' then i said "hay dont you

    drive a mercedes benz" and she paused and said well thats becase are husbins are anthony & docters (only 1 is an anthony btw) but her husbin is the fucking gym

    techer. then like 2 weeks later she show pic. of her big ass fucking boat and is big

    too then you need a big ass truck to tow it and a big ass house to park it at

  • @dmaninthewall but she is a rich snob you know skiny wight girl with makeup and jewelry on rich cothes long blond hair w/ a high pich tone to her voice and lifes in the rich parts not even in are town like a good 3-5 miles out but i told her that alex is an ass of course she didit do shit then alex told like a litt. kid that i wuz sniffing a sharpy (i was't) she said ( in a real bichy tone)"siffing markers can kill your brain cells and with your grades you cant afford to lose any more cells"

  • I GOT PISSED but i wasint awar that she cant do that but at the time i just nod and sat down but NOW I WHANT

    TO TAKE THAT SHARPY AND SHUFF IT UP HER FUCKING NOSE AND KILL WHAT 2-3 CELLS SHES GOT AND

    SPELL OUT WE DONT NEED NO THOUGHT CONTROL BITCH soory for the cussing i just needed to vent!!

  • @notebook629 takes millionaires that dropped out of college to say that :3

  • I WAS WONDERING.........who that second person playing a solo is. It's not Gilmour, because he was done with his at 4:57......I saw a suggestion the second solo was performed by a Mr. "Snowy White". Turns out after a little investigating: Snowy White was a guitarist for Thin Lizzy from 1979 to 1982. But he WAS invited by Pink Floyd to play as a backup player for tours, in 1977, and also in 1980 THE WALL TOUR. Look it up.

    Also played for the Roger Waters Band.

    Snowy White, kicking our asses in.

  • The seconds after 6:30 are absolutly phenomenal, as it's any part where Gilmour performs

  • Extended solos by Gilmour are the best thing in any circumstance.

  • He play the cymbal with a tambourine!! Awesome!! :D

  • @notebook629 YEAH, we don't need no education! Hahahahah. That's what David Gilmour taught us =D.

  • @notebook629 Hahahaha, me too! xD. But Pink Floyd is much more important than homework, hahaha.

  • waters is juist like fuck u teach lol

  • ORKEY!

    

  • where is "Best song ever" button??!!

  • 5 people:

    a) are stupid

    b) are very stupid

    c) are not humans

    

  • 5 people get thrashed by their fat and psychopathic wives.

  • Where's Rick Wright ???

  • this is my favorite song ever

  • we don't need no copyright

    we don't need no censored versions

    no removed videos or chipmunked songs

    hey vevo leave youtube alone!!!

  • why are 2 keyboardings?

  • I LOVE THAT FUCKIN' TWO GUITAR SOLOS AND THE FINAL ORGAN SOLO !!

  • 3:03 I think someone's on dope....... LOL

  • That high note Roger keeps throwing in on the bassline is annoying the hell out of me. Definitely quite a difference from the album version...

  • Three things we don't need:

    1) Education

    2) Thought Control

    3) Dark Sarcasm

  • @MrJamacianBob haha!

  • Today is show in Zagreb , Croatia.. can't wait to see that!

  • pink floyd has always gave me the chills

  • who is the guy doing the solo after david gilmour? not sid, right?

  • @shafieem  Snowe White.

  • @shafieem Syd left the band in 1968

  • Who else thinks that the four of them had the best hair during this concert?

  • WIch of the two keyboardists is good ol´ Rick??

  • 1:00 ..... is that Gilmour?

  • @Theinoch

    yeah that's gilmour. second guitarist is mr. snowy white!

  • I wish that I was there, what a show, what a band nearing the the end of the golden age of rock 'n roll.

  • although I like everything before and after this.. and even their solo albums.. this is the last pink floyd album with the authentic pink floyd sound for sure..

    Seen this live in chicago this past summer.. brilliant!!

  • Awesome solo, Dave!

  • 5 people:

    a) seem to have some kind of brain damage;

    b) maybe have hearing problems;

    c) or just prefer Justin Bieber.

  • @adrialbati

    5 people are "the teachers who would hurt the children any way they could"

  • @88theresistance Exposing every weakness however carefully hidden by the kids!

  • @adrialbati Actually, I disliked it because of the horrible sound quallity.

  • @Azimuth95 That's not a very good reason...

  • @adrialbati 6 people :)

  • I remember seeing this very video some years ago, and I remember being surprised by how someone as young as that singer/bassist could make such complex/mature music.

    Now, I know much more about Pink Floyd, and that Roger Waters was actually 38 years old in this video haha. I used to think he was about 20.

  • THIS IS BLUES

  • Waters seems somewhat ironic here. I like that.

    

  • i cant believe dave gilmour said this album lack soul fir him maybe out of anger towards waters taking over and being a megalomaniac

  • I would have loved to be one of those people in the audience. Just to have been sitting there and seeing something that had never been done before. But at least I saw the Roger Waters the wall tour last november.

  • Water's looks like the only one truly happy to be on that stage - too bad for all of them - at least they did it

  • pink floyd , im 18 , but you're right :)

    i love pink floyd ! :)

    i like to play floyd's songs on my guitar ^^ :)

  • Hands down the best concert I have ever seen ( Original in Berlin ) !!! Great music never dies !!!

  • this is the best version

  • now i can die, i dont need anymore in this wolrd

  • happy new year

  • happy new year

  • A GIBSON LES PAUL??????????????????????????­??

  • Pink the master of songs sound live shows and more there will never be another FLOYD

  • between the children stop singing an the solo, david changes the strar for a les paul

  • @tadeofa I think thats actually snowy white playing guitar on the les paul

  • i'm 15 and i went to Roger Waters The Wall Live and i haven't been to too many concerts but that is by far the best one i've been and probably ever will go to. I went with my parents and my 2 uncles, and my 2 uncles went to one of the original 1980 shows and they told me about it and i wanted to buy the video, but they told me it was never released and I WAS PISSED. but now i've found all of these and i want to know, can you buy these as a DVD?

  • El mejor tema del mundo

  • finally an appropriate ad: "Roger Waters Tickets"

  • man this prestation sucks

  • who is the second guitarrist? there is a enourmous(?) dif beetwen gilmour improvisation and his. gilmour is pure soul, he speak throw the guitar, its only an instrument but he´s the god of it

  • @rios9283 he is Snowy White =)

  • @Thexile123 thanks man!!

  • how can you have any pudin if you dont eat your meat?

  • So does anyone know if there is a story behind the #1 shirt Roger wears

  • Pink Floyd discography:

    Full discography from hotfile(dot)com:

    hotfile(dot)com/list/998266/b8­d7e5d

  • Who is playing the other guitar?

  • @jaketodate Snowy White i think :)

  • nice edit job. I only know of 2 sources for the live film that was shot

  • David has such power in his playing,like no other,This is the real Floyd!!

  • i love pink floyd

  • man i love these guys, Nick looks stoned O.O

  • @6:13 onward .... just awesome!

  • Roger needs to hurry up remastering these tapes i hope he puts them out for sale when he does

  • @Rokky616

    Not a roger waters concert. This is Pink Floyd.

  • @fordescortracer sorry bout the accidental thumb down, ik this is floyd, but roger waters recently found some tapes of this concert in excellent condition, not dark crap footage in the bootleg, but really nice quality vids. that was last december when he reported he found the tapes.

  • How DAVID GILMOUR switched from his black strat to his LES PAUL GOLD TOP is amazing. I lwould like to have a gold top like SNOWY WHITE's, expect I want the white trim around the humbucking pickups and the switch.

  • I hate Snowy White he never got it right not even in the current 2010 Roger Waters Wall tour!

  • @Pink000Floyd What in the hell are you talking about? What a silly statement to make.

  • Really nice solo.

  • amazing version, gilmour's second solo improvising is just amazing

  • @leomessi1 The second solo was played by Snowy White..... Not Gilmour

  • @bettsaj Check out the Pulse version the whole thing was played by Gilmour

  • @Pink000Floyd On the Pulse version I saw, (P.U.L.S.E live full part two)Tim Renwick played the 2nd solo

  • i like daved gilmour better then snowie white as a guiate playier

  • @birds85us00000000000 who wudnt

  • some very fierce bass by roger throughout...excellent production. Wish I was alive for when they were together.

  • Damn.

  • this 1 got a veeerrry good swing in it :)

  • The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD, check my channel for info on how to obtain it so you can enjoy at home on TV

  • damn longhairs...

  • i love the visuals of this concert but i love the happiest days of our lives more!!

  • is this on dvd

  • ah still gives me goosebumps and chills. thumbs up for gilmore being out of this world on guitar.

  • if the happiest days of our lives didnt existed it would be still like the old version of pulse

  • Yes it is snowy white @skeletonkey6

    and @MrRathazar: I believe up to 1:41 is the actual audio from the show, after that I believe it is uploaded audio. Quality of audio seems to improve at the end of Happiest days and you hear the crowd briefly. The vocals of Roger and David also sound clearer.

  • This is amazing, because it's the actual audio from the concert. All the other videos of this concert I've seen use audio dubs from the specific concert that was used for the album/cd release. I simply love it! All hail Floyd.

  • simplemente la mejor banda que existe

  • Thumbs up if your going to "The Wall" Roger Waters Concert!!!!

  • @MissLauraDevine i saw it and it was incredible, ive never seen a better concert

  • @MissLauraDevine Can not wait for it! :)

  • @MissLauraDevine i was suppost to go to the one in cali but tickets were sold out, i cried

  • @MissLauraDevine lucky bastards though i would perfer David Nick in the line-up

  • @MissLauraDevine i have been there! it was insane man, i have never seen something like that!

  • @MissLauraDevine I've already been there! :) unforgettable

  • @MissLauraDevine why the hell do you want all those thumbs up? *rolls eyes* oh and yes... i have tickets...

  • Who is the guy who plays the second guitar solo?

  • @skeletonkey6 snowy white. who, in my opinion, should just let gilmour run the show.

  • @skeletonkey6 I believe it is Snowy White

  • @skeletonkey6

    nick mason i think. 

  • I hate the concert where you can't see the musicians.

  • Roger Waters may very well be my favorite bassist.

  • Brilliant to watch Gilmour and Waters singing together.Love it.

  • It's hilarious.. Those 4 guys absolutely hated eachother during this period- hell, Richard wasn't even an official member anymore.. and then they go out and do without a doubt the greatest rock concert of all-time...

  • @SydPring

    Why did they hate each other?

  • @SydPring I dont think all of them hated each other.....it was basically waters against others with Rick out of floyd....and even after that to do a concert like this, they were musically connected to each other.. :) Floyd rocks

  • Great feeling at the keyboards piece.

  • David looks better today than he did in 1980

  • @krollaostmedburger , ahaha, a bit of gossip.

  • The drum solo right before another brick took over.. in "the happiest days of our lives" was held back a little... still awesome.. i been searching for a long time for vid of the wall live... now to find animals..

  • FUCK YEAH TODAY WAS MY LAST DAY! i dont need no education!! ahahaha WOO SUMMER 2010 MAN!!

  • @Skatemore1243 I know how you feel! I don't need no education ever again too!

  • gilmour is really angry that waters is singing off tones becuz he wants to show up .... is funny he's a t shirt with number 1 on it !!! ( i am pink floyd ! )

  • " their fat and psycopathic wives would thrash them within inches of their lives" CLASSIC.

  • all i know is......gilmore can squeeze every drop of cool that was built into that stratocaster

  • @anotherbastardchild I KNOW, BUT I'M SUPRISED TO SEE HIM PLAYING THAT SOLO ON A GIBSON LES PAUL.... I THOUGHT HE ALWAYS PLAYED FENDERS... SEEN ALMOST EVERY CONCERT ON VIDEO AND NEVER SAW HIM PLAYNG GIBSON

  • @cheminwey me neither...

  • I believe the idea of a "time machine" should solely be invented to see this concert live. Too bad i was born in the wrong fucking generation. This should have been my generation. I have been deprived of seeing the greatest band that ever lived, live.

  • oO First time I saw Gilmour playing with a Les Paul.

  • @afsartori Also, if you notice, it's an real vintage 1950's era gold top with single-coil soap bar pickups. He doesn't use it that often. However he did play it on several On An Island tracks and can be seen playing it on the DVDs of Remember That Night and Live In Gdansk

  • @afsartori

    i was thinkin the same

  • Can anyone tell me where I could buy same looking headphones as roger has?

  • pls someone post tabs for that magnificent solo!

  • Gilmour and Wright were Floyd. Waters, although great in his own right, wanted to recreate Floyd as his own, and it was'nt.

  • @NikonFstopper That's why waters flipped out and became an ass

  • kickassss

  • Why does it all got to be so terribly loud? For me, frankly, its too loud. I just can't bare it. I happened to have grown up with the string quartet which is a bit softer. So, uh, why does it got to be so loud?

  • Well I guess it doesn't have to be so loud but that's the way they like it. But they didn't grow up string with the string quartet so I guess that could be one of the reasons.

  • @Gold753 You grew up with the string quartet? Wow, looks like your life really sucks.

    Learn to appreciate real good music, not gay string quartets, dumbfuck.

  • @PanekPL You don't get the joke, do you?

  • @Gold753 to anyone who does not understand this, its a quote from a presenter who was interviewing early pink floyd

  • Long live David Gilmour.

  • Roger Waters is the voice of Pink Floyd!

  • all the concerts of pink floyd are amazing...

    this is te best of all, brillant !

  • Wrong,..... DO it again

  • any1 heard of radio kaos by roger waters?

  • 2:20 - 2:22 - Bass from playback! Hahaha:)

  • @jasiugm : There was the "Surrogate Band" backing some parts

  • Aww, I was hoping to hear Roger's famous scream live!

  • I love how it goes into another brick in the wall part 2! Just epic!

  • Yes, it is the live version. I have it on CD, and that`s his live guitar solo. And there is no second guitar solo or organ solo on the studio version.

  • This is a live from Earls Court version, where you have Gilmour's solo, and Snowy White's solo! In Live from Nassau colliseum you have only Gilmour's solo! And it is on the Fender instead of Gibson....

  • WTF? That wasn't the live version!

  • 1:13 <3

  • Roger Waters and David Gilmour may of had there differences at some points but without the two of them this is a very different band. After waters left they still produced some good tracks but it was a different pink floyd

  • Agreed, How much more would they have done. Division Bell would have been even better if Waters didn't have such an ego. Now with Richard dead, its never going to happen again.

  • ♥♥♥ i love roger waters

  • I love David Gilmour's guitar playing. He is like a bluesman, he knows how to speak the language of the soul with his instrument. He has a strong connection with his guitar playing.

  • @Ryanyarb24 notes like legit butter. Land o lakes must make his strings

  • @Ryanyarb24 well ya! Pink - Floyd is named after 2 Blues artists. The keyboard really keeps the Blues roots too.

  • at 1:43 this is "another brick in the wall (part 2)", "the happiest days of our lives" is finish. sorry for the english but i'm french ^^'

  • Bonjour, comment allez-vous ne vous préoccupez pas de votre niveau d'anglais est très bon, ce que je voulais dire, c'est que si vous avez raison, lors de la composition de la chanson changé isieron alparecer très bien que si. Excusez mon français n'est pas très bon .....

  • lol love that little look roger gives at :55

    great song btw, always thought this album was one of their more overrated ones but now i see why its played over and over again on the radios lol

  • If you don't eat your meat, you can' t have any pudding! lolololololol

  • This is the best song from The Wall Album especially live!

  • me encantan los gestos de Roger waters