From my point of you it's subjective who is the better vocalist. I think it's not easy to compare Simone Simons and Tarja Turunen because the the musical pitch and the vocal range is completely different. I had to get used to the voice of Simone ,but finally i like both vocalists in the same way.
En mi opinión es subjektivo que cantante es mejor. Yo me gusto Simone y Tarja!!!!
Ambas son geniales. Personalmente me gusta más Simone, porque es mi mismo tipo de voz, y puedo practicar perfectamente con sus canciones... Conocí primero a Tarja, pero Simone se la lleva...
I love them both. They have different types of voices, but they are both sublime. I just wish they would do a duet, sing something together! I would be breathtaking!
Simone Simons la mejor xD ... tarja canta increíble pero Simone tiene una calidad impresionante en su vos que claro necesita pulir pero es impresionante ademas las dos tienen distintos registros y muy diferentes y dentro de sus registros son las mejores
Ambas tienen voces impresionantes, La de Simone es como mas dulce pero la de Tarja tiene mas fuerza y cuando no canta lirico igual se nota que es una soprano, en cambio Simone cuando no canta lirico tiene la voz como la de una cantante de pop xD
Tarja has a very deep and divine voice. She was born to sing in a group like Nightwish, she's just perfect for the Symphonic Metal.
Simone is just an angel, her voice is something sweet and powerful at the same time. Simone was inspired by Tarja, so here we have the Mother of the Symphonic Metal and the Daughter.
los registros no indican quien es mejor o peor...sino el domino de la voz, afinación, colocacion, etc...dentro del rango de cada uno y gana tarja, simone deja mucho que desear en vivo
esta muy buena la comparacion, pero yo fui a ver a epica en enero de este año... y a tarja en marzo, no se pueden comparar en vivo, ya que simone se desafina mucho y se le salen los gallos(sin ofender) me kedo con tarjaa es la mejor de todas!!!!
Esta muy bueno tu video sin embargo, colocar en comparación a Tarja con Simone es algo muy cruel para cada fans ya que las 2 son muy buenas aunque me quedo con Tarja... Sin embargo el mezzosoprano de Simone no esta mal es muy buena pero su voz no alcanzaria a la de Tarja por ser soprano....
Tarja is better for me... more range... Other one is just ok... And to do a comparison on a studio recording, are you kidding me... Get the live versions of upbeat songs for crying out loud...
En lo personal, ambas son grandes voces, por tanto no hay punto de comparación, y además, a ninguna de las dos les interesa, cada una sabe que es buena con lo que hace, y todo lo que nosotros podamos decir es desde la perspectiva de nuestros gustos, o sea, todo parcial
Las dos cantan muy bien, tienen timbres de voces totalmente diferentes, pero siendo sincera Tarja me llega a poner la piel de gallina cuando oigo sus canciones, es fantastica, todavia me da pena q ya no este en el grupo de Nightwish.
como pueden comparar a dos grandes vocalistasss como ellas ademas tienen un registro vocal diferentee..traja es sopranoo y simone es mezzosoprano obvio que no podran hacer lo mismo empezando por que tarja tiene mas potencia en la voz
Tarja es la mejor!!! aunke simone se da duro con ella..aun asi nadie superara a tarja!!! siempre sera la mejor y mas sexi vocalista asi tenga 239847923847298347462374 años!
@Cloud0208 Tarja le gana a Simone, pero Simone le da la pelea, pero hay que decirlo.... Nadie le gana a Floor Jansen tiene una octava mas de registro que Tarja y puede hacer guturales.... A Floor nadie le gana, Y Tarja no me parece muy sexy :/
LAS 2 TIENEN UNA VOZ HERMOSISIMA, SIN EMBARGO HAY QUE ACLARAR QUE TARJA ES SOPRANO Y SIMONE ES MEZZO-SOPRANO QUIERE DECIR QUE SIMONE NO ALCANZA LOS ALTOS QUE TARJA PUEDA ENTONAR PERO LAS PROYECCIONES DE SIMONE SON MAS CLARAS POR LO TANTO LE ES MAS FACIL, TARJA POR SER UNA VOZ DE OPERA CLASICA ES MAS AGUDA Y SIMONE NO SE LE COMPLICA TANTO CANTAR CULAQUIER COSA....ALGO MUY CIERTO ES QUE LAS SOPRANOS SON MUY CHILLONAS Y MAS COMPLEJAS, LA MEJOR FACILIDAD SOMOS LAS CONTRA ALTO Y LAS MEZZO!
A la mierda los que tratan mal a Simone. Ambas son hermosas y cantan excelente. Sin embargo yo me quedo con Simone, su voz es mas dulce y te hace sentir mas cosas que cuando escuchas a tarja, ademas de las letras. Es mi opinion. Ademas, Simone a pesar de ser menos estudiada y mas joven que Tarja en edad y carrera musical se ha ganado un gran respeto en el mundo de el metal. Ella es una de las diosas del metal duelale a quien le duela, asi que no la insulten estupidos!
@kodiak423 Now that you put it that way, it kinda does. I try and be respectful in these sort of debates, but Tarja's voice, despite how many people love it, annoys me. But that's just my opinion. Simone, on the other hand, is like like a vocal goddess. Simone>Tarja IMO.
@AngelRika Now you have. Keep listening. Simone is going places. @thbritneyfan the highest compliment for a teacher is to have a student who surpasses her. No need for a to-the-death comparison; there is room in the musical world for both the queen and the princess :-)
I wish American girls could sing this stuff. LeeAnn Rhimes would actually rival Tarja. You guys have got to check out live stage video from Germany, Tarja with her guest band THE SCORPIONS. Her vocals there are positively HAUNTING. I am VERY PLEASED SHE GOT BACK TO ROCK/PROG MUSIC!!!! Die alive is great video, and Falling Awake is great song. SHE IS NOT AN OPERA SINGER, THAT WOULD WASTE HER AMAZING STAGE PRESENCE.ONLY ONE TARJA. I like lots of others even Annette Olzon, Tarja is still top.
I WAS WITH EPICA LAST NIGHT! SIMONE IS GORGEOUS!!!! 5 years ago I told her I loved her and made all my friends jealous. Although Simone became a singer BECAUSE OF TARJA INFLUENCE, their styles are somewhat different. Tarja IS THE PROG DIVA of alltime. Simone is a little lighter and a little more of a rocker, though not nearly as much a rocker as Annette Olzon. Simone told me that as she listens more to new nightwish this could change, so watch out. MEANTIME, HOW BOUT CHARLOTTE WESSELS?
@MrWinestyle You've got to check out DELAIN. Charlotte Wessels is coming up fast, she emulates Simone and Tarja but with different sound. Frozen is an amazing song, and in The Gathering her voice IS PERFECT with Marco Hietala. Meantime...Mark Jansen told me Epica is working on new stuff. I am trying to arrange a visit to this year ProgPowerUSA for them. Delain was just there AND STOLE THE SHOW! EVEN OVER HAMMERFALL. Anybody like LIV KRISTINE? She's a sweetheart, and sings too....
@kevingthompson13 Delain is good, and you're right when you say that she emulates Tarja and Simone with different sound!Only it seems that Tarja is still the best for energy and originality. Other singers are just variations on a theme. For me best on the planet are Tarja Turunen and unsurpassed Sara Brightman !
@MrWinestyle The one REALLY good thing about Charlotte Wessels, is that with quality newcomers like her this type of music will not die. She also brings a difference that is enjoyable but not copycat. Mark Jansen told me Epica is working on a new direction to rebirth this genre. I dont know if this SCARES me or EXCITES me. If it totally features Simone I would think it not bad. Here's to the music....the saga continues.
@kevingthompson13 Thanx for new information!You're right! this kind of music should find a place on the MTV channel or any other medium! Somehow everyone else forget this important fact. I agree that the Charlotte Wessels, has their own style which is very important for an artist. I guess it therefore stands out from the group of singers who imitate Tarja Turunen.
@MrWinestyle you're right when you say that Charlotte Wessels emulates Simone and Tarja with different sound!Only it seems that Tarja is still the best for energy and originality. Other singers are just variations on a theme. Best on the planet are Tarja Turunen and unsurpassed Sara Brightman!
I know alot of people are about to hate me, but Tarja's voice is unappealing to me. Simone, however, gives me chills when I listen to it. But that's just my opinion, I know alot of people like Tarja and I can respect that, I know she's a big influence in symphonic metal.
Simone has a dead flat voice. Compared to opera singers she lacks vocal creativity or anything to set her apart from every other singer. At least Tarja allows her accent to permeate everything she sings, which is beautiful. Simone is too precise, she lacks scope.
Simone has a dead flat voice. Compared to opera singers she lacks vocal creativity or anything to set her apart from every other singer. At least Tarja allows her accent to permeate everything she sings, which is beautiful. Simone is too precise, she lacks scope.
Obviusly i prefer TARJA TURUNEN, i think she has a really beautifull voice. Simone is great too but if i had to choose... i say Tarja Turunen... my meatl goddess!!!
This video shows us clearly that Tarja's quality of voice is richer and beautifuler, her voice is powerfuler than Simona's voice. Simons has a pretty appearance, but has no voice. Her timbre is inexpressive.
well i prefer simone cause her voice is sweeter than tarja s but they both sing better than the black girls from america i mean the both are goddess but lindsey lohan or some black bicth singer suck!!!!!
Simone. I'm not going to get into the technical stuff this is just based on the melody and tone of the voice and I like Simone's better. Also, her voice is easier to get into than Tarja's.
We're talking about two different worlds here. Of course Tarja > Simone. Tarja made classical singing her life, she's been doing it for years and years. Simone started singing classically after she heard Tarja in Oceanborn, Tarja's experience in classical kicks Simone's ass, though Simone's non-classical voice is really good, but she's relatively new, and she's improving a lot, and with a teacher like Amanda Somerville!! But yeah, Tarja owns her.
Tarja obviusly, she have a very beautiful voice and she is very sweet with her fans..simone have a really sweet voice too but she is not very friendly with her fans
I love the video! You did a very careful and good work! Of course myself I choose Tarja Turunen but I like Simone too! You may chose some songs that Tarja seems to be better than Simone but I don't mind 'cause you put a great effort to have such a result! Goes to favorite :D
Epica is my favourite band so I prefer Simone without doubt but I really like Nightwish too.You should have taken Death of a Dream,Simone's voice in that song is AWESOME.
@fantasyfair2009 thank you I love all the singers you mention and you are right Tarja and Simone are very talented and you can't chose and I think videos like these no offense to the maker of the video you are not a stupid but these kind of competitions are stupid and the comments get nasty.
From my point of you it's subjective who is the better vocalist. I think it's not easy to compare Simone Simons and Tarja Turunen because the the musical pitch and the vocal range is completely different. I had to get used to the voice of Simone ,but finally i like both vocalists in the same way.
En mi opinión es subjektivo que cantante es mejor. Yo me gusto Simone y Tarja!!!!
PansBoy93 1 day ago
match draw
vasilizaciya 2 days ago
Обе хороши... Но Тарья Богиня :)
Pashyta87 1 week ago
Es dificil compararlas. Creo que es un empate considerando los aspectos en los que se juzguen a ambas vocalistas.
LaPoderosaLluvia 1 week ago
TARJA TARJA TARJA THE BEST !!!!! TARJAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
LuNaTIIkAleXxFR 2 weeks ago
TARJA TARJA TARJA TARJA TARJA TARJA TARJA TARJA......
77elvistheking 3 weeks ago
Ambas son geniales. Personalmente me gusta más Simone, porque es mi mismo tipo de voz, y puedo practicar perfectamente con sus canciones... Conocí primero a Tarja, pero Simone se la lleva...
Petal0oza 3 weeks ago
simone simons the best!!!!!!!!!!!
xaviargento 4 weeks ago
Tarja!!! i like that she play more with her voice!, she inspires me a lot!
ThePakito1990 1 month ago
simone simons!!!!!! <3 <3
blackdemon66ful 1 month ago
simone simons i love she is .... wow
metalerablack 1 month ago
really like them both but i think what Tarjas voice is more strong if be honest
Strelok11129 1 month ago
Tarja Turunen
Sanderus 1 month ago
Simone is more attractive.
Nemsault 1 month ago
Have they ever done a song together? Cuz they totally should!
TheAdversaryAlliance 1 month ago
@TheAdversaryAlliance SE SUPONE QUER hicieron una llamada ilusive consensus pero nunka existio en vd....
metalerablack 1 month ago
@metalerablack Okay, well hope it DOES happen one day :) Thanks!
TheAdversaryAlliance 1 month ago
Comment removed
HalfBloodSeverus 1 month ago
i love them both, but i preffer simone
Raquelitacr94 2 months ago
SIMOOOOOOOOOOOONEEEEEEEEEEE
XBurning18AngelX 2 months ago
They are both wonderful singers, but if you ask for my opinion, then I choose Tarja. :)
bayraktari 2 months ago 2
I love them both. They have different types of voices, but they are both sublime. I just wish they would do a duet, sing something together! I would be breathtaking!
Makamonica 2 months ago
Sono tutte 2 grandiose ma preferisco tarja
folletto984 2 months ago
Simone Simons la mejor xD ... tarja canta increíble pero Simone tiene una calidad impresionante en su vos que claro necesita pulir pero es impresionante ademas las dos tienen distintos registros y muy diferentes y dentro de sus registros son las mejores
EpicPandorNOX 2 months ago
Simone Simons fronting NIghtwish makes me salivate.
Ironcabbit 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ambas tienen voces impresionantes, La de Simone es como mas dulce pero la de Tarja tiene mas fuerza y cuando no canta lirico igual se nota que es una soprano, en cambio Simone cuando no canta lirico tiene la voz como la de una cantante de pop xD
einsholdElliottSmith 3 months ago
Comment removed
einsholdElliottSmith 3 months ago
Comment removed
einsholdElliottSmith 3 months ago
Mil veces Tarja lejos!!!
GothikaMetalera666 3 months ago
oviooo...Tarjaa turunen x siempreee...
morgann325 2 months ago
Simone of corse !
Itchitsu 3 months ago
Simone :)
MetalNecrophagist 3 months ago
I absolutely love both bands, but I must give the edge to Simone Simons because her voice is simply that of an angel.
JEFFERYNOTHING 4 months ago
Simone is great, but I think Tarja workes better with her huge Voice.
H3ll3ni 4 months ago
3 persons were rejected by tarja and simone!
wbarahona 5 months ago
Tarja!!! +1
evmuv1 6 months ago 6
Both are godd singers but i'll stay with tarja because her voice is espectacular.
Backspacer12 6 months ago
my choice simone sorry tarja <3
EuroHawk777 6 months ago
Tarja has a very deep and divine voice. She was born to sing in a group like Nightwish, she's just perfect for the Symphonic Metal.
Simone is just an angel, her voice is something sweet and powerful at the same time. Simone was inspired by Tarja, so here we have the Mother of the Symphonic Metal and the Daughter.
Sakotoriel 7 months ago 2
Tarja... You can't compare. I absolutely LOVE Simone, she's my idol, but as singer Tarja is something inexplicable.
Sakotoriel 7 months ago 2
I prefer Simone but both are extremely talented
MouthOfTheUnknown 7 months ago
Both!!
ElizabethSirenLuna 7 months ago
Tie, nothing else to say....
thecookchef 7 months ago
I can't compare these two singers, both are as great as the other.
Qabcdefghijklmnop 7 months ago
si hablamos de tecnica y habilidades vocales, gana tarja seguramente, si hablamos del color vocal y todo lo subjetivo, me gusta mas Simone!
klahuss 7 months ago
Las 2 cantan muy bien pero me quedo con TARJA me gusta mas su voz y como es en esenario
gracefilths666 7 months ago
Simone!!! Simone is the best!
noamaximiliano235 8 months ago
Both are very talented and beautiful
riversoflust 8 months ago
Simone : Beautiful
Tarja : Beautiful and the best singer of the world
Ivannnz 8 months ago
pero tarja no es perfecta ni la mejor soprano eso si
katalinaheathcliff 8 months ago
los registros no indican quien es mejor o peor...sino el domino de la voz, afinación, colocacion, etc...dentro del rango de cada uno y gana tarja, simone deja mucho que desear en vivo
katalinaheathcliff 8 months ago
esta muy buena la comparacion, pero yo fui a ver a epica en enero de este año... y a tarja en marzo, no se pueden comparar en vivo, ya que simone se desafina mucho y se le salen los gallos(sin ofender) me kedo con tarjaa es la mejor de todas!!!!
maGotT1000 8 months ago
Esta muy bueno tu video sin embargo, colocar en comparación a Tarja con Simone es algo muy cruel para cada fans ya que las 2 son muy buenas aunque me quedo con Tarja... Sin embargo el mezzosoprano de Simone no esta mal es muy buena pero su voz no alcanzaria a la de Tarja por ser soprano....
Saludos..!!!
yohandry666 8 months ago
TARJA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
saatananpalvoja66615 8 months ago
Love them both, i cant say one is better than the other, but I will say this, Simone blows Tarja out of the water in the looks department.
Ginnungagap418 9 months ago
Comment removed
ThrashAndKill666 9 months ago
I love them both. They are both wonderful singers.
But I wanted to congratulate you, who made this video, because you worked on compairing songs that were alike. Well done =D
orlyane 9 months ago 5
@orlyane thank you so much =)
batman5089 9 months ago
Tarja is the best!
IOMEPROLO 9 months ago
Tarja....!!
GothicAngel00100 9 months ago
it was a close fight, but i think that Angela Gossow one XD
MurderousTeddyBears 9 months ago
Tarja is better for me... more range... Other one is just ok... And to do a comparison on a studio recording, are you kidding me... Get the live versions of upbeat songs for crying out loud...
mphill66 9 months ago
Simone Simons is prettier AND has a better voice, in my opinion.
SMBGamer 9 months ago
Fuck yea, Nemesis
ericsimaginaryfriend 10 months ago
both...
roumburack 10 months ago
En lo personal, ambas son grandes voces, por tanto no hay punto de comparación, y además, a ninguna de las dos les interesa, cada una sabe que es buena con lo que hace, y todo lo que nosotros podamos decir es desde la perspectiva de nuestros gustos, o sea, todo parcial
lacra20 10 months ago
Comment removed
rubenmol13 10 months ago 2
Why put them against each other!? I love them both!!!
CrazyChevChelios 10 months ago
Las dos cantan muy bien, tienen timbres de voces totalmente diferentes, pero siendo sincera Tarja me llega a poner la piel de gallina cuando oigo sus canciones, es fantastica, todavia me da pena q ya no este en el grupo de Nightwish.
Saludos!
Clinfer4 10 months ago
anyway.. there's a huge difference between them.. traja is a lyric soprano and simone is a mezzo soprano, so practically it's hard to compare them
lixtila 11 months ago
simone ftw
lixtila 11 months ago
como pueden comparar a dos grandes vocalistasss como ellas ademas tienen un registro vocal diferentee..traja es sopranoo y simone es mezzosoprano obvio que no podran hacer lo mismo empezando por que tarja tiene mas potencia en la voz
LauradeFilth 11 months ago
Me quedo con Tarja! Yeah! Tarja the number one forever
5axs 11 months ago
No puedo decidir!!! las dos me super gustan!!!
ehekatl013viento 1 year ago
I prefer Tarja because she has a much more powerful voice, but I like Simone's singing too.
Yanga617 1 year ago
simone's voice is more beatiful, but tarja's voice is better
AitorDivas 1 year ago
Simone!
asdatriel 1 year ago
pues la verdad me gusta mas la voz de Simone
aunque Tarja sea genial
myfire93 1 year ago
I love both of them! They are beautyfull singers! But for me, Tarja is the Queen of metal!!!
raistxxx 1 year ago 3
PTM! me ponen en aprietos! bueno, creo que me gusta mas Tarja, sin menospreciar el gran talento y belleza de Simone
MusicaCool23 1 year ago
Tarja es la mejor!!! aunke simone se da duro con ella..aun asi nadie superara a tarja!!! siempre sera la mejor y mas sexi vocalista asi tenga 239847923847298347462374 años!
Cloud0208 1 year ago 4
@Cloud0208 Tarja le gana a Simone, pero Simone le da la pelea, pero hay que decirlo.... Nadie le gana a Floor Jansen tiene una octava mas de registro que Tarja y puede hacer guturales.... A Floor nadie le gana, Y Tarja no me parece muy sexy :/
Caos0828 4 months ago
I just love them both!!!!!!!!!
666Meeshell 1 year ago
I love them both and I can't say who better sings.. they are so different, but has similar styles. Great. That's all..;p
martynianna14 1 year ago
LAS 2 TIENEN UNA VOZ HERMOSISIMA, SIN EMBARGO HAY QUE ACLARAR QUE TARJA ES SOPRANO Y SIMONE ES MEZZO-SOPRANO QUIERE DECIR QUE SIMONE NO ALCANZA LOS ALTOS QUE TARJA PUEDA ENTONAR PERO LAS PROYECCIONES DE SIMONE SON MAS CLARAS POR LO TANTO LE ES MAS FACIL, TARJA POR SER UNA VOZ DE OPERA CLASICA ES MAS AGUDA Y SIMONE NO SE LE COMPLICA TANTO CANTAR CULAQUIER COSA....ALGO MUY CIERTO ES QUE LAS SOPRANOS SON MUY CHILLONAS Y MAS COMPLEJAS, LA MEJOR FACILIDAD SOMOS LAS CONTRA ALTO Y LAS MEZZO!
vanex51 1 year ago 3
Tarja fans and Simone fans are the greatest fans ever.
Instead of bitching at each other which one is better, they agree both singers are awesome.
I REALLY LOVE YOU GUYS.
heisenmanFC 1 year ago 28
Dos ángeles cantando, no tenemos que compararlas, sólo tenemos que honrarlas...
AlexandrosRedle 1 year ago 2
It's really messed up to compare them since they both know each other and Tarja is Simone's reason for singing.
Stargeek2006 1 year ago
A la mierda los que tratan mal a Simone. Ambas son hermosas y cantan excelente. Sin embargo yo me quedo con Simone, su voz es mas dulce y te hace sentir mas cosas que cuando escuchas a tarja, ademas de las letras. Es mi opinion. Ademas, Simone a pesar de ser menos estudiada y mas joven que Tarja en edad y carrera musical se ha ganado un gran respeto en el mundo de el metal. Ella es una de las diosas del metal duelale a quien le duela, asi que no la insulten estupidos!
tatis0320 1 year ago
Both are great singers, but Tarja is better than Simone.
Thats my opinion.
hajnalikod 1 year ago
I think they 're having both really gr8 voices , but i prefer Simone's one because it's easier to listen
SantiSimmons 1 year ago
Well... Simone decide to take classical singing lessons after listening to Nightwish CD ''Oceanborn'' (wikipedia). Because Tarja is the Queen!...
Harmoner 1 year ago
Tarja!!!!!!!!!!!
PegoutMarsean 1 year ago
@kodiak423 Now that you put it that way, it kinda does. I try and be respectful in these sort of debates, but Tarja's voice, despite how many people love it, annoys me. But that's just my opinion. Simone, on the other hand, is like like a vocal goddess. Simone>Tarja IMO.
MissBonaparte 1 year ago
Who is the Simone? oO Never heard of her
Tarja rules!!!
AngelRika 1 year ago
@AngelRika Now you have. Keep listening. Simone is going places. @thbritneyfan the highest compliment for a teacher is to have a student who surpasses her. No need for a to-the-death comparison; there is room in the musical world for both the queen and the princess :-)
RameshChotanagour 1 year ago
Tarja! I absolutely love Tarja and the old Nightwish.
Epica is great as well though.
OnlyforEternity 1 year ago
no deberian compararlas las dos tienen voz de angeles..... ELlas cantan hermosoooo¡¡
AngelikALeeWilliams 1 year ago
@AngelikALeeWilliams mui sierto
admiro muxisimo a estas dos xikas!!!!
d vrdd son exelents las dos x iwal
y no es mui necesario la cmparacion
y menos la prgnta d kien es mjr!
mcr89gee 1 year ago
QUEENS OF DIFERENTS KINGDOMS
LoganLinoge 1 year ago
Simone has a very cute voice is very sweet and she is pretty tarja has the voice but is ugly sorry her forehead is big
azabache1525 1 year ago
I´m prefer Tarja.. she just be perfect!!
tekkaway 1 year ago
tarja es 1000000 de veces mejor con solo el hecho de que es soprano y simone es messoprano.pero me encantan las 2!!!
braian1818 1 year ago
really (for me) is hard to choose one: Tarja Tha Majesty Of The Metal vs Simone: The Angel Of The Metal
lukkaturi 1 year ago
@danielss1772siick Agreed!
MissBonaparte 1 year ago
I wish American girls could sing this stuff. LeeAnn Rhimes would actually rival Tarja. You guys have got to check out live stage video from Germany, Tarja with her guest band THE SCORPIONS. Her vocals there are positively HAUNTING. I am VERY PLEASED SHE GOT BACK TO ROCK/PROG MUSIC!!!! Die alive is great video, and Falling Awake is great song. SHE IS NOT AN OPERA SINGER, THAT WOULD WASTE HER AMAZING STAGE PRESENCE.ONLY ONE TARJA. I like lots of others even Annette Olzon, Tarja is still top.
kevingthompson13 1 year ago
Tarja's voice is so deep & dramatic.. I like it!
Zigzag111ful 1 year ago
Tarja is an unchangeable queen
chopantura 1 year ago
Dos bellezas de voz melodiosa, dos ninfas definitivamente no tengo palabras para dos maravillas de mujeres y voces pera mi las dos ganan es un empate
VampireLordable1 1 year ago
I like Tarja more, but that doesnt mean that i dont like Simone
satircon 1 year ago
I WAS WITH EPICA LAST NIGHT! SIMONE IS GORGEOUS!!!! 5 years ago I told her I loved her and made all my friends jealous. Although Simone became a singer BECAUSE OF TARJA INFLUENCE, their styles are somewhat different. Tarja IS THE PROG DIVA of alltime. Simone is a little lighter and a little more of a rocker, though not nearly as much a rocker as Annette Olzon. Simone told me that as she listens more to new nightwish this could change, so watch out. MEANTIME, HOW BOUT CHARLOTTE WESSELS?
kevingthompson13 1 year ago
@kevingthompson13 Your comment is the best !Agree!
MrWinestyle 1 year ago
@MrWinestyle You've got to check out DELAIN. Charlotte Wessels is coming up fast, she emulates Simone and Tarja but with different sound. Frozen is an amazing song, and in The Gathering her voice IS PERFECT with Marco Hietala. Meantime...Mark Jansen told me Epica is working on new stuff. I am trying to arrange a visit to this year ProgPowerUSA for them. Delain was just there AND STOLE THE SHOW! EVEN OVER HAMMERFALL. Anybody like LIV KRISTINE? She's a sweetheart, and sings too....
kevingthompson13 1 year ago
@kevingthompson13 Delain is good, and you're right when you say that she emulates Tarja and Simone with different sound!Only it seems that Tarja is still the best for energy and originality. Other singers are just variations on a theme. For me best on the planet are Tarja Turunen and unsurpassed Sara Brightman !
MrWinestyle 1 year ago
@MrWinestyle The one REALLY good thing about Charlotte Wessels, is that with quality newcomers like her this type of music will not die. She also brings a difference that is enjoyable but not copycat. Mark Jansen told me Epica is working on a new direction to rebirth this genre. I dont know if this SCARES me or EXCITES me. If it totally features Simone I would think it not bad. Here's to the music....the saga continues.
kevingthompson13 1 year ago
@kevingthompson13 Thanx for new information!You're right! this kind of music should find a place on the MTV channel or any other medium! Somehow everyone else forget this important fact. I agree that the Charlotte Wessels, has their own style which is very important for an artist. I guess it therefore stands out from the group of singers who imitate Tarja Turunen.
MrWinestyle 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MrWinestyle you're right when you say that Charlotte Wessels emulates Simone and Tarja with different sound!Only it seems that Tarja is still the best for energy and originality. Other singers are just variations on a theme. Best on the planet are Tarja Turunen and unsurpassed Sara Brightman!
MrWinestyle 1 year ago
I love Simone she is the queen of metal and is very beatiful
dialonso17 1 year ago
eu prefiro a simone!!!
TheHenriques1 1 year ago
Tarja is the queen forever....
Tarjista1 1 year ago 3
Tarja = Goddness
Simone = Queen
Katra = Princess
:)
NicoleAlicjaB 1 year ago 13
I know alot of people are about to hate me, but Tarja's voice is unappealing to me. Simone, however, gives me chills when I listen to it. But that's just my opinion, I know alot of people like Tarja and I can respect that, I know she's a big influence in symphonic metal.
MissBonaparte 1 year ago
tarja is unique and the best
TheIcePurple 1 year ago 4
@TheIcePurple you are right
MrWinestyle 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Simone has a dead flat voice. Compared to opera singers she lacks vocal creativity or anything to set her apart from every other singer. At least Tarja allows her accent to permeate everything she sings, which is beautiful. Simone is too precise, she lacks scope.
multiosguy 1 year ago
Simone has a dead flat voice. Compared to opera singers she lacks vocal creativity or anything to set her apart from every other singer. At least Tarja allows her accent to permeate everything she sings, which is beautiful. Simone is too precise, she lacks scope.
multiosguy 1 year ago
simone have a voice so difrent tu tarja... simone is mezzo soprano she have more floreos than tarja... i love simone's voice
chikreversible 1 year ago
Tarja is my number 1!
Simone number 2.
MrsLesleyOlivia 1 year ago
Obviusly i prefer TARJA TURUNEN, i think she has a really beautifull voice. Simone is great too but if i had to choose... i say Tarja Turunen... my meatl goddess!!!
AnteroomOfDeath 1 year ago 3
Thi is ehatat is called lirical si ging they are both great but I choose tarja for her raenge and power
jackesdmollay79930 1 year ago
Both are terrifics.. singers and females.. In between lies my heart
sarddok 1 year ago
SIMONE forever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
cordelya77 1 year ago
Only Tarja.
AgnisJ8 1 year ago
This video shows us clearly that Tarja's quality of voice is richer and beautifuler, her voice is powerfuler than Simona's voice. Simons has a pretty appearance, but has no voice. Her timbre is inexpressive.
Kedavra73 1 year ago
Simone SImons 10 ::::::Tarja Turunen 9.9...No ay forma d k tarja c le compare a Simons, en el ambito musical claro esta...
pinochosaurius 1 year ago
greet singers both....They are so unique...!!Love them both...Great voices....
cyprus694 1 year ago
Simone. Tarja is too harsh.
Mpavblue 1 year ago
wahoooo me quedo con las dosss de verdadd queee las dosss me encantann sus vocess no las comparo con ningunaaa otraaa
thereyesy7 1 year ago
epica stupid :S
TheLayira 1 year ago
idiotas no pueden comparar son muy buenas las dos a demas de ser amigas.. manga de pelotudos
KaelSPS 1 year ago
Both are great singers but Tarja is the best
jackesdmollay79930 1 year ago 2
ONLY IS ONE ORIGINAL - TARJA TURUNRN ! She is real metal singer, Simone is like POP singer with soft voice.
MrWinestyle 1 year ago
Simone simons<3 I love Tarja and all but simone simons is my favourite <3 her voice is just amazing and she just -WOW. <3 simone simons always<3:)
withintemptationrock 1 year ago
@withintemptationrock Simone is like pop singer with her soft voice!
MrWinestyle 1 year ago
well i prefer simone cause her voice is sweeter than tarja s but they both sing better than the black girls from america i mean the both are goddess but lindsey lohan or some black bicth singer suck!!!!!
end2810 1 year ago
Preferisco Simone
drillingolf 1 year ago
Simone. I'm not going to get into the technical stuff this is just based on the melody and tone of the voice and I like Simone's better. Also, her voice is easier to get into than Tarja's.
lildarkrose13 1 year ago
las dos son muy buenas y prefiero no hacer comparaciones a las dos las amo igual XD
juanmchairez 1 year ago
Tarja is the QUEEN, Simone is the princess ;)
evanescencesp 1 year ago 51
@evanescencesp they complet each of other you must admit that they both queens in my opinion
universfan01 1 year ago
Tarja!!!!!
szalmapityi 1 year ago 3
ich one is perfect!
Veredain 1 year ago
We're talking about two different worlds here. Of course Tarja > Simone. Tarja made classical singing her life, she's been doing it for years and years. Simone started singing classically after she heard Tarja in Oceanborn, Tarja's experience in classical kicks Simone's ass, though Simone's non-classical voice is really good, but she's relatively new, and she's improving a lot, and with a teacher like Amanda Somerville!! But yeah, Tarja owns her.
arturesteve 1 year ago
@arturesteve You are so right !
MrWinestyle 1 year ago
tarja (:
elviraluu 1 year ago
Tarja obviusly, she have a very beautiful voice and she is very sweet with her fans..simone have a really sweet voice too but she is not very friendly with her fans
edeyale 1 year ago
I love Nightwish and Epica,but Tarja wins,but they are diferent,we cant compare both :S
nightwish231 1 year ago
the queen and the princess!!!
liricobarroco 1 year ago
I love the video! You did a very careful and good work! Of course myself I choose Tarja Turunen but I like Simone too! You may chose some songs that Tarja seems to be better than Simone but I don't mind 'cause you put a great effort to have such a result! Goes to favorite :D
tomavroxricopcaro 1 year ago 12
@tomavroxricopcaro Thanks so much!!
batman5089 1 year ago
Tarja has more experience! But Simone is awesome too and she has a lot of things to learn yet!!! I say BOTH!!!!!!!!!!! <3
IntampestusNox 1 year ago 2
Both!!!
MarsTerrible 1 year ago
Epica is my favourite band so I prefer Simone without doubt but I really like Nightwish too.You should have taken Death of a Dream,Simone's voice in that song is AWESOME.
spupydo 1 year ago
Tarja y Simone son distintas, yo prefiero a las dos por igual.
PAFR24 1 year ago
simonee duermee askoo kn esa viejaa y tarjaa hermosuraa de voz laa amoo
tarja i lovee(L)
alexortto 1 year ago
Hmmmmm..... I do love Simone but Tarja has to win here :)
BeckyLouiseMcIntosh 1 year ago
Simonee(L)
Fleur6metal 1 year ago
Simonee(L)
Fleur6metal 1 year ago
wtf
o.O
how STUPID you are ....no offence
Simone and Tarja are so talentated and beautiful...
i think Tarja,Simone,Sharon and Amy lee are the best metal female singers!!!!
you can`t chose!!!!!!
fantasyfair2009 1 year ago
wtf
o.O
how STUPID you are ....no offence
Simone and Tarja are so talentated and beautiful...
i think Tarja,Simone,Sharon and Amy lee are the best metal female singers!!!!
you can`t chose!!!!!!
fantasyfair2009 1 year ago 3
@fantasyfair2009 thank you I love all the singers you mention and you are right Tarja and Simone are very talented and you can't chose and I think videos like these no offense to the maker of the video you are not a stupid but these kind of competitions are stupid and the comments get nasty.
mariahthebest1 1 year ago
If any title says Tarja vs someone, then the winner is Tarja obviously.
BlankoPie 1 year ago
Tarja FTW!
contentmentiswealth 1 year ago