Ammar Nakshwani- Speakers who don't charge a lot of money are a disease!

[AbuLuLu110]

Great drawings :P

[MrAlikazmi110]

grow up!!!

yeah youve done it

made the ppl around the world aware that he charges for lectures

what a pointless video

sit there in your low life bedroom and make another one

get a life

[tiadeals]

An individual will pay thousands and thousands of dollars to a jewish university to get education but when it comes to paying a scholar who speaks of the ahle bayt, is this that big of an issue?!?! ppl are upset because hes right. realize it and change pls. we live in a country were we all can afford it believe me. in one majlis there must be over 500 ppl, 5 dollars, not even for one day you cant afford that!! don't eat a fancy dinner meal for one night im sure ur not going to starve to death!!

[FMKAZIMI]

Unfortunately, people get blinded by a person who can speak the language well, and forget that the purpose is knowledge and understanding of message of Ahale-ul-bait. Is ziker-e-Ahalul-Bait for the purpose of fancy cars and flashy Dressing?

[nomoreuniqueidsleft]

Please watch this: youtube.com/watch?v=JLV9r7MwMQ­Y&feature=yt#t=64m09s

(Sorry about multiple posts... previous links didn't work.)

[TheAnneJDelkem]

@mukhtar5420 Brother, I do agree with what you have to say but at the same time many of these speakers dedicate extensive time and effort to learn and perfect their knowledge so that they may spread it in other words this is their profession of course they still need to make a living somehow in order to support their families. To pay a speaker who dedicate their time to spread their knowledge I do not think is too much to ask.

[mukhtar5420]

@TheAnneJDelkem I agree as a community it is our responsibility to support our scholars and make sure that they can support their families, but on the same note there is a very delicate balance between the two. When a speaker asks outrageous amounts to spread the knowledge of Ahl-e-bait and request 1st class plane tickets to recite majalis that is unacceptable. To top it off calling other Ulema that do not demand a fee a "DISEASE" is wrong how ever you look at it.

[madilakif]

He takes over $1000 per Majlis, he is one of the scholar for dollar and he wants to come up with arguments to justify his commericialization of Karbala. The diasease we need to work on is GREED in the so called scholars for dollars. What needs to stop is the exploitation of the great sacrifice of Imam Husain (AS).

[syedalubahussain]

he is referring to habit,of these speakers.if he takes money he is open about it . but people who at the same time wana be nice and show they donot take money but hidden words say give what ever you want . is not good and disease means here is habbit or act of these ppl

[mukhtar5420]

@syedalubahussain Doing something wrong openly in the public does not make it right. It just shows that one has just lost there inner voice of reason and rational and that Hub-e Duniya, "GREED", has totally clouded their judgemnet. Do not confuse the issue here, what was said was clear... you don't need to crack out a dictionary to explain it. We need to take off our blinders and reassess our priorties in life before letting a speaker enter our center and address our children and community.

[syedalubahussain]

Noun:

1 A disorder of structure or function in a human, animal, or plant, esp. one that produces specific signs or symptoms or that affects a...

2 A particular quality, habit, or disposition regarded as adversely affecting a person or group of people

[syedalubahussain]

he is saying that these scholars should write before if they want money . if you want to take take it . if you dont want to take say it too but if from inside you want hadiya write a contract. coz this will create problem for speakers who take money and , ppl attack them and say them bad . and disease is not medical disease as cancer . but here as you can search disease meaning it

[syedalubahussain]

woh log jo yeah kehtay hain keh app jo bhi daina chaho woh dey do aur phr pareshan hotay hain har chez ko likh laina chahiyay .if you listen carefully unko kaha hai un zakareen ko naseehat ki hai keh likh liya karo naa kay sab zakareen jo nahi laitay . he said some speakers come frwrd and say " I am not going to charge,u give me what ever u can give me. These speakers are the disease ( not every speaker who does not take money ) and he explain why.please listen carefully again.before you frwrd

[syedalubahussain]

woh log jo yeah kehtay hain keh app jo bhi daina chaho woh dey do aur phr pareshan hotay hain har chez ko likh laina chahiyay .if you listen carefully unko kaha hai un zakareen ko naseehat ki hai keh likh liya karo naa kay sab zakareen jo nahi laitay . he said some speakers come forward and say " I am not going to charge,you give me what ever you can give me. These speakers are the disease . ( not every speaker who does not take money ) and he explain why . please listen carefully again .

[mukhtar5420]

There is a diff. b/w giving what one can afford and a speaker demanding a fee. Muharram should not be commercialized..the event of Kerbala should not be viewed as commodity. People get confused with the argument of "The Alim has to feed his family" this not about the family, but about greed and Hub-e Dunya.Calling other Ulema a"Disease" is wrong.

[Sayyida110]

What lecture is this from???