Cmon guys i like this band along with you, but its going a little far to think you all knew him and whatnot, just shut the fuck up i dont care get over it.
you know, i didn't know layne personally but i cant help but feeling like i knew him and he knew me... that if we ever met, he could have understood me. and that's rare these days, that i can actually say that i feel a connection to a musician through his or hers music.
i still can't listen to any of the new AIC songs. i think that a death of a crucial member of a band is more than enough to kill this band. i respect Duvall, but, comparison to layne is inevitable, and that costs fans to AIC.
wtf is this "true fan" bullshit. i keep seeing this phrase all over music. if i liked alice in chains in the 90's right up to laynes death and only listen to THAT music to this day, im not a "true fan" because i dont like duvall??? how are you going to define what type of fan I am?
excuse me? pitchy? William Duvall in some of the performances I've seen goes off key a lot on the old songs. And I mean a lot. And its annoying. Layne was in a horrible state during unplugged and he did flawlessly. Of course, his voice was not up to par all the time, but that happens to every singer, not just Staley. Duvall is not void of this either, just look up I Stay Away AIC did with an orchestra, he sucked hard.
I think the reason I hate duvall, is because look who's shoes he is trying to fill. How can you go from one the best rock singers ever in staley. To guy like duvall who is honestly just a slightly above average vocalist.
People who think Duvall sounds great are tone deaf and or just can't admit he's not that good. AIC has a great legacy and made music that was holy.
BGW2B is an average album. and AIC never made average records. AIC is dead
@Wesson4 Have you listened to the above video, Layne wasen't that great live. Not knocking him but I saw them on the Facelift tour and the Dirt tour and saw them with Duvall last night and he was flawless. So to call him slightly above average is way off. Lane was always pitchy live, Duvall gave a great performance..
@Wesson4 - Dude - I'm the biggest Staley fan ever....but if you can't admit that the man struggled live at times (because he was FUCKED up) than you're delusional, sir.
Oh no he wasn't at all buddy ;) listen some bootlegs from 1996 ... You will understand what i mean . Listen to a version of Man in the box in 1996 , you'll see that he's voice was really really fucked up . He couldn't hit the high notes ... His voice was perfect in 1990 - 1993 . Then the 94 - 96 era fucked up his voice ..
@Wesson4 No i didn't say that dumbass . Of course i prefer 1000 times layne , like everyone ... But I think that duvall is fits well Layne's shoes... So what? You were expecting a layne wannabe ?
@williamduvallFTW Bullshit. Yes at times his voice was fucked up. Check out the unplugged performance in 96. IMO one of his best vocal performances ever. His voice is still unfuckingbelievable in 96. Hes just like any other vocalist, he had his good shows and bad shows. I remember seeing a vid of man in the box from 91 and his vocals werent that great. It toke him years to finally perfect his vocals.
It seems like i am talking to a WALL . You are freaking stupid man . HEROIN AND CRACK DOES FUCK UP YOUR VOCALS, ITS A FUCKING FACT. GO READ A LITTLE BIT . Some people really enjoy layne's voice in 1996 ( and I do ) , sounds more " raw " , but it's a fact that he couldn't hit the very high notes anymore.. ( Love hate love wasn't sung anymore in 96 ) . I LOVE the mtv unplugged performance, even is layne was sick as hell ...
@williamduvallFTW i know that herion and crack fucks up your vocals. but im just saying that still in 96 he had amazing vocals. and your right about the unplugged performanace his vocals were more raw and thats why I love it so much.
@williamduvallFTW Nah in 94 they didn't tour as AIC. In 94 his voice was still deep and not fucked up. His voice got higher and fucked ip in 95.. There are videos of Layne live 1994, but with Second coming and Tool he still had a sturdy voice. 95 bweas the beginning of his downward spiral.
Sure nobody will ever replace Layne or be as good as Layne was, BUT DuVall is doing a fucking brilliant job and he's not trying to imitate Layne and that's one of the best things about him. He's just himself. Sure we miss Layne but if you're a true Alice fan you accept that DuVall is now the singer. I mean there is a reason why Jerry, Sean and Mike chose him to be their new singer. And DuVall is actually a great singer. Will, you rock !
people rip on Duvall, cause AIC was Laynes' band at least 50 percent if not more than Jerry... Jerry can play the songs, but change your name out of respect... AIC died years ago... also I did give Duvall a chance kinda sounding like layne, but a little different.. Well how come on their new cd, He actually sings and makes the sounds layne did... Now thats a rip off... They are banking off Laynes' sound...
i gave duvall a chance too while still vehemently disagreeing with them about keeping the same name & it makes me sick, not only because layne's dead but cuz the band is dead. it's like a progression of jerry's solo career which wasn't very successful & mike & sean worked with him then but now banking off the AIC name they're successful. i'm afraid of the young people thinking the new stuff is AIC when it's so simply NOT!
I agree. Old AIC is like my fave band, but the new stuff doesn't even make top 20, that might be just me ofc, but when I feel like I'm not even hearing DuVall singing at all. It's as if they've got two of Jerry backing up nothing.
AiC's Music was actually ahead of it's time IMHO. Miss Layne, but it's great they are touring again. Some are ripping DuVall, but true fans should give the guy a break. Just hearing AiC songs again LIVE is very comforting. Laynes death was terribly tragic, but somewhat predictable with Heroine addiction. RIP Layne!
@sakonhagakure ctrl+f for black, nig and afr turned up ZERO matches. I went ahead and skimmed through the comments anyway and found absolutely nothing that pointed to racism. How the fuck does that make you right?
@sakonhagakure you must be one of those liberal douche bags who turns everything into a racial crime. Fuck off idiot, duvall sucks...end of story. And it has absolutely NOTHING to do with the fact he's a moolie.
@sakonhagakure i dont hate on duvall but some songs (like nutshell or junkhead) i dont think anybody should sing exept layne its just like burning a bible for me some thing u just dont do
I can't speak for everyone but I do it because he's not the right fit for AIC's original stuff live. I respect him for stepping in but had the original members decided to form a new band with DuVall under a different name of formed a tribute band then I might like him more but he just cannot sing Layne's parts well at all.
Doesn't mean to say he isn't a good singer, he really can be at time. Just not quite right.
i wish that i have seen them live. same with nirvana. but i wasn't even born when kurt cobain died. and i was just 8 years old when layne staley died.
fucking cant get enough live versions of this, its fun hearing cantrels many variations of the guitar solo. its odd for such a simple solo to hold my attention for so long
I agree with Cantrell's guitar solos. I like how he changes them up a tiny bit everytime! I've been paying attention to that with all these live versions... he's amazing! So is Layne... they were a perfect pair. :(
did u question yourself if he is too drunk or junk or tired and forget the notes what u don't believe that come on shit just happens daaa no offend i like Alice in Chains but this thing it happens even to guitarist like Cantrell
@2:48 ham
1989aliceinchains 1 month ago
my uncle was at this gig i think, he said that Staley kicked some1 in the audience :)
Corpzmaker91 5 months ago
@Corpzmaker91 Sort of. He bitch-slapped a neo-Nazi and he fell off the stage.
ItHurtsWhenIPee100 2 weeks ago
@ItHurtsWhenIPee100 lol :P
Corpzmaker91 2 weeks ago
Cmon guys i like this band along with you, but its going a little far to think you all knew him and whatnot, just shut the fuck up i dont care get over it.
lukeindeed 6 months ago
you know, i didn't know layne personally but i cant help but feeling like i knew him and he knew me... that if we ever met, he could have understood me. and that's rare these days, that i can actually say that i feel a connection to a musician through his or hers music.
i still can't listen to any of the new AIC songs. i think that a death of a crucial member of a band is more than enough to kill this band. i respect Duvall, but, comparison to layne is inevitable, and that costs fans to AIC.
octopusxoctopus 9 months ago
wtf is this "true fan" bullshit. i keep seeing this phrase all over music. if i liked alice in chains in the 90's right up to laynes death and only listen to THAT music to this day, im not a "true fan" because i dont like duvall??? how are you going to define what type of fan I am?
123gal456 1 year ago 4
excuse me? pitchy? William Duvall in some of the performances I've seen goes off key a lot on the old songs. And I mean a lot. And its annoying. Layne was in a horrible state during unplugged and he did flawlessly. Of course, his voice was not up to par all the time, but that happens to every singer, not just Staley. Duvall is not void of this either, just look up I Stay Away AIC did with an orchestra, he sucked hard.
ImmortalLayneStaley 1 year ago
I think the reason I hate duvall, is because look who's shoes he is trying to fill. How can you go from one the best rock singers ever in staley. To guy like duvall who is honestly just a slightly above average vocalist.
People who think Duvall sounds great are tone deaf and or just can't admit he's not that good. AIC has a great legacy and made music that was holy.
BGW2B is an average album. and AIC never made average records. AIC is dead
Wesson4 1 year ago
@Wesson4 Have you listened to the above video, Layne wasen't that great live. Not knocking him but I saw them on the Facelift tour and the Dirt tour and saw them with Duvall last night and he was flawless. So to call him slightly above average is way off. Lane was always pitchy live, Duvall gave a great performance..
stonedbonez420 1 year ago
@stonedbonez420 Ya right buddy. Layne's voice live was just like studio version. Stop being biased.
Wesson4 1 year ago
@Wesson4 - Dude - I'm the biggest Staley fan ever....but if you can't admit that the man struggled live at times (because he was FUCKED up) than you're delusional, sir.
jz881 1 year ago
@jz881 He struggled in 96 perhaps, but from 1990 to 1993. Seeing this man live was a godly vocal experience
Wesson4 1 year ago
@Wesson4
Oh no he wasn't at all buddy ;) listen some bootlegs from 1996 ... You will understand what i mean . Listen to a version of Man in the box in 1996 , you'll see that he's voice was really really fucked up . He couldn't hit the high notes ... His voice was perfect in 1990 - 1993 . Then the 94 - 96 era fucked up his voice ..
williamduvallFTW 1 year ago
@williamduvallFTW haha so what a 96 layne staley is still about 100 times better than your boy Duvall. Duvall is a fucking joke.
Wesson4 1 year ago
@Wesson4 No i didn't say that dumbass . Of course i prefer 1000 times layne , like everyone ... But I think that duvall is fits well Layne's shoes... So what? You were expecting a layne wannabe ?
williamduvallFTW 1 year ago
@williamduvallFTW Bullshit. Yes at times his voice was fucked up. Check out the unplugged performance in 96. IMO one of his best vocal performances ever. His voice is still unfuckingbelievable in 96. Hes just like any other vocalist, he had his good shows and bad shows. I remember seeing a vid of man in the box from 91 and his vocals werent that great. It toke him years to finally perfect his vocals.
kamikazi5489 1 year ago
@kamikazi5489
It seems like i am talking to a WALL . You are freaking stupid man . HEROIN AND CRACK DOES FUCK UP YOUR VOCALS, ITS A FUCKING FACT. GO READ A LITTLE BIT . Some people really enjoy layne's voice in 1996 ( and I do ) , sounds more " raw " , but it's a fact that he couldn't hit the very high notes anymore.. ( Love hate love wasn't sung anymore in 96 ) . I LOVE the mtv unplugged performance, even is layne was sick as hell ...
williamduvallFTW 1 year ago
@williamduvallFTW i know that herion and crack fucks up your vocals. but im just saying that still in 96 he had amazing vocals. and your right about the unplugged performanace his vocals were more raw and thats why I love it so much.
kamikazi5489 1 year ago
@williamduvallFTW Nah in 94 they didn't tour as AIC. In 94 his voice was still deep and not fucked up. His voice got higher and fucked ip in 95.. There are videos of Layne live 1994, but with Second coming and Tool he still had a sturdy voice. 95 bweas the beginning of his downward spiral.
RamonesSkater4life 1 year ago
@RamonesSkater4life Yes you're right forgive my mistake
williamduvallFTW 7 months ago
eat your heart out duvall
Wesson4 1 year ago
Sure nobody will ever replace Layne or be as good as Layne was, BUT DuVall is doing a fucking brilliant job and he's not trying to imitate Layne and that's one of the best things about him. He's just himself. Sure we miss Layne but if you're a true Alice fan you accept that DuVall is now the singer. I mean there is a reason why Jerry, Sean and Mike chose him to be their new singer. And DuVall is actually a great singer. Will, you rock !
RIP Layne
kurtcourtney67 1 year ago
people rip on Duvall, cause AIC was Laynes' band at least 50 percent if not more than Jerry... Jerry can play the songs, but change your name out of respect... AIC died years ago... also I did give Duvall a chance kinda sounding like layne, but a little different.. Well how come on their new cd, He actually sings and makes the sounds layne did... Now thats a rip off... They are banking off Laynes' sound...
sorrow1678 2 years ago
i gave duvall a chance too while still vehemently disagreeing with them about keeping the same name & it makes me sick, not only because layne's dead but cuz the band is dead. it's like a progression of jerry's solo career which wasn't very successful & mike & sean worked with him then but now banking off the AIC name they're successful. i'm afraid of the young people thinking the new stuff is AIC when it's so simply NOT!
divinereference 2 years ago
I agree. Old AIC is like my fave band, but the new stuff doesn't even make top 20, that might be just me ofc, but when I feel like I'm not even hearing DuVall singing at all. It's as if they've got two of Jerry backing up nothing.
CollusionOfChains 2 years ago
AiC's Music was actually ahead of it's time IMHO. Miss Layne, but it's great they are touring again. Some are ripping DuVall, but true fans should give the guy a break. Just hearing AiC songs again LIVE is very comforting. Laynes death was terribly tragic, but somewhat predictable with Heroine addiction. RIP Layne!
fastguild2007 2 years ago 17
Sad thing is most of the people who are ripping on Duvall are doing it simply because he's black and/or they miss Layne.
sakonhagakure 2 years ago 20
@sakonhagakure I dont think anyone would be ripping on Duvall if the band was named anything other than AIC. Its just not "AIC"
jacknife10000 1 year ago 2
@sakonhagakure yeah, im sure it's a race thing fagot.
MrLegendg26 1 year ago 2
@MrLegendg26
So I take it you must fall into the latter category then? Hey douche bag read the comments on this page and you'll see that i'm right.
sakonhagakure 1 year ago
@sakonhagakure ctrl+f for black, nig and afr turned up ZERO matches. I went ahead and skimmed through the comments anyway and found absolutely nothing that pointed to racism. How the fuck does that make you right?
MrLegendg26 1 year ago
@sakonhagakure you must be one of those liberal douche bags who turns everything into a racial crime. Fuck off idiot, duvall sucks...end of story. And it has absolutely NOTHING to do with the fact he's a moolie.
WeDieYoung1083 1 year ago
@WeDieYoung1083
Thanks for making conservatives look bad jack off. Btw I voted for McCain.
sakonhagakure 1 year ago
@sakonhagakure
Or maybe because he is a terrible singer.
2pacinseattle 11 months ago
@sakonhagakure No I dont think theyre doing it cause hes black. Because they miss Layne? Sure.
csmzcs 3 months ago
@csmzcs i hope so
1989aliceinchains 1 month ago
@sakonhagakure i dont hate on duvall but some songs (like nutshell or junkhead) i dont think anybody should sing exept layne its just like burning a bible for me some thing u just dont do
MsJilsephonie 1 month ago
@sakonhagakure
I can't speak for everyone but I do it because he's not the right fit for AIC's original stuff live. I respect him for stepping in but had the original members decided to form a new band with DuVall under a different name of formed a tribute band then I might like him more but he just cannot sing Layne's parts well at all.
Doesn't mean to say he isn't a good singer, he really can be at time. Just not quite right.
RDprodx 2 weeks ago
@fastguild2007 i agree im glad to see them on the road again, but still miss layne but i think ppl should give duvall some credit bc its nt easy
joshmacisaac18 1 year ago
i wish that i have seen them live. same with nirvana. but i wasn't even born when kurt cobain died. and i was just 8 years old when layne staley died.
RIP both
kurtcourtney67 3 years ago
well that can't be right since they died exactly 8 years apart! hehe
pannell81 2 years ago 2
okay i was 7 and a few months later(3 months) i became 8 ;)
kurtcourtney67 2 years ago
fucking cant get enough live versions of this, its fun hearing cantrels many variations of the guitar solo. its odd for such a simple solo to hold my attention for so long
nashnwo1234 3 years ago 3
I agree with Cantrell's guitar solos. I like how he changes them up a tiny bit everytime! I've been paying attention to that with all these live versions... he's amazing! So is Layne... they were a perfect pair. :(
feeebieee 3 years ago 2
did u question yourself if he is too drunk or junk or tired and forget the notes what u don't believe that come on shit just happens daaa no offend i like Alice in Chains but this thing it happens even to guitarist like Cantrell
darreldevill 3 years ago
he changes it on purpose. im sure of that.
penal420 3 years ago
It's called inprov haha and I am a hell of a big fan of it
kevinAIC33 3 years ago 2
fucking amazing
PEDUNCLEPOWER 3 years ago 3
P-E-R-F-E-C-T!
"Am I wrong?
Have I ran too far to get home?
Have I gone and left you here alone?
Am I wrong?
Have I ran to far to get home yeah
Have I gone and left you here alone?
If I would could you?"
I was singing like crazy right now. That's Alerisa! That's awesome! *hugs*
RIP Layne <3
Iluska81 3 years ago 3
alerisa great find!!! RIP LAYNE THE BEST BEST BEST BEST BEST EVER EVER!!! LOVE YA LAYNE
k4aic 3 years ago 4
alerisa83, where did you get the full shows that your uploading? I'd like to watch them on my tv on dvd or something...
sorrow1678 3 years ago 2