Ah, Amanda Palmer from Dresden Dolls covering a Bright Eyes song, two of my favorite people and two brilliant artistis. Could it get any better than this?
Amanda Palmer is either a dumbass scientologist or just naive. She hangs around with Scientologist Cult member Neil Gaiman who appears in graduate lists in The Auditor Worldwide. Neil Gaiman has given over $100,000.00 to Scientology and the US Gaiman family were awarded Patrons" of Scientology for 2004 & 2006 (the highest ranking membership of the International Association of Scientologists). According to Celebrity Scientology blog Neil Gaiman takes services at FLAG.
From what I read, Neil's dad is/was a Scientologist. Doesn't mean that Neil is one, too. Unless you can prove what you say is true, it is nothing but meaningless accusations. Find a statement from Neil himself and I might believe he is a member of that "church" (which, by the way, I disapprove of as much as you do).
BUT even if he was, what would that say about Amanda ? Nothing !
And it certainly wouldn't allow you to insult her or even judge her like you do.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
You really are naive if you think the Scientologists like Neil Gaiman and Amanda Palmer are going to admit it. Even Cruise was outed. Watch them spam down any suggestion of Scientology, they are afraid that if tou find out it will affect their sales.
So you admit you have no proof for your weird accusations. Thant's what I thought. The only issue that ought to be discussed here is Amanda the ARTIST. Unless you know her personally (and you obviously don't), that's the only statement you can make, anyway. A person's faith/beliefs or what they DO in their private lives is irrelevant to their quality as ARTISTS. It simply shouldn't bother us. (Btw: Tom Cruise sucks as an actor, no matter what his faith is.)
Sure, Amanda Palmer would probably never admit that she was a scientologist, and neither did the other thousands of people who are scientologists. And what's your damage with scientologists anyway? And why do you have to post the SAME thing on at least 3 Amanda Palmer vids? I'm not a scientologist, i just think your really messed up.
No mother fucker, I won't shut the fuck up or get the fuck out. Palmer has gotten involved with one of the biggest Scientology families on the planet. Does she have no shame? How does she pretend to believe in human rights while her boyfriend Neil Gaiman funds the Scientology CULT?
I still can't believe I was blessed enough to be there for this...I also can't believe it's been over 2 years since...
BuzzkillRomantic 7 months ago
I'd hoped it was the same Lua. And it was. Love this song. And love how happy a ukulele can make sad songs like this one.
AdderSIG 1 year ago
Comment removed
KaptnKabaret 2 years ago
listening to this is like eating ice cream after you've been craving ice cream for a reallly reallly realllly realllllllllllly long time.
anabop 2 years ago 2
Yay- 'such a lovely song and-... etc.
'Love Amanda Palmer and Bright Eyes, of course!!!
... yes, I see my comment will probably be pointless, but it's all good.
RAre61636 2 years ago 2
Amanda is brilliant. I love this song.
affably 2 years ago
Ah, Amanda Palmer from Dresden Dolls covering a Bright Eyes song, two of my favorite people and two brilliant artistis. Could it get any better than this?
Beautiful cover.
anathemaarienette 2 years ago 5
beautiful song, one of my faves, as are you :')
SailorTacos 2 years ago
Fucking beautiful voice.
leeloo741 2 years ago 2
the first time i heard lua by bright eyes i balled but never did again . this made the water works come back x))
NaomiLovesDifferent 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Amanda Palmer is either a dumbass scientologist or just naive. She hangs around with Scientologist Cult member Neil Gaiman who appears in graduate lists in The Auditor Worldwide. Neil Gaiman has given over $100,000.00 to Scientology and the US Gaiman family were awarded Patrons" of Scientology for 2004 & 2006 (the highest ranking membership of the International Association of Scientologists). According to Celebrity Scientology blog Neil Gaiman takes services at FLAG.
ExcaliburofLight 2 years ago
Comment removed
altosecondo 2 years ago
@ ExcaliburofLight:
From what I read, Neil's dad is/was a Scientologist. Doesn't mean that Neil is one, too. Unless you can prove what you say is true, it is nothing but meaningless accusations. Find a statement from Neil himself and I might believe he is a member of that "church" (which, by the way, I disapprove of as much as you do).
BUT even if he was, what would that say about Amanda ? Nothing !
And it certainly wouldn't allow you to insult her or even judge her like you do.
altosecondo 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You really are naive if you think the Scientologists like Neil Gaiman and Amanda Palmer are going to admit it. Even Cruise was outed. Watch them spam down any suggestion of Scientology, they are afraid that if tou find out it will affect their sales.
ExcaliburofLight 2 years ago
So you admit you have no proof for your weird accusations. Thant's what I thought. The only issue that ought to be discussed here is Amanda the ARTIST. Unless you know her personally (and you obviously don't), that's the only statement you can make, anyway. A person's faith/beliefs or what they DO in their private lives is irrelevant to their quality as ARTISTS. It simply shouldn't bother us. (Btw: Tom Cruise sucks as an actor, no matter what his faith is.)
altosecondo 2 years ago 11
@ ExcaliburofLight
Sure, Amanda Palmer would probably never admit that she was a scientologist, and neither did the other thousands of people who are scientologists. And what's your damage with scientologists anyway? And why do you have to post the SAME thing on at least 3 Amanda Palmer vids? I'm not a scientologist, i just think your really messed up.
Bottom Line:
Amanda Palmer is not a scientologist
She's not a dumbass
She's not naive
She's just a great artisit
dkingrules666 2 years ago 9
Shut the fuck up. Get the fuck out.
hideandgleek 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
No mother fucker, I won't shut the fuck up or get the fuck out. Palmer has gotten involved with one of the biggest Scientology families on the planet. Does she have no shame? How does she pretend to believe in human rights while her boyfriend Neil Gaiman funds the Scientology CULT?
ExcaliburofLight 2 years ago
"we'll Make Great Pets" ..............
BillysEvilCuzan 2 years ago
OMG I was there. It was so wonderful!
lavimdida 2 years ago
sign of Great Art....
everyone shuts up when you sing.
applause, afp.
katmaidog 2 years ago 4
this is a lot different then her normal sound (dark scary deep) this is nice =] great job amanda palmer ily!
imsofierce182 2 years ago
you could bring tears to my eyes... the good kind though... thanks a fucking lot! :)
poetick31 2 years ago
ILY
Devilt0wn 2 years ago
was just listening to Lua and, lookie there! i check out YouTube and this has just been posted. Great song and great cover.
chickencookie49 2 years ago
Ah, two of my greatest loves combined, this was like The Cure at the auction thingy. Loveee <3
bexterdreams92 2 years ago 3
randomly stumbling across this on youtube seriously made my day! i totally know the feeling. :D :D
pyriteheroine 2 years ago
i love bright eyes! :D how awesome :D:D:D
ANproduction 2 years ago
amo cuando grandes músico coverean grandes canciones
superchilangopunk 2 years ago
amanda panda a lurv you muchley
xxxxx
wesker01 2 years ago
ahahahahha amanda your awesome
MCRmy0611 2 years ago
FUCKING amazing
Nolaxrs 2 years ago
i remember this
weirdgirl27 2 years ago
*I get a coffee and a paper*
I don't know why, but I loved this line :}
AFP is more than wonderful.
grimmble1994 2 years ago
Love Conor Oberst, love her, love her live even more, it's perfect!
AstronautAnachronism 2 years ago 2
beautiful song and a beautiful cover.
iamcoolalot 2 years ago
such a beautiful song, such a beautiful singer :) You inspire me.
erica0shmerica 2 years ago 2
wish i couldve been there!
dramafreak219 2 years ago
Shes so incredible! She sounds even better in real life. I can't wait to get this beautiful and wonderful song on my i-pod.
I LOVE YOU!!!!!!
oceanwaves17 2 years ago
Amanda, you're my hero.
penelopedreadful 2 years ago 2
Lovely!
DeadLuwave 2 years ago 2
- Love this .
ShiriniFTW 2 years ago 2
Beautiful!
badbutt570 2 years ago
amazing!
:D
richardpaulgriffin 2 years ago
You never fail to make me smile. :]
UniqueeSkull 2 years ago
Is there anything she can't friggin do...
AFP...you're amazing!
CrazyGrin 2 years ago 2
Amazing.
AleeEvermore 2 years ago
UGGH I LOVE THIS SONNGG!!!
And I love Bright Eyes and I love AFP!
This made my day!
Kijanawazhere 2 years ago
That was incredible. I love you amanda! Amanda Palmer + bright eyes can only end with win!
<3 This is my favourite bright eyes song
TehClakster 2 years ago 2