This song is amazing... :) I totally agree that it has a Coral Room feel to it, and I love it as much as the original - i think of this one as a slightly sadder, more emotional version, for when I'm in that kind of mood. :) This version isn't boring at all, just different :)
@gilbertomerighi I think it means: "You may think you're odd and unloveable, but there's someone for everyone, and when the time is right, you'll find each other."
@beyondtheforest, I wonder if the little instrumental break we hear when she sings that line (2:43) will be somewhere on "50 Words for Snow" ? The chords that she plays have nothing to do with the original - it's like she drifts into another song for a moment, then coming back to it...
Kate sits me down and quietly says to me: "Think about the people you love, with love: it's important. Embrace the sorrow and the joy", then creates the space to do it. How can you thank someone enough for helping you find compassion again?
One of the things I hate the most about writing is the realization that, once I write something and publish it, I can't go back and make changes. Sometimes, I'd love to go back and make some changes. The execution didn't come out quite the way I'd meant the first time, and I like revisiting the old pieces and seeing how I could have done things differently. Even here, I'm making choices, and way leads to way, as Robert Frost would say. How nice to take a chance to revisit these old pieces!
This is awful. It's like a hymn and makes my eyelids feel heavy. Kate how could you go back over and rehash songs from 15-20 years ago? Leave them alone, they are fine as they are.
@GINGERALER It is obvious you dont like Director's Cut, at every opportunity you have expressed you discust on here. So why do you keep coming back to listen to songs from this album if you hate it so much?
I have followed Kate's work since 1985 and loved all her albums.....but....like the British say, this is 'bloody awful'. When an artist returns to previously released work to re-interpret, revisit, remix, or just to supposedly update it...its not a good sign. This adds nothing to the original, in fact, it strips it down, removes the entire chours, and makes me yawn.
@GINGERALER Why do you insist on repeating the same sentiment - which is quite ill conceived I might add - on the thread of every video from the new album? Just let it go man. Some of us can enjoy a new interpretation of an original song. If you can't, well then just listen to the old version.
That choir seems exactly the sound of memory: of the mind reaching back and the people from the past finding us. It just seems that even more than ever, she is working on triggering our subconcious, just-hidden emotions with sound.
A true artist is capable of making timeless music. Songs like this and great part of this woman's catalogue prove so. When you are able to recreate moments out of a group of musical notes, you surely are a genius. That's Kate Bush's case.
fair comment calling this part two.Dreading hearing this as the red shoes is my (flawed)favourite album, but absolutely love it. Its the bad tracks that produce the great tracks and i would never criticise any of Kates music. spent the last thirty odd years having people laughing at me enjoying kates music and couldn't care less.
I so loved the original. But this is awesome...........like listening to a Coral Room, hoping for it to continue, wanting for more....and then Kate answers with this....absolutley awesome, spell binding. She is a genius, I just wish people would understand and recognise her.
this is not a remake ..its part two ,its a reprise ...a reflection on the original..not to be compared perhaps but understood in sequence ....with the many years and the experiences in between just adding ,if anything needed adding,a new emotional chord...aweight ..an intensity ..an extra dimension if you like ...beautiful...the ethereal choir floors me each and everytime..its whats not said...class act
The difference between this and the original is as different as spring and autumn. As much as I love the delicate flowers of spring and the thick green grass of summer, they could never replace for me the sight and scent of mouldering moist leaves on a forest floor in the depths of autumn.
In the woods decay is everywhere mixed with growth, and dark with light, and death with life.
I DO like this more than the original, the etheral choir makes me feel quite overcome with emotion. But I'm not so sure about Kate leaving off the names at the end from the original (Maureen and Bill), makes me kinda feel that she's forgotten them after all these years...
@Broomfield1965 I don't think she's forgotten them, but I do feel she's learned to put certain people in perspective in terms of their transitions. Some she's still working on. She'll never forget Bill Duffield--every time she's asked about touring, you can bet he pops in to her head.
Okay i've listened to this at least 10 more times today (I have the album) and I don't prefer it to the original after all. It becomes more and more dreary with repeated listening; there's no energy or momentum to it. Kate's vocal together with the soporific instrumentation is yawn-inducingly dull. Thankfully the rest of the album makes up for it.
A bit sleep-inducing, but I prefer it to the slick, over-produced original. And I always thought that "just being alive/it can really hurt" was one of the stupidest lines Kate's ever written so i'm happy she's ditched it.
Ooooh This is so ravishingly lovely
MrPlownds26 2 months ago
This song is amazing... :) I totally agree that it has a Coral Room feel to it, and I love it as much as the original - i think of this one as a slightly sadder, more emotional version, for when I'm in that kind of mood. :) This version isn't boring at all, just different :)
GirlWithOneEyeXxx 2 months ago 2
what happend to, "Hey there, Bill. Can you turn the lights up"? I liked that part.
sptfgpn 2 months ago
What does " every old socks meet an old shoe" mean?
gilbertomerighi 4 months ago
@gilbertomerighi everybody needs a bit of company now and again .
robleeds13 4 months ago
@gilbertomerighi I think it means: "You may think you're odd and unloveable, but there's someone for everyone, and when the time is right, you'll find each other."
supermaxim109 3 months ago
@gilbertomerighi Every old sock needs an old shoe. Me Grammy used to say that.
drogheda1966 3 months ago
@gilbertomerighi - It means that there's someone - the *right* one - for everyone. The right fit.
catinmychair 3 months ago
@gilbertomerighi Who connects with each other.
usergently 2 months ago
"On a balcony in New York...it's just started to snow.."
So beautiful. For some reason, when I hear this song, I think of the Titanic.
beyondtheforest 5 months ago
@beyondtheforest, I wonder if the little instrumental break we hear when she sings that line (2:43) will be somewhere on "50 Words for Snow" ? The chords that she plays have nothing to do with the original - it's like she drifts into another song for a moment, then coming back to it...
Cicilo1983 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
anyone with any taste or sheer class will always appreciate Kate, she is and always will be the bomb ! x@theyanplan
theyanplan 5 months ago
anyone with any taste or sheer class will always appreciate Kate, she is and always be the bomb ! x@theyanplan
theyanplan 5 months ago
I love this!! for me is a new wonderful song, I need it every day!! thanks Lady Kate!!
lokubitz 5 months ago
It's stunning, especially the end: "Hi there, Michael. Do you really love me? DID you really love me...?".
Takehaniyasubiko 6 months ago 2
@Takehaniyasubiko Was always my favourite line of this whole song ....
johnmcnab 3 months ago
Comment removed
Takehaniyasubiko 6 months ago
Beautiful. I actually shed tears. I feel mixed about this project overall and think some of it is disastrous, but this was brilliant. Thanks, Kate.
TheHolisticMystic 6 months ago
Kate sits me down and quietly says to me: "Think about the people you love, with love: it's important. Embrace the sorrow and the joy", then creates the space to do it. How can you thank someone enough for helping you find compassion again?
supermaxim109 6 months ago 3
One of the things I hate the most about writing is the realization that, once I write something and publish it, I can't go back and make changes. Sometimes, I'd love to go back and make some changes. The execution didn't come out quite the way I'd meant the first time, and I like revisiting the old pieces and seeing how I could have done things differently. Even here, I'm making choices, and way leads to way, as Robert Frost would say. How nice to take a chance to revisit these old pieces!
glvdtxn 7 months ago
I think that this version of Moments of Pleasure is the most beautiful song she has ever recorded
cornpap2k9 7 months ago
Music masterclass 101: you can say it with all just a piano and the human voice.
maxmucksaround 7 months ago
This is awful. It's like a hymn and makes my eyelids feel heavy. Kate how could you go back over and rehash songs from 15-20 years ago? Leave them alone, they are fine as they are.
GINGERALER 7 months ago
@GINGERALER It is obvious you dont like Director's Cut, at every opportunity you have expressed you discust on here. So why do you keep coming back to listen to songs from this album if you hate it so much?
cornpap2k9 7 months ago
i discovered kate just 2 years ago and truly loved her work.
it was/is something special, really unqiue and classy.
i was happy like a little kid when i heared about new versions.
but unfortunately i like all the originals much more than the new versions.
some tracks like this one has nothing to do with the originals except the lyrics.
thats sad
but i will still adore kate for her era
jensaushamburg 7 months ago
Comment removed
jensaushamburg 7 months ago
I have followed Kate's work since 1985 and loved all her albums.....but....like the British say, this is 'bloody awful'. When an artist returns to previously released work to re-interpret, revisit, remix, or just to supposedly update it...its not a good sign. This adds nothing to the original, in fact, it strips it down, removes the entire chours, and makes me yawn.
GINGERALER 7 months ago
@GINGERALER Why do you insist on repeating the same sentiment - which is quite ill conceived I might add - on the thread of every video from the new album? Just let it go man. Some of us can enjoy a new interpretation of an original song. If you can't, well then just listen to the old version.
nofranchise 7 months ago 2
all we ever needed was kate bush and a piano... just beautiful
cornpap2k9 8 months ago
That choir seems exactly the sound of memory: of the mind reaching back and the people from the past finding us. It just seems that even more than ever, she is working on triggering our subconcious, just-hidden emotions with sound.
supermaxim109 8 months ago
A true artist is capable of making timeless music. Songs like this and great part of this woman's catalogue prove so. When you are able to recreate moments out of a group of musical notes, you surely are a genius. That's Kate Bush's case.
sidhcore 8 months ago
fair comment calling this part two.Dreading hearing this as the red shoes is my (flawed)favourite album, but absolutely love it. Its the bad tracks that produce the great tracks and i would never criticise any of Kates music. spent the last thirty odd years having people laughing at me enjoying kates music and couldn't care less.
MrSqueeky1 8 months ago
A much different version, so bittersweet... she grew so much, we can hear it.
AkuraNanabi 8 months ago 2
sat here weepin love the feeling of Kate
HELLO2YOU3 8 months ago
FLAWLESS.
biggoodness 8 months ago
Her music makes me feel long forgotten memories and emotions because she sings from her heart and is so honest. Thank you Kate Bush x
68hejira 9 months ago 2
I so loved the original. But this is awesome...........like listening to a Coral Room, hoping for it to continue, wanting for more....and then Kate answers with this....absolutley awesome, spell binding. She is a genius, I just wish people would understand and recognise her.
jhonboy669 9 months ago 16
@jhonboy669 , yes Coral Room is just class.
robleeds13 9 months ago 3
Agree 100%. Very beautiful, very reminiscent of Coral Room, and better than the original.
qpid2020 8 months ago
this is not a remake ..its part two ,its a reprise ...a reflection on the original..not to be compared perhaps but understood in sequence ....with the many years and the experiences in between just adding ,if anything needed adding,a new emotional chord...aweight ..an intensity ..an extra dimension if you like ...beautiful...the ethereal choir floors me each and everytime..its whats not said...class act
monkeyboymacc 9 months ago 21
Prefer the original myself.Bit too 'acoustic' this version.
galenkia 9 months ago
The ghostly choir remember me "The Madama Butterfly" humming chorus from G. Puccini
TheNightflier70 9 months ago 2
Kate Bush Santa Subito!
zosothebelly 9 months ago
Wonderful remake.
I like to cite what an other YT user said about
BY treeoftears ...
The difference between this and the original is as different as spring and autumn. As much as I love the delicate flowers of spring and the thick green grass of summer, they could never replace for me the sight and scent of mouldering moist leaves on a forest floor in the depths of autumn.
In the woods decay is everywhere mixed with growth, and dark with light, and death with life.
I weep.
TheNightflier70 9 months ago 3
she made it so happy
0ntology 9 months ago
I DO like this more than the original, the etheral choir makes me feel quite overcome with emotion. But I'm not so sure about Kate leaving off the names at the end from the original (Maureen and Bill), makes me kinda feel that she's forgotten them after all these years...
Broomfield1965 9 months ago 2
@Broomfield1965 I don't think she's forgotten them, but I do feel she's learned to put certain people in perspective in terms of their transitions. Some she's still working on. She'll never forget Bill Duffield--every time she's asked about touring, you can bet he pops in to her head.
keithdeweese 9 months ago
Okay i've listened to this at least 10 more times today (I have the album) and I don't prefer it to the original after all. It becomes more and more dreary with repeated listening; there's no energy or momentum to it. Kate's vocal together with the soporific instrumentation is yawn-inducingly dull. Thankfully the rest of the album makes up for it.
iamnotaplatypus 9 months ago 3
A bit sleep-inducing, but I prefer it to the slick, over-produced original. And I always thought that "just being alive/it can really hurt" was one of the stupidest lines Kate's ever written so i'm happy she's ditched it.
iamnotaplatypus 9 months ago
I like the ghostly choir, but the song seems a bit pointless without the chorus lyrics. "just being alive/it can really hurt ... etc"
MrLexical 9 months ago 2
beautiful.
spatafora 9 months ago