Original and 3d side by side

[Ruiso7]

do a barrel roll 

[MarkThaCat]

They're both ADORABLE

[awsomebamse]

you know that 3d method when you put two copies of the same image and then look at them with crossed eyes? it didnt work here :\

[WhereAreTheStairs1]

She's so blonde

[MRresievil310]

I love how the hub sigh is over RD's plot at one point in all of this.

[Zolega89]

the gmod is like a 3d movie of the cartoon

[FoxiAndFriends]

.....they should just do the show in gmod from now on.

[Timic83tc]

this video needed to exist

[Cooladrian14]

What epi was this?

[CaptainSeacup]

Why can't they show emotion?

[nib0rtehepic]

Lol, the 3D part is on 2Fort.

[TehUlmer]

@nib0rtehepic not 2Fort, but instead Dustbowl.

[GhostNSkullers]

lol in 3D form :D

[ps3tagup789]

@MysticRixel never clicked it never will because the word fapping and the thumbnail says alot

[SupaSoap590]

One of these days! The hunt for my comment will begin..

[ebe92]

I do? :D

[fefor18]

@ebe92 i am? :D

[ebe92]

@fefor18 lol :D

[MysticRixel]

All what I see is the "Stop fapping To Horses" video.

[toocheaptobuyatripod]

@MysticRixel Don't give him any ideas!!

[GeneralSchultz]

3d is shit

[DarkDragonGirlY]

i like the 2d better. their faces are much more expressive and the art style fits tthe plot better. 3ds still good though

[ZombieRG144]

They should really make a game of it.

[Ferrari334405]

and thats why i play Need for speed

[Quadrenaro]

warning... warning... there is a breach in the forth wall... all esencial base personel evacuate the containment area immediately

[Gudjon1000]

this is gmod and real show

[Baboonaiih]

WARNING: This does NOT make a 3D effect when you cross your eyes :(

[purplegill10]

eeyup

[treos2]

O.O woah

[FrenchyToastyy]

Needs a good plot.

[Kaweebo]

Awwwwwwh that's adorable!!

[NegauKagamine14]

3D one scares me. o A o|||

[ness123456798]

backround looks odly like tf2

[carolynxstumph]

I think Pinkie Pie looks cuter in 3D form...

[MrRage71]

Pinkie Pie Haz Down Syndrome

[Arceale]

@pein672 Source Filmmaker actually.

[power6053]

nice use of that useless boulder in capture point dustbowl in team fortress 2

[boomerang2455]

The sound is lolwut

[Rainb0wSkittle]

A YAM?

[scrabblan]

The 3d one I'm pretty sure was shot in Team Fortress 2. Look at the background.

[pein672]

@scrabblan it's IN a map of tf2 (Gmod game, obviously)

[clubpenguintvization]

DO IT WITH THE ENTIRE SERIES.

[Fuyons9999]

Asside from some of the eye movement that was spot on

[SupaSoap590]

Pinkie Pie broke the forth wall! Abandon ship!!!

[Superclame01]

@SupaSoap590 If we abandoned ship everytime Pinkie Pie broke the fourth wall, we'd have no ships left!

[Thehunterpwn]

@SupaSoap590 Do you understand there is no escaping Pinkie Pie!?!

[codafett]

@SupaSoap590 But wouldn't 3-d be the 3rd wall?

[sinshiro]

@SupaSoap590 she broke the 3rd demetion lol

[KampferXeon]

@SupaSoap590 Actually *Cough* Faust said that it was unintentional.

[WorldWalker128]

You realize of course, now that you've done the comparison once, that people are going to start demanding you do that with the ENTIRE SERIES now, right?

[airwolfman]

@WorldWalker128 If he does it as fan commission and demand paypal-cash... ;D Of course... subtely *Ferengi smiles*

[SuperVipers]

@WorldWalker128 he didn't make it.

[EvilboyBackUp63]

how did you make them move at same time?

[CaptainAlliance2]

Um. WHy is pinkie eating rainbow dash? *puts closes cupcakes storybook* OH GAWD, RUN RAINBOW DASH, RUN!!!!!!!!!!!!

[007StopMotion]

soo stupid pinkie pie but to cute :3

[Abracamoron]

My Little Pony has entered Treehouse of Horror VI

[007StopMotion]

:D awsome in all parts XD

[warlerker]

ლ(ಠ益ಠლ) 3D IS SHIT

[hejlaleczko]

jhj

[hejlaleczko]

@hejlaleczko j

[TheRamenMaster]

Since when was Apploosa in Dustbowl?

[Goldie267]

@TheRamenMaster Since when there wasn't a Apploosa map in TF2 :L

[mikublaze]

cool



[sonicthehedgehog46]

Rainbow Dash: They're shooting at us!

Pinkie Pie: They are.

[eishikibahamut]

The models look a bit off, and the lack of emotion in them makes them more creepy, which is made only more obvious by the side by side comparison.

[SpyroAndMLP]

Pinky Pie brakes the 4th wall agan xD

[josefu0]

u sir must reanimate the whole season 1 episodes. so 3D animation will be 20% cooler.

[jinjoshorts]

TF2 in the background? O_O

PONY UPDATE?!?

[LUVRofPokemon]

how do u make these

[Kurus38]

would cross-eyed vision make it 3d?

[1dirvish]

@Kurus38 No it just makes a 2D RD holding the mouth of a 3D Pinkie...

[arlowedelitian]

If they made an actual episode like this, (3D, but with better animation) everypony would watch it.

[TheDragonHat]

Decent animation, would like to have seen some blend shapes on the face and eyes and cheeks to add more definition but its better than what I expected i.e generic gmod movement....GRAVITY GUNS ARE NOT FOR REALISTIC ANIMATION.....although they should be /)^3^(\

[Rcrby525]

@TheDragonHat he used source film maker, not gmod

[urikh9]

And good by fourth wall you will be missed.

[UberKrassMann]

original == better

[navybrony]

For those wondering, Zav appears to use Gmod for rendering, but he does most, if not all the animation work in Maya.

[amozy88]

@navybrony It's called Source Filmmaker. Garry's Mod is nowhere near capable of this.

[navybrony]

@amozy88 I stand corrected.

I've heard of people animating their own custom animations in 3d programs and getting them to work in GMod.

[tmscar]

THAT was garrys mod? Omfg I need to pay attention to addons.

[35kaspar]

its made out of garrys mod game! XD nice

[dominoboy08]

It sounds like they're talking into fans.

[Nemone98]

In 3D version i can't see their's emotions... Pretty freaky ^^

[starwarsnerdable]

Pinkie pie is adorable in both 2d and 3d......but what about 4d ._O

[shimmerpaw]

MOOOORE

[LittleMangaColours]

MLP THE MOVIE!

WANT IN CINEMAS RIGHT FUCKING NOW

[MsCaveJohnson]

TF2 map XD

[comicshaun07]

Apart from 3D Pinkie not breaking the 4th wall he did an awesome job.

[Daimando]

Why is it I find the 3D models more interesting than the 2D models?

[Daimando]

@Daimando Err, no.  I meant 2D Drawings. God, I hate miswriting things.

[UniversalVision]

If the CG gets better, this can compete with Pixar.

[UniversalVision]

If the CG gets better, this can compete with Pixar (>_o)

[UniversalVision]

If the CG gets better, this can compete with Pixar (~_o)-b

[YoshiAngemon]

Sometimes, I wanna imagine Applejack being asked 'Would you like to hear some birdies?" And she'd say "I'd love it." And after being told "Take off your hat," she'd do it and get clonked, with a silly expression, like Curly in "Crash Goes the Hash!" In fact, use the original audio for it!

[MartySnowdog]

wow!!! I like it



[Lasergun45]

Wow. one person can mnake a better animated short than a team of paid people.

I compare this to, of corse, "the clone wars"

[AmericanWarHero]

I like how they're in dustbowl

[Redemptioner123]

Does this count as the fourth wall, or wall 3.5?

[thejking]

alright somebody needs to remake all the episodes in gmod. Somebody go do it now!

[npx190]

I still can't get over the character change from the 2006 Paramount version compared to the Hubs. Their not even drawn the same.

[TruPayne75]

This reminds me of the Fairly Oddparents/Jimmy Neutron crossover episodes.

[TheIRWC]

Is dat TF2 Dustbowl map :D?

[AnesBosna]

a yam? =D

[Buddyb309]

I see so many errors in the animation with this video. But that because I do animation as a profession

[draconpost]

despite the lack of shrinking irises Zavs version is imo cuter, the last two second made me daww

[pinkyoshiequalshappy]

haha cool

[MinusMan561]

Zav's misses something.

The tv watermark.

[DwarfNinjas]

I love the head tilt in the 3D version, captures the same kind of innocence one would expect from Pinkie

[metaXzero]

And goddamnit. Valve doesn't want to make a Source 2 yet.

[metaXzero]

When comparing them side by side, Zav could've done more with the emotion on their faces. Pretty sure you can shrink their irises and stuff.

Zav's vid is still a top of the line vid though.

[ZavCoyote]

@metaXzero Nope. The eyes are a texture. You can't dynamically resize part of a texture in Source (or any other engine, far as I know). Neither can I eyepose them, which kinda sucks because I can in Garry's Mod.

[metaXzero]

@ZavCoyote

Ah. Source doesn't allow it. That sucks. Because I knew Gmod allowed it.

[DenyDenDenzel]

@metaXzero You can't change iris size in Source Film, or in GMod, or in Maya (actually, the eyes and eyelids are not changed in Maya, but in SF itself). When you see some GMod videos where some models with large heads have small dots for an iris... well, that's the reason, it doesn't change in size.

[metaXzero]

@DenyDenDenzel

ZavCoyote told me that a day ago. The comment is actually still in view.

[superspy6]

@metaXzero sorry mate, this the best you can do with the models :) i should know

[metaXzero]

@superspy6

ZavCoyote already told me of Source's limitations.

[BobDole2isback]

@metaXzero

Ya really can't, I tried for my self.

[mainmanhocolo]

@metaXzero You can't as far as I know. Then again I animate using Gmod and he uses something else so...

[RonEeniAli]

@metaXzero sadly i've seen the eye skin in gmod, if zav shrank pinkie/dashes eyes they would appear to have a million eyes in one socket

[macaroniman2000]

@metaXzero now if only he could redo the entire episode in Gmod, THAT would be interesting.

[FRSyndicate2]

@metaXzero I believe you can't.

The irises are textures on a 3D surface. He should change the texture or something in order to do that.

[thewolffox]

Zav did a great job on the animation, right on par.

[EvilboyBackUp63]

@thewolffox let me guss, uhh he used that, animation beta right?