Added: 3 years ago
From: CLOUDCLUB
Views: 43,185
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (86)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • LOVE

  • Story of my fuckin life.

  • this song is much better slow like this, not like at live performaces

  • Beautiful and tragic. I LOVE this!

  • Yeah did that for the first time the other week there.....i am never doing it again. Has now sent me into a strange mood and now i have anxiety after the blow made me relise how stressed i am all the time now. Ill be stronger the next time the urge ever comes.

  • @ExcaliburofLight Uhhm? So, you draw to attention Neil's escapades, and then randomly call Amanda a 'clam' too, with zero connected evidence.

  • This song definitely represents my state for the past 2 years

  • Most talented couple ever. And it's convenient that I can talk about my favourite writer and favourite singer together without being off topic.

  • damn I do this hahahha. So straight to the point ^^'' She's a stalker too :P hahaha

  • @BabyTheSkyIsBlue maybe she is. but the song is written by neil for amanda. :D

  • @rockdddddd ohhh so Gaiman's the stalker!! :D awesome song tho

  • Neil is so awesome, Amanda's certainly lucky to have him! And vice versa of course (:

  • It's funny how I went to google something while listening to this.

  • WTH- Neither Neil nor Amanda are Scientologists. How did that even get brought up?

  • What is with this crappy spamming? Scientology is a load of crap and a nasty scam, but there are a number of people whose families are involved with Scientology who aren't themselves. Danny Elfman, for one.

  • Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

  • confirmed. read neil's and amanda's post .. :)

  • Oh, that was directed at the scientology bs. I'm happy for Neil and Amanda :)

  • Congratulations and happiness to Amanda and Neil for their marrage.

  • they are getting married? woah??

  • Who the fuck cares about scientology!? Oh, come on, this is just wonderfully magical.

  • So... both are scientologists?

    A pity... I hate scientology. That's why I don't like Tom Cruise. But as long as both make great books or great music and don't exaggerate with their "religious" ambitions, it's OK for me...

  • @Schattenschleicher neither of them are so there's no pity.

    These idiots are just spamming because Neil's family are scientologists and he was until he left it in the 80's.

  • Amanda and Neil make a beautiful couple.

    Sadly, I rooted for Amanda and Brian, but hey.... People change and grow so who am I to judge. As long as they are happy- that's all that matters.

    Who gives a fuck what religion they are, if any. :). I just enjoy all of amanda's music.

    She kills in concert.

  • they are dating? wow. I had no idea. neither did I know that he writes songs.

  • she's gorgeous and has a killer voice, and dates one of my favorite authors, that's one hot couple!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • this is such a sad and funny and cute song!!

    by the way, Neil Gaiman is not a scientologist. hasn't been since the 1980's, and it's debatable that he was then. there was one instance of him 'promoting scientology" but he could have been explaining Coraline. I'm just as opposed to the cult as you are, but there are many bigger fish to fry than Neil Gaiman. that's just as bad as saying danny elfman is a scientologist, because his family is. let it go. go after the big wigs.

  • hey brah, scientology may be odd, but no need to diss on religion. (i'm not a scientologist, but it's just not cool to throw down other beliefs) every religion is a cult. take Christianity (i'm a christian)some guy was magically given 10 commandments and some other guy could do all this crazy miracle stuff. oh and he died and after 3 days came back to life! and it's all written in this mysterious book! everyone puts faith in different things.while it may not lead to good things, it's still faith

  • alot of people have this reaction to criticism of Scientology, it is good hearten but naive, i would encourage you to do some research on Scientology and find out for yourself why they are not a organization to be defended.

  • Amanda Palmer ... is so amazingly beautiful.

  • i google amanda palmer too!

  • this song is depressing and fucking amazing.

    I LOVE her sincerity.

    you can actually feel how precious and artistic she is without the need of the media to tell you to do so.

    she's so fucking amazing and one of the reasons is that she's unique enough to be her real self, unlike others who strive to appear perfectly flawless and desirable and arrogant and synthetic...

    you get my point.

    Maybe it's hard or perhaps not desirable for some people to understand but she's a fucking precious woman.

  • this song eirrely suits my situation right now

  • my family is all over the catholic church and i dont even believe in that religion... i havent been disowned yet ^^' family can sometimes be stronger than what you might believe... but whaterver, amanda palmer is freaking amazing and im not the first to say that i dont care who she hangs with.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • What's your source? What's your source that these americans are related to Neil at all? Neil lives in the UK primarily

  • Neil Moved the States a while back.

    He lives in Minnesota.

  • What does Gaiman's alleged support of a wacko cult have to do with you? Who the F are you and why do we care that you have "issues" with his choices? It's his money, and if he chooses to spend it on the LDS, Jehovah's Witnesses, Kabbalah or Scientology, let him. This is a swell song that stands on its own merit.

  • Why exactly are you using all of AFP's music videos for this song as your personal anti-scientology soapbox? Lemme guess ... if we play this song backwards, we'll hear some hidden subliminal scientology propaganda? Aren't there some Tori Amos videos you could rant on instead?

  • scientology is a really awful cult, and have been doing some serious shit for awhile...you'd need to be concerned if neil WAS a scientologist, but as anyone with any sense can deduct that he isn't. he's friends with Penn Gillette and dating Amanda palmer, for crying out loud. those two people are incredibly smart and wonderful people who would know better than to get sucked into a cult like that.

  • ExcaliburofLight: I did a pretty thorough search of the intertubes for personal connections w/ Neil and Scientology. I know his dad was an officer, and he was prolly raised inside, but I can't find anything that proves he personally has given the church money (as opposed to his family).

    Has it occurred to you he is out but keeping quiet so his family doesn't disconnect? And if he were still in, what's he doing hanging out with Alan Moore, much-hated SP?

    Now ffs, stop spamming vids. It's crass.

  • Citation and some links to prove all that please.

  • This is the best version of this song I've seen on youtube. Excellent work!

  • i google you amanda palmer

  • Just an amazing song, I know who the words were written by, but a song is not a type or font that makes it an amazing song. It's the singer that has the skill to makes the font and lines flow into a dream for the people to enjoy. In short I loved the song and I hope you do more, good luck.

  • This is gorgeous! You really brought Neil's words to sultry life, Amanda. Bravo!

  • I google youuuuu... I love it!  How stalkerish. How great. :

    ) Brilliant people!

  • does anyone know how to play this song on piano?

  • no, but I'm thinking about learning it

  • My goodness, it was SUCH a good day getting to see Amanda inn Portland. PLEASE, give us another go, won't you? It was an absolute pleasure.

  • now that amanda is working with neil, it would be cool if she met tori amos. that would be pretty interesting..

  • I second the notion. Probably my two of favorite female artists.

  • haha, you can read a blog she wrote about tori's music, she kind of has a love-hate relationship with it.

  • Comment removed

  • neil gaiman is my favorit male writer! Him and amanda working together is amazing!

  • Oh god, I'll be singing this all night now.

    Neil Gaiman and Amanda Palmer! Wooo!

  • I google her ^_^

  • And now whenever I read the old Sandman issues, I'll hear Amanda's voice as Death. And possibly Desire too.

  • omg i just started reading those comics, amanda fits perfectly. tori amos did the first intro thing in neil gaimans death comics though

  • The final lyric should have been 'I google her too'.

  • Damn! Thanks for posting the vids from her Portland show! Such a great show. I was sitting about 2 feet from her. Such a perfect place for that kind of show.

  • she's incredible.

    and she's beauuutiiifuuulll

  • Funny stuff and amanda is sexy. Also the cloud club has a channel, get in!

  • i was there too. i couldn't see much from where i was. do you have more video?

  • -sigh- a perfect meshing of two of my favourite people...

  • what?! lmao

    that was great!

  • oh, the most hilarious yet serious-sounding song. i love it!

  • woop woop :3

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more