Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (7,728)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Three things came to mind while watching this: 1.Wow beautiful voice and lovely cover of the song, I like this one better than the original 2.the guy at first resembled Adam Hicks then later for a split second he looked like Colin Firth 3.I'm wearing a pair of earrings right now that perfectly match her necklace. Wonderful song Josie

  • ameeeii

  • I love and I'm now crying cuz its do good

  • Perfection.

  • I really wish Taylor Swift creatd this song as a ballad. I like this rendition so much better than the orignial high tempo version...and I am a HUGE Taylor fan. But this version is so much better. Congrats you sound beautiful :)

  • damm mad skillzzz.

  • Not as good as Tay Tay

  • Girl, have you heard of American Idol? The Voice? America's Got Talent? Go for it!

  • Alright boys, let's clear this up.

    On cover video's there is always, always someone who comments saying 'not as good as the original'. Which is fine- maybe it's not, but tbh... who cares? Of course it's not the original! - it's a COVER. People don't set out to outshine the original, or make exact replicas of the originals- so they're little point in comparing then. View them as entirely new songs.

    So next time you find yourself about to comment 'not as good as the original' ?

    Don't.

  • @Bittersweet16Blogs check out her channel ppl she has plenty of orginals

  • She's the next Taylor Swift.

  • 11 years old?? WTF:O

  • 713 were deaf :(

  • voice of an angel

  • OMG UR VOICE IS AWSOME ITS BETTER THAN MY FRIEND ADRIANNA AND U HAVE A BEAUTIFUL VOICE FOR A WHITE GIRL

  • You are Good !!

  • if u have singing lessons, of course, still impressive though :|

  • looks like some people are jealous...... the dislike button is the i am jealous button

  • I think it's what is her music what matters, but improvements aren't bad. Sometimes we can advise people.

  • her voice is very mature for an 11 year old! :P

  • She´s so amazing *-*

  • oh my goodness D:

  • <3

  • She's in need of a youtube channel. (If she already has one, PLEASE give me the link)

  • @twinchomckeith its in the description .

  • holy mother of god O.O

  • WOW :))

  • wow..great voice..!!.

  • A new Taylor is born! Amazing!

  • WoW! Just WOW! serious, that's really really good!! awesome!

  • oh garota parabens!!!!

  • MY GOOOOOOOOOOOOSH?? WHATTT?????? 11??? HELL NO!

  • i listen to this song first before taylor swift , i think this cover is even more better.. O.o

  • only thing needing improved, her teeth

  • @TheVictoriaCheung

    She is 11 years old! shut up! She is beautiful! And she has the most amazing voice! her original songs are great, too! my favorite is the deep end. check it out everyone!

  • @TheVictoriaCheung :( That's a little cruel. It's what inside that matters, right? And she's got a good .... throat inside...? :D I dunno. Anyway she'll probably get braces :)

  • she can't be only 11 years old her voice is so... woooow !!! *__*

  • Awesome!

  • Wow, This girl will go Far

  • She is totally amazing. I have been a musician in excess of 30 years and have never heard such a talented girl ever.. I am totally astonished.. Mike

  • I have that necklace! XD

  • SHE'S ELEVEN?! I'm 14 and I sing like a troll.

  • I love this slow version so much more than the original. It's filled with more ...eh... sadness and emotions. The lyrics absolutely fits me... so I really appreciated this version which I like. Anyway...Josie is a great singer! :)

  • Good cover

  • JOSIE... SING BUBBLY BY COLBIE CAILLET!

  • Josie's star is going to keep getting brighter! what an amazing voice!!

  • u should be singing with great singers u r so good

  • I'm not saying she isn't good, but better than the original? No.

  • @talia13ish agreed :)

  • Autotune :/

  • @breathefairy Just because she is good to sing does not mean that she has autotune.

  • @breathefairy ARE YOU KIDDING ME!! SHE IS AMAZING AND SO WHAT! t pain autotunes 24/7 she has pure talent and if you dont like her then dont watch her and go away...

  • @allynliv75 woah, i think shes amazing and i cant stop listening to this. im just saying that they have done this more professionally than for fun. thye have used auto tune. im not saying thats a bad thing. listen to the radio and almost every song has auto tune as a finish whether its used as an effect (T-Pain) or just to make it sound perfect.

  • I think she's Canadian, but a lot of good artists hail from Canada; Alanis Morisette, Celine Dion, Justin Bieb- Oh wait... I guess Josi only makes three.

  • Ok I am a huge HUGE taylor swift fan BUT i definately love the way this girl sings this song WAAAYYY better

  • If this girl doesn't get famous, theres something wrong with this world....

  • haha tylers hair! josie has an amazing voice:)

  • wow u sounded great !

  • Does he really cry in 2:07 ?

  • She would be an amazing country singer too! :)

  • She's got almost 2 million views! :) Wow. She's awesome!

  • Oh my god, she's amazing!

  • @RUJordanian2011 I would definitely say that this cover is not better than the original. But I do have to say it is an awesome cover, they did a great job

  • this is amazing!! you should go for americas got talent!! i am!!

  • She's 11 turning 19! wow!

  • wow, and your only 11. Keep on! you're gonna be really big someday, i know - and i'll be proud to say that i was a fan from early 2012!

  • 710 dislikes are Tayor Switf's Fan

  • I wish i had a great voice like her :/

  • she's good but maddi is best !

  • Mini Tay Swift :3

  • So unique voice (y)

  • she's awesome

  • Great!

  • Even though I like Taylor swift....i like this cover way BETTER !

  • wie kann sie es wagen taylor swift zu covern?!? da wird sie niemals rannkommen. und es ist auch nicht besser als das original.

  • @LindaTheKitCat Sie ist 11 Jahre alt. Das sie and das Niveau eines erwachsenen Profis nicht rankommt ist klar, aber zu sagen sie soll es nicht wagen jemanden zu covern ist kindisch.

  • @LindaTheKitCat keine ahnug von musik oder was?

  • @LindaTheKitCat ich will dir ja jetzt net zu nahe treten aber es gehört sich nicht einfach so zusagen man dürfte ein lied nicht covern es ist kindisch. Mach es doch besser... ich glaube nicht dass du auf ihr niveau herankommst. jedes lied und cover hat ihre guten und schlechten seiten. und jeder hat einen andren geschmack deshalb ist es dumm so etwas zu schreiben.

  • pure.

    

  • If she's this good when she is 11, what's it gonna be like when she's 20?

  • She looks so much like Stephanie from Full House :))

    Great job !

  • good! nice

  • AWESOME JOB!!!!!:D

  • Nice one, keep them coming!

  • </3

  • i guess she doesn't even know what she's singing, but she has a nice voice! :)

  • you are so cutie<3 Iloveyou voice 

  • cannot get over the fact she's only 11, her voice is phenomenal!

  • yu suk shit

  • This was really, really impressive dear :) I don't say that a lot on younger singers - you have potential!

  • She has an amazing voice.

  • Comment removed

  • that's auto tuned and you can tell.

  • She as an angel voice *-* <3

  • She is really good but not better than Tay

    <3

  • her voice is like an adult i like it>>

  • And shes how old? Shes going far.

  • He looks at her with such pride :)

  • she really looks so YOUNG...and cute....^_^..!!! Im a FAN ALREADY!

  • @13tdman Stop being a fucking cunt.

  • Comment removed

  • Wow. I'm exactly ur age..and compared to u.....I suck. I sad now XD lol u have a beautiful voice! Keep it up.

  • she sing it so good

  • my gosh.

    just..

    my gosh.

    <3

  • such a mature voice for 11.. oh my gosh.

  • That awkward moment when the cover is better than the original

  • @RUJordanian2011 No, this is good, but no one beats Taylor.

  • @RUJordanian2011 actually its not.

  • She was AMAZING!!!!!!!!

  • I love her voice! She is one very talented girl.... I'm 13 years old and I also sing but my problem is I don't like to sing in front of people or post videos of me singing... That's just me but this girls voice almost made me cry

  • Was it just me who thought it was Taylor Swift singing at first?

  • you should duet with Maddi Jane, Josie.

  • You give the name Josie a good name :)

    You are a blooooooody good singer!

  • SHE IS AMAAAAAAZING !!

  • she's amazing !!

  • Very good just seems to fast

  • she has a good voice, but it sounds as if its been auto tuned... :/

  • @emmz54 it doesn't sound like its been auto tuned what so ever.

  • :O Wow! She is amazing... Does anyone know if she's been on the Ellen show yet???

  • @nhussain98 she hasnt ! but she needs to :)

  • She needs to challenge herself. her voice has so much more potential. I can hear it. But shes going for a style. Make your own girl.

  • o.m.g her voice is just amazing ...:))))

  • wow

  • @leobara15 she absolutely looks 11....

  • @ConnorKnaideDean Honestly i think it's just her teeth that make her look eleven. Sounds weird, but yeah.

  • she doesn t look like an 11 year old girl. love it

  • :)

    

  • wow you go!

  • OMG sooo good. i will too :(

  • That girl is simply AMAZING! Her voice is beautiful!

  • I don't think she is 11 don't ask me why. U should notice you self

  • @112simonh You're an idiot.

  • Gosh, she's amazing.

  • who the f*ck is kesha?? THIS is real talent :)

  • Thats amazing!!! Im 11 and i cant sing anywhere nere that good!!! Yayy josie!! -3

  • omg we're back in the 50s where the videos are black and white!

  • Amazing

  • i cannot believe that voice is coming out of that little girl's body. Josie, you are amazing and i hope that you are able to pursue music because i would love to see you when your famous and tell my friends, you see that girl, i loved her from the beginning <3

  • Tyler's hair ! <3

  • she's amaaazing! and she's sooo cute! <3

  • This little lady has an OUTSTANDING voice! Well done, Josie! (: You will go so far.

  • she sings this better than Taylor Swift!

  • How is she even eleven, lord this is wonderful.

  • @lettucelive I guess she was born eleven years ago but you know.. >.> might be something else

  • @xxcio I meant that as a compliment. As in "how is she even eleven her voice sounds much more mature, this is wonderful."

  • @lettucelive NO I know what you meant xD I was just being sarcastic

  • @xxcio my apologies then, people like to argue tons on youtube and I assumed you were being trying to be clever and pick a fight. :p xx

  • i dont sing as good as that wishen i did

  • you can hear the autotune in it :S awkward .

  • LETS GET TWO NAMES ON THE TOP COMMENT LIKE PLEASE (:

  • YES! MY COMMENT IS #1

  • It makes me mad when people are all like «She's 11, sooo amazing!» Talent has no age.

  • @lovexmusic17 Well not really, but when you hear an 11 year old sing like this, it is pretty amazing.

  • OMGKDFOWNAFKSDKCNQWO Tyler's hair!! :O

  • I love Your'e voice Josie !!!!!!!

  • Josie has the best voice ive ever heard i think....o.O ps. Tyler's hair hahaha :D <3

  • maybe she is good live, but she's lip synching.

  • This has got to be the best cover of it! :D

  • don't mean to be rude but you notice its "perfect"like it sounds like they fix it in studio but anyways good job

  • I love this cover. I don't like Taylor Swift. How can I explain this to people? Go ahead, Josie! :)

  • @MJmadethis TAYLOR SWIFT IS THE BEST,YOU MUST BE DEAF TO THINK JOSIE IS BETTER THAN HER,SUCKER =)) =))!!!!!!

  • @hameo97 Lol, are you calling sucker to yourself? You're doing exactly what I did, which was expressing my tastes. I won't say that you're from Mars if you like Taylor Swift, I'll just say that you have to learn how to live with other people's preferences. :) Have a great day.

  • when i was 11.. there were no youtube if i'm right :P