Added: 3 years ago
From: ItszBrandO
Views: 151,177
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (370)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 6:47 LMFAO

  • oh nevermind

  • wait. he DIED?!?!?!?!

  • @leya10089 no he is dying but if u watch the rest of the movie u find out ivy gets medicine and he lives

  • 1:14 - 1:43 Noob Assasain lol

  • This movie takes forever to get started

  • Noone else knew who was hurt..but I think Ivy automatically knew it was luscious.

  • How is it the blind woman was the first to find the stabbing victim?

  • wtf is up with all these shots of empty chairs?

  • i would have slapped the shit out of him too.

    he knew what he was doing was bad, which is why he cried after.

  • Noah should get the red riding hood monster to play with, lol.

  • I "love" how they call it an "accident..." see how he was stabbing Lucius? That's not exactly an accident... >.>

  • THAT BITCH GOT SLAPPED!

  • Good acting at 1:12

  • just feed noah to that red riding hood-like monster! damn it!

  • But the beautiful women who slaps the retarded boy name is Bryce Howard and she also plays in hereafter :-) shes sooooo sexy, goooood!!!! :-p

  • 6:47 lol funny how she felt around for his face then gave it a good slappen like was bread dow lol she could make quick and nice pizzas with those hands :-) slap, slap, slap, done

  • You know, I've just noticed, how did that blood get on Ivy? 5:39

  • i feel so bad for Ivy, Lucious, and even Noah. i mean, i know he killed Lucious and that was aweful, but still, i feel like he thought the one person in his life he loved was being taken away from him. but more than anyone else, poor Ivy D:

  • @yesidono Lucious isnt dead.

  • @iBeChamp i know that now that iu finished seeing the whole movie. at the time they made it seem like he died, cuz she herself said that she couldnt see his color or whatever. anyways, its not that big of a deal, point of my whole comment was that it was sad :/

  • the dude who plays Noah is one HELL of an actor. And I don't swear.

  • When Ivy cries in anguish you really feel it. Because M. Night built such a strong relationship between the two and it felt so real that her cry of pain felt just as real. I swear they were the most convincing couple that I've ever seen in the history of cinema.

  • i love how at 1:20 Noah was like "ok, what do i do now??"

  • wait is she blind????????? i didnt know that til now

  • he did that shit smooth as hell..Lucius was still talking the whole time he was stabbed up..damn.

  • @NightrisRyder He wasn't talking he was grunting. When you get hit or punched or stabbed sometimes a grunt will escape from the harsh breathing or lack there of.

  • 'momma..' 2:56

    amazing acting

  • At the cinemas, I remember very well at 0:58 the huge OOOOOHHHHHHHH's and AAAAAHHHHH's!

  • aw poor noah. :( i mean, it's horrible that he did it and the fact that he's mentally ill dosn't clear that, but he was in pain DX

  • 2 fine actors... phoenix and brody.. damn!

  • this is like if master chief would of gotten stabbed by the arbiter in halo 2 ;( WDF!!!!!!!!!!!

  • My mind has been blown :-0

  • Ooh yeah, gotta' love Adrian Brody's acting <3

  • Noah scares the shit out of me :L

  • LUCIUS!! =(

  • 8:44 It's Horace!! :D

  • Aahhh! Noah you fucktard! >.<

  • I'm sorry but the part when she slapped him and he cries is just too funny

  • Hes Autistic, yes...Good lord lol. And I agree with Melissa, he did deserve it...but he loves Ivy so much (Noah). This section of the movie is terribly sad for all the people involved.

  • noah is a fucking retard

  • Noah has otizm i think

  • IM just watching this because of scary movie 4

  • @awsome6423 Oh my god same here I just saw it on scary movie four and looked it up lol

  • noah is an asshole

  • LMAO!!!!WOW THOSE ARE SOME PERFECT ASS SLAPS LIKE I HAVE NEVER SEEN 6:48-6:54.

  • im watching this so often and everytime im so sad when noah starts to cry....

  • 2:20 .......

  • "There is an infection." well if you lived in an urban city you wouldn't have to deal with shit doctors like that duhhhhhhhhhhh.

  • I don't know whether to laugh or be silent at what Noah does after he stabs Lucious...

  • kommudus..XD

  • 2:25..... Damn, brilliant acting

  • I'm this far in the movie and I just realized the girl was blind.

  • @ChristendomArcanum seriously, I was thinking that in all the prev parts.....

  • @ChristendomArcanum ....me too

  • @ChristendomArcanum lol dude seriously??

  • @ChristendomArcanum hmmmm. u didnt catch on when luscious asked her doesnt she wish to c again huh?

  • @ChristendomArcanum She's blind??

  • Joaquin is a great actor...love that "fall"----ah, I just love him period!!

  • WDF is he doing stamping him?... That was NOT an accident the fucker planed it to kill him...

    I wanna punch his fucking face not slap

  • why does he stab him?:S

  • @britney3xx8 because he likes Ivy (the same girl) Lucius (joaquin phoenix) loves...

  • @britney3xx8 Noah stabbed Lucas because he heard that Lucas intented to marry Ivy. Therefore he became jealous and felt left out. Still it was very bad of him for what he did to Lucas and he deserved to be slapped by Ivy. What's even very sad is that Lucas actually cared for Noah and intented to get him some medition for mental treatment.

  • why does he stab him:S

  • I feel bad for penis-nose but bad for lucifer at the same time

  • is ivy blind?

  • I wanted to cry:///

  • Jesus, I forgot how heartbreaking this scene was! Brody's expression of extreme guilt actually choked me up and I don't cry easily. Maybe it's due to the emotion of both the acting and the soundtrack combined, but damn does it work!

  • 6:12 is a fail

    You see the flag blowing kinda good and look at Ivy's hair

  • am i the only one who thinks noah is sooo scary

  • @YouFightLikeACow are sure your a guy?

  • bitch slapped :D

  • I'm a guy, and I almost cried at around 5:30. :'(

  • Noah would make a great Joker

  • @MaleficDan thats like saying rebecca black would make a good popstar

  • @dude1123445 just pretend he is the Joker and Lucius is Batman after Joker discover his ID from 0:47-1:49 hypothetically of course

  • He deserved that slap.

  • First time I watched this movie, when Noah stabs Lucius, my jaw literally dropped. I honestly, this is gonna sound mean considering his mental illness, don't feel bad for Noah. He deserves that slapping from Ivy. I was like, "YEAH, GIRL! GET HIM!" I don't know, this part of the movie is so disturbing and sad.

  • @themelissashow827 lucius himself said in part 2/10 that noah is innocent

  • The youngest sister, named Ivy (Bryce Dallas Howard) has been blind since she was very young, Ivy claims that Lucius has a 'color' around him, that she can sense.

  • did anyone else notice that when she was pulled away from Lucius there was no blood on her clothes, then all of the sudden you see blood all over her blouse?

  • @FireStar32005 you are right, i didn't realized

  • i hate noah but i felt so bad for him when he started screaming after that bitch slap and he was banging on the door

  • Noah's insane :O

  • LOLLLL, SHE SEES THE HOUSE MAGICALLY AND TURNS. 03:45 .

  • @Jfrozin I think she actually count the steps, so she knew what direction to turn to when she was going from her home directly to lucius place.

  • Lol, 00:01 - 01:50 I laughed the whole time. I'm the devil :D. Sue me.

  • @Jfrozin that isnt funny

  • random chair on the hill.... 1:50

  • awwwww so sad!!!

  • awwww so sad!!!! :(

  • Omw! He stabbed him!

    

  • Retards belong in prison from the moment of their conception

  • @Lanthanideatoms

    thats fucking bullshit and you know it.

  • wha?????? what!! WHAT??!!

  • Is it me or does Izy tap dance @6:54?!?!

  • Dude, "mama..." at 02:55 stabbed me through the heart. I also have to say that this movie killed my sexual fantasies for Adrian Brody for a good year.

  • this is such a sad part.

  • poor Noah, he just doesn't understand what happened.

  • poor Noah! I cheered for him!

  • 6:33 - 7:10 LOL! Those two are great performers, I sware! Adrien screamed like overexaggerating child after she slapped him (as if he just got done getting a spankin) XD

  • @Mio248 ikr! but i thought there was something significant of why they locked him in that room...i dunno what tho but he hated it for some reason

  • put in the quiet room and slapped by the girl he likes, damn noahs had a bad day.

  • I always thought one of the points of this movie was that the dark side of human nature will eventually come out. You can hide from the world all you want, but you can't hide from the human spirit, which has the capacity to murder. Noah simply had less ability to contain his dark side because he was handicapped, but that darkness lives in us all.

  • Noah is not responsible for his actions, it is because of mental illness and insanity.

  • Its been about a year since first saw this and I still cannot get over this scene. Stabbing him as soon as he turned around was one thing, but Noah sat there and proceeded to stab him again and again. Thats always struck me as extremely disturbing. Theres something wrong with a person that can calmly do that and then just go sit on his parents porch covered in blood.

  • @Orochi2345678 Imagine his parent's reaction too. They know he injured, possibly killed someone.

  • Bryce is one of the best actress!

  • thumbs up if you came here by watching The Dentist 2.

  • lol. Noah feels like if he was slapped by his mother and locked up in his room by his parents !!! crying off like a baby with no freedom!

  • Too bad they're a long way away from that wicked, wicked town with its wicked, wicked doctors. *Rolls eyes* Looney bin.

  • @AslansButterfly lol, as if towns in the 1800s were any safer to live in. In those towns you are more likly to die from the plauge being 100% healthy, rather than die from a wound and an infection.

  • what did noah say at 2:32

  • @BridgettCullen23 diff account nevermind!!!

  • he has not even done it yet y am i sooo close 2 tears

  • bryce dallas is amazing I can't believe she hasn't been in more stuff

  • this whole scene made me want to cry.. i loved lucious he wasa great carachter and the romance between him and ivy..... depressing all of it

  • dont you feel so bad for noah when he locked away

  • Jackson Brown's weird-looking younger brother is playing the doc.

  • 6:47 - 6:52

  • Were is part nine At!!!!!!!!

  • lmfao. well i'd say noah's just a little pissed XD

  • I'm taking a film studies class right now and one of my assignments is to take a random sequence of shots from any film and talk about what's going on in the scene ( lighting, camera, lens, dialogue, music, sound ). I was going to pick this scene where Noah stabs Lucius because my teacher talks about how thriller movies with violent scenes need dramatic music and fast shots and fast editing so the viewer feels the horror. This scene goes against that. The lack of sound makes this unique.

  • Adrien Brody as a great actor as well. 

  • @ghoststudyswed fuck you!!!

  • Adrien Brody is virtuoso level.

  • @DontStepOnMyFunk Have you ever seen "The Pianist"? His performance is absolute perfection. I think he is one of the most talented actors ever to live.

  • Adrien Brody is an amazing actor.

  • hahahahaha at 1:12 that fall is fucking hilarious

  • awwwdang, I thought it was going to turn out that Adrien Brody was gay for him

  • noah scares me in this part...

    but i really want to hug him at the same time

  • God I feel so bad for Noah! He loves ivy but he doesn't kno how to handle his jealousy and when she slaps him! I just started to bawl!

  • @NJbug3 I feel the same :(

  • @NJbug3 As crazy as Noah is, he still understands the concept of good and bad near the beginning of the movie. He also shows it whenever he stabs Lucius by the tears and complexion of his face... Knowing the difference between good and bad is separate from the lack of comprehension for certain feelings. What he did was wrong and he knew that, which is why I found it creepy and had no compassion for him whatsoever.

  • @NJbug3 she told him never beat someone else

  • Hahahahaha! Best stabbing scene ever! I'm very glad I didn't have to rent the movie again to see it. Thank You.

  • @MrFightable Me too! I just wanted to see that part again and missed it when it was on TV tonight.

  • LOL Noah shanked a bitch!

  • Did anyone ever consider the fact that Noah might be "normal"?

    He could just be a malicious character who is playing the perfect angle. Similar to Abagail in "The Crucible".

  • @zeypher57 or mabye kinda like the orphan in the orphan

  • Just give him an advil, he'll be fine. Stupid Amish people... lol

  • the fact that the stabbing is so quiet and undramatic makes it so much more poeweful!

  • @MatchCard I'm not 100% sure what you are trying to get across but it seems you mean that Noah consdered lucious Bad like the colour red.

  • glad to see Adrien didn't go full retard.

  • I was bawling at this part. If I were her and that were my man I would DIE. I would not want to live.

  • I feel sorry for noah as he is going through the same jealousy and rage any normal thinking person would go through but he also has the lack of morals most autistic people haveyou can tell he did not truely realise what he had done until it was too late, stabbing him again was probably a reaction to the confusion.

    even though in watching the film i do believe lucious was always very good to noah so it was unreasonable really.

  • @08alexg I want to say lucious' color was red and so Noah killed him because he was the, "bad color." Not only could the blind women see it, Noah could too. That is another explanation.

  • @MatchCard Actually, once you watch the entire movie you find out that this color really doesn't mean anything and I won't go further because I might spoil it for people who haven't watched the whole thing. Once you watch the rest you will know what I mean by this statement: the walls are imaginary.

  • oh my goodness! i could tell smthn bad was bout to happn but what the heck Noah?!? he's actin like a seeminlgy clueless nut in every other scene...then this happens. he's no eistein, but apparently he's not so very stupid either. he just knowingly, intentionally killed luscious because of his own desire for ivy, then he looks around & goes over & stabs him again!

  • @carm8421 there a world of difference between stupid and retarded

  • @bookworm6795 yeah. still, when i'd watched i hadnt thought of him as necessarily being either.

  • Damn Noah - brilliant Adrien! :)

  • i like the way she slapped him :)

  • dang when ivy slapped him all hell broke loose. she made him promise in the beginning never to hit another person and when she hit him..... DANG

  • If you look closely then you will notice that the girl that plays Ivy. Her eyes are really slanted. Like some weird american/asian chick who wasn't cross bred or whatever.

  • When I first saw this movie and Joaquin turned around and stopped talking all i could think was "whats wrong?" then he looked down and i screamed. lol! since then i hahve watched this movie multiple times but this scene is still the hardest to watch!

    -Bryce Howard is such a beautiful actress I love to watch her. her facial expressions can portray so much without her saying anything. and Adrien even as a mentally disabled murderer is still adorable with those electric eyes of his.

  • Adrien Brody is an amazing actor.

  • And that is why we shouldnt keep retards around.

  • man, characters like phoenix is easy. he had the easiest role, straight face, and thats about it

  • oh i know why red is a bad color, it represents blood

  • i hate it when noah kills lucis or how ever you spell its so sad i made me cry

  • @peacegirl484 Ahhh see the thing is, he didnt , at least , watch the rest of the film to see what happens.. he just stabbed him over and over and he did it so calmy it was really screwed up. I think my heart musta stopped the second time he stabbed him.

    He is completely insane...

  • for some reason, that noah person, when he says "Bad Color" makes me want to punch him out.... sorry for being rude but it does

  • "there has been an accident"...lol...yeah he accidentally fell on the knife about a dozen times..

  • fuck Noah i wanted to kill him when he stabbed lucius lol