elle fait partie de la génération du "je mange mes mots, je parle dans ma barbe, je n'articule pas, je me fiche de savoir si les autres me comprennent ou pas, de toutes façons l'opéra c'est pas fait pour comprendre ce qu'on dit..." dommage,
I mean that she's singing like for herself, she doesn't mind if the public can hear her words or not...it's a pity
Whoa! Brava! So many sopranos botch this aria badly. I have never been wowed by Anna, though I think she has a beautiful voice, but now I am wowed! Nobody sings this as well as Leontyne Price IMO, but she comes darn close!
Extraordinaria la voz de la Netrebko. Cada día canta mejor. Este repertorio le permite lucir sus notas graves y agudas, así como la potencia de su voz. Bravísima
Poor Anna, she thought if she put on 40 pounds that it would give her a dramatic voice. It didn't. Whatta shame for her formerly perfect figure. Now she is a caricature of herself.
Stunning. I am liking the extra weight. Now people can't say she gets everything because of her figure. Now those who stupidly criticize her have no excuse not to respect this fantastic voice!
@ididete I'm not looking to get into an idiotic YouTube argument by any means, but I have heard all sorts of sopranos sing Verdi, and I think she is great in those roles. Not completely perfect, but then no one is.
@musicmuse56 If you are so sure of your opinion, then you shouldn't be afraid to have it challenged. Anna Netrebko is a lyric soprano, she says it so herself. Lyric sopranos are not meant to sing Elisabeta. End of story. Not even 40 pounds extra will make her a Verdi soprano, because a Verdi soprano is a heavy-weight category. Like Ofelia Hristova, Ghena Dimitrova or Elena Baramova. And no, you won't hear them in big houses because in the latter looks matter more than voice type.
@ididete *Sigh* I don't care what she has said about herself in the past--voices change, and right now she is perfect for Verdi. And weight has nothing to do with anything. Plenty of great Verdi sopranos have NOT been obese.
@musicmuse56 If you say that Anna is a perfect verdi soprano, than you haven't heard one true verdi soprano live in your life. Even here on youtube, if you go and listen to the singers I had suggested to you, you will notice immediately the difference is weight, texture, richness, in brief the DRAMATIC quality of the ladies in question, and you will understand that singing a dramatic role for Anna would be a hazardous affair.
@ididete Not all Verdi soprano roles are for the same type of voice. Some are for lighter voices eg Gilda, some like Leonora for heavier voices, others like Aida or Abigaille for full dramatic voices. It is also a fact that voices change with age. Netrebko's voice has changed a lot in the last 4 - 5 years. I heard her live in opera houses many times. Ten years ago she had a much lighter lyric voice. Now her voice is becoming bigger and heavier. So she is moving onto heavier roles.
@Ariadne7710 You see the truth at least partly. But in order for you to be fully persuaded that Anna should NEVER sing any dramatic roles, please please check out Ofelia Hristova a Bulgarian dramatic soprano I found accidentally here on youtube. You will see what I am talking about. The art of making truly DRAMATIC VOICES sing DRAMATIC roles is being lost today.
@ididete I have just listened to some posts of Hristova. Yes, big dramatic voice but not good technique yet. Some unintentional vibrato and both colouring and phrasing are lacking. This is a problem with many singers today. Good voices but poor technique. Not enough time training. Most singers think that after about 3 years they are ready for big roles. In the days of Callas singers had very intense training for 6-7 years. Then they had a fully developed technique. As for Netrebko her voice ...
@Ariadne7710 excuse me, you have no idea what you are talking about. That woman has no extra vibrato and she has perfect phrasing. She can sing her ass off. She has been singing all big dramatic roles for decades now. And Maria Callas lost her voice pretty rapidly. You are truly misinformed.
@ididete I have more idea what I am talking about than you will ever have. She has potential but she is nowhere near the finished article yet. No matter what her fanatical fans think. Callas's early vocal decline was the result of a heavy rep from Brunhilde to Elvira 3 days apart, plus taking on Konstanze, Armida, Brunhilde, Isolde, Kundry, Amina, Elvira, 3 Leonoras (Trovatore, Forza, Fidelio) Tosca, Lucia, Norma, Rosina, Bolena, Vestale, Medea etc before the age of 30! Plus early menopause.
@Ariadne7710 NO dear. Maria was a lyric soprano who wanted to be a dramatic soprano. She wanted to be something that she was not. Her vanity and sick ambition killed her. Plus, how can you have more idea about opera singing if you are not a singer yourself? Oh I get it you are a singer. But you will never become a dramatic voice dear if you already are not. Kick that teacher in the butt who ever told you otherwise.
Maria was not a lyric soprano, anyone who heard her live can testify to how huge her voice was, and I quote Richard Bonynge: "Callas' voice in person was as big as Flagstad's, the sound just poured out of her".
But you are right, Maria wasn't a dramatic soprano, she was a Soprano Sfogato, and Assoluta...she was able to sing dramatic mezzo as well as high light coloratura soprano, and everything in between with her 3 octave range.
@primohomme I know, I have no intention of carrying on any further discussion with someone of such monumental ignorance and bigotry. He/she clearly thinks I am a frustrated failed singer like him/herself, which as you know already I am nothing of the sort!!! Enough said:-)))
@ididete continued .... is growing bigger and heavier so nobody can say what will be suitable for her to sing in the future. Some voices start as big dramatic voices from the beginning and can even become mezzo in later years, some change from lyric to a heavier dramatic type over the years. Some, like most of the very leggera coloratura sopranos' voices stay light throughout their careers. Each singer is different. You can't force these changes they either happen or they don't naturally.
@Ariadne7710 No honey, -- you don't become a dramatic soprano starting as a lyrico. You have never heard a dramatic soprano live if you think that. You do or you don't have the SHEER POWER of the voice. THe color may change but the size cannot change signficantly. Just as one's tits don't grow past a certain age. They can only --sag.
Anna's voice has changed significantly since her pregnancy
The color has become darker, the voice has grown in size somewhat
She is not a dramatic soprano, perhaps a lyric-spinto with high tessitura and some agility, but the voice was never a simplye "lyric soprano" as you describe it.
@primohomme Hormonal changes, just as smoking perhaps, can change the COLOR of the voice. Not its size. A young dramatic soprano is usually dark. But it can be a glaring light voice with tremendous volume. What defines a dramatic voice is primarily its SIZE, its ability to SING OVER LARGE ORCHESTRAS. For example, Birgit Nillsson was a light-colored voice. But she was not lyric. Why? Because she could sing, they say, over 4 orchestras playing at the same time.
@Ariadne7710 Then you are either vain, or a dramatic-soprano wannabe yourself when you can be so deaf/blind to avoid to acknowledge that from Anna Netrebko's voice, nothing truly dramatic will ever come out. I know that sort of people. They cannot accept who they are, so they start imagining that their voices will grow over time. Anna herself is modest. She calls herself a lyric soprano, nothing more.
@Ariadne7710 But that's beside the point. THe point is: if a lyric soprano is being cast as a dramatic she will both sound miscast/inappropriate and ruin her voice. Check out Tenellivoiceguru's channel. The man explains there everything. And hey, no hard feelings. Singing is not all there is to life :) In fact unless you want to be a diva -- which is a stupid lifestyle as everyone told me-- it's just a small percentage of your life. I know personally a few opera singers
@Ariadne7710 continuing: all opera singers professionals that I know are unhappy people. Only a small percentage gets to the very top where it's all nice and glamorous but even in that case you have to have a protection, "a strong back" as they say in my native country Serbia. So unless you like sucking dicks up to the top, you shouldn't be doing it as a profession. I hope you are smarter than that.
@musicmuse56 to clarify: a Verdi soprano is a VOCAL heavy weight category, not body heavy weight category. And voice type is something you are born with.
@ididete Just saw this--I'm glad you're talking about vocal weight and not body types, haha...but if that is what you mean, stop talking about Anna's figure.
Really liked her "D'amor sull'ali rosee" with nice piani but the Miserere seems a bit too low for her and as usual the coloraturas are sloppy in the cabaletta.
You need have guts to sing this, hm i like her i think that she has the guts. We forget that she is 40 and should start singing little by little big roles, I just didn't like the coloraturas- 14:08. I think that that this role suits her really good waaaay better then Anna Bolena when all that she did was screaming and forcing the vocal chords. All in all this performance is really good
i say "great job!" in respect to me having very little formal musical training and a node to Netrebko's bravery at attempting a difficult aria. but i say "a little sloppy" when i compared to the number of other sopranos tackling this passage (trust me, i spend way too time than i should youtubing these beautiful arias). A for effort, C for technical execution.
Although Netrebko has a wonderful capacity for pianissimi in alt, it is not really in evidence here, as the line is too frequently spoiled by a fast vibrato and some rushed phrasing. Armiliato also seems a bit unsure of how to keep the whole show together especially from 5.05 onwards.
It is surprisingly good up to the high c but from that point on (and a little earlier too) her interpretation does not match Leonora's despair in this aria. It gave me impression she was going to start dancing or that she was saying she loves someone.
It is one thing to be a legendary opera singer. It is another thing to be the prophet of an exclusive religion. Callas belongs to + leads the first category. Anyone who finds her incomparable should perhaps stop comparing her for exactly that reason. Netrebko is amazing and one of the least risk averse singers around today, I love the way she can throw herself at a role, an aria or just a note with all the risks attached: her 26 + 30 Sept Bolena performances were very different and both great.
@tiengallavant You can easily see them performing without microphones if you search for opera videos here or concerts in strictly classical music venues built for acoustics. The easiest is just to search by opera name e.g. in this case Il Trovatore, but you can try any other, say Carmen. Then choose not the concert performances (especially outdoor performances) but those that have sets and costumes - i.e. that come from an opera stage. Qutie a few videos here.
is this opera?!!!! she is totally pathetic!!! go back to the conservatoire!!! listen to Callas if you really want to hear how this aria should be performed!!! Netrebko, you'd better sing hip-hop!!!
@primohomme have you ever listened to Callas?..have you ever studied voice (which I have)?....maybe if you did, we could talk about..otherwise, stick to Netrebko, but please don't call it opera!!!!
Yes, I have listened to Callas, and perhaps far more than you have ever done so as I own her entire discography. And yes, I have studied voice, as I am a vocalist with a 5+ octave vocal range.
Netrebko is not Callas, and she doesn't need to be. End of story.
@primohomme so if you're a 5 octave vocal range what?...since when big means quality?!!! (and amazingly your vocal range seems to be almost the double of Calla's vocal range who had a 3 octave range- you should join Netrebko I guess)..and I've never said she has to be Callas (as if she only could!!!) I have mentioned Callas a milling stone example, of musical technique and artistic interpretation..Netrebko's voice is just plain, boring..Lucia, Leonora, Norma, Violetta,they all sound the same
@ovidiubobaila Some of us like to go to opera and listen to singers live rather than live in the past. No singer is perfect. Everyone has flaws. Callas was a great interpreter, but hers was hardly ever a beautiful voice; many people found it too harsh. Anna Netrebko has a gorgeous instantly recognizable voice - those who've heard her live can attest to - and she is an excellent actress. I heard her at the Met in both Don Pasquale and Anna Bolena - and no, her voice didn't sound at all the same.
bravisima......de verda pensais que a alguien importa lo que vosotros penseis de tecnica y de que si la callas o la sutherlan esto y aquello?????.........mas sexo y menos tonterias chicas
@primohomme ya lo es sobretodo para nosotros los cantantes, que lo hacemos de todas maneras pero no de la manera encarnizada qeu discutis cobre apoyos e interpretaciones los aficionados ........muchoas vecs repitiendo lo que algu critico reputado (un artista frustrado ejerciendo su resentiiento ......tratamos de rescatarr lo bueno por la supervivencia del arte
@gustavoanmosura te equivocaste de videeo imbecil, si quieres ver nalgas, tetas y reggaeton busca los videos de musica latina mierdera, para mierdas como tu.
You said NO breath, heavy exaggeration don't you think ? I read somewhere once a suggestion that
AN has asthma, don't know how true that is, but in interviews in years past, just in speaking voice she
has had a slight gaspiness, could be what nitpickers seize upon. Sometimes, yes, she is a little breathy, sometimes too breathy. However I have personally heard a very famous sopranos + can think of at least three other very high reputation female singers who who have been worse.
Enjoyed the performance... Then started reading comments on this page and oh boy - too many experts here who don't see the forest for the trees, who are so good at seeing art as a collection of technicalities... I think, you guys are getting too close. Move away from your microscope, look at it from a distance. Love the art in yourself... Art is about feelings, and the stronger the feelings the fewer words are needed.
@wwwvisitor you are absolutly right..........menos mal que tambien hay gente sensata ademas del atajo de locos nazis que insultan,, da muchisima tristeza, creo que no hay que leer estas cosas y ya esta
Actually, her main coaching has been done by Gerard Moore, who is also a long time coach of Renee Fleming
and a big fan of Sills, that's why many of the ornaments on Netrebko's Bolena are similar to Sills' as opposed to Callas which would be the case if Scotto was her main coach, as Scotto was obsessed with Callas to the point of sickness.
Actually, I think Scotto understood bel canto more than others. She just didn't have the voice to sing it truly well.
Il microfono mette in evidenza la fatica vocale e la velatura di una voce tecnicamente mal impostata e inespressiva ..... degna di un compagno altrettanto otturato come Kauffmann. Un "DUO" decisamente ORRENDO !!!!
Anna worked her ass off. I was impressed. Usually she would have been sharp throughout the whole thing. Let alone a piano high C and somewhat of a trill towards the end. She's improved quite a bit! brava
@DeutschSoprano Yes it is a great blessing. It would have been a tragedy both for his family and for the world of music if his illness turned out to be much more serious. We are all looking forward to hearing him sing again soon.
@DeutschSoprano He had surgery for a Thoracic Node which I understand is a node in the lung area which in some cases can be malignant. He made an announcement at the end of August that he would cancel his tour of Japan to have the surgery which his doctors said needed to be done straight away. That is why it was worrying. Since it was urgent people thought maybe it was something bad. Fortunately it has not turned out that way and he has announced that he will start to perform again in October
GREAT NEWS!!!! KAUFMANN'S SURGERY WENT WELL. HE IS NOW RECOVERING AND EXPECTS TO RESUME PERFORMANCES NEXT MONTH WITH RECITALS IN GERMANY, ATHENS, LONDON AND THE MET.
@tiengallavant Not stupid at all. When they sing in a huge arena like here and it is being broadcast via TV and cinema they have mics. When inside an Opera House or closed concert hall they don't. Except on odd occasions when the performance is either recorded to be made into DVD or broadcast on TV or cinemas which happens on some occasions. In recent years Opera Houses like to transmit some operas into some piazzas for people to attend free of charge to popularise operas to a wider public.
This is the best suited music for Netrebko. Finally, I can rave about her singing. She needs to forget about Gilda, Lucia, and Norina. TROVATORE is perfect for her voice, and there are many other Verdi and Puccini roles that will suit her better than the roles that she has chosen in the past.
Yes, how else would they be recorded? And also at a venue that large where there's not the proper acoustical settings, they must use microphones.
The difference is how far the microphones are placed. You will note operatic singers have the microphones place about 4 to 6 feet from them, while most pop singers or classical/crossover singers like Sarah Brightman or Andrea Bocelli need microphones placed just a few inches from their mouth.
BRAVO! I think perhaps Netrebko is finally finding her voice and moving into roles better suited to her voice. This was beautifully done and it is ravishing! I wish she was singing Trovatore instead of Anna Bolena at the MET this season!!!!
It seems AN has everything for this role, ( and plenty of other roles ).
A beautiful resonance as well as power in the lower and mid ranges of the voice.
The mid range is smooth and lyrical, there seems to be a flowing integration of the voice from bottom to top. The lack of intrusive vibrato,or mannerism, makes the performance very clean and uncluttered. She has nice trills. The voice itself, the timbre, to me, is simply ravishing.
No sir. Please not this tone! I'm not talking about that channel and the postings of September, I'm talking about those of August 18. But you know all this yourselve.
So, just stop to steal from other members or tell us how you got the recordings of the German TV channel. Thank you.
@familyfilmfund Take a fucking seat! Stealing from someone else's channel would mean you have exclusive copyright to these videos, which you don't. NEXT!
That idiot claimed I stole this videos first from his channel which I showed him wasn't possible as he uploaded the videos A WHOLE WEEK after I did. Then he says I stole them from another user who had uploaded the videos before I did, which that person did upload them before I did...but in a lower resolution as opposed to HD as I uploaded here!! I can't stand these idiots, another nazi asswipe with a nasty sense of entitlement.
@primohomme I'm still dying at the fact that he says you're stealing when the asshole doesn't have any legitimate copyright claims to do so. Where's this lunatics channel with the vids?
@primohomme Hey primmo,please cool down.Let's forget about that lad who's stolen your beautiful video.Your uploadings are always excellent and correct which bring a lot of pleasure to all of us. Let's better congratulate dear Anna with her 40-th birthday, she's one of unique living sopranos we have today.
Happy birthday dear Annna! Sincerely love your voice!
Are you fucking kidding me? Take this video you uploaded for example
watch?v=f3p1gAxm1jY
You uploaded it on September 6th. I uploaded mine on August 29th. How could I possibly steal it from your channel if you uploaded it AFTER I uploaded this one??? THINK ABOUT THAT!!!
@cuoredeinidi The Cast of the Don Giovanni I am talking about is stellar!!! Raimondi as the Don, Van Dam as Leporello, Edda Moser as Donna Anna, Kiri Te Kanawa as Donna Elvira, and Teresa Berganza as Zerlina. doesn't get much better than that. And visually a feast for the eyes. As a production it is worthy of Visconti:))) There is praise for you if you like!!!!!
@cuoredeinidi Van Dam's Voice is to die for. Pure velvet dipped in chocolate. Yum yum. Have you seen his Leporello in the Joe Loosey Don Giovanni movie filmed in Palladian villas in Italy? Amazing singing amazing orchestral performance, amazing photography in amazing locations. And Van Dam looks so sexy. Buy the DVD if you can. I first saw it in an Art Movie theatre when it first came out in the 70s but now it is available on DVD.
@spqrmorGrazie per la poesia sei simpatico,ma io preferisco poeti come Leopardi,Esenin etc...!
Ho capito il tuo 'messaggio', purtroppo il tuo fanatismo non aiutera Netrebko di diventare una bellissima attrice come lo erano Tebaldi,Gencer,Dimitrova,Callas etc.etc.Insomma IL FANATISMO uccide,non dà LA VITA.Coraggio Amico,coraggio.La sua 'pesia e più bella(se si può 'apprezzare' la poesia d'un fanatico)dalla interpretazione di Netrebko.
perchè nella sua poesia lei mette tutto il suo cuore e anima.
@bodiloto Я не очень силен в итальянском, хотя легко разбираю Ваши "перлы",поэтому отвечу Вам на русском,раз понимаете.Я то как раз не фанатик, а человек ,который разбирается в музыке и имеет музыкальное образование(жаль что не консерваторское!),слух и музыкальный вкус,.. А вот Вы ,занимаетесь ФАНАТИЧНЫМ и ПУСТЫМ КРИТИКАНСТВОМ буквально на каждом ее видео.Вы просто тролль с уймой свободного времени! А лучше Нетребко сейчас все равно НИКТО не поет!Все ваши Димитровы просто рядом не валялись.
brava! great actress, great voice. she looks like she enjoys every single moment of the singing, and it is very pleasant to watch
summerrain206 6 hours ago
magnifique
carbonnelle1 8 hours ago in playlist Favorite videos
brava
tarik19501956 2 days ago
elle fait partie de la génération du "je mange mes mots, je parle dans ma barbe, je n'articule pas, je me fiche de savoir si les autres me comprennent ou pas, de toutes façons l'opéra c'est pas fait pour comprendre ce qu'on dit..." dommage,
I mean that she's singing like for herself, she doesn't mind if the public can hear her words or not...it's a pity
Sikalyn 3 days ago
@Sikalyn Yes, she doesn't articulate her words at all.
ididete 2 days ago
Semplicemente....MERAVIGLIOSA!!!!!!!
bachianasop 5 days ago
Dios pone a anna cuando quiere escuchar buena musica
miguel07743 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos
Whoa! Brava! So many sopranos botch this aria badly. I have never been wowed by Anna, though I think she has a beautiful voice, but now I am wowed! Nobody sings this as well as Leontyne Price IMO, but she comes darn close!
flyinghow 1 week ago
Perfecto. Que voz!
Eglezrguez 1 week ago
She has a golden voice..If you get the chance to meet her she is fun.I know because I do all Ushering,opera ,Symphony,concerts,Ballet,and more..
MsSandtime 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She is amazing
cutie6734 2 weeks ago
Extraordinaria la voz de la Netrebko. Cada día canta mejor. Este repertorio le permite lucir sus notas graves y agudas, así como la potencia de su voz. Bravísima
GabrielaMMJ 2 weeks ago
Great performance...brava Anna...
sisifus100 2 weeks ago
Anna Netrebko is the best!!!Grande!!!Bravissima!!!Callas????????I dont like!!The voice it was orribol!!!!!
aaaoooaaful 3 weeks ago
It's a good concert aria/scene, but I would definitely not want her to sing Leonora in a whole opera.
LordHettrick 3 weeks ago
Estas son las arias perfectas para su hermosa voz de soprano lirica!!!
Por favor que no cante arias para soprano ligera, porque si no la tandremos que comparar, y eso es feo.
acitipo 3 weeks ago
brava e bella....
thefrancesco1967 3 weeks ago
super HD - better than the super bowl!!
hswatnik 3 weeks ago
Simplemente brillante
Eglezrguez 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
musicmuse56 3 weeks ago
@musicmuse56 Yes and you have a 10 inch cock. Also, you have the dignity of a pornstar to brag with your bodily attributes over internet.
ididete 3 weeks ago
@ididete And you had the audacity to be a patronizing twat after I said we both have rights to our own opinions, a fact which you denied.
musicmuse56 3 weeks ago
Exelente1!!! Anna Argentina te espera siempre!!!
gardelito69 3 weeks ago
Poor Anna, she thought if she put on 40 pounds that it would give her a dramatic voice. It didn't. Whatta shame for her formerly perfect figure. Now she is a caricature of herself.
ididete 4 weeks ago
Her trills have gotten sooo much better!
sarahbadell 1 month ago
Stunning. I am liking the extra weight. Now people can't say she gets everything because of her figure. Now those who stupidly criticize her have no excuse not to respect this fantastic voice!
texasfntc26 1 month ago
She is absolutely fantastic in the right rep. OFFICIALLY A NETREBKO FAN!!! :D
TheBiggestFan32752 1 month ago
Ditemi che mi sbaglio e che la sua voce non si è appesantita.
sincrotto 1 month ago
I just watched this opera last night and would have enjoyed it MUCH more if she had been the one singing Leonora. . . .I love her in Verdi roles.
musicmuse56 1 month ago
@musicmuse56 That being said, she is NOT a Verdi soprano, and she admits it herself.
ididete 4 weeks ago
@ididete I'm not looking to get into an idiotic YouTube argument by any means, but I have heard all sorts of sopranos sing Verdi, and I think she is great in those roles. Not completely perfect, but then no one is.
musicmuse56 4 weeks ago
@musicmuse56 If you are so sure of your opinion, then you shouldn't be afraid to have it challenged. Anna Netrebko is a lyric soprano, she says it so herself. Lyric sopranos are not meant to sing Elisabeta. End of story. Not even 40 pounds extra will make her a Verdi soprano, because a Verdi soprano is a heavy-weight category. Like Ofelia Hristova, Ghena Dimitrova or Elena Baramova. And no, you won't hear them in big houses because in the latter looks matter more than voice type.
ididete 4 weeks ago
@ididete *Sigh* I don't care what she has said about herself in the past--voices change, and right now she is perfect for Verdi. And weight has nothing to do with anything. Plenty of great Verdi sopranos have NOT been obese.
musicmuse56 4 weeks ago
@musicmuse56 If you say that Anna is a perfect verdi soprano, than you haven't heard one true verdi soprano live in your life. Even here on youtube, if you go and listen to the singers I had suggested to you, you will notice immediately the difference is weight, texture, richness, in brief the DRAMATIC quality of the ladies in question, and you will understand that singing a dramatic role for Anna would be a hazardous affair.
ididete 4 weeks ago
@ididete Not all Verdi soprano roles are for the same type of voice. Some are for lighter voices eg Gilda, some like Leonora for heavier voices, others like Aida or Abigaille for full dramatic voices. It is also a fact that voices change with age. Netrebko's voice has changed a lot in the last 4 - 5 years. I heard her live in opera houses many times. Ten years ago she had a much lighter lyric voice. Now her voice is becoming bigger and heavier. So she is moving onto heavier roles.
Ariadne7710 2 days ago
@Ariadne7710 You see the truth at least partly. But in order for you to be fully persuaded that Anna should NEVER sing any dramatic roles, please please check out Ofelia Hristova a Bulgarian dramatic soprano I found accidentally here on youtube. You will see what I am talking about. The art of making truly DRAMATIC VOICES sing DRAMATIC roles is being lost today.
ididete 2 days ago
@ididete I have just listened to some posts of Hristova. Yes, big dramatic voice but not good technique yet. Some unintentional vibrato and both colouring and phrasing are lacking. This is a problem with many singers today. Good voices but poor technique. Not enough time training. Most singers think that after about 3 years they are ready for big roles. In the days of Callas singers had very intense training for 6-7 years. Then they had a fully developed technique. As for Netrebko her voice ...
Ariadne7710 2 days ago
@Ariadne7710 excuse me, you have no idea what you are talking about. That woman has no extra vibrato and she has perfect phrasing. She can sing her ass off. She has been singing all big dramatic roles for decades now. And Maria Callas lost her voice pretty rapidly. You are truly misinformed.
ididete 2 days ago
@ididete I have more idea what I am talking about than you will ever have. She has potential but she is nowhere near the finished article yet. No matter what her fanatical fans think. Callas's early vocal decline was the result of a heavy rep from Brunhilde to Elvira 3 days apart, plus taking on Konstanze, Armida, Brunhilde, Isolde, Kundry, Amina, Elvira, 3 Leonoras (Trovatore, Forza, Fidelio) Tosca, Lucia, Norma, Rosina, Bolena, Vestale, Medea etc before the age of 30! Plus early menopause.
Ariadne7710 2 days ago
@Ariadne7710 NO dear. Maria was a lyric soprano who wanted to be a dramatic soprano. She wanted to be something that she was not. Her vanity and sick ambition killed her. Plus, how can you have more idea about opera singing if you are not a singer yourself? Oh I get it you are a singer. But you will never become a dramatic voice dear if you already are not. Kick that teacher in the butt who ever told you otherwise.
ididete 2 days ago
@ididete
Maria was not a lyric soprano, anyone who heard her live can testify to how huge her voice was, and I quote Richard Bonynge: "Callas' voice in person was as big as Flagstad's, the sound just poured out of her".
But you are right, Maria wasn't a dramatic soprano, she was a Soprano Sfogato, and Assoluta...she was able to sing dramatic mezzo as well as high light coloratura soprano, and everything in between with her 3 octave range.
primohomme 2 days ago
@Ariadne7710
Don't waste yourself with ididete, that person is obviously still traumatized about the war in Bosnia 15 years ago and wants to fight with the world.
primohomme 2 days ago
@primohomme I know, I have no intention of carrying on any further discussion with someone of such monumental ignorance and bigotry. He/she clearly thinks I am a frustrated failed singer like him/herself, which as you know already I am nothing of the sort!!! Enough said:-)))
Ariadne7710 1 day ago
@ididete continued .... is growing bigger and heavier so nobody can say what will be suitable for her to sing in the future. Some voices start as big dramatic voices from the beginning and can even become mezzo in later years, some change from lyric to a heavier dramatic type over the years. Some, like most of the very leggera coloratura sopranos' voices stay light throughout their careers. Each singer is different. You can't force these changes they either happen or they don't naturally.
Ariadne7710 2 days ago
@Ariadne7710 No honey, -- you don't become a dramatic soprano starting as a lyrico. You have never heard a dramatic soprano live if you think that. You do or you don't have the SHEER POWER of the voice. THe color may change but the size cannot change signficantly. Just as one's tits don't grow past a certain age. They can only --sag.
ididete 2 days ago
@ididete
Hormonal changes CAN change a voice too
Anna's voice has changed significantly since her pregnancy
The color has become darker, the voice has grown in size somewhat
She is not a dramatic soprano, perhaps a lyric-spinto with high tessitura and some agility, but the voice was never a simplye "lyric soprano" as you describe it.
primohomme 2 days ago
@primohomme Hormonal changes, just as smoking perhaps, can change the COLOR of the voice. Not its size. A young dramatic soprano is usually dark. But it can be a glaring light voice with tremendous volume. What defines a dramatic voice is primarily its SIZE, its ability to SING OVER LARGE ORCHESTRAS. For example, Birgit Nillsson was a light-colored voice. But she was not lyric. Why? Because she could sing, they say, over 4 orchestras playing at the same time.
ididete 2 days ago
@ididete I have heard live more sopranos, lyric, dramatic, and every other kind you can think of than you have had hot dinners.
Ariadne7710 2 days ago
@Ariadne7710 Then you are either vain, or a dramatic-soprano wannabe yourself when you can be so deaf/blind to avoid to acknowledge that from Anna Netrebko's voice, nothing truly dramatic will ever come out. I know that sort of people. They cannot accept who they are, so they start imagining that their voices will grow over time. Anna herself is modest. She calls herself a lyric soprano, nothing more.
ididete 2 days ago
@ididete I am not a soprano or a singer of any kind. Or anyone's fanatic fan either. Just grow up!!!!!! end of discussion!!
Ariadne7710 2 days ago
@ididete And tits also grow just in case you are interested!!!!
Ariadne7710 2 days ago
@Ariadne7710 But that's beside the point. THe point is: if a lyric soprano is being cast as a dramatic she will both sound miscast/inappropriate and ruin her voice. Check out Tenellivoiceguru's channel. The man explains there everything. And hey, no hard feelings. Singing is not all there is to life :) In fact unless you want to be a diva -- which is a stupid lifestyle as everyone told me-- it's just a small percentage of your life. I know personally a few opera singers
ididete 2 days ago
@Ariadne7710 continuing: all opera singers professionals that I know are unhappy people. Only a small percentage gets to the very top where it's all nice and glamorous but even in that case you have to have a protection, "a strong back" as they say in my native country Serbia. So unless you like sucking dicks up to the top, you shouldn't be doing it as a profession. I hope you are smarter than that.
ididete 2 days ago
@Ariadne7710 no thanks, I have plenty of my own, both that and voice!
ididete 2 days ago
@musicmuse56 to clarify: a Verdi soprano is a VOCAL heavy weight category, not body heavy weight category. And voice type is something you are born with.
ididete 4 weeks ago
@ididete Just saw this--I'm glad you're talking about vocal weight and not body types, haha...but if that is what you mean, stop talking about Anna's figure.
musicmuse56 4 weeks ago
Really liked her "D'amor sull'ali rosee" with nice piani but the Miserere seems a bit too low for her and as usual the coloraturas are sloppy in the cabaletta.
TheMahouraw 1 month ago
You need have guts to sing this, hm i like her i think that she has the guts. We forget that she is 40 and should start singing little by little big roles, I just didn't like the coloraturas- 14:08. I think that that this role suits her really good waaaay better then Anna Bolena when all that she did was screaming and forcing the vocal chords. All in all this performance is really good
8Goldie 1 month ago
i say "great job!" in respect to me having very little formal musical training and a node to Netrebko's bravery at attempting a difficult aria. but i say "a little sloppy" when i compared to the number of other sopranos tackling this passage (trust me, i spend way too time than i should youtubing these beautiful arias). A for effort, C for technical execution.
fll7181 1 month ago
Bravo, great performance!
tenordramaticitm2 1 month ago
Although Netrebko has a wonderful capacity for pianissimi in alt, it is not really in evidence here, as the line is too frequently spoiled by a fast vibrato and some rushed phrasing. Armiliato also seems a bit unsure of how to keep the whole show together especially from 5.05 onwards.
vocalissimo1 1 month ago
Amen
listenere 2 months ago
me encanta anna
elsirui 2 months ago
Excelente Anna, seria genial en el papel de Leonora en el MET
martinTU100 2 months ago
Jonas Kaufmann,
7CALLAS 2 months ago
what is the tenor name in Miserere?
Skyriver80 2 months ago
@Skyriver80 jonas kaufmann
1963pina 2 months ago
It is not her chubbiness that impairs my hearing.... it's her rendering of this aria.
Far too early for her voice and of course she needs a suitable trainer to
teach her she should mean what she's singing.
john5748 2 months ago
It is surprisingly good up to the high c but from that point on (and a little earlier too) her interpretation does not match Leonora's despair in this aria. It gave me impression she was going to start dancing or that she was saying she loves someone.
LazarNewDeal 2 months ago
Grande diva e poi il Travatore è assolutamente il suo grande repertorio.
biancanevelet 2 months ago
Sie ist ALLES .... echte DIVA ..... i love
GOGGYgant 2 months ago
she's too chubby takes the pleasure out watching her,...maybe she's happy but I'am not.
listenere 2 months ago
@listenere - There is so much of her more to love, you nut. ... :)
salt1955 2 months ago
Wunderbares Konzert in der ,Waldbühne, in Berlin, August 2011
MrMusikkenner 2 months ago in playlist 111Casta Diva & more
PIU GRANDE DIVA
giustizzera 2 months ago
Im amazed how good she is here! She already suprised me in Anna Bolena, and now this! Amazing!
spenzur 2 months ago 2
...always and always beautiful and sexy...for a long time she's stay a the star !!
so451 2 months ago
Brava, Anna. Hope she'll do Leonora on stage.
fandabbler 2 months ago
terrible
sttar1982 3 months ago in playlist Classical
TOO DARN SLOW!! This tempo drove me insane..
actionsrlouder 3 months ago
Well done. But this is much too slow for my taste
wTrevorh 3 months ago
She is WONDERFUL!
gillimut 3 months ago
teneis razon no se porque me meto.............seguir discutiendo tranquilamente sobre lo que no sabeis.............
gustavoanmosura 3 months ago
I always love it when she sings in concerts. She gets into character, especially if she has performed that character on stage.
raindyns 3 months ago
Brava Netrebko!
Si sigue así lo podrá con todo.
00ceroalaizquierda00 3 months ago
Bravissima!
antonello035 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
omg.. she got really fat
bakiotarra 3 months ago
Manifestement elle ne comprend pas ce qu'elle chante!
aurelitoful 3 months ago
j'ai regardé la diffusion samedi dernier sur rtb2 c'était magnifique.
carbonnelle1 3 months ago
Callas is dead?!!!! Maybe it's you who's dead, and you don't even know it, you poor thing!!!
ovidiubobaila 3 months ago
JUST ENJOY HER VOICE STOP ARGUING! SHES THE BEST OF HER TIME! CALLAS IS SO DEAD! PLEASE MOVE ON!!!
jermainecutie 3 months ago
@jermainecutie
Callas elle ne se dandinait pas pour faire passer les vocalises!
aurelitoful 3 months ago
Her voice, acting and beauty are as close to perfect as we are likely to ever experience.
CarlDLawyer 3 months ago
The best performance of this scene for last 30 years. Bravissima. Grandissima.
Daran1972 3 months ago
@Daran1972
N'importe quoi!!
aurelitoful 3 months ago
ta guatona... pero su voz esta hermosisisisima... que maravilla de aria... I love her and her ART!!!!...
waldotube 3 months ago
AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!! BRAVO!!!!!!!!!!!!
galochka777 3 months ago
@galochka777 totally agreed!
mabemawi 3 months ago
It is one thing to be a legendary opera singer. It is another thing to be the prophet of an exclusive religion. Callas belongs to + leads the first category. Anyone who finds her incomparable should perhaps stop comparing her for exactly that reason. Netrebko is amazing and one of the least risk averse singers around today, I love the way she can throw herself at a role, an aria or just a note with all the risks attached: her 26 + 30 Sept Bolena performances were very different and both great.
mabemawi 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Yuck... Netrebko singing Verdi? She is awful
XP11XP 3 months ago
@tiengallavant You can easily see them performing without microphones if you search for opera videos here or concerts in strictly classical music venues built for acoustics. The easiest is just to search by opera name e.g. in this case Il Trovatore, but you can try any other, say Carmen. Then choose not the concert performances (especially outdoor performances) but those that have sets and costumes - i.e. that come from an opera stage. Qutie a few videos here.
jewelmarkess 3 months ago
is this opera?!!!! she is totally pathetic!!! go back to the conservatoire!!! listen to Callas if you really want to hear how this aria should be performed!!! Netrebko, you'd better sing hip-hop!!!
ovidiubobaila 3 months ago
@ovidiubobaila
Your comment is ridiculous
I don't think you know what opera sounds like.
primohomme 3 months ago
@primohomme have you ever listened to Callas?..have you ever studied voice (which I have)?....maybe if you did, we could talk about..otherwise, stick to Netrebko, but please don't call it opera!!!!
ovidiubobaila 3 months ago
@ovidiubobaila
Yes, I have listened to Callas, and perhaps far more than you have ever done so as I own her entire discography. And yes, I have studied voice, as I am a vocalist with a 5+ octave vocal range.
Netrebko is not Callas, and she doesn't need to be. End of story.
primohomme 3 months ago 5
@primohomme so if you're a 5 octave vocal range what?...since when big means quality?!!! (and amazingly your vocal range seems to be almost the double of Calla's vocal range who had a 3 octave range- you should join Netrebko I guess)..and I've never said she has to be Callas (as if she only could!!!) I have mentioned Callas a milling stone example, of musical technique and artistic interpretation..Netrebko's voice is just plain, boring..Lucia, Leonora, Norma, Violetta,they all sound the same
ovidiubobaila 3 months ago
@ovidiubobaila
According to you what is wrong with her singing here? Technically speaking...
primohomme 3 months ago
@primohomme Si eres tan bueno como presumes, ¿por qué estás aquí viéndola y criticándola, en vez de estar en su lugar cantando lo que ella?
scoorpio931031 3 months ago
@scoorpio931031
Eres retardado mental o simplemente idiota? En ningun momento he atacado a Anna, yo la defiendo, duh!
primohomme 3 months ago
@ovidiubobaila Some of us like to go to opera and listen to singers live rather than live in the past. No singer is perfect. Everyone has flaws. Callas was a great interpreter, but hers was hardly ever a beautiful voice; many people found it too harsh. Anna Netrebko has a gorgeous instantly recognizable voice - those who've heard her live can attest to - and she is an excellent actress. I heard her at the Met in both Don Pasquale and Anna Bolena - and no, her voice didn't sound at all the same.
jewelmarkess 3 months ago 3
This is simply stunning!
fonseca524 4 months ago
bravisima......de verda pensais que a alguien importa lo que vosotros penseis de tecnica y de que si la callas o la sutherlan esto y aquello?????.........mas sexo y menos tonterias chicas
gustavoanmosura 4 months ago
@gustavoanmosura
La cultura de la opera no es una disco gay, aunque a veces lo parezca...
La gente que escucha opera usualmente esta interesada en la tecnica vocal de los cantantes
Y es un punto totalmente valido el hablar de la tecnica vocal.
primohomme 4 months ago
@primohomme ya lo es sobretodo para nosotros los cantantes, que lo hacemos de todas maneras pero no de la manera encarnizada qeu discutis cobre apoyos e interpretaciones los aficionados ........muchoas vecs repitiendo lo que algu critico reputado (un artista frustrado ejerciendo su resentiiento ......tratamos de rescatarr lo bueno por la supervivencia del arte
gustavoanmosura 4 months ago
@gustavoanmosura te equivocaste de videeo imbecil, si quieres ver nalgas, tetas y reggaeton busca los videos de musica latina mierdera, para mierdas como tu.
BenjaminWagnerFan 4 months ago
bravisima......
gustavoanmosura 4 months ago
@gilgameshdue
Another factor I think, is that today, a few months is all that is available to prepare for any given role.
Joan Sutherland is said to have never performed a role that she had not prepared for ,for at least two years.
I suspect not even a concert performance. Different times. At a guess, AN will refine this quite a bit further.
Have to say I love Callas in this, enjoy Eva Marton (Met Trovatore DVD, DG), among others, also.
orewa14 4 months ago
@gilgameshdue
You said NO breath, heavy exaggeration don't you think ? I read somewhere once a suggestion that
AN has asthma, don't know how true that is, but in interviews in years past, just in speaking voice she
has had a slight gaspiness, could be what nitpickers seize upon. Sometimes, yes, she is a little breathy, sometimes too breathy. However I have personally heard a very famous sopranos + can think of at least three other very high reputation female singers who who have been worse.
orewa14 4 months ago
unbeliveable :) thank you xxx
Higbby 4 months ago
Enjoyed the performance... Then started reading comments on this page and oh boy - too many experts here who don't see the forest for the trees, who are so good at seeing art as a collection of technicalities... I think, you guys are getting too close. Move away from your microscope, look at it from a distance. Love the art in yourself... Art is about feelings, and the stronger the feelings the fewer words are needed.
wwwvisitor 4 months ago
@wwwvisitor you are absolutly right..........menos mal que tambien hay gente sensata ademas del atajo de locos nazis que insultan,, da muchisima tristeza, creo que no hay que leer estas cosas y ya esta
Un saludo
gustavoanmosura 3 months ago
@gilgameshdue
Yes, she has breathe control issues still
That's still not as bad as some other so called bel canto specialists
who simply had no voice at all, but a hollow shell of a voice which they wrecked trying to be like Callas
primohomme 4 months ago
@gilgameshdue
You are hearing things ...
orewa14 4 months ago
@gilgameshdue
Actually, her main coaching has been done by Gerard Moore, who is also a long time coach of Renee Fleming
and a big fan of Sills, that's why many of the ornaments on Netrebko's Bolena are similar to Sills' as opposed to Callas which would be the case if Scotto was her main coach, as Scotto was obsessed with Callas to the point of sickness.
Actually, I think Scotto understood bel canto more than others. She just didn't have the voice to sing it truly well.
primohomme 4 months ago
Il microfono mette in evidenza la fatica vocale e la velatura di una voce tecnicamente mal impostata e inespressiva ..... degna di un compagno altrettanto otturato come Kauffmann. Un "DUO" decisamente ORRENDO !!!!
fdmoperanews 4 months ago
Really nice performance.
montsyblackmadonna 4 months ago
Le dernier contre-ut est parfait!
Sparafucile84 4 months ago
Anna tu estupenda voz ha mejorado.
40turati 4 months ago
I wouldn't be caught dead at one of those German mega opera events but this was very beautiful, Netrebko and Kaufmann jointly in top form: WoW!
mabemawi 4 months ago
hack-work!!!
zarinakum 5 months ago
@zarinakum the most short and idiotic comment...
spqrmor 4 months ago
Anna worked her ass off. I was impressed. Usually she would have been sharp throughout the whole thing. Let alone a piano high C and somewhat of a trill towards the end. She's improved quite a bit! brava
mugrad25 5 months ago
No puedo decir que cante mal, canta muy bién pero a mí me aburre, no me hace vibrar, no siento nada, noi le pone alma....
Maripudelmonaco 5 months ago
Anna eres la mujer más linda de éste mundo!!!!! y amo tu voz, hermosa.
valencienne1 5 months ago
@DeutschSoprano Yes it is a great blessing. It would have been a tragedy both for his family and for the world of music if his illness turned out to be much more serious. We are all looking forward to hearing him sing again soon.
Ariadne7710 5 months ago
@DeutschSoprano
Thank God he's ok
primohomme 5 months ago
@DeutschSoprano He had surgery for a Thoracic Node which I understand is a node in the lung area which in some cases can be malignant. He made an announcement at the end of August that he would cancel his tour of Japan to have the surgery which his doctors said needed to be done straight away. That is why it was worrying. Since it was urgent people thought maybe it was something bad. Fortunately it has not turned out that way and he has announced that he will start to perform again in October
Ariadne7710 5 months ago
wow, her voice doesn't move, AT ALL. And why is she so fat?
balabanov11 5 months ago
@balabanov11 She's not fat, she's 40 and she had a baby. One of the two is more than enough to inflate, she's quite OK in fact.
Instrumotional 5 months ago
GREAT NEWS!!!! KAUFMANN'S SURGERY WENT WELL. HE IS NOW RECOVERING AND EXPECTS TO RESUME PERFORMANCES NEXT MONTH WITH RECITALS IN GERMANY, ATHENS, LONDON AND THE MET.
Ariadne7710 5 months ago
@Ariadne7710
Wonderful :)
primohomme 5 months ago
@tiengallavant Not stupid at all. When they sing in a huge arena like here and it is being broadcast via TV and cinema they have mics. When inside an Opera House or closed concert hall they don't. Except on odd occasions when the performance is either recorded to be made into DVD or broadcast on TV or cinemas which happens on some occasions. In recent years Opera Houses like to transmit some operas into some piazzas for people to attend free of charge to popularise operas to a wider public.
Ariadne7710 5 months ago
This is the best suited music for Netrebko. Finally, I can rave about her singing. She needs to forget about Gilda, Lucia, and Norina. TROVATORE is perfect for her voice, and there are many other Verdi and Puccini roles that will suit her better than the roles that she has chosen in the past.
TheOperadaddy2 5 months ago
@TheOperadaddy2 You are so right!!!!
She is perfect for Verdi but not for Belcanto...
Why she doesn´t understand it?
maggeo78 5 months ago
@tiengallavant
Yes, how else would they be recorded? And also at a venue that large where there's not the proper acoustical settings, they must use microphones.
The difference is how far the microphones are placed. You will note operatic singers have the microphones place about 4 to 6 feet from them, while most pop singers or classical/crossover singers like Sarah Brightman or Andrea Bocelli need microphones placed just a few inches from their mouth.
primohomme 5 months ago
BRAVO! I think perhaps Netrebko is finally finding her voice and moving into roles better suited to her voice. This was beautifully done and it is ravishing! I wish she was singing Trovatore instead of Anna Bolena at the MET this season!!!!
KathrynARyder 5 months ago
It seems AN has everything for this role, ( and plenty of other roles ).
A beautiful resonance as well as power in the lower and mid ranges of the voice.
The mid range is smooth and lyrical, there seems to be a flowing integration of the voice from bottom to top. The lack of intrusive vibrato,or mannerism, makes the performance very clean and uncluttered. She has nice trills. The voice itself, the timbre, to me, is simply ravishing.
orewa14 5 months ago
@primohomme
No sir. Please not this tone! I'm not talking about that channel and the postings of September, I'm talking about those of August 18. But you know all this yourselve.
So, just stop to steal from other members or tell us how you got the recordings of the German TV channel. Thank you.
familyfilmfund 5 months ago
@familyfilmfund
You mean this one? watch?v=uZI9_zYScLs
How could I have stolen it if it's SHORTER than this video and is 480p instead of HD?
Or you mean this one? watch?v=kKkd5fnTAw4
Which is also in lower resolution than this video.
So you see, the evidence shows that I did not steal these vids from anyone on youtube
As the length and resolution DOES NOT MATCH.
If you must know, I downloaded them from an opera sharing site called "Opera Share".
Now, I demand an APOLOGY!!!
primohomme 5 months ago
@primohomme
primohomme, shhhhhhhhhhhh. lol
asdfopera 5 months ago
@familyfilmfund Take a fucking seat! Stealing from someone else's channel would mean you have exclusive copyright to these videos, which you don't. NEXT!
BZBlaner 5 months ago
@BZBlaner
That idiot claimed I stole this videos first from his channel which I showed him wasn't possible as he uploaded the videos A WHOLE WEEK after I did. Then he says I stole them from another user who had uploaded the videos before I did, which that person did upload them before I did...but in a lower resolution as opposed to HD as I uploaded here!! I can't stand these idiots, another nazi asswipe with a nasty sense of entitlement.
primohomme 5 months ago
@primohomme I'm still dying at the fact that he says you're stealing when the asshole doesn't have any legitimate copyright claims to do so. Where's this lunatics channel with the vids?
BZBlaner 5 months ago
@BZBlaner
user/ff4610 <-------That's his profile
You can see he uploaded videos after I did.
He is just pissed he has less views on his posts
primohomme 5 months ago
@primohomme LOL, the lunatics channel was deleted for severe community guideline violations.
BZBlaner 5 months ago
@primohomme Hey primmo,please cool down.Let's forget about that lad who's stolen your beautiful video.Your uploadings are always excellent and correct which bring a lot of pleasure to all of us. Let's better congratulate dear Anna with her 40-th birthday, she's one of unique living sopranos we have today.
Happy birthday dear Annna! Sincerely love your voice!
spqrmor 5 months ago
@familyfilmfund
Are you fucking kidding me? Take this video you uploaded for example
watch?v=f3p1gAxm1jY
You uploaded it on September 6th. I uploaded mine on August 29th. How could I possibly steal it from your channel if you uploaded it AFTER I uploaded this one??? THINK ABOUT THAT!!!
You are slandering me and I demand an apology!
primohomme 5 months ago
@cuoredeinidi
Bitch take a fucking seat and shut the fuck up
primohomme 5 months ago
@cuoredeinidi
You rude nasty old queen
Go back to listen to that voiceless nobody you worship, rat-faced Scotto,
And leave music, beauty and solid voices to those who can really appreciate it.
primohomme 5 months ago
@cuoredeinidi Не тебе писалось дураку, не внемлющему русскому языку..
Although, if the shoe fits, wear it.
spqrmor 5 months ago
@cuoredeinidi The Cast of the Don Giovanni I am talking about is stellar!!! Raimondi as the Don, Van Dam as Leporello, Edda Moser as Donna Anna, Kiri Te Kanawa as Donna Elvira, and Teresa Berganza as Zerlina. doesn't get much better than that. And visually a feast for the eyes. As a production it is worthy of Visconti:))) There is praise for you if you like!!!!!
Ariadne7710 5 months ago
@cuoredeinidi Van Dam's Voice is to die for. Pure velvet dipped in chocolate. Yum yum. Have you seen his Leporello in the Joe Loosey Don Giovanni movie filmed in Palladian villas in Italy? Amazing singing amazing orchestral performance, amazing photography in amazing locations. And Van Dam looks so sexy. Buy the DVD if you can. I first saw it in an Art Movie theatre when it first came out in the 70s but now it is available on DVD.
Ariadne7710 5 months ago
@cuoredeinidi
But quite honestly, who is singing better than her right now out of the sopranos?
I think Renee is the best even if her bel canto is not pristine, but most solid voice we have right now
But after her, only a couple of mezzos...DiDonato, Larmore, etc
primohomme 5 months ago
Voce e tecnica fuori repertorio.
Che cosa hanno fatto da questa bellissima donna?...
Con questo viso 'severo' e maschile,e questi movimenti e le facce che fa...si ammalata dalla stessa malattia come la Bartoli?
Ecco il prodotto finale di una donna bella e una voce stupenda!
E chi e il ragazzo con questa voce brutta tutta appoggiata sulla gola e questi suoni orrendi?
Che tristezza!
Ben venuti nel 21 secolo...
bodiloto 5 months ago
Comment removed
spqrmor 5 months ago
@bodiloto
Пришел, нагадил втихаря,
Обиженный за прошлое,
Ну что же ждать от чудака,
Который пишет пошлое?
Никто не вечен под луной,
И Вы,увы, не гений,
Забудут Вас как дурака,
Без всяких сожалений...
spqrmor 5 months ago
@spqrmorGrazie per la poesia sei simpatico,ma io preferisco poeti come Leopardi,Esenin etc...!
Ho capito il tuo 'messaggio', purtroppo il tuo fanatismo non aiutera Netrebko di diventare una bellissima attrice come lo erano Tebaldi,Gencer,Dimitrova,Callas etc.etc.Insomma IL FANATISMO uccide,non dà LA VITA.Coraggio Amico,coraggio.La sua 'pesia e più bella(se si può 'apprezzare' la poesia d'un fanatico)dalla interpretazione di Netrebko.
perchè nella sua poesia lei mette tutto il suo cuore e anima.
bodiloto 5 months ago
@bodiloto Я не очень силен в итальянском, хотя легко разбираю Ваши "перлы",поэтому отвечу Вам на русском,раз понимаете.Я то как раз не фанатик, а человек ,который разбирается в музыке и имеет музыкальное образование(жаль что не консерваторское!),слух и музыкальный вкус,.. А вот Вы ,занимаетесь ФАНАТИЧНЫМ и ПУСТЫМ КРИТИКАНСТВОМ буквально на каждом ее видео.Вы просто тролль с уймой свободного времени! А лучше Нетребко сейчас все равно НИКТО не поет!Все ваши Димитровы просто рядом не валялись.
spqrmor 5 months ago