Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (24)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This is a wonderful remake!

  • Regarding Trevor's cameo, I just like to pretend that it's just an ordinary traction engine, since you don't get to see his face, properly.

    I also like how you had Percy nowhere near Wellsworth when he was waiting at a signalbox.

  • pretty cool, you're getting better with these. Having the brake coach on the other end of the train is an interesting detail, something not many people do.

    Only thing i wasn't sure of was Trevor and George in the flashback, i don't think they were introduced yet (Trevor would be in a scrapyard wouldnt he?).

  • @sixbluewheels Yeah. I'm suprised no one picked up on that :P. I just put Trevor in to see if anyone would notice :P. Nothing was said about what happened to George before he was introduced, so I thought "meh, I'll put him in"

  • @FfarquharBranchLine2

    Frankly its prototypical to the real thing.

    The southern railway ran its coaches in sets, which often had a brake coach on both ends of train, it was pretty common on other railways as well. Nice touch. The general attention to detail as well as the decent length of trains is good.

    I like it.

  • @sixbluewheels Ah well I suppose this episode was years before Edward actually found Trevor (At least as far as the RWS goes) so for fun we could assume his old owner still has him at this point but none of the engines know him :)

  • Nice! I love it!

  • Looks like your episode production rate has reached a whole new level since your switch to Trainz :) It just goes to show how hard it was to make episodes in MSTS and I commend you for it :D It's almost like you've been doing this for ages but it's actually only been a few months :)

  • @Damocles178 I think the MSTS progress has REALLY helped make my Trainz videos the best they can be. If people can work MSTS as well as I did, Trainz is a doddle. Just getting content in the game that was the initial problem for me :P

  • Some great face masking.Just one thing if in the beginning, if Thomas was pulling the coaches out of the sidings, how did he get back to be with Edward and Percy?

  • No particular reason, but I really like that shot of Percy at 3:57. :P

  • Great Job Once Again. I especially like the panning shot of the big engines at the beginning.

  • You just keep getting better and better at this! I loved it!

  • Good remake, like the masking at the beginning.

  • 3:58, small goof, Percy's driver is still in his cab :P I know that cant be helped thou, great work :)

  • I hope you can remake the episode "thomas and terence" i dunno why but it just seems to be a childhood fav

  • @thomas5070 Maybe soon :)

  • @thomas5070 But next time, please send any requests to my channel page and only leave opinions of the remake here

  • @FfarquharBranchLine2 alright i'll remember that for future viewing

  • An Epic End..To An Epic Trilogy Of Remakes.

  • You've remade the saga well. I don't mind the brake coaches on the 'wrong' end, sometimes trains are like that and it helps this feel more realistic. The little memory flashes like with Edward and Percy, and the different angles made it very enjoyable to watch.

  • @Lightninging63 Yeah, that's what i did it for, a more realistic feel

  • One of my favourite Thomas stories, this is a great remake. I love the flashbacks like when Edward was warning Percy. Very well done :)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more