Tarja Turunen vs Anette Olzon - Wishmaster

[MrMontilius]

I fucking hate these videos, why? because it's just a source of hate and ofensive comments. Why the hell can you just stop insulting Anette?. Is it really wrong if I fucking like both singers?. @LadyEleanor05 you're showing me the prick you are insulting someone that has nothing against you, you may dislike her style but by insulting her and waiters you made you look really bad. RESPECT. If they both Tarja and Anette know what you all are saying about them, they would be embarrassed.

[sarahtheg1]

You take Tarja's from a professional recording and Anette's from a crappy cell phone vid. Jesus... get over yourselves already.

[YamiraSrima]

Jesus Christ you guys, it's been six years. Tarja is not coming back. Accept it and get over yourself.

[GunShooter1314]

ok quit comparing tarja to anette, neither one is better than the other, if ur a true nightwish fan ull like the band either way, if your a big tarja nut then just listen to her solo career and quit hating anette,

[luciferihQ]

Tarja's video is taken from dvd and Anette's from some random guy's shitty camera. How can you compare that? If you hate Anette so much, just listen to old Nightwish, don't go to gigs and stay home. Don't you people have anything else to do than keep complaining how Tarja is better than Anette? Jesus.. Tarja is not Nightwish. Tarja hasn't been Nightwish's singer in years. Get over it or fucking kill yourselfs. By the way Im not big Anette-fan. Not even big Nightwish-fan. Peace out..

[MsWisdomfan]

TARJA FoREver!!!

[MustaineIStheMessiah]

Annette is better

[majomanak]

With anette and huge orchestras it´s much more powerfull !!

[CarolineForbesFan]

Tarja is so much better for nightwish!

[sophiaas]

Tarja clearly wins.

And for gods sake annette is blowing up all epics --

Thumbs up if you agree.

[cCcAhmetseliMcCc]

tarja says wishmaster , anette says fishhamster.

[cCcAhmetseliMcCc]

tarja 4ever

[RulezXP]

Anette Olzon: Go a hell!

Tarja Turunen: Come back to sing for us!

[TheCl0ckMan]

I don't hate Anette but the old Nightwish songs were written and performed for Tarja's powerful voice and opera style. Anette is more suited to a girl band to be honest. Her voices range isn't sufficient to sing the old Nightwish songs.

[hardraynesgonnafall]

hahahaha again, yet another video where the video creator tries to reinforce his bias of an argument by having the clip of the singer he likes in fantastic quality, and the clip of the singer he doesn't like was recorded from a fucking cellphone, dude a cellphone video is never gonna hold up to a friggin professionally filmed and recorded dvd rip. It doesn't matter who sings better, this video blows

[ISeeAnIdiot]

@hardraynesgonnafall

the video was made in 2007. nw had NO dvd vids released then my dear.

fail.

[Astrid584]

TARJA IS THE BEST!!!!!!!! I WANT HER IN AN AMAZING GROUP SUCH AS NIGHTWISH!!!!

[darkhunter513]

is it just me or am i the only one on this PLANET who can accept that arja is gone and admit that anette is also good?!?!?

[ultimatedimfirebrand]

lo que sea anette no esta lista para nigthwish su vos me suena a pop o algo asi simplemente no encaja

[PanteraDzika]

TARJA BETTER!!!

[krikzuz]

jjajajajjajajajaajajajajajajaj­aj escuchar cantar a anett es para la risa jjaajajajaj ...no se compara a TARJA jjajjaajajj......io opino q se vuelva a cantar a la ducha.. es imposible q cante las canciones de mi diosa TARJA

[zazkita]

Pinches inmaduros! dejen de pelear, ya cambienle, como las comparan? tarja tiene un tipo diferente de Tarja, es como si pusieron a Billie joe contra Till Lindemann son dieferentes tonos!

[Aeznout]

Anette Olzon is not better than biever!!! Tarja Turunen better then all!!!!!!!

[Glory2theLamb11]

Why make this video? It's Tarja verses Anette; obviously there IS no comparison. What voice can compare with Tarja's??

It's Tarja singing OPERA and Anette... doing something, what exactly, not sure? The question shouldn't be brought up who is better because anyone with ears to hear can tell straight away Tarja rules this arena.

[TIFFANYRAY84]

TARJAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAA s2222222222222 FTW!

[JenniferRisueno]

hahahahaha es muy gracioso como deben darle apoyo vocal a Anette... Tarja es lo máximo!!! ; )

[ViperPrincess92]

Tarja is amazing!

[Svenspages]

Ohne Tarja ist Nightwish nur Night... ohne wish.

[Svenspages]

Ohne Tarja ist Nightwish nur Night... ohne wish.

[wolf2272]

Gosh.... Imaginarium only 5 months away and the battle continues. Obviously, Anette does not stand a chance versus Tarja in Tarja's song, because they were made FOR her. I think it is really spiteful to compare her. Tuomas, Marco, Emppu and Jukka chose her for a reason.

[2610DMJ]

@wolf2272 Approx 3 months away.

[2610DMJ]

@wolf2272 Going to release it in 2011

[cahc1990]

Wishmaster is Tarja!!

[llnag]

Annete Sucks!!

[gael509]

Tarja Turunen is the best!! please Anette ... dont try to sing the old songs!!!!!

[kristinasabiniciene]

Tarja Forever!



[masterofpiano1]

obviusly anette lose because tarja is an OPERA SINGER and anette a normnal singer but both are good

[Psychosocialyt]

Anette... Please tape your mouth shut if they ask you to sing Nightwish's old songs x.x

[riversoflust]

Anette please do us all a favor and stop singing the old Nightwish songs

[riversoflust]

Tarja is the winner

[AtsushiSakurai5555]

=/ naaa nightwish dejo d ser nightwish cuando tarja se fue anette canta muy bonito pero naaaaaaa

[mywithcandyface]

Tarja won

[Amandio099]

Nightwish de ahora no es nada que ver con Nightwish de antes... Nightwish es Nightwish con Tarja..

me gustaba cuando estaba Tarja..ella le daba el toque perfecto!

[Feanor2345]

Nightwish now = only empty name

[finalfantasy10892]

@Feanor2345 yes empty the shadow of Tarja

[finalfantasy10892]

this song's only for Tarja but nightwish never die even without Tarja

[rivercolalight]

nightwish died when tarja left

[Alex5DX]

Shit video...

Video Tarja quality = 10

Video Anette= 0 (Wiht mobile phone...).

[jhjkhkjkjhjkhkjk]

0:42 oh shit!

[Mcjohny92]

Someone should ban Annette to sing these songs

[Obuhova2]

Tarja THE BEST!

[TheFullmoonTraveller]

Nettie is SUFFERING to sing this this song....Tarja is ENJOYING every minut of it! Is there even a comparison??? It's a diva aginst a (talented) high school girl!!! I think Tarja wiped the floor with Nettie...Pooor Nettie, ur gonna be Tarja's shadow for ever.. She is a metal GODESS you are a metal princess....Long inaccessible way to go!

[TheEcliptyca]

Tarja vs NOTHING u.u Tarja obviously won u.u

[TheEcliptyca]

Tarja is the only one that can sing this song..

[KatherinesBlood]

Honestly? I'm convinced that Tuomas regrets choosing Anette. I can't believe that there wasn't any better vocalists to join Nightwish.

Anette is not bad though, but her style doesn't fit NW music at all. I dare to say she rapes their songs.

I'm also anxious about their new album. Is it going to be kinda dissappointing like DDP?

[Hellasforever915]

@KatherinesBlood Hmm, I was thinking the same. But I think he wanted to choose a completely different road for the evolution of the band with a singer of that range. I don't doubt she can do a good or even great job in the future but definitely not excellent like Tarja had always been doing. I think it's better to completely ignore or delete from our memories the hopeless efforts of Anette to resurrect the old era and focus on the future work of the band.

[Hellasforever915]

@KatherinesBlood I don't of course claim DPP was a great album it is probably the worst one of Nightwish yet but fair enough.Remember Tuomas wrote and composed without having any idea about the abilities of the singer he would choose. I'm positive or only hoping that Imaginarium will surpass DPP just because of this asset now.. the knowledge of what Anette is capable of.

[ElizabetHxD2]

aneetteeeee!!! ♥

[cintratavares]

come on. annete is nothing close to tarja!!

[HorcsinAttila]

I think it's a really disgusting mix. Why?

It mixes a better picture and voice quality when Tarja sings, and a poor picture and voice quality when Anette sings so as to suggest that Tarja is a good, and Anette is a bad. And of course Tarja won in this competitions, because the editor of this video wanted so.

Why don't you mix similar picture and voice quaility videos?

Tarja sings, Anette sings in her style. Both are good, but different.

[Plevell]

@HorcsinAttila true but you can still hear the catastrophic screaming trying to "sing" highs.. tarja deffinitely won

[pocholski]

tarja epic win!

anette epic fail!

[heisenmanFC]

Tarja is more connected with the public and enjoying herself as she sings, Anette is too busy struggling to get the notes to connect with the audience.

I mean, it's not bad, but she doesn't put passion in what she does.

[marciomoutinho2010]

sera anette nao entedeo que o nightwish nao e o lugar dela??? aff

[capang9555]

there is no comparison,

[AitorDivas]

Tarja is the master. Anette isn't even the aprentice...

[TheEvilMidnight]

Tarja Forever!

[rammkalmah]

anette olzon

no sirve para nada

al lado de tarja parece una

recien expulsada de la academia 4° generacion

[Oberleitenant]

Anette SUCKS!

[greendaydave1]

tarja rules!

[681EEE]

sorry Anette, not even close

[EmppuRock]

@681EEE oh my god you are so so so so right , Wen i hear Tarja i have goose bumps and my heart is beat so fast out of my chest....and wen i hear Anette my face its all down my ears are bleeding and my brain is destroyed! Thats how i feel!

[51313932]

Composer composed the song for Tarja Turunen

[51313932]

Anette is good but Tarja Turunen is very very very very good

[BuriedTeeth]

I can't believe people have the audacity to say that Anette doesn't have enough power in her voice, yet this video switches between studio-quality recording to shitty hand cam.

[yoruichisan19]

My father is gonna cry, if I show this video to him. And not because of Tarja. Anette just hasn't got enough power in her voice to sing this song. She HAS a good voice, but not for this kind of music.

[heisenmanFC]

/watch?v=YQ8LwCuSKV0&t=41

LORI-EYEYEYEH lol wtf

[cccerg]

заебали сравнивать Тарью и Анетте !!! Каждая по своему хороша !! просто вы привыкли изначально слышать исполнение Тарьи ...

how much can you compare Tarja and Anette - not you sick? ! Each in its own good! just that you originally used to hear Tarja's performance ...

[13thphantom]

anette you are discusting!TARJA<3

[NetherlandsDragon]

its both just... lovely

but, dont you think, that if you watch screen and quality, that

A) its taken from the crowd with annette and from the high cams etc with tarja?

B) the quality from annete is just taken with a really sukky quality and noise that isnt at tarja?

C) if u negate the quality difference, its just both kickass!!

just a diff style of singing, the one does it drama-like the other does it rocking/metal style

get used to it, get over it

[mishonacro]

Anette has a very good voice, but her voice does not run for this kind of music. Tarja has a wonderfull voice and her voice fits to this kind of music , I wish I that she will return to the group.

[lestatdosseldorf]

jajajaja que patetica se oye anette con sus gritos, pero mas pateticos son ustedes jajajaja.

[lpsh0rty]

tarja 100%

[sebacanallaman]

Annete STFU!!!!!!

[crazyanitka01]

Anette lag unfortunately. Her voice is too enough not deep for this repertoire. Vocals scale she can and has, but her voice is not coloratura. The woman of breath has not in lungs with in a word. This was not good decision to evict of Tarija,because Tarija and so will be forever unique

[PaulBeauregard1979]

It is not a surprise to me. Wishmaster was writen for TARJA`s voice and singing style, not Anette`s. Stop slamming Anette, she`s doing her best with music which wasn`t writen for her singing style. Realise this and get over it.

[CarolCamilaTwilover]

I don't think that anette is a waitress, is just her voice is not so beautiful like traja's voice.

Just it.

[Tim7676Tim]

once again, a bad way of comparing, get a good live video of both and not a suckish made one and one nice... or take a album track. But this is not the way to compare them, i see it as two diffrent bands, and i like them both!

[PaulBeauregard1979]

Tarja.

[royalhunt0603]

歌唱力が、ぜんぜん違うんだけど・。。

なんで、アネットのようなそこら辺にいそうなレベルのやつを迎え­たのか、理解に苦しむな。

薬でもやって、らりってんじゃねえの？ばかだぜ。

[km0rrt]

Tarja is like Chuck Norris in this case...oh and also in every case

[Aaga223]

scream vs sing

Tarja won.

[AliceMakeupymas]

team tarja!!

[Evenstar988]

omfg

[seannaesseannaes]

umm.... its not anette's fault the guy filming is not a professional crew

[heisenmanFC]

@seannaesseannaes is not the crew's fault if Anette can't keep the notes and has to go "heyheyhey" at the end of some sentences because she has run out of breath.

[MrsLesleyOlivia]

Nightwish is born with Tarja

And died with Tarja



[deadwolf696]

@MrsLesleyOlivia I agrre with you, you're right NW is born and die with Tarja

[strangelittlebeing]

@MrsLesleyOlivia By Tarja's hand.

[ElizabetHxD2]

@MrsLesleyOlivia 're wrong and dies, is reborn with anette

[evanescence9314]

@MrsLesleyOlivia Nightwish is TarjaBorn?

[MrsLesleyOlivia]

@evanescence9314  Jup.

[domiukas1]

@MrsLesleyOlivia I know what you mean, but I disagree :) Nightwish is good now, Tarja is good now too. Lets say like this : We have to great bands - Nightwish and Tarja Turunen - instead of one Epic Amazing Band - NIGHTWISH ( 1996 - 2005 ) But its still good =) yep?

[ludahr]

Heh - I do not know what to say - sorry anette ther recording sucks and you do your best, but this is like comparing little boy to a supernova.... it is an order 34 magnitude difference at least. That is the output from little boy was 10^13 Joules where the supernova is 10^44 joules..... sorry for the physics compairson...

[cuttlefisch]

Tarja is just a TOTAL GODDESS!!!! No-one but no-one can compare with her. Annette is a very good singer and frontwoman but it's not her fault that she is so greatly inferior to Tarja. I'm sure that she does the best she can in concert and in the studio. It is really obvious when Annette sings Tarja's songs how much better a singer Tarja is.However, we have to face the fact that Tarja's not coming back. Ever,

[SpuzzyKat]

Nice try but you completely missed. Wow Anette should not be doing this.

[VincentValentineTdJ]

I think this video should be called "Tarja Turunen v/s Alvin and the Chipmunks"..

March 23, 2011: Tarja Turunen in Chile!

[darkcarolineriddle]

I like both singer. Obviously, I'm a huge Tarja fan, but I really like Anette too. Just, XD not when she sings tarja's songs. They are not for you anette!

But I understand it. It would be quite dissapointing to go to a NIghtwish concert and just hear dark passion play songs.

But, damn, Annete may be a soprano but she can't sing the same way that Tarja does.

[2000BlaDe2000]

all of us think that tarja is the best because that is the truth but we can see that and the band can't and i dont know why.....I think that Nightwish need to give us some explications.Whos with me push the Like button(sorry my bad english)

[XDking9]

lol

[didolinata]

TARJA IS THE BEST

[Dojadilomi]

4:32 Wishmaster the Trooper :))

[PaAfrodita666]

q regrese tarja a nosotros nos vale un pito q se bañe y kiera todo el dinero para ella,q se quede todo a nosotros nos importa q regrese tarja nightwish no s es lo mismo sin ti y annete q sea segunda voz o bailarina como sea !!

[TruzziSlayer]

0:39 - 0:44 Ha mal di pancia? Poverina!! :(

[BiancaBio1]

Anette cover da Sandy 2 hahahaha

[holmebubben]

Går inte att jämföra eftersom Anettes inspelning är troligen via in videokamera eller telefon!!! Dom sjunger bra båda två men har olika röster så varför jämföra alls?? Och varför trycka ner Anette som många gör, det var väl bandet som valde henne efter Tarja, eller????? Har jag fel???

[Aptemishe]

Oh my God! This is simply horrible! Both just awful! Anette has voice but dont know how use it and Tarja....awful parody opera.....

[marilena6]

0:40-0:43 god it's as if someone butchered her.... I don't like being mean , but Anette shouldn't try to sing old NW song, these are only for a soprano's voice! Tarja 4 ever!!!!

[y4t3z]

OMG.......!

Anette just SCREAM NOT SINGING!!!

WHY ANETTE STILL SING N.W OLD SONG?

I THINK ANETTE NEVER HEARD TARJA SOUND BEFORE!!!

SHAMELESS !!!

[Kleptomanuel]

Tarja is way overrated.

Anette does a great job.

[rockeira818]

Pq uma canta e a outra caga?

Wishmaster é lendária, A Anette estragou a música T-T

Pq cagar?Não canta porquê?

Tarja é uma cantora.A outra é cover da Sandy

[y4t3z]

this compare just make me laugh.. :D

enette is nothing in this song.... ahhahahaaha poor anette sing this song..

just my opinion. . .

[Vitaliyspb]

Day and night.

Tarja rules Respect from Russia

[Toertchen1983]

Anette sucks so badly! Tarja is the best, fuck the rest! Nightwish is dead!

[AngelRika]

@Toertchen1983

Yeah, so dead without Tarja! I miss the old spirit of Nightwish

And it´s not only because of the better voice! The whole image is ruined now! Everything!

[arpharazon999]

tarja is the best but ins't fair you make the comparison between a PRO record from the DVD and a record make by a person with a cell phone

[eternaldeathproject]

Anette não aguenta cantar Wishmaster pq é uma canção poderosa e ela não da conta!Porra manda essa Sandy embora e coloca uma cantora a autura da Tarja ou chama a Tarja devolta!!!!!

[sieka134]

Are you all retarded? firstly the record with Tarja singing is much better and on that record with Anette which is recorded with i think a drainer, and secondly Anette and Tarja have different voices both very good but you cant compare them... damn

[y4t3z]

@sieka134

YES!!! cannot compare... and don't need to compare,,...

because "DEAF" people also know which one is better and have a quality vocal!!

ANETTE PLEASE STOP SINGING OLD N.W SONG !!!

[GinnyIceHearth]

Tarja!!!!! <3

[xXKaitosXx]

dude.. but dont help anette so much.. the sound on the tarja version its a lot cleaner.. the bass and drums sounds much more powerful.. the anette version sounds like it was filmed with a blackberry.. and a cheaper one.. =/

i agree too.. i like tarja! 100 times over anette.. but nightwish cant die just because they dont have tarja anymore.. we fans have to try to get used to it.. and backup nightwish a lil bit..no? give anette some time.. she's practing a lot i heard.. long live to Nightwish!

[Deathryx]

/watch?v=m1A1XsdmqYM This is our cover of nightwish's phantom pls watch;;)

[DafniNik]

i don't beleve that they let Anette sing Tarja's songs! She is very good when she sings Amaranth and Bye Bye Beautiful but she is HORRIBLE when she sings Wishmaster, End Of All Hope or Nemo! Of course Tarja is better in this song but we all know that she can't sing Amaranth! :P anyway, i think Tarja's voice is mutch better than Anette's... :)

[Revivedwolfhajime]

Tarja had a vampyric touch and annet sounds like Belinda jojojoj

[minhtri7821]

Hey LadyEleanor05 , your mother is screaming ...

[LaPameita]

@jonaesteban24 TRAJA????

JAJAJAJAJA

[jonaesteban24]

@LaPameita TARJA IS THE BEST!!!!

[Masormy]

Just realised that Tarja and NW were two parts which were fitting perfectly, lost theirselves and are now... nervermind. Why couldn't they just come toghether again? I also never liked my work colleagues.

[Reymond112386]

0:40 just sounds like a dog being run over by a car.

[mywinterstorm07]

Puag....

[VelvetTearsNana]

while annete sounds relative good on dark passion play sh butchers the old songs

[VelvetTearsNana]

while annete sounds relative good on dark passion play sh BUTCHERS the old songs

[daliamar2123]

TARJA RULES!!!

[VEX350Z]

@daliamar2123 + 1

[Nurse00]

It's not anette's fault....she did'nt choose herself for being the new singer. Toumas and the others has something bad into his mind....

[MrsLesleyOlivia]

OMG

WTH is Anette doing!!!!!!!!?

She don't know how to sing this song!

[narkutometa]

ANETTE OLZON!!!!

[MihaelaMadalinaN]

@narkutometa sucks

[iparihangya]

OMG, Anette.... She is.... don't know, what is she doing...

[Motyleeczeek]

Tarja, Tarja, Tarja !

[pestilentrabbit]

I am sick of people being nasty about annette, I mean fair enough the pure truth is she is bad compared to Tarja but that does not give you a reason to make comments that tarja should come back and kill her etc. It was Tuomas that chose her so imagine being in her shoes right now.

[ojki26]

Tarja Turunen is the Queen!!!!!

Has a phenomenal voice!! Anette sings really bad!!

[dant697]

think about this

if anette sang it first and then tarja sang it people would be critacizing tarja

people generally like the orginal singer over the new one becuz its what there used to

i have to say i prefer tarja but thats cuz her voice is more powerfull

but anette makes the song happier so i like both

[AlldaylongRock]

damn 0:44 wtf was that!!!

anette isn't the best live that one was outrageous

hahaha man the poster chose End Of An Era's performance for comparison, that was well done, the best of tarja(she was sick on that night!) and something from Anette, but the anette's concert sound is a little shitty on every aspects, i cant hear emppu or the others

hahaTarja's headbanging

[NavarinTR]

"but Olzon is screaming" I absolutely agree...

[MrsLesleyOlivia]

Tarja = the queen!!

Anette sucks!

[Dojadilomi]

@MrsLesleyOlivia yeaaaaaaaah! :D

[royalhunt0603]

@MrsLesleyOlivia I think so,too!!!!

Anett voice is very very sucks!!!!!!!

[aguimartz]

estoy de decuerdo comtigo ANETTE OLZON JAMAS PODRA CANTAR LAS CANCIONES QUE TARJA CANTABA PORQUE ANETTE GRITA NO CANTA Y TARJA ES UNA CHIGONERIA

[elvarbuk]

ANETTA CANT EVEN HIT THE FUCKING NOTES. SHES LIKE AN CROW AND TARJA IS A CROW KILLER

[raccccccccg]

annete is singing like in cheap disco..............

[Laymon121]

without Tarji it is not it.... Aneta cannot replace will never Tarju.......

[TheMist2008]

Автор убейся ап стену. Твое видео отстой и звук тоже, как ты и сам усосок гребанный, научись работать пержде чем выкладывывать. Возомнили из себя творцов никуя делать ниче не умееете.

[estiveaqui]

i agry, tarja is singing but anette isn't xD

[LovingLife411]

TARJA SUCKS!!!

[vruchtegebak]

@LovingLife411 She does not suck, but Anette is just way better!

[LovingLife411]

@vruchtegebak I actually don't think she sucks.

Hartwall especially was one of the best concerts she's ever done.

I only said that, because I was proving a point.

Someone comments, "ANETTE SUCKS", and people don't defend her

but rather put "thumbs up" on the comment. I was trying to

see how many more people will defend Tarja compared to Anette.

Truth is I completely love them both;=)