mariotehplumber is just annoying, in my opinion and I fully understand that he is just a troll, the reason we make commentaries on this plumber is because we need to speak up about what we think. Youngblood,thank you.
@MrSirRaven Well, you didn't mess up as much as you just latched onto an old subject. By looking at your video you seem to have a unique edge and I'm sure if you practice, you will improve. Not everyone is perfect the first time, so I won't crucify you for it.
Whelp, sorry for reccomending doing a commentary on MagicalPockyUsagi. I just thought it would be a bit funny seeing your interpretation on that user (Whom I understand is either a troll or dillusional).
Unless the person your doing a commentary on absolutely doesnt listen to anything, then I can understand doing a commentary. But there's no point of making fun of them, thats kind of sad actually if you used time out of your life to make a commentary on someone just to insult them. If they don't take advice, then dont even bother with them.
I find it annoying that people even make commentaries. If you dont like a video, then just leave a comment instead of making a whole video about it. Seriously, its just wasting your time.
You are a rare example of immense insight and common sense that I've seen on this site, and I thank you for making this video. Also, I firmly believe in editing/scripting reviews (or whatever other videos one makes), although I make unscripted videos on occasion (like updates, gameplay bits, and other things). It's good to know I'm not the only person daring to be bold and distinct from the herd, the diamonds underneath the autumn leaves, and so forth. Keep up the good work, man. :)
Excellent job with this rant; you've piqued my interest in your works, so I subbed you. :) In any event, I'm a reviewer (of anime, and the occasional Western animation, installments) and not a commentator (although reviews do have commentary to a certain degree, but I digress); I completely agree with your point about being original (and hilarious, in the process). I try my best in my reviews to balance insight and entertainment, while being fair (though harsh) to said installments.
Even though I haven't made a commentary in a while and I hope to go back again I just want to say this. I'm pretty sure that 95% percent on the people I commentated on in the past were trolls I just made them for fun. and to be honest I find all of those troll videos funny. I just wanted to say that.
@Luceroj104 It really is no problem and I feel that you did nothing wrong. But thanks for apologizing, even though you did not do anything out of line. I accept your apology either way.
im kinda a noob on my commentaries, I play the "constructive criticism" card several times on my videos(scratch that, i use it all the time). Im also guilty of jumping the bandwagon by making a joshua OSC. This video makes me want to improve a bit. thanks youngblood.
I want to try my first commentary, but I don't know what to do anymore, what are your advise Youndbloodfantasy91? And please don't include "add humor" on, I don't have a "sense" to humor of what I "attack" anymore. =(
Great rant, YB. That's how I feel about the commentary community. Its just the epitamy of starting drama and being so repetitive. Not to mention bandwagon jumpers and dare I say it. using the term '' 3rd gen '' and '' constructive criticism''
great commentary for an unscripted sort :) i am impressed with the information you gave out. im definitely keeping all these things in mind when i make my next commentary...which i dont know when and who on xx; anyways...would you mind if i show you my first and only OSC? i wanted to give it a try to see if im even capable of doing a good commentary....up to you though...im just looking for any extra feedback :3
This is a great rant youngblood and I agree with u all the way. I did two commentaries in my previous account and I stopped because commentaries cause drama and the people won't bother to listen. This is an excellent for an unscripted rant. Great job!
You want to know what I can't stand about this community? I can't stand the fact that some people have to cry whenever someone changes their ways in the community... And I also hate this retarded "3rd-gen" bullshit that people like to fling like Monkey shit. Look, just because someone joined the community at a certain time, that doesn't mean that people should "classify" them as "3rd-gen faggots". Anyways dude, awesome video. The community really needed to be addressed.
i remember when I made my first and only commentary on this one douchebag who made a pretty piss poor list on anime cliches. there was no humor i acted all angry and shit and i made the mistake of thinking i could change his mind. some brief drama ensued and i even considered redoing my commentary, but the more i thought about it the more i realized how little i cared and decided in the end commentaries weren't for me. reviewing anime and zombie flicks are my thing and i'm content with it.
This was excellent Youngblood. I was afriad that you would bring up the idea that most people love inserting quotes into their videos. Honestly I was going to do that for a video I had in mind this past summer, but a part of me just knew that there was something wrong with that. I've tried to come up with clever jokes, but then again, they very generic and things that some other commentators have come up with. That I mostly why I don't have any commentaries on my channel.
@DotNetWolf (Cont.) The mostyou are going to get from me from a terrible video that seriously needs work on is from the comments I leave behind and some final thoughts. After that I move on. It's a shame there are so many problems with Commentaries these days, because when I first heard about it, Joshua8428 was just becoming a new hot topic. I'm glad you did this rant because NOW I know that isn't about constructive criticism. UGH!
Seriously? people are STILL commentating on Joshua and mariotehplumber? There as old as Adam Sandlers carrer. I should try to add alittle more humor into my commentaries because, (well I only have two), but even I looked at them and I think there alittle boring. But the one thing that pisses me off is when 5-7 people make a commentary on the same freakin topic thinking, I may have done that once or twice, but doing that to much does make you lazy.
I really wish people could stop taking Mariotehplumber seriously. He is such an obvious troll and an oddly succesful one.
One problem I have with commentaries is that they focus too much of faggots(Joshua included). The thing that made commentaries great was that it challenged fans of other people like Hellsing, RandomDCE and Darkness. Now I see people do rants on kids or recolors. The closest I can think that dose try to challege people is Shadowstar but he has too many flaws.
You know what's funny most of the guys who preach "Constructive Critisms" always end up getting asshurt when people call them out and they end up deleting everything they made and come out with "Well I don't want other people giving me shit" ie. YuGiOhSonicNiGHTS64.
Heres something I got to say (I forget who said this so Youngblood if you know who I'm quoting please tell me) a wise man once said "Instead of worrying about what people say about you do something that will make them admire you."
Nice rant! Commentaries have been causing flame wars.
And one thing. Isn't the whole point into commentaries about helping people? I know we should add jokes so they are fun to watch, but I thought the whole point is to help the users. Just a bit curious.
And when it comes to commentaries, I prefer Shadsilvson11. He has good sense of humor, and he mainly commentates on bad video game reviews to stay out of flame wars. I feel he deserves a spot in your list.
I forgot to say this when I first saw this, but you put it much better than I did or ever could have. And I'm one of the idiots who fell for Jim's troll video!
So I take it I'm on the list too? By the way I'm having trouble finding commentary material and I'm itching to get back to commentating again. If you have any advice, send me a PM please.
I was going to do commentaries, but atfer hearing bullshit drama in this Community has, it makes me have second thoughts about doing commentaries. Oh great rant as always by the way Youngblood. XD
Thank you Youngblood for being the voice of reason yet again in this community. I think there were a few points you forget to mention when you said you'd go over but alas so that is the curse of no script
Reading the comments made here tempts me to make a how to commentate on youtube series. Kinda pointless I know, but the temptation is definetly there. Maybe then we might be able to cut the number of people making the "community" worse than it already is. That though is just wishful thinking.
Hey, do you guys think there is any place for someone like me in the community. I really have something to say and a few jokes to throw out but I'd rather have one like you and the other commentators look at it first. I was thinking of doing commentaries of the past events. I call them Time Travel Comms.
@ShadicHero777 If you are stating that you intend to do commentaries on old videos I would have to say, rethink your video choices. Doing really old videos, there by commentating on dead meterial is not a good thing. If you wish I might be able to look through one, but initially I do have to say to stick with things that are currently relevent, don't take the path of FoxTrotDeltaLima it never ends well.
@TOGProfessor You know I said the same thing to myself but thanks for responding. I personally beieve that this might be both a good and bad sign.
Bad: There's no interesting stuff to commentate on, not even tubers93 or the geek put any big stuff, and rehashing the constantly based is uninteresting and annoying. I was an idiot for thinking this,
Good: The internet is finally realizing its mistakes and the fail will stop soon.
@ShadicHero777 I'll reply to both with this one. There's no reason to not try doing commentaries. There is still stuff out there to do you just have to look a little harder than usual. Plus it is kind of weird to have someone say they are jealous of me, but thanks for the compliment.
The recent bandwagon is Flippyinvader782. I actually starting that by telling supergodzilla1 about him. So once you think about it, I started something without doing crap.
To be honest, I don't give two frickin shits about commentaries anymore. I used to like them, but nowadays people cynical-minded, whiny assholes who need to chill the fuck out and need to do something else in their life. I mean, seriously, commentaries just focus on ripping a person as a whole, why can't people have more idealism in their lives and try something else that's both fun and productive? That's it screw commentaries, I go to TvTropes now.
@MasterTP10 The point of using outside sources in general is normally to get a laugh out of the audience. If you find something that works with your point, then by all means, use it. The issue YB is talking about is that people tend to rely solely on outside sources without bringing in any of their own thoughts as well. They may think it makes the job easier but in return, it only makes them look lazy, especially when said person is using clips we've all seen a million times.
I agree with you 100% on the troll subject. But even if you point out trolls to these ignoramuses they will still insist on investing time into them. This community is just plain stupid youngblood.
Okay... One question... How? How are you able to do this with little to no stuttering? Also, @12:15 Well, there go my eyes! You might want to clean the liquidated remains on the carpet.
Agreed 100%. I've always balanced criticism with humor in my commentaries to please both crowds. I'm glad that I stopped doing commentaries on Joshua because I ran out of funny material for the guy's videos.
OMG u bitch. I go through all that work to make that green screen video that you couldn't stop laughing at and I don't get any mention in your "funny commentators" section. Ur suhc a buly jurk!
Oh and to clarify, my Joshua videos are there for one simple reason. I intend to ridicule him for making those ignorant little videos on Dani's rertospective not help him in the slightest bit. Mocking him is fun.
I agree with you 100%, though one slight issue, you stated 90% of what I was going to say in an upcoming rant. Oh well life moves on. This was very well done YB and needs to be seen by all in the community. I hope people will watch this and learn.
This rant was absolutely beautiful. Constructive criticism is bullshit, I stopped trying to help people improve a long time ago. People like Joshua and Tess the Lioness I stayed away from because I didn't want to make the EXACT SAME COMMENTARY as 5 or 6 other people, saying"oh, do this do that constructive criticism!"
And people like Flippyinvader782 and SeriousHedgehogCo shouldn't have even STARTED commentaries until they found YT Downloader and WMM. There flip cams are shit.
Well, the reason why I haven't been making commentaries often is because after realizing how awful my commentaries were. I've trying to add humor to my commentaries and make a few other changes.
This rant was incredible. It's as if you found every single little problem the community has and tore each of them a new one. And in record time no less.
NO, it's not "as if". IT IS. Well done, Youngblood. This was truly in Stereo.
If I ever become a commentator, I'll make sure to look back to this for reference.
Great rant there Youngblood. I will admit, my commentaries were so bad, I decided to quit commentating because my points were flawed and I used too much clips that people treated as if I'm ChiefShadow the 2nd. People are right, I'm a 3rd gen fag and I deserve to beat myself up! -_-
I agree with just about every word you said here. And I suppose I do belong on the part of the list that you didn't mention. ;)
Well, anyway though I agree that a commentary is meant to be about entertainment, I also do feel commentaries is a great way to express a viewpoint in the process and try to place something into your audience and give them something to think about. So, your not "helping" the video, but giving the well-educated audience something.
I'm a commentator myself however there are some points I disagree with,one of them is the amount of over used clips...but one reason I give constuctive critism too those who actually will listen is too help them improve,if they don't take it,that isn't my problem it's their's
@Fatality65 I included them indirectly by saying "you know who you are," so if they make good commentaries in my mind, they are included in the list. So since they are indirectly included, I pretty much sealed their respective fates as being great commentators in my book.
The drama was one of the reason I've lost interest in watching commentaries. They used to be cool, but... yeah. *embarrassed laugh* Sorry if you're rubbed the wrong way about this.
I hate people who consider themselves to be better than somebody else when they act like 9 year olds constantly making dick jokes
Its a sinking ship YB its a sinking ship, Grab a lift boat and abandon while you can, leave the community to burn and crumble, come back in 2 years and rebuild it.
I was there when Joshua called Airiana stupid for MLP I was chatting with Slaps during HR's little ego trip with Jen and NJK
@Lentertament Ha ha, sorry for not including you in the list dude. But remember when I said at the end of the list "you know who you are"? Well, if you make good commentaries in my eyes, then you're indirectly included. So you're indirectly included! XD
@youngbloodfantasy91 You know I wonder if people hate the commentary community because we are trying to be something mostly we are not. I'm not a big a-hole in real life but in order to make a good commentary you well have to be funny so I wonder if that's the problem.
I know my work is just bad so I wonder if that's the issue along with the other problems.
@youngbloodfantasy91 LIES, U NO LOVE ME NO MORE ;_; FINE, I'M MOVING AWAY SO YOU'LL NEVER SEE ME AGAIN! xD Lol thanks anyways though, I understand you were only limited.
@youngbloodfantasy91 I am going to be the most unorignal, butthurt commentator ever and do everything wrong of a commentator.Do you think that would be beast?
I getting requests for commentaries on mariotehplumber but what's the point he's a troll and repetitive but great rant youngblood your windom was definely needed here
I'm adding LifeInATent to that list of people who couldn't tell the difference between a troll and a critic. In fact, I still hold that guy up as a prime example of everything NOT to do on the Internet.
I don't care if he's old news, that whole Earthquake video drama caused by him gives me a headache everytime I think about it.
@VoiceoftheBoa2 to be honest, after I saw all the commentaries and criticism and his response videos, I concluded to think that he's a communist. Basically when he said that he's monitoring his comment sections, and that we don't have freedom of speech, and he flags video's that prove him wrong.
@Unknown213546 What he is, is the ultimate definition of an egotist. He did anything and everything he could to make himself look good and in the process made a complete ass out of himself.
You said most of the things that I would say if I took up ranting. I agree with every point you said. I joined youtube to have fun and see what I can do when it comes to commedy. Alot of these people seem to have forgoten how to enjoy oneself. I'd feel sorry for them if I wasn't laughing all the time. Exellent rant. Definitely worth a listen.
Honestly, I just laugh at Joshua's mishaps. To me, the guy is such a horrible commentator that he's not even worthy of an OSC from me. You guys have pretty much said all that can be said about him.
01:31 that man on the bottom right sitting down is that man who ranted about youtube poop and pilli10
jojafnot 3 weeks ago
mariotehplumber is just annoying, in my opinion and I fully understand that he is just a troll, the reason we make commentaries on this plumber is because we need to speak up about what we think. Youngblood,thank you.
MegaInbetweener 1 month ago
BTW Awesome rant. This is one of your best rants ever.
tomboygirlP5 1 month ago
I should've wateched this video before making a commentary.
tomboygirlP5 1 month ago
I'm kinda guilty of milking my targets to death, but I'm working on trying to fix that.
SpaceGuru5 1 month ago
Man, this has to be my all-time favorite rant by you, my friend!
I couldn't stop laughing at the part from 11:10-11:45.
Especially the part when you started talking in monotone.
BWayans2001 1 month ago
You deserve a medal, my friend. Awesome rant.
PokermaskProductions 1 month ago
mariotehplumber is such a good troll
Sonicboom731 1 month ago
The Tiger of the Internet had spoken!
spellbreakerko 2 months ago in playlist Higit pang mga video mula kay youngbloodfantasy91
on the Joshua8428 I am guilty of that. i will admit.
hooray first commentary on youtube and I already mess up :D
MrSirRaven 2 months ago
@MrSirRaven Well, you didn't mess up as much as you just latched onto an old subject. By looking at your video you seem to have a unique edge and I'm sure if you practice, you will improve. Not everyone is perfect the first time, so I won't crucify you for it.
youngbloodfantasy91 2 months ago
@youngbloodfantasy91 true. and i was aware he was an old subject. I learn to bury that.
although I still want to do a commentary on his Shadvic meets Sonic, Shadow and Silver. not so much for criticism but for fun.
MrSirRaven 2 months ago
13:20 VIDEOCEPTION :D
TheAverageTurtle 3 months ago
Whelp, sorry for reccomending doing a commentary on MagicalPockyUsagi. I just thought it would be a bit funny seeing your interpretation on that user (Whom I understand is either a troll or dillusional).
Maxrock9 3 months ago
Unless the person your doing a commentary on absolutely doesnt listen to anything, then I can understand doing a commentary. But there's no point of making fun of them, thats kind of sad actually if you used time out of your life to make a commentary on someone just to insult them. If they don't take advice, then dont even bother with them.
Dont rage at me, just my opinion. :3
Raider6604 3 months ago in playlist More videos from youngbloodfantasy91
I find it annoying that people even make commentaries. If you dont like a video, then just leave a comment instead of making a whole video about it. Seriously, its just wasting your time.
Raider6604 3 months ago in playlist More videos from youngbloodfantasy91
You are a rare example of immense insight and common sense that I've seen on this site, and I thank you for making this video. Also, I firmly believe in editing/scripting reviews (or whatever other videos one makes), although I make unscripted videos on occasion (like updates, gameplay bits, and other things). It's good to know I'm not the only person daring to be bold and distinct from the herd, the diamonds underneath the autumn leaves, and so forth. Keep up the good work, man. :)
TheLavaBuster 3 months ago 2
Excellent job with this rant; you've piqued my interest in your works, so I subbed you. :) In any event, I'm a reviewer (of anime, and the occasional Western animation, installments) and not a commentator (although reviews do have commentary to a certain degree, but I digress); I completely agree with your point about being original (and hilarious, in the process). I try my best in my reviews to balance insight and entertainment, while being fair (though harsh) to said installments.
TheLavaBuster 3 months ago
@tubers93.....HA!...
southparkrulez15 3 months ago
69 videos...
SWAG.
KrazyWinning 3 months ago
I assume the 2 dislikes are Shadowstar1224 and Joshua8428? Or one of them could be guptill89... he disliked my half-assed video on him. LMAO.
KingOfClubz100 3 months ago
I hope that I will become a good commentator. It's not gonna be easy.
BlazeTheMovieFan 3 months ago
13:37
video within a video
VIDCEPTION
ProfessorSummerfang 4 months ago
@ProfessorSummerfang at the time "1337"
anotherrandomnobody 3 months ago
Even though I haven't made a commentary in a while and I hope to go back again I just want to say this. I'm pretty sure that 95% percent on the people I commentated on in the past were trolls I just made them for fun. and to be honest I find all of those troll videos funny. I just wanted to say that.
entertamentguy77 4 months ago
*watches your video* PANTS OFF NOW!
hodgeson3172 4 months ago
Good rant.
That's why I don't do allot of commentaries, because I just fail. :P
That's why I just watch. >:P
BandicootSugar45 4 months ago
I love how you never mentioned my commentaries being thumbed down by sensitive, autistic 3rd gens :P
tubers93 4 months ago
@tubers93 Hey, now that you mentioned it here, everyone will know. :P
youngbloodfantasy91 4 months ago
@Luceroj104 It really is no problem and I feel that you did nothing wrong. But thanks for apologizing, even though you did not do anything out of line. I accept your apology either way.
youngbloodfantasy91 4 months ago
Wow, never heard of these people but this is an interesting video.
Hyman74Roth 4 months ago
im kinda a noob on my commentaries, I play the "constructive criticism" card several times on my videos(scratch that, i use it all the time). Im also guilty of jumping the bandwagon by making a joshua OSC. This video makes me want to improve a bit. thanks youngblood.
pkfire343 4 months ago
And isn't JustSomeRandomGeek2 a bad commentater?
NiGHTS4life 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@NiGHTS4life No what gave you that idea?
realmwarssII 4 months ago
What's so great about Boomstick anyway?
NiGHTS4life 4 months ago
Youngblood, I wish more people in the world were like you. Bravo. Just... Bravo.
OmegaRedhead2 4 months ago
I want to try my first commentary, but I don't know what to do anymore, what are your advise Youndbloodfantasy91? And please don't include "add humor" on, I don't have a "sense" to humor of what I "attack" anymore. =(
6t76t 4 months ago in playlist More videos from youngbloodfantasy91
My next commentary will be on Dynakirby63, and I plan on making some jokes in it.
meta527II 4 months ago
I wish I could I add humor, but I can't, thanks to a classmate of mine who ruined it for me.
6t76t 4 months ago
What Edditing systom do you use
megawiglergalaxy 4 months ago
Great rant, YB. That's how I feel about the commentary community. Its just the epitamy of starting drama and being so repetitive. Not to mention bandwagon jumpers and dare I say it. using the term '' 3rd gen '' and '' constructive criticism''
MidnightPrime 4 months ago
I got mentioned? MY LIFE IS COMPLETE!
But seriously, good job.
SavageBroadcast 4 months ago
Great rant~
All the points was very well presented. Another great video as always Youngblood 8D
Slaphappygam3r 4 months ago
great commentary for an unscripted sort :) i am impressed with the information you gave out. im definitely keeping all these things in mind when i make my next commentary...which i dont know when and who on xx; anyways...would you mind if i show you my first and only OSC? i wanted to give it a try to see if im even capable of doing a good commentary....up to you though...im just looking for any extra feedback :3
Wolfdragoness 4 months ago
only problem with this rant is YOU say "you're uh butthurt" kinda a lot
Hyralc 4 months ago
@Hyralc Last time I checked, I say it at least twice. That's totally equal to "a lot."
youngbloodfantasy91 4 months ago
@youngbloodfantasy91 oh you meant in 1 video i thought you were talking about alltoghether
Hyralc 4 months ago
This is a great rant youngblood and I agree with u all the way. I did two commentaries in my previous account and I stopped because commentaries cause drama and the people won't bother to listen. This is an excellent for an unscripted rant. Great job!
splashdream15 4 months ago
You want to know what I can't stand about this community? I can't stand the fact that some people have to cry whenever someone changes their ways in the community... And I also hate this retarded "3rd-gen" bullshit that people like to fling like Monkey shit. Look, just because someone joined the community at a certain time, that doesn't mean that people should "classify" them as "3rd-gen faggots". Anyways dude, awesome video. The community really needed to be addressed.
KyFriedPlatypus 4 months ago
This was actually very constructive. I have actually gotten annoyed by the mariotehplumber thing, but you brought in pretty good points.
My voice normally sounds unenthustiastic, so i'll try to be original and more enthusithastic.
Thanks!
SmugleafCarriesOn 4 months ago
i remember when I made my first and only commentary on this one douchebag who made a pretty piss poor list on anime cliches. there was no humor i acted all angry and shit and i made the mistake of thinking i could change his mind. some brief drama ensued and i even considered redoing my commentary, but the more i thought about it the more i realized how little i cared and decided in the end commentaries weren't for me. reviewing anime and zombie flicks are my thing and i'm content with it.
IloveOtherPplsMsry 4 months ago
Very good job YB.
ThatGiy 4 months ago
This was excellent Youngblood. I was afriad that you would bring up the idea that most people love inserting quotes into their videos. Honestly I was going to do that for a video I had in mind this past summer, but a part of me just knew that there was something wrong with that. I've tried to come up with clever jokes, but then again, they very generic and things that some other commentators have come up with. That I mostly why I don't have any commentaries on my channel.
DotNetWolf 4 months ago
@DotNetWolf (Cont.) The mostyou are going to get from me from a terrible video that seriously needs work on is from the comments I leave behind and some final thoughts. After that I move on. It's a shame there are so many problems with Commentaries these days, because when I first heard about it, Joshua8428 was just becoming a new hot topic. I'm glad you did this rant because NOW I know that isn't about constructive criticism. UGH!
DotNetWolf 4 months ago
Seriously? people are STILL commentating on Joshua and mariotehplumber? There as old as Adam Sandlers carrer. I should try to add alittle more humor into my commentaries because, (well I only have two), but even I looked at them and I think there alittle boring. But the one thing that pisses me off is when 5-7 people make a commentary on the same freakin topic thinking, I may have done that once or twice, but doing that to much does make you lazy.
ARegularguy971 4 months ago
Hey YB... Constructive Criticism. :7 *trollface*
BlackRaven117 4 months ago
You forgot to put me on 5:18
TyRiders2 4 months ago
I don't know if you've seen my commentarys but I wanted to say...
You inspired me to make commentarys :)
kenman66 4 months ago
I really wish people could stop taking Mariotehplumber seriously. He is such an obvious troll and an oddly succesful one.
One problem I have with commentaries is that they focus too much of faggots(Joshua included). The thing that made commentaries great was that it challenged fans of other people like Hellsing, RandomDCE and Darkness. Now I see people do rants on kids or recolors. The closest I can think that dose try to challege people is Shadowstar but he has too many flaws.
SimplyMasonZero 4 months ago
You know what's funny most of the guys who preach "Constructive Critisms" always end up getting asshurt when people call them out and they end up deleting everything they made and come out with "Well I don't want other people giving me shit" ie. YuGiOhSonicNiGHTS64.
Heres something I got to say (I forget who said this so Youngblood if you know who I'm quoting please tell me) a wise man once said "Instead of worrying about what people say about you do something that will make them admire you."
realmwarssII 4 months ago
Nice rant! Commentaries have been causing flame wars.
And one thing. Isn't the whole point into commentaries about helping people? I know we should add jokes so they are fun to watch, but I thought the whole point is to help the users. Just a bit curious.
And when it comes to commentaries, I prefer Shadsilvson11. He has good sense of humor, and he mainly commentates on bad video game reviews to stay out of flame wars. I feel he deserves a spot in your list.
Cster91 4 months ago
tbh you are good at unscript as well i dont script eather i just save all i have to say in my mind
MrDiablolord 4 months ago
I forgot to say this when I first saw this, but you put it much better than I did or ever could have. And I'm one of the idiots who fell for Jim's troll video!
TransformersFanCo328 4 months ago
Wow I need to make more commentaries on my own channel.
I have that group, NiceGuyEddies but I haven't done a solo in a while.
GoodCanBeDone 4 months ago
Song opening name?
And you sound sick.
JenJenRome123 4 months ago
@JenJenRome123 Cherry Blossom Clinic by The Move.
And I wasn't sick. Perhaps I was exhausted for doing this whole rant three separate times. XD
youngbloodfantasy91 4 months ago
@youngbloodfantasy91 Ah. Okay. XD Because it sounded like your nose was stuffed up.
JenJenRome123 4 months ago
@JenJenRome123 The song is called "Cherry Blossom Clinic" by the British band called "The Move."
agbrown83 1 month ago
@VoiceoftheBoa2 Thanks for clearing that up. Again, I'll make sure to remember that if I start commentating ever.
MasterTP10 4 months ago
Haven't you made video on this before?
JustASpaceCowboy1 4 months ago
So I take it I'm on the list too? By the way I'm having trouble finding commentary material and I'm itching to get back to commentating again. If you have any advice, send me a PM please.
Boundwithflame23 4 months ago
I was going to do commentaries, but atfer hearing bullshit drama in this Community has, it makes me have second thoughts about doing commentaries. Oh great rant as always by the way Youngblood. XD
Dragoncore7 4 months ago
Thank you Youngblood for being the voice of reason yet again in this community. I think there were a few points you forget to mention when you said you'd go over but alas so that is the curse of no script
CloudCereal553 4 months ago
HOORAY! I'm considered a funny commentator in your book! (I did hear my name, right?)
Speaking of which, would you consider my recent co-op commentary a good commentary?
DanielLaux42992 4 months ago
@DanielLaux42992 Oh my gosh I forgot to watch your co-op commentary!
meta527II 4 months ago
Reading the comments made here tempts me to make a how to commentate on youtube series. Kinda pointless I know, but the temptation is definetly there. Maybe then we might be able to cut the number of people making the "community" worse than it already is. That though is just wishful thinking.
TOGProfessor 4 months ago
Another great rant, youngblood. I need to take these and any words into consideration. This will definitely help in the future.
Croreloth 4 months ago
Hey, do you guys think there is any place for someone like me in the community. I really have something to say and a few jokes to throw out but I'd rather have one like you and the other commentators look at it first. I was thinking of doing commentaries of the past events. I call them Time Travel Comms.
ShadicHero777 4 months ago
@ShadicHero777 If you are stating that you intend to do commentaries on old videos I would have to say, rethink your video choices. Doing really old videos, there by commentating on dead meterial is not a good thing. If you wish I might be able to look through one, but initially I do have to say to stick with things that are currently relevent, don't take the path of FoxTrotDeltaLima it never ends well.
TOGProfessor 4 months ago
@TOGProfessor You know I said the same thing to myself but thanks for responding. I personally beieve that this might be both a good and bad sign.
Bad: There's no interesting stuff to commentate on, not even tubers93 or the geek put any big stuff, and rehashing the constantly based is uninteresting and annoying. I was an idiot for thinking this,
Good: The internet is finally realizing its mistakes and the fail will stop soon.
ShadicHero777 4 months ago
@TOGProfessor To be honest I was acutally jealous of you guys. So I guess that's where that original idea came from.
ShadicHero777 4 months ago
@ShadicHero777 I'll reply to both with this one. There's no reason to not try doing commentaries. There is still stuff out there to do you just have to look a little harder than usual. Plus it is kind of weird to have someone say they are jealous of me, but thanks for the compliment.
TOGProfessor 4 months ago
And this is why my commentaries I'm not trying to help nobody, I usually have fun and make fun of them.
Also, Every single god damn word is so amazing in this...
VesperTheSnake 4 months ago
The recent bandwagon is Flippyinvader782. I actually starting that by telling supergodzilla1 about him. So once you think about it, I started something without doing crap.
VesperTheSnake 4 months ago
To be honest, I don't give two frickin shits about commentaries anymore. I used to like them, but nowadays people cynical-minded, whiny assholes who need to chill the fuck out and need to do something else in their life. I mean, seriously, commentaries just focus on ripping a person as a whole, why can't people have more idealism in their lives and try something else that's both fun and productive? That's it screw commentaries, I go to TvTropes now.
MrTerrorFace 4 months ago
@MrTerrorFace Having fun entertaining people is fun and productive.
dreadspellera 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is why I don't do commentaries... Too much of the same damn thing...
TheDrunkenwhale 4 months ago
Comment removed
TheDrunkenwhale 4 months ago
Quick question:
Can we use (but not overuse) clips not used before, provided it has relevance to the topic at hand?
MasterTP10 4 months ago
@MasterTP10 The point of using outside sources in general is normally to get a laugh out of the audience. If you find something that works with your point, then by all means, use it. The issue YB is talking about is that people tend to rely solely on outside sources without bringing in any of their own thoughts as well. They may think it makes the job easier but in return, it only makes them look lazy, especially when said person is using clips we've all seen a million times.
VoiceoftheBoa2 4 months ago
@MasterTP10 So to summarize, yes you may. :)
VoiceoftheBoa2 4 months ago
I agree with you 100% on the troll subject. But even if you point out trolls to these ignoramuses they will still insist on investing time into them. This community is just plain stupid youngblood.
The98Funnyman 4 months ago
Okay... One question... How? How are you able to do this with little to no stuttering? Also, @12:15 Well, there go my eyes! You might want to clean the liquidated remains on the carpet.
TwinsaneIncarnation 4 months ago
Great rant YB! : D
SarcasticallyRandom3 4 months ago
Yay, i made a cameo appearance. XD anyways great rant Young Blood
Steventhemaster95 4 months ago
Agreed 100%. I've always balanced criticism with humor in my commentaries to please both crowds. I'm glad that I stopped doing commentaries on Joshua because I ran out of funny material for the guy's videos.
Angryjon 4 months ago
Youngblood's law: There will always be drama. No exceptions.
ubahootahv3 4 months ago
Nostalgia Critic...Funny, Steve Martin, Funny....constantly using them to "REACT" to a subject...not funny.
Trollaverse 4 months ago
OMG u bitch. I go through all that work to make that green screen video that you couldn't stop laughing at and I don't get any mention in your "funny commentators" section. Ur suhc a buly jurk!
TheTigerStrike 4 months ago
Oh and to clarify, my Joshua videos are there for one simple reason. I intend to ridicule him for making those ignorant little videos on Dani's rertospective not help him in the slightest bit. Mocking him is fun.
TOGProfessor 4 months ago
@TOGProfessor hey that's what I'm planning doing his so called motivational commentaries are just fail
pikachu0Z 4 months ago
I agree with you 100%, though one slight issue, you stated 90% of what I was going to say in an upcoming rant. Oh well life moves on. This was very well done YB and needs to be seen by all in the community. I hope people will watch this and learn.
TOGProfessor 4 months ago
This rant was absolutely beautiful. Constructive criticism is bullshit, I stopped trying to help people improve a long time ago. People like Joshua and Tess the Lioness I stayed away from because I didn't want to make the EXACT SAME COMMENTARY as 5 or 6 other people, saying"oh, do this do that constructive criticism!"
And people like Flippyinvader782 and SeriousHedgehogCo shouldn't have even STARTED commentaries until they found YT Downloader and WMM. There flip cams are shit.
HonestlyIronic56 4 months ago
Well, the reason why I haven't been making commentaries often is because after realizing how awful my commentaries were. I've trying to add humor to my commentaries and make a few other changes.
XxTrentEchidnaxX 4 months ago
This rant was incredible. It's as if you found every single little problem the community has and tore each of them a new one. And in record time no less.
NO, it's not "as if". IT IS. Well done, Youngblood. This was truly in Stereo.
If I ever become a commentator, I'll make sure to look back to this for reference.
MasterTP10 4 months ago
U forgot to mention ppl like flippyinvader782 for doing 2 much commentaries on steventhemaster for saying flippyinvader sux
Simpsonsfan1011 4 months ago
Great rant there Youngblood. I will admit, my commentaries were so bad, I decided to quit commentating because my points were flawed and I used too much clips that people treated as if I'm ChiefShadow the 2nd. People are right, I'm a 3rd gen fag and I deserve to beat myself up! -_-
GSTSUPERWORLD87 4 months ago
I LOVE you for making this video!
I agree with just about every word you said here. And I suppose I do belong on the part of the list that you didn't mention. ;)
Well, anyway though I agree that a commentary is meant to be about entertainment, I also do feel commentaries is a great way to express a viewpoint in the process and try to place something into your audience and give them something to think about. So, your not "helping" the video, but giving the well-educated audience something.
TheLeetCasualGamer 4 months ago
let me guess, courtesy of this video, you think I'm a horrible commentator, do you?
SKULLCRUSHER8127 4 months ago
I'm a commentator myself however there are some points I disagree with,one of them is the amount of over used clips...but one reason I give constuctive critism too those who actually will listen is too help them improve,if they don't take it,that isn't my problem it's their's
KaitosTH 4 months ago
"Go through the Cracker Jack box to look for a coupe de ville."
That Meatloaf reference was just perfect.
Great video, by the way. It really is sad that we're trying to be the "voice of reason", yet "reason" is a term that we can barely grasp.
MSkull01 4 months ago
well i do agree with you
but i can care less if i make a entertaining commentary or not
it just something for me to do in my spear time
but however i'm more into Online gaming than anything else
and as for me doing good quality video i can't unless i get a news computer
i'm uploading from my Ps3 at the moment but like i said i can care less if i'm entertaining or not commentary are just something for me to do
thought i do care mostly about My Pokemon Competitive Wi-Fi Battle
DraBahamutShirocenny 4 months ago
So would this mean that TOGProffesor and Realmwars should stop commentating??
Fatality65 4 months ago
@Fatality65 I included them indirectly by saying "you know who you are," so if they make good commentaries in my mind, they are included in the list. So since they are indirectly included, I pretty much sealed their respective fates as being great commentators in my book.
youngbloodfantasy91 4 months ago
Wow, I'm on your list.
But I was soooo boring before!
Phoenixangelgal 4 months ago
The drama was one of the reason I've lost interest in watching commentaries. They used to be cool, but... yeah. *embarrassed laugh* Sorry if you're rubbed the wrong way about this.
Idachan 4 months ago
I'll take this lesson to heart. I might throw my thoughts on the community in the future.
DemonSlayerDarkna 4 months ago
So I searched Joshua8428 on the youtube search bar . ..
665 results (as of now).
Who wants to bet at least 95% of them are commentaries
Phoenixangelgal 4 months ago
I couldn't have said it better myself. Many good points there.
blackoutworm 4 months ago
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA........
You put the 58 minute video in here!!!!! Just for that, this has become my favorite rant of yours, by far...
VoiceoftheBoa2 4 months ago
I left because I hate everyone here
I hate the Drama
I hate people who consider themselves to be better than somebody else when they act like 9 year olds constantly making dick jokes
Its a sinking ship YB its a sinking ship, Grab a lift boat and abandon while you can, leave the community to burn and crumble, come back in 2 years and rebuild it.
I was there when Joshua called Airiana stupid for MLP I was chatting with Slaps during HR's little ego trip with Jen and NJK
I was there and I hated It
BrickishStudios 4 months ago
Wow...your voice has really matured over time.
Great rant BTW!
;)
MrWarners14 4 months ago
I'm Not on the List so I'M NOT FUNNY??? LIFE IS MEANINGLESS!!!! xD
Anyway, I don't know how much I could thank you for this...so I'll just Rape you to show how much I love you C:
But I agree with Every, single, dame, word, you, said!
Lentertament 4 months ago
@Lentertament Ha ha, sorry for not including you in the list dude. But remember when I said at the end of the list "you know who you are"? Well, if you make good commentaries in my eyes, then you're indirectly included. So you're indirectly included! XD
And thanks a lot, I really appreciate it man. :)
youngbloodfantasy91 4 months ago
@youngbloodfantasy91 You know I wonder if people hate the commentary community because we are trying to be something mostly we are not. I'm not a big a-hole in real life but in order to make a good commentary you well have to be funny so I wonder if that's the problem.
I know my work is just bad so I wonder if that's the issue along with the other problems.
TheHeartless09 4 months ago
@youngbloodfantasy91 LIES, U NO LOVE ME NO MORE ;_; FINE, I'M MOVING AWAY SO YOU'LL NEVER SEE ME AGAIN! xD Lol thanks anyways though, I understand you were only limited.
No Problems anyway =)
Lentertament 4 months ago
@youngbloodfantasy91 I am going to be the most unorignal, butthurt commentator ever and do everything wrong of a commentator.Do you think that would be beast?
Empirewild010 4 months ago
I getting requests for commentaries on mariotehplumber but what's the point he's a troll and repetitive but great rant youngblood your windom was definely needed here
pikachu0Z 4 months ago
0:32 - 0:51 - welcome to my world.
And damn man, that was actually quite a rant. :O
dreadspellera 4 months ago
THANK YOU! You pretty much nailed it on the head, YB.
Don't get me started on the friggin' "nth-degree" commentaries... I'm getting sick and fucking tired of seeing that shit.
NeuGristle87 4 months ago
You know, for an unscripted rant, this one is pretty good.
powerpup97 4 months ago
Yeah, I have to agree with you. Also, I am underage, but I will take your rant's points and get an editing system and learn to download videos. : )
Jangwoofilms 4 months ago
I'm adding LifeInATent to that list of people who couldn't tell the difference between a troll and a critic. In fact, I still hold that guy up as a prime example of everything NOT to do on the Internet.
I don't care if he's old news, that whole Earthquake video drama caused by him gives me a headache everytime I think about it.
VoiceoftheBoa2 4 months ago
@VoiceoftheBoa2 to be honest, after I saw all the commentaries and criticism and his response videos, I concluded to think that he's a communist. Basically when he said that he's monitoring his comment sections, and that we don't have freedom of speech, and he flags video's that prove him wrong.
Lets face it, he's a communist.
Unknown213546 4 months ago
@Unknown213546 What he is, is the ultimate definition of an egotist. He did anything and everything he could to make himself look good and in the process made a complete ass out of himself.
VoiceoftheBoa2 4 months ago
@VoiceoftheBoa2 I agree with your statement, and I admire your use of vocabulary. I never heard of such a word before to be honest.
Unknown213546 4 months ago
@VoiceoftheBoa2 Although watching him get sodomized over Skype by the BBC was pretty awesome.
GameOverthinkerFan7 4 months ago
@GameOverthinkerFan7 True, except he tried to play it off that the BBC was bullying him in that call.
VoiceoftheBoa2 4 months ago
You said most of the things that I would say if I took up ranting. I agree with every point you said. I joined youtube to have fun and see what I can do when it comes to commedy. Alot of these people seem to have forgoten how to enjoy oneself. I'd feel sorry for them if I wasn't laughing all the time. Exellent rant. Definitely worth a listen.
landon29 4 months ago
Honestly, I just laugh at Joshua's mishaps. To me, the guy is such a horrible commentator that he's not even worthy of an OSC from me. You guys have pretty much said all that can be said about him.
VoiceoftheBoa2 4 months ago
Yeah I have my faults but I try to be diffrent but I agree with this rant.
TheHeartless09 4 months ago
*ignores the fact that I got mentioned and resists temptation to squeep loudly*
Yeah, I got magicalpockyusagi in my requests box once, and I could tell from the comments that she was a troll.
Akriloth2160 4 months ago
Hmm I do eff up on occasion by saying I'm part of the community despite the fact I have only made 2 commentaries. (Technically 6 but UPLOADED 2)
Interesting opinion, I don't exactly agree with it, but very interesting anyway
TheRello99 4 months ago