華人星光大道 2011-07-24 劉悅

[yankai09]

She's run = she has run (?)

So it's totally grammatical lol

Her singing is so creepily powerful!!! Like!!!

[h15881522]

我起雞皮疙瘩ㄌ..很厲害!!

[tenddyson]

最有實力，能表達最多的參賽者。

[1234567899878754]

NICE!

十分感動。

或許有些人並沒有感到共鳴 但那不盡然是歌手的問題

因素可以是你當時的心境、當時的環境或你對原唱的熟悉度、對新版­的接受度抑或對劉悅個人的偏見、期望......等等 影響了你對這個演出的觀感 總之就別再批評啦

就算真的沒感動到你 她的技巧總沒話說了吧

[noerichk]

計算精準的完美演繹.



[peter60207]

唱歌機器

[EsQue90]

@bafflinbook, lovefetish100

arguments accepted. music is subjective. we can just agree to disagree. doing this debate shit on youtube is really pointless IMO.

anyway she's a very skillful singer. only on this instant i think she failed to convey the very emotion of this classic tune. and emotion is a very crucial part of performance.

[bartdyw]

她不拿30分，谁可以拿30分？我觉得按照华语歌坛的歌手广泛实­力来看没多少人能唱到这个水准，很多天王天后都唱不到，在场的歌­手出身的评审更不一定唱的到，如果这个给低，那不是说明自己的水­平也不能说很高了么

[reaver0414]

好猛- -...有點麻

[tim520520]

好猛!!!好強.....



[oliver2046]

太短了 期待日後完整版的其他歌曲 她算是這一屆的看點了 

[EsQue90]

Singing was very good.

But at her level, and having such great opportunity to participate in 星光大道, she could at least have put some effort into MASTERING THE VERY SIMPLE LYRICS?!?!? "SHE'S RUN??" WTF?

Am disappointed. Mistakes like this ruin the whole song especially if you understand English. :(

[lovefetish100]

@EsQue90 She run or she's run, what a big deal? Huh? You should be disappointed cuz you are not listening to a song but trying to get at the singer. It's ridiculous to be rigid about the grammar of the lyrics especially when you base your judgement on that part. Anyway, I know what you really wanna say is" Hey! I understand ENGLISH!" -_-

[BafflinBook]

@EsQue90 Singers deliberately alter syllabus of words to make the lyrics in rhyme.Very often we can find sentences in improper tenses were scattered throughout the lyrics.However,i have never seen anyone and complain how incorrect grammar,pronounciation ruin a song or taint and singer's talent.

[TheHeaven1930]

如果他的run再拉長一點會更爽!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!

[happy726158]

我覺得每個人都有自己的獨特性，也沒必要拿厡唱或是宥嘉來比，第­一次聽她唱這首歌我整個是起雞皮疙瘩，反覆去聽也一樣，很高興她­能來參賽，希望你能唱更多好聽的歌給我們，加油!



[6925ericlin]

這首她技巧驚人阿

只要她唱抒情歌時也能感動到觀眾(還是感覺她太炫技了)

她人氣會大幅提升的

感覺這屆要找到威脅到她的對手似乎不太容易

好像只有吳盈靜和大馬冠軍那位(一個穩一個曲風多變)有點點機會

其他像關詩敏金旋獎捨我杯那幾位

火侯我覺得還稍嫌不足

[KennRicky]

这样就拿满分? 侮辱了林宥嘉。。。

[kenyu87]

what a powerful creep... 劉悅

too bad im a super failure creep... 

[aa2268888]

只能說唱的不好 而且太油了

整首歌完全沒感覺了 只覺得很假仙而已

原本那種簡單純粹的感情完全不見了

[y920232]

@aa2268888 如果真的很有實力批頻別人 請妳上台唱給大家聽 . ：))

[aa2268888]

@y920232 話不能這樣說

你難道覺得評審每個都很會唱嗎

照你的邏輯

那影評人是不是每個都當大導演了



[y920232]

@aa2268888 你是評審嗎？ 你是影評人嗎？

為什麼你不去星光當評審？ 你不去當影評人？0.0

他們能當評審 ... 只少都有他厲害的地方適用於唱歌 電影方面

至於不行的話 就乖乖的聽歌吧 覺得太油就別聽 別回應阿

如果當事人看到了 ﹝只覺得很假仙而已﹞ 心理做何感想

她唱的要死要活 被說成這樣 .

你不喜歡聽根本不用浪費你的時間 也不用留下你的寶貴建議

[q0952258911]

@aa2268888 這首歌 所能表達的 不只有 "簡單 純粹" 一種方法, 誰教你 一首音樂只能被侷限在 所謂的公式:A+B?

如果要這樣 刻意侷限自己的情緒 感情 來表達所愛的一首音樂, 這樣早已扭曲了 唱歌時的情緒 感情, 只淪落於 所謂的模仿 公式化。

千變萬化的音樂 始終最單純的是 它所寄託的情感、感動與 情懷, 你大可表達劉悅唱這首歌無法感動你, 但我非常不認同 "假先"這個字眼, 一首音樂不該被侷限在一種方式 你那所謂的簡單 純粹, 否則只是淪為公式化而已, 否則你也只是 自我感覺良好的人。^ ^

[aa2268888]

@q0952258911 我承認我用假仙這個詞確實是過分了

不過沒辦法感動我是真的

因為radiohead太經典了 就像hotel california 網路上很多翻唱 改編的版本

但是聽起來就是怪 不對味

[EsQue90]

@aa2268888 华人一大缺点就是接受不了别人的主观批评。　你就放弃跟粉丝争论吧。

我其实也同意你的看法，她技巧是非常棒，但唱不出这首歌的意境，­可能因为不明白歌词内容吧。太油了。而且唱错歌词。听了很不舒服­。

[3697241]

唱得真是好，歷練使然

[George712]

I think this is the best performance of the season so far

[Qing0414]

楊乃文唱法

[ajohn8399]

@Qing0414 真的好楊乃喔

[tzinwei90]

愛劉悅一萬分...聲音很有辨識度...夠粗大...拉起音來也­特別好聽=)可是長期聽會覺得有種壓迫感的感覺...

[cc760330]

這首歌唱的太好了 不過滿就就太跨張了 大概是27~28的實力



[Heavensdust135]

My personal opinion-I liker her version MUCH better than the original "Creep"s. The power fit the song more than the original mellow vocals.

[Lovingyou455]

没人能说她唱得不好，因为她用自己的想法来唱！也只有她能唱出次­感觉

[sayakatesumi]

唱得太好了, 根本完全不需要比賽, 她需要的是一個早於2006那年夏天已經要出現的機會

[bkpc3388]

far worse than the original

不喜歡,匠氣十足

[jamieson369]

太激動了  驚人的爆發力

[poin7474]

哇!!太強了!!這好聽到會跟著唱~magic

[cc760330]

只能說她所擁有的東西比這首歌更多...

[trendstom]

To be honest, if you notice, all the judges gravitate towards contestants who sang english songs- that is why Zhou appeared like she did not sing too well.

imho, that wasnt a good rendition of Creep. Yes she did well in the chorus, brought out her emotions and was explosive. However, she was also flat in her tone in the beginning. I thot both should get around 20. Def not the high of 29- because 29 means all are almost perfect: pitching, emotions, control.

time will tell if she can progress

[trymingray]

不能說唱得不好，技巧驚人而富有層次

但單以這首歌曲整體詞曲氛圍的掌握上　似乎還有著進步的空間

這樣的詮釋或許已經遠遠超過Creep一曲所得乘載...

[cc760330]

超屌...



[docras]

very bad pronunciation...close your eyes and you do not really apprehend most of the words that she sang.

[torderlata]

not a good cover of creep nor a good performance. i think the emotions were there but maybe too much... sounded like she "oversang"... anyway, just my opinion. i really like Liu Yue and i hope she goes far in this competition.

[JayneHon]

为什么还没有完整的…几时才可以看到…好期待T.T

７/17的也没有完整的TT"谁可以放上去？

[taotao79]

this is by far the best moment of the show!!!

[dawn22ism]

amazing skills